Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Interesting tidbit about genocide

By CosmicConservative
In the recent debate about whether the Ukraine should be allowed to join NATO, Russia's vigorous opposition has opened some nasty old wounds. Among the nastiest of these is the Ukranian's charge that Soviet Russia committed "genocide" against the Ukranians in the 30s when tens of millions of private land-owning farmers were forcibly starved to death when soviet armed forces came to villages and took all the grain away. Here's the deal. Russia is arguing that it wasn't genocide because it was class-based not ethnicity-based! Now I can't quite figure out what bothers me more, the idea that Soviet Marxists would argue that the murdering of tens of millions based on class is somehow not as heinous as murdering tens of millions based on race, or the fact that the Leftist apologists for Soviet crimes seem to accept this argument as having merit.
The Associated Press: Russia: 1930s Famine Was Not Genocide MOSCOW (AP) — The 1930s famine that killed millions of peasants, mainly in Soviet Ukraine, should not be considered genocide, Russia's lawmakers said in a resolution Wednesday. Renowned writer and Soviet-era dissident Alexander Solzhenitsyn backed the Kremlin line on the divisive issue, dismissing Ukrainian claims that the famine was genocide as a "fable." The 370-56 vote in Russia's lower parliament house and the rare comment from the 89-year-old Solzhenitsyn were a pointed rejection of claims by Ukrainian leaders that the Soviet authorities engineered the famine to target Ukrainians. They came amid Russian anger over the pro-Western Ukrainian leadership's drive to join NATO, which will decide at a summit this week whether to grant the nation a road map for membership.
There is something profound here, and profoundly frightening. What this tells me is that the Soviets are effectively saying that although it might be horrible to murder people due to prejudice it is apparently understandable to murder people based on their being an obstacle to progress. Because that's what they are saying if you dig into the rhetorical roots of this argument. "Look, it's not because we HATE you that we're going to kill you and twenty million of your peers, you see you're just in the way of our ideological goals is all. It's nothing personal you see. Geezus criminy! If anything that's MORE creepy, and just as evil! It is a never-ending source of amazement to me how people can reveal such deep insights into their evil nature without even realizing it, because they've already rationalized it as not being evil to themselves! This sort of "meh, they're in the way of progress, the world is better off with them dead" attitude is not restricted to Soviet Russia in the 30s, I've seen similar sentiments stated by eco-nutzos in the Global Warming debate. Scary, scary stuff people.

Comments (1)

Bob Hawkins
In the early days of the Revolution, there were of course innumerable late-night bull sessions about the glorious path ahead. But a disturbing point came up that couldn't be argued away. Communism would require 100% buy-in. And you never get 100% of people to agree on anything. The solution to this problem was simple. "Look, we really need only, say, 90% buy-in. We kill the remaining 10%." So the revolutionaries themselves proved that mass murder is inherent in the Revolution.