Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Biofuels finally getting the attention they deserve

By CosmicConservative
A CNN story on biofuels quotes an economist, a biochemist and an environmentalist. All three unequivocably say that the current rush towards biofuels is a massive mistake which could have disastrous consequences. Which is sort of what I've said all along, I believe. And for exactly the same reasons. First, it costs more to make biofuels in the temperate latitudes than you can get from them, so it makes no economic sense. Second, the conversion of sunlight into actual energy is orders of magnitude less than simple photovoltaic cells, which means that to actually have biofuels provide a significant amount of fuel, the amount of arable land committed to fuel production would rival, if not exceed, FOOD producing land use. Third, the whole business of biofuel production is decidedly anti-green. Basically what you have going on in the world right now is a lot of old-growth forest and rainforest being cut down and burned away so that biofuel plantations can be planted. Besides the net negative carbon footprint this creates, it also destroys huge amounts of diverse ecosystems around the world, most notably in southeast Asia and South America. In short, this is a classic example of liberal groupthink at work. Just like hybrid car technology. It SOUNDS good, and makes people FEEL good, but in the end it actually ends up doing more harm than good. When you see CNN doing a story on their front page that is overwhelmingly critical of biofuel production, you know we've reached a tipping point on this issue. At PRECISELY the same moment that the US Government is drafting legislation to push biofuel use even harder than it is currently being pushed. It's bad for the economy, it is bad from an energy-conversion perspective and it is terrible for the environment. It's a trifecta of environmental do-goodism unintended consequences. I'm sure all those green people are justifiable proud of their results.

Comments (5)

Dadman
I just hope we can quickly reverse the push toward biofuels before too much harm is done.
CosmicConservative
I'm afraid it's already too late for that, and these things have a natural momentum that is based on yearly crop cycles, so even if the entire world decided TODAY that biofuels need to be rethought, it is too late to replant all of the northern hemisphere crops that have already been planted. I need to dig into deeper detail but I suspect that even corn that is planted for biofuel use is not the same corn that is grown for the table. Even if so, a lot of that has already been committed to be delivered based on government mandated quotas for fuel production. As I said, these things have momentum...
Andy
Cosmic: It is possible that CNN has finally taken a "reality check (or a poll)," and found that their idiotic viewers are sick and tired of high food prices, and this ethanol madness. Don't quote me on this, because I'm not sure. But I think that the corn grown for ethanol production is the same as feed corn for cows and chickens. I'm not sure, but if anybody with some spizerinkum would stand up in the Congress right now and start quoting CNN, and the overwhelming evidence against this stupid biofuels disaster, I think the tide might turn. But it's gonna take a huge force to stop the rolling ball right now.
pace
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=91342960 If you click the 'Listen Now' link, you'll hear US Secretary of Agriculture Ed Schafer talk about the global food 'crisis'. Although he doesn't speak to the concerns cited in CC's article above, he does address the perception held by many that corn being used for ethanol fuel production is significantly responsible for food price increases. Beyond that, he speaks to the pressing need for developing countries to modernize their agricultural infrastructure. Just thought some of you might find it interesting, as it relates somewhat to the topic of discussion.
CosmicConservative
I consider these orthogonal issues. Sure developing countries need to modernize their agricultural infrastructure, heck the U.S.A. needs to. But when we are having food riots in many countries due to the high cost and short supply, for governments like the EU and the United States to mandate corn for conversion to ethanol strikes me as just about as immoral a policy as you can imagine. "I know you have starving children, but we NEED to put fuel in our cars that doesn't come from OIL!" Please.