Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Another musical gem from the 70s...

By Dadman
I'm throwing down the gauntlet and just flat-out saying that the 70s was the greatest musical decade of the past century. Bring on the debate. This video will no doubt evoke a flood of memories for all the old fogeys who peruse this blog...

Comments (4)

Andy
Yea, that one's okay. I'm more of a rap fan myself.
CosmicConservative
I can't watch the video, my connection is too slow, but based on Dadman's musical taste in the seventies, I'll assume this is Leo Sayer. As a teenager through most of the seventies (I turned 10 in 1969 and 20 in 1979, so do the math) I did most of my formative music listening during that decade. However, I was fortunate enough to have older brothers who listened to sixties music and so I was exposed to both more or less equally until my junior and senior year of high school when I did most of my music listening in my car instead of through the walls of my brothers' bedrooms. The seventies are indeed a great period in rock and roll. The quality of bands like The Eagles, Fleetwood Mac, Pink Floyd, Heart and Boston have been repeatedly lauded here, and I agree that they are some of the best bands of all time. But I'm sorry, if we were to pick the absolute best band of the 70s, it would probably be The Eagles, Fleetwood Mac or Pink Floyd. And as good as they are, they can't remotely compare to the Beatles, the Beach Boys, Simon and Garfunkel or The Rolling Stones (although the Stones could also lay claim to being a seventies band...) I suppose it is technically "debatable" in the sense that someone can make assertions that have to be dealt with, but that's only in the most technical sense. Even the one-hit-wonders of the two decades strongly favor the sixties. Songs like "Something's Happening Here" or "One Tin Soldier" aren't just great songs, they have crystalized a moment in time in a way that transcends music and have become cultural phenomenae. The closest thing in the 70s had to be Don McClean's "Bye, bye miss American Pie" which was, in fact, an ode to the sixties itself. The seventies probably had better pure technical mastery, and better pure studio wizardry, and as such perhaps the majority of the music was better. But the peak music of the sixties is as good as any decade before or since. And the sixties was all about the message, and the message of the seventies was as shallow as the sixties was deep. So as good as "Peaceful, Easy Feeling" was musically, it simply doesn't have the power of "Fortunate Son" or "Revolution" or "Scarborough Fair." In fact it's really not fair to compare the two. The 60s were intense and culturally transformative, in the 70s the world more or less took a break and tried to regain its footing, and the music of the seventies reflects that, just as the music of the 60s reflects a world at war with itself. Seventies music makes me feel good. Sixties music makes me feel transported.
Dadman
It's a 10cc video not Leo Sayer. I sure hope you were kidding. I have wonderful taste in music. It's much broader than yours. I love the Beatles, The Beach Boys, and Simon & Garfunkel but I can also appreciate a good song when I hear it, even if it comes from obscure bands that no one has ever heard of. So much of the 60s music is overtly political. Not that there is anything wrong with that, but you seem to be making the case that if a song is not making a profound social or political statement it's just 'feel good' music and therefore inferior. I disagree. The 70s gave us such a variety of quality music and was loaded with gifted singer/songwriters. Artists like Stevie Wonder, Carol King, James Taylor, Jim Croce, Billy Joel, Elton John, John Denver, etc. It also gave us the rock bands you mention in addition to The Doobie Brothers, Boston, Led Zeppelin, etc. Add in genres like R&B, Funk, even Disco, and it becomes clear the 70s truly was a musical smorgasbord unlike any other decade. I am rushing through this...need to get to a baseball game. I will write/debate more later. For the record, I would rate the 60s as the second best musical decade, but given the depth, variety and quality of 70s music overall, I have to give our coming-of-age decade the nod. More later...
Dadman
For the record, it was Cosmic who was the Leo Sayer fan, not me. He would sing 'You Make Me Feel Like Dancing' it at the top of his lungs every time it played on the radio. It was really quite unseemly... ;)