Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama's brilliant economic analysis

By CosmicConservative
Here's a short excerpt from Obama's current stump speech. This is when he descends into typical Democrat populist rhetoric of the sort John Edwards used to spew. Read it carefully because if Obama actually thinks this way, and gets elected President, we will be in a heap of trouble.
Barack Obama | Change We Can Believe In | Think about it. The top mortgage lenders spend $185 million lobbying Congress, and we wonder why Washington looked the other way when they were tricking families into buying homes they couldn't afford. Drug and insurance companies spend $1 billion on lobbying, and we're surprised that our health care premiums, and co-pays, and the cost of prescription drugs goes up year after year after year. The big oil companies play the same game, and we wonder how they're making record profits at a time when you're paying close to $4 a gallon for gas.
Here's the deal. Let's parse his "mortgage lenders" comment and see what it means. 1. Apparently Obama believes that lenders are responsible for borrowers agreeing to loans they can't afford. This is the same thing as saying that McDonald's is responsible for people buying Big Macs. There is such a fundamentally condescending attitude that it is hard to even describe how offensive it is. Basically this is a direct refutation of the fundamental concept of personal responsibility. What does Obama think these lenders do, stand behind borrowers with a club in their hand and a knife at the borrowers' throats? Those poor simple-minded borrowers are lined up like lambs to the slaughter while those evil lenders are FORCING them to buy houses they can't afford. 2. I'm not sure if they teach economics at Harvard, but if they do, they must teach a liberal, socialist version of it. Last time I checked on this, forcing poor, innocent borrowers to take loans they can't afford and will then default on is not a sustainable business model. I guess Obama has not realized that large numbers of lenders are also going bankrupt since they can't get their loan payments collected. Other than pure evil I can't imagine why a business owner would embark on a business model that was guaranteed to bankrupt himself AND all his customers. But then there you go, that's what Obama seems to think, that lenders are "pure evil." 3. Obama actually thinks that our health care prices are high because of drug companies spending money on LOBBYING? Is he really that stupid? I certainly hope this is just more class warfare rhetoric and he doesn't actually believe that drug companies raise prices because of lobbying. The research and development cost of a single drug dwarfs their lobbying dollars by orders of magnitude. Surely Obama knows this. Doesn't he? Apparently he thinks that drug companies should be banned from lobbying. 4. And then he goes after the evil oil companies. Surely that's like shooting fish in a barrel in liberal circles these days. But then again, Obama clearly believes there is some limit to what are "moral" profit levels. I wonder what he thinks about the Clinton's 100 million dollar windfalls in the past seven years? Surely that's as immoral as oil company revenues. Someone needs to ask Obama what limit he would set on profits for a corporation. What would that be? Every dollar over 10% profit automatically goes to the government? Where does he think oil companies' ability to develop new energy resources comes from? Since the government makes probably ten times as much in taxes on a gallon of gas than oil companies make in profit, does that mean Obama believes the federal government is ten times as immoral as oil companies, and he will repeal those gas taxes down to a moral level? Somehow I don't think so. The more I read Obama's words, the more convinced I am that he is either a naive idiot, or a zealous socialist or both simultaneously.

Comments (6)

Me
"Where does he think oil companies’ ability to develop new energy resources comes from?" Yeah, because they're trying REALLY hard to do this...please! They're making boatloads of money with the OIL game...there is VERY little motivation for them to "develop new energy resources" outside of government grants and tax credits. Them undermining their own source of business seems to me as bad of a "business model" as your fictional portrayal of the mortgage industry. "Since the government makes probably ten times as much in taxes on a gallon of gas than oil companies make in profit..." You're going to have to back this up with real numbers -- not skewed, messed-up agenda-driven Republican numbers -- for it to have any authority whatsoever. It's nice that you're trying, though.
CosmicConservative
Gee, "me", I guess I'll have to put you in the category of knee-jerk anti-Energy company reactionist. Here's a quote from a story on Exxon working with several partners on a hydrogen fuel cell prototype:
IRVING, Texas--(BUSINESS WIRE2)--Exxon Mobil Corporation (NYSE:XOM) today announced it is partnering with QuestAir Technologies, Plug Power Inc. and Ben Gurion University on plans to commercialize an on-vehicle hydrogen production system for use in a fuel cell-powered lift truck application. Under the arrangements, Plug Power will seek to commercialize unique technologies developed by ExxonMobil, QuestAir Technologies and Ben Gurion University that take liquid fuels -- gasoline, diesel, ethanol or biodiesel -- and convert them into hydrogen onboard the vehicle where it will be used in a fuel cell power train.
And that took me about five seconds to find with a search on Google. Now, comparing profits to taxes, the Department of Energy has this to say (I'll paraphrase for brevity): The average tax on a gallon of gas in the USA is 42 cents. California has the highest combined state and federal tax, which is close to a dollar a gallon. This puts California gas as much as fifty cents higher than the national average for gasoline. But sticking with the average, according to a 2005 analysis from the DOE, roughly 95% of the cost of a gallon of gas went into purchasing the crude oil, shipping the crude oil, refining the crude oil, producing the bewildering variety of special blends for different geographical areas, shipping the resulting gasoline and then pumping it at that station. For a $1.75 gallon of gas (not counting taxes, which is pretty close to the gas price in 2005) that means the gas companies were making 8.75 cents per gallon in 2005. (I would be very surprised if they are making more per gallon today. Crude oil prices have doubled since then, and that doubles pretty much every other aspect of the chain since all of them use energy to make or distribute energy.) Out of that 8.75 cents the gas companies have to pay salaries, pay dividends on their stock, purchase equipment, repair equipment, advertise and, oh yeah, make a profit. If they are able to spend a penny per gallon on research, that would be pretty amazing (that would mean well more than 10% of their profit going to energy research). Taxes are at least six times the profit on a gallon of gas, and in some places (like California) more than ten times the profit. Do you have any other request to educate you on basic economics? Oh, wait, I'm sure these are "messed up agenda-driven Republican numbers." Man do people like you even realize how irrational you are? How completely you have drunk the koolaid? How completely unwilling or unable you are to face reality directly without a shield of ideological zealotry in your hand, protecting you from actual facts?
Drax
Just a thought on the "sustainable business model..." If you make a loan that you think is marginal (at best) at high interest rates (which is what you do when the loan is marginal) then SELL THE PAPER to someone else, then the business model is quite sustainable for quite a long time.
CosmicConservative
Well, long enough until the people you sell your loans to realize that they're all losing propositions anyway...
Me
Glad you're so quick to label....guess that means I can call you a head-in-ass, anti-consumer establishmentarian apologist. Again...these companies certainly make overtures at "researching" alternatives, because it makes them look good and because they can get some nice tax advantages for doing so. None of them, however, are willing to undermine their own business for it...it's the same with Philip Morris' half-hearted stop-smoking efforts ("Please stop using our product...we really don't want you to...WE PROMISE!). Also, on the "cost of production" front...explain to me all of these unfortunate SEVERAL-MONTH LONG refinery shutdowns. If a commercial manufacturer like Ford or Maytag had any part of its process shut down for several months, it wouldn't survive. Yet refineries are being shut down regularly for long periods of time (for "maintenance," of course!), causing the supply to barely match demand for their product. If all of these refineries are online, doing the work they're supposed to be doing, that only increases supply and reduces consumer cost. You can't prove that it's price fixing...but you also can't prove that it's NOT. The simple fact is that people buying gas for their cars are paying more and more at the pump, while the MARGIN of profit for these companies simultaneously keeps getting higher. Obviously higher prices equate to higher profits, but why is the MARGIN increasing? If there's that categorically strong of a correlation between what it costs the oil companies to make their product and what they clear in profit (as you assert), why isn't their overall margin holding steady? [Yes, this is a rhetorical question.] "Do you have any other request to educate you on basic economics?" By the way, being pompous and condescending is not generally the best way to have healthy dialogue...not that it seems you're a fan of that. I'm actually a CFP, so my grasp of economics is, shall we say, rather strong.
CosmicConservative
Me: You don't want to be labeled, then don't post insulting ideological zealotry of this sort: "not skewed, messed-up agenda-driven Republican numbers". In other words, if you want to be treated well, treat others well. If you spew insults unprovoked, expect the same by the one you provoked. Now, instead of asserting all these evil motives to the gas companies, how about you do some research to see if you can figure it out. I'm not going to do your homework for you twice. By the way, if you don't like pompous and condescending treatment, don't dish it out. I'm perfectly willing to keep things civil, but I am tired of zealots coming here, spouting intolerant ideological claptrap, and then acting all hurt and insulted when someone does the same to them. One more "by the way". These energy companies have been begging the government for the approval to build more refineries for years, only to have "environmentalists" shut down any such requests. I suppose the environmentalists are in collusion with the energy companies to keep supply down. I don't care what your credentials are supposed to be, your ideology is trumping your education.