Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Geeky concerns about new version of D&D

By CosmicConservative
So most of you can just skip this. Dungeons and Dragons 4.0 is due out on June 6th. Not a day I would have chosen to launch a new version of the venerable role-playing game. Now it's D&D on D-Day... Nicely alliterative, but not necessarily the image you really want to visualize. Here's a picture of their new Players Handbook: I'm sure I've mentioned before what an unrepentant geek I am, and no doubt that makes some readers uncomfortable, but hey, this is still my blog and on occasion I'm going to post some personal interest stuff just because I can. But I'll hide it behind a <more> tag to spare most readers. So As I said, June 6, D-Day, is D&D 4e day. (The "e" stands for "Edition"). D&D has been through several versions over the 30 or so years it has been around. It originally started as a variation of a miniature-based war game, but instead of pieces on a board and a lot of charts and dice-rolling rules you got pieces on a board and a lot of charts and dice-rolling rules with role-playing!. Why did this make a difference? Well, I'm sure there have been numerous doctoral dissertations on this subject. I think it was because when you created a unique character and started loading him/her/it down with stuff you found, won or bought during the campaigns you were in, it allowed the player to identify with the character as a virtual version of themselves, instead of just a piece on a game board. Through all the revisions of the game, that core concept has remained the major attraction of the game to me. I enjoy creating complex "backstories" for my characters, narratives of their lives, their families, their motivations and their experiences before and during their career as virtual versions of myself wandering through imaginary worlds as they encounter and overcome challenges. It's sort of like writing a novel, but without total editorial control, so even the "author" doesn't know where things are really going to go. I am one of those geeks who has a box full of stuff related to the game. I've got notebooks full of maps and characters who populate the worlds I've created, and other notebooks full of characters I have played over the years in worlds created by OTHER gamers. Some of those characters eventually became so powerful that it was difficult to find any sort of playable challenges for them. I mean when you can summon and defeat the great demon-lord Azmodius, what else are you going to fight? It's sort of the Superman conundrum, you have to start creating opponents with god-like powers, and then the battles become virtually impossible to manage as the combatants manipulate the very fabric of space and time. So I tend to play lower-level characters, characters who still have to sneak around on tip-toes to avoid waking up the goblin guards at the wrong time, and who are at real risk of actually being killed by a lucky arrow or two. Right now I am playing in two campaigns, and am running a third campaign myself. My characters are third and fourth level, which means they are still weak enough that they would have to be careful if a mob of angry townspeople decided to gang up on them. At that level each time you advance to a new level, it feels like a butterfly emerging from a cocoon. Gaining new powers or enhancing existing ones just makes you want to try them out on some unsuspecting dungeon dwellers... And that's the problem, see... With this latest upgrade to the game rules, the rumors are rampant that the designers have thrown away so much of the old game that it will be impossible to convert existing 3.5e characters into 4e characters, and so my active characters will simply become frozen in time, living forever in a notebook between clear plastic protective sheets. I'm hoping that's not the case. And to find out if it is or not, I have managed to get to play in a Fourth Edition sneak preview game this weekend. That means I'll get to roll up a fourth edition character, outfit him or her and put them through a campaign to see how it all works. Many die-hard 3.5e fans swear they will never buy the new books and will stick with their comfortable old rules, and that's fine. But I have found that over time that strategy just ends up with fewer and fewer players and fewer and fewer options. So I have already pre-ordered the books so that I'll get them as soon as they hit the shelves. Of course that means I now have a vested interest in actually liking the new rules. So I am hoping I do. I'll give you all an update when I get through.

Comments (4)

JSullins
I had actually not yet thought about whether I would try to convert my current campaign to 4.0. I guess seeing the system will help... If I do, I feel certain that some kind of way to convert characters to the new system can be concocted, even if it is not rooted in the methods for conversion provided (or not) by Wizards of the Coast.
CosmicConservative
Actually, the recommendation I've seen is to simply take your character's concept, and recreate the character from scratch in 4e. There are some rather serious caveats though. For example, the current 4e classes do not include many existing classes, like "druid" for example. Yes you read that right. There is currently no "druid" class. So druid characters would have to be converted into "divine casters" which basically means "clerics". There are expectations that "druid" and other classes (like "monk") will be added to a 4e "Players Handbook 2" but I haven't seen an announcement on when that would come out. There certainly isn't a "spellthief" class, and there may not ever be such a class in 4e. I haven't seen anything on it.
JSullins
I'm guessing those will show up in expansion books, yeah. *mutter* Guess they have to make a living same as the rest of us, though. Too bad D&D didn't go open source -- who better to maintain the system than players and DMs with no profit goals to meet? The D&D foundation could do it instead.... hmmmmm.... MEh. Then we wouldn't have the cool miniatures, probably. Guess it's time you and I create a system, eh?
CosmicConservative
Heh, we could do it, you know. Drax and I were working on something like that 25 years ago. The whole "System Reference Document" that Wizards released a few years ago was supposed to be that "open gaming" system, but Wizards hung on to too much (like the character creation process) and it has been mostly successful with commercial games, not with independent game designers, primarily for that reason. You probably know more about the GNU and Open Gaming movements than I do, but I know that there have been several attempts to create an open role-playing game system, but they've always sort of vaporized after a while. Probably because the people trying to drive it had to stop spending all their time on an effort that provided very little financial return. The biggest problem with creating a game system is that there is so much material you have to create from scratch. D&D fills up three "core" books and a dozen or so supplemental ones. The main advantage with using an existing system is that you can invite players to play the game and they can bring existing players, or take new players they create in your campaign into other games. To do a game system of your own, you really need some dedicated gaming partners who are willing to invest the time in characters that are not going to be portable. That's not as easy as it sounds. But of course I would always be willing to try. There are a lot of things about D&D that I don't like. I don't like the arbitrary class designations and the way certain abilities are tied to classes. D&D has always been "class-based" as opposed to "skill-based." Class-based systems just feel constrained to me. It is also too heavily level-centric, with so many things tied to level advancement. Again that just feels arbitrary and restrictive to me. And don't get me started on the whole magic thing. Talk about restrictive... In fact I would say that magic is about the worst aspect of the game. Maybe I should start a blog that ONLY covers role-playing games and we could discuss ways to improve the experience..