Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Justices: Gitmo detainees can challenge detention in U.S. courts - CNN.com

By CosmicConservative
CNN gets this right. This is another legal blow to our efforts to fight terrorism. They call it "Bush's fight" and that pretty much sums up CNN's opinion of the War on Terror. It's Bush's fight and since they hate Bush, they hail this decision. Scalia, as usual, gets it right. The U.S. will regret this decision.
Justices: Gitmo detainees can challenge detention in U.S. courts - CNN.com WASHINGTON (CNN) -- Suspected terrorists and foreign fighters held by the U.S. military at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, have the right to challenge their detention in federal court, the Supreme Court ruled Thursday The decision marks another legal blow to the Bush administration's war on terrorism policies. The 5-4 vote reflects the divide over how much legal autonomy the U.S. military should have to prosecute about 270 prisoners, some of whom have been held for more than six years without charges. Fourteen of them are alleged to be top al Qaeda figures.

Comments (11)

Drax
We give terrorists greater protection and greater deference than we did the Nazis (or any others with whom we have been at war with for more than two centuries.) Insanity. And, Coulter would rather have Clinton nominating Justices than McCain. Insanity.
Cullen
The real scary thing about this isn't so much what the court said, but rather the implications their rulings may have on future challenges. We are, essentially, granting Consitutional rights to foreign nationals who have never set foot within the United States. This is dangerous ground on which we tread.
CosmicConservative
Cullen, it's worse than that. We are granting Constitutional protections to individuals PICKED UP ON THE BATTLEFIELD apparently engaged in acts of war against this country. These aren't merely "non-citizens" getting this protection, these are ENEMY COMBATANTS that we are granting these protections to. I have been sorely, sorely disappointed in Kennedy before, but this is perhaps the worst moment in his entire career, and that's saying something. Breyer, Ginsberg, Souter and Stevens I expect this sort of pathetic ruling from, Kennedy I had higher hopes from.
Andy
I have always been fascinated, and perplexed by the make-up of the SCOTUS. Watching supreme court nominations in my lifetime has really stumped me. Our modern conservative icon RayGun gave us the swishy O'Connor, and then the swishy Kennedy. I'll give him is due on Scalia. Our liberal Republican Nixon gave us Rhenquist (though not on the Court, it is still interesting to me). Our liberal Republican, Bush the Elder gave us Souter (the worst justice on the Court in my book), and Thomas...a real surprise from Bush the Elder (after the Bork lynching...so Bush did try). Clinton's nominees are of no interest to me. I expected them to be idiots. But then our liberal Republican, Bush the Younger, gave us Roberts and Alito. So by my count, in my paying attention lifetime the only conservative Republican President batted 1 for 3. The liberal Republican Presidents have batted 5 for 6 in nominations (though only 4 were confirmed). Maybe the liberal McCain will turn this mess of a Court around! Looks like the lib side of the party has a better track record... To the subject...I am wondering who is going to be the first Federal Judge to jump up and order the release of all detainees because they weren't read their rights. Who is going to be the first Federal Judge to jump up and exclude all evidence collected by the military in these interrogations...and order the military to not proceed on anything they collected, because it was "illegally" obtained? The worms are out of the can with this idiotic ruling. Maybe another revolution is necessary.
CosmicConservative
Andy, I'd say that the lawyers are working on the paperwork for all the things you mentioned now, except that I think they've been working on that paperwork for years already. It won't be long before this ruling bites us hard, and it won't be pretty. And the mainstream media will jump all over the chance to depict murderous terrorists as poor downtrodden victims of the Bush trumped-up war machine.
Andy
Amen! We're in trouble big with this one. I'm not a fatalist...but this is a pretty nasty pill to swallow (it's big, and it worsens your illness).
BetterThanYou
"...individuals PICKED UP ON THE BATTLEFIELD apparently engaged in acts of war against this country..." Don't keep up with the news much, do you?
CosmicConservative
BetterThanYou, well, apparently more than you do.
BetterThanYou
Then how did you miss the Seton Hall-Denbeaux report?
Andy
BetterThanYou, I know that you are probably a really hot chick because of your passion and ignorance. But I'm going to take issue with you on this one. I don't really care about the detainees at Guantanamo. The only concerns I have for them are that they are sucking up tax dollars, and are about to clog up the courts. I know that is "cold and un-Christian," but who really cares? Just because some law professor (cough cough) writes a report...you're gonna buy that? Girl, get a life! We enjoy a lifestyle here in the US that most of the world can not imagine. You can surf the net, make really weird comments on the internet, and get your nails done at the mall...all within a few hours. Think about it. These people at GTMO have no idea of what "justice" really is. All they know is "America Bad...Allah good!!!!" If poor Ahmaad had been fooling around with his girlfriend, she would probably be dead from a stoning. If he was so dirt broke that he had to steal a piece of bread to survive the day, he'd likely be known as "stumpy." Think about what you are saying here. These people hate us...no...they hate you! They wish that you were dead...or wish to convert you, or force you to convert to Islam, and put you in a Burka... These are not rational humans we are dealing with here BetterThanYou. Their concept of "justice" is as foreign to ours as night is to day. I'm not willing to put them all in a big hole somewhere and bulldoze over them. They do deserve a hearing. But come on girl...do you want one of those guys running your life?
BetterThanYou
"BetterThanYou, I know that you are probably a really hot chick..." Wrong already.