Did Obama "win" it , or did Hillary "lose" it?
By CosmicConservativeOr was it a little of both?
I tend to want to give people credit when they do something well, and I do think that Obama ran a very good campaign, so although I think Hillary did a lot to "lose" the nomination, I think Obama did more to "win" it. I'd say that Obama's "winning" it was 70% to Hillary's "losing" it at 30%.
So what did Obama do to win it then? Here's my list:
1. Obama crafted a better, more compelling narrative. His "Hope and Change" message is not as easy to make successful as people think it is. Yes people are always yearning for such a message, but Obama and his team picked the right moments to present the right rhetoric to capitalize on a nation (and particularly a Democrat party) that was fed up not only with GW Bush, but with virtually all of Washington, including some of Hillary Clinton's own record. Obama is a gifted speaker and has some good speech writers. He built an early buzz and reinforced it with carefully calculated events and speeches, going all the way back to 2004, really. Sure Hillary's narrative was flawed, and that helped Obama a lot, but Obama's narrative could have been flawed too, and it wasn't. (Not for Democrats anyway, it remains to be seen if his narrative is as compelling in a general election.)
2. Obama planned for a long, bitter and divisive primary campaign. He created a powerful money-raising system for his campaign. He built both a national and a state-by-state infrastructure and had plans for each state and resources to execute those plans. Even if Hillary had bothered to campaign in many of the states that she ignored, she would have found it quite difficult to compete with Obama's forces in many of those states. The fact that Hillary ignored many states was quickly exploited by Obama's national and local resources, true, but even if she had been there, in many, probably most, cases, Obama's superior organization would still have won the trench battles, and would have bled Hillary's inferior money-raising dry.
3. Obama understood the primary and caucus system and created a strategy that was specifically targeted towards gaining as many delegates as possible. Obama gambled that the superdelegates would follow the delegates when the rubber hit the road, and he was proven right. He aggressively exploited Hillary's weaknesses in uncontested states to build large margins of victory while he battled Hillary to a near-tie in virtually all of the states that Hillary "won." The best example of this is probably Texas, where Hillary's primary victory was hailed as a major milestone for her campaign while in reality Obama actually walked away from Texas with six more delegates than Hillary did. Obama's team recognized how to play the game to win, and they scrapped for every delegate they could get.
4. Obama courted the press. Hillary simply assumed that the press would always be her lap-dogs. Obama made it a point to court key members in the media (including Oprah) and to get favorable media treatment. Once he had that favorable treatment, he exploited it skillfully. While Hillary's team annoyed the press with thousands of emails and press releases of dubious veracity, Obama's team targeted key members of the press with far more personal and engaging emails and press releases designed to win the hearts and minds of the press, not just the daily news cycle. The best evidence of this is the number of reporters and editors who have publicly complained about how the Clinton campaign had been "spamming" them with junk emails. You never heard such complaints about Obama's campaign.
5. They played the race card by claiming that their opponents were playing the race card at every opportunity. I personally find this sort of thing reprehensible, but there is no denying the effectiveness of Obama's claims that every attack on him was race-based. Any misstep from the Hillary camp that could be found was viciously exploited. Obama and his team recognized that it was not enough for Obama to simply claim the black vote by virtue of his own racial heritage, they had to explicitly separate Hillary from the black vote by convincing people that Hillary (and more precisely BILL) was actually racist. This caused the tide of black votes for Obama to become a flood and delivered him huge margins of victory (and therefore huge leads in delegates) in several key southern states. Look for him to do the same in the general election, I am sure John McCain will be surprised by how many claims of "racist" will be hurled his way by the time the general election is over.
Those are the top five ways that Obama WON the nomination as opposed to Hillary LOSING it.
Comments (8)