Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

I hate insurance companies

By CosmicConservative
Have I mentioned lately how much I despise insurance companies? Just in case I haven't made it clear in past posts, let me reiterate how deep, abiding and profound my nova-hot hatred is for insurance companies. I can't think of any other "legitimate" business that I have such intense abhorrence for. Even telemarketing companies are far less execrable and cause me much less pain, suffering and emotional distress. The latest installment of "why insurance companies are Satan's emissaries on earth" goes like this: I had gall bladder surgery in January. It's now June. Last month I received a bill from the surgical assistant for the surgery. We submitted it to our insurance company since I had checked with the insurance company before the surgery and was told that they covered assistants so long as they were "in network" and I had checked with my surgeon to make sure that he chose an "in network" assistant. Well, it turns out that the assistant who performed the assistance is "out of network" and as such is not covered by my insurance. So suddenly I'm sitting on an unpaid bill that I had expected to be at least partially covered by my insurance. This is how it always works. Pretty much everything that IS covered is covered less than you think. And they will scrutinize every detail of every procedure to wring as much cash out of you as possible. I think the IRS could learn some tips from insurance companies. So now I'm battling with my surgeon, the surgeon's assistant, the billing company and my insurance company, when the bottom line here is that the only one who is likely to end up holding the bag is me. I hate insurance companies. Yes, at the moment I also have a great deal of anger towards the surgeon and the assistant who I believe performed the surgery under false pretenses, but that's not the point. The point is that insurance companies make it ridiculously difficult to manage your own insurance, and every little uncrossed "t" or undotted "i" ends up coming out of my checking account.

Comments (13)

Drax
Sue the doctor. Small claims court. Not malpractice, but breach of contract, perhaps "detrimental reliance." After all, there was an agreement to have a covered assistant and he decided not to live up to that agreement. You relied on his promise to your detriment. I'm with you on insurance companies.
pace
My wife is in the *exact* same situation with our insurance company due to an out-of-network technician who was present during a surgery she underwent last fall. In our in-network hospital. This was relating to her cancer diagnosis, so as you can imagine the last thing on our minds was checking the credentials of everyone in the O.R. I hate health insurance companies too.
CosmicConservative
I've said it before, as much as I despise government health care systems, I would actually benefit from it. I find it harder and harder to support the free market approach the more I deal with insurance companies.
Dadman
I'm not a big fan of insurance companies either, but I've personally never had an issue with our provider (Cigna). I would like to see some controls and regulations imposed on the insurance companies (e.g. limits on pre-existing condition restrictions, transferability, etc.) and perhaps some kind of government-provided safety net made available to uninsured people, before we turn away from a free market based health care system. I had government health care in the Air Force for 4 years and I can tell you what I have now is vastly superior in terms of quality and convenience...
CosmicConservative
My major problem with insurance companies is that I believe that they explicitly work to do exactly the opposite of what their marketing claims they do. Every one of them claims to be all about solving your health care concerns if you sign up with them, but my experience has been that their goal is always to do as LITTLE as possible to help the patient and as much as possible to maximize their financial gain or minimize their financial loss from every transaction. I admit that my family has special needs, but they are needs that are supposed to be covered, but I would guess that about 30% of our total claims end up in some sort of escalation or appeal. And as if that isn't bad enough, they sit on things for months and months and then send you an urgent notice (which usually includes veiled threats) that ths situation MUST be taken care of NOW since it was for services rendered months ago. That's the situation here, I just received the bill for the surgical assistant and already I'm being told that it is going 90 days past due if I don't act immediately. Frankly, minus the thugs with the ball-peen hammers for use on kneecaps, I find very little difference between modern insurance companies and classic protection schemes run by organized criminal syndicates.
Dadman
I don't disagree with you. As much I believe in the free market, these insurance companies need to be stepped on hard by reasonable government controls and expectations that have the best interests of people in mind as opposed to profits. But we still need to be very careful about transferring the control of our national healthcare system to government.
Andy
I am a health insurance dinosaur. It has been 20 years since I carried any. I figure I've probably saved about $150,000 in premiums, plus the thousands of dollars of deductibles I'd have paid out of pocket. That's why I'm so rich! ;) But I offer this: I hear the horror stories all of the time. My last experience with health insurance was with Blue Cross. I never had any problems whatsoever with claims. I share Dadman's ignorance of living (or working) through claim difficulties, but I know that Cosmic is not a "whiner," and his frustrations are shared by millions of others. Before oil hit 135 per barrel, the most profitable companies (truly profitable...not just on paper) in the US were insurance companies. And that's just fine. I would never begrudge a company a profit. But the consumer that pays the bill, and has to beg, or sue for "his bill" to be paid should be angry. I think they should be angry at government. I know it's different in every State, but I really think that there is TOO MUCH regulation of health insurers. For example. Our newly elected "conservative" legislature in Louisiana has passed a law requiring all health insurers to cover "prosthetic devices." Okay...how many people do you know with a prosthesis? Maybe you do know somebody. But how many of them lose a limb outside of military service? The VA will handle prosthetic devices for them. So, all two million or so insured people in the State of Louisiana will now pay more for prosthetic coverage. How many of them will ever file a claim on that????? How many 60-year old couples that got fixed 20 years ago will ever file a "maternity" claim? But they are paying for it through their health plan. It's a two-edged sword. The State legislatures require all this junk, raising the costs. The insurers include it (knowing that they'll never have to pay off on most of these stupid mandates), knowing that some friendly legislator probably put a loophole in the legislation like an "off-plan deal," or something. It is an unholy alliance. If health insurance was totally unregulated, true market forces could fix the mess...no legislation requiring anything (except for solvency of the companies)...just a real "free market." I really believe that employees covered by company health insurance plans (both unionized, and not) would demand more of their employers. A la carte coverage as a start. The insurers would have to respond to that, or hit the bricks. The employer would have great leverage to make their best deal. They wouldn't have to listen to the yada yada yada of "we have to cover this, that, and the other thing." The doctors would have to get in line, too. They know what's up, and what's not. A few years ago my youngest son needed some urology tests. The tests were going to be about $900. Mrs. Andy told the Doctor that we didn't carry health insurance, and it would be cash. When the tests were done they presented us with a bill for about $400. We recently had some eye surgery done on one of our sons. It was elective surgery, but some insurers cover partial costs for the procedure. For cash, with no insurance, it was about 30% less. The doctors know. They would have to bring rates of service in line with what people can actually pay. Like Reagan said: (paraphrased) "If you think medical care is expensive now, just wait until it doesn't cost you anything!"
Dadman
Heh. I totally agree with your analysis, Andy, I just don't think it is even remotely possible anymore. Health insurance and politics are inextricably entangled. Given this reality insurance companies inclined to behave in the ways pace and Cosmic (and millions of others) have experienced should be mandated to live up to some 'good faith' or 'golden rule' standard that doesn't include rigging a system designed to deprive customers as much service as it delivers. Of course, I'm arguing for the lesser of two evils. At this point in time, more government regulation seems less evil than a government takeover of our healthcare system...
Andy
Dadman: Yep! It seems unlikely for sure. I believe that those two snakes are slithering in the same hole. Your approach is pragmatic, and much more likely to lessen the impact on the public at large. Mine is a "pie in the sky" wish list. It is an "If I were the King of the forest" deal. Sigh.
Jack
We definitely need some government regulation of insurance companies. The best reason being that medical problems and emergencies are unplanned and unscheduled. A financially responsible person should not have to live in a society where an unexpected medical problem destroys their credit due to unpaid bills or completely bankrupts them. I've been self-employed for 11 years and I carry my own insurance. Every year the premiums go up and the only way I can keep it under some kind control is to reduce my coverage; i.e. increase my deductible, drop certain services, etc. I try to stay responsible and ahead of it, but as I write this, I'm sitting on about $4000 of unpaid medical bills due to, like Cosmic, a gall bladder operation, plus I had some heart tests. The 4G is the uncovered portion of everything and I'm just not solvent enough to pay it right now. What is the answer? I don't know. But I do know that I am a responsible hard-working, tax paying, bill paying, person (like most people). And yet I have a bunch of medical bills that remain unpaid and are hurting my credit. And unless there is some kind of change, it will only get worse for me and everyone else.
CosmicConservative
I'm just tired of fighting tooth and nail for something that I have already paid for. It wears on my soul. Or what passes for a soul anyway.
Andy
Cosmic: I really do understand how frustrating this is for you. Though I've not dealt with an insurance struggle, I have dealt with a few hated enemies that really tested my soul..."or what passes for a soul anyway." You will get through it. You have persevered through worse.
mtnlurker
I am sorry but if you look at how insurance companies work you wonder how they make any money at all. I am not defending their evil practices but just from a business point of view they make no sense. They are betting that the number of people making claims is less than those who don't make claims. But society is moving in the direction of going to the doctor for everything. I just doesn't compute. My vote is for making insurance illegal altogether. I think the market would come up with a way for people to still get what they need.