Help! I'm a snob like Obama! - By Mickey Kaus - Slate Magazine Does that mean I'm condescending too? It's hard to avoid the charge. If a Chinese Communist Party Official somehow came to me and declared that, no, China would out-compete the West while maintaining Mao-era control over free inquiry, I'd think 'You poor deluded fool. Just wait.' I support Western policies of bringing China into the global marketplace in large part because I think that means Chinese Communism will collapse even if the Chinese Communists don't realize it. Same with fundamentalist Muslims--e.g. Pakistan, when prosperous, will no longer be such a breeding ground of jihadist fanatics. They'll be too busy making money to blow up the world. My attitude toward Pakistan is roughly parallel to Obama's attitude toward rural Pennsylvanians: if the economy really delivered for them, they'd stop clinging to their God. And their guns.I would say I have to agree with all but the last sentence. And I think Mickey, like many liberals who have rushed to defend Obama's "What's the Matter with Kansas" comments by saying that it is undeniably TRUE, no matter how unpleasant it may sound, have stepped into a deep pile of steaming excrement when they then engage in moral equivalence between rural Pennsylvanians and jihadist terrorists. But they do. And they don't even seem to realize they are doing it. Or the ones who do realize it, are fine with the moral equivalence because, after all, they've been morally equalizing the terrorists with George Washington and Thomas Jefferson for a decade now, and if they can condescend to George and Tom, why not condescend to a bunch of backwoods rural hicks? Now, I guess that I also have to admit that I share some of the condescension that Mickey Kaus describes because I would totally snicker at a Chinese apparatchik who believed that communist governments could coexist with a capitalist economy. But is that really condescending to the people of China? I don't think so. And when it comes to having an opinion of a ideological zealot, I don't think "condescension" is the right word anyway. I think "disgust" or "disdain" is a better word, and although I might condescend to that person that doesn't mean that I condescend to an entire group of people. To put it another way, it is my personal belief that liberals are way, way wrong when they hold up "What's Wrong With Kansas" as liberal doctrine and claim that it is historically proven that people lose their interest in their religion when their economic conditions improve, or that they lose their interest in guns. In fact I think that the most obvious case in point that proves the complete idiocy of this position is the United States itself. The United States has for over 50 years been the dominant economic powerhouse on this planet. To be "poor" in the U.S.A. is to live a lifestyle that the vast majority of people in the world would consider to be a life of luxury and privilege. The vast majority of "poor" people in the U.S. have cars, air conditioners, televisions, radios, refrigerators, food and water and many other privileges that a poor person in, say, Somalia, would find unbelievable luxury. And yet the U.S.A. is still one of the most religious nations on earth and one of the few "Western" societies that still "cling" to the right to bear arms. So the whole liberal argument falls to pieces on that one example. So to say that providing economic opportunities to the people of Pennsylvania will vacate their churches and hunting areas seems to me to be nothing but condescension. It flies in the face of over 200 years of actual verifiable empirical evidence. So back to whether I am as condescending as Obama is. I guess that when it comes to how I view the mental acuity of your average liberal, I have to say I am guilty as hell. If they can believe this sort of nonsense, then yes, I think they are either lacking brains, or choosing not to use them.
Am I as much of a condescending snob as Obama?
By CosmicConservativeMickey Kaus, one of the few liberals whose writing is rational enough to read on occasion, has examined his own attitudes in the aftermath of the Obama "guns, god and racism" comment about rural Pennsylvanians and has concluded that he too is a condescending elitist, and that bothers him, but he can't help it.
Comments (23)