Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Expelled at the movies...

By Dadman
Bueller...Bueller...? Ben Stein of 'Ferris Bueller's Day Off' fame has produced a film documenting the suppression of 'intelligent design' concepts in academic circles by what he calls 'Big Science'. The film, Expelled, is scheduled to open in 1000 theaters nationwide on April 18th. From WorldNetDaily:
“Expelled” calls attention to the plight of highly credentialed scholars who have been forced out of prestigious academic positions because they proposed Intelligent Design as a possible alternative to Charles Darwin’s 150-year-old theories about the origins of life. Instead of entertaining a debate on the merits of competing theories, the scientific establishment has moved to suppress the ID movement in a “systematic and ruthless” way at odds with America’s founding principles, the film asserts.
I have mixed feelings about the so-called Intelligent Design movement. Personally, I believe an intelligent designer was the catalyst behind the organization of the universe and the origins of life. I do not believe faith and science are mutually exclusive, but I do believe they tend to ask and answer completely different questions. Religion will tell us God is the creator of the universe and all life in it. Science will attempt to identify and explain the natural processes we can observe. Science, if you will, attempts to explain HOW God does what He does. At least that's how I view it. I believe the gaps and weaknesses of the evolutionary theory should be examined openly as part of a science curriculum without risk of suppression, ridicule, or worse. Where science fails to offers answers, such as how life itself got its start, then the open discussion of intelligent design should be permitted without retribution. The problem is intelligent design is not testable and therefore not really within the scientific domain so some realistic limits need to be placed on how far you take such a discussion in a traditional science course. And no one deserves to be punished for facilitating such a discussion in a context of academic freedom. The bigger issue seems to be the utter lack of respect, even disdain, many scientists have for the idea of God. Too many are dogmatic secularists that ooze contempt for anything outside the scientific domain. And, of course, too many people of faith are overly skeptical and critical of what science has given us. Can't we all just get along?

Comments (1)

CosmicConservative
I too have mixed feelings about this. On our drive into Kentucky yesterday we heard Laura Ingrahim interview Ben Stein on this very subject, and then we heard a couple of other conservative talk show hosts discussing it. One thing that irks me is the assertion that all of them have made that "Intelligent Design" is a "conservative" position. I don't think it is at all, it is a religious position and has nothing to do with conservatism as a political movement. My own position on this is similar to Dadman's. There is no inherent conflict between an "Intelligent Designer" and evolutionary theory. However, I do think there is a major difference between evolutionary theory and strict Biblical fundamentalism, especially of the sort that asserts the earth has only been around for 10,000 years or so. The Catholic Church has officially accepted evolutionary theory as the mechanism God used to implement his divine plan. This seems to me to be a rational position to take on the issue. During the Ben Stein interview by Laura Ingrahim I was almost embarrassed by the simplistic straw man arguments Ben Stein proposed and how he asserted that scientists simply refused to debate with him. I have to say that if he approached me the way he said he approached some of the prominent biologists or academics, I would have told him to go away too. His position boils down to this: If you can't explain to me how life began in every detail, then God must have created it. So there. The problems with this simplistic argument are so obvious and so downright lame that I call this sort of reasoning "kindergarten debating." It is not true debate, it's a simple attempt to achieve a "gotcha" on your opponent by asking a question that nobody on earth can answer and then claiming equivalence in the debate positions without examining any of the legitimate areas of debate. In short, it's an attempt to shut off debate entirely disguised as a demand for open debate. Now I don't have a problem with universities teaching "Intelligent Design" so long as they keep it as much within the observed scientific results as evolution is. By which I mean you can teach "intelligent design" as long as you don't claim to know who the designer is, what its purpose was or whether that designer was even divine or not. Nothing in the scientific data supports any divine source of DNA or species differentiation or anything. At best you can try to point out some things in the fossil record or DNA genome that seem to be hard to explain as random variation and say "see, something must have tweaked the DNA there" but to suggest that "something" is "God" is no more supportable than any other explanation, and jumping to the conclusion that it was God is simply bad science. The reason scientists and academics react so vehemently to the sort of argument Ben Stein raises is not because they are afraid of it, as Stein claims, but because they are tired of trying to explain basic scientific principles to people who are trying to twist evidence around to support their own religious beliefs, and who use pathetic attempts to skew the debate in order to do so. Even if you could "prove" that the human DNA genome could not have come about by natural selection of random mutations (which is far from proven, regardless of what the Intelligent Design proponents believe) even if you could prove that, it would not prove anything about divine origins. All you need now is an alien race with powerfule gene sequencers and a desire to muck around with Earth's gene pool a few times.