Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

These boots were made for Mongolia...

By Dadman
So, fate has taken me down the odd path of extreme cold weather boot shopping. It's certainly a path I didn't expect to be on as the weather heats up here in Phoenix, but in just a few short months my son will be facing a winter in Mongolia and temperatures approaching -40 F. He's going to need some warm boots and I think these will do the trick... boots.jpg We are told he can purchase a parka at the Ulaanbaatar Black Market for about $35. Sounds fun...

Comments (13)

CosmicConservative
I've only been in such extreme cold-weather situations while ice-fishing up in the high Rocky Mountains (Lake Granby area actually) where we got to at least -30 one day. I happen to love my Sorels. I've had them forever, they are still solid, still waterproof and still warm and snug at any temperature I've encountered. If you are looking for cold weather tips, here is what I can offer. 1. There are few things as important as good boots. Many boots "look" warm, but actually don't perform that well. The main thing that you need for a warm boot is good foot circulation so your warm core body blood keeps circulating to your toes, and good waterproofing, so that your warm toasty toes aren't wet. And don't discount the importance of the boot breathing, because foot sweat can build up and reduce the insulating power of the boot considerably. Boots with a lot of insulation sometimes end up doing two things that are counter-productive to warm, toasty feet. First they compress the insulation because there's just too much of it. And compressed insulation performs poorly. Secondly, they compress the feet which reduces blood circulation, and no matter how good the insulation is down there, if you aren't circulating nice warm blood to your toes, they will eventually get cold. 2. Hats. Now I know that due to my lack of hair up there I am particularly sensitive to losing heat through the head, but this is where most people lose heat without realizing it. Even if you wear a hood, you will be throwing that back frequently. A good gore-tex head covering is worth its weight in gold. The gore-tex is both wind and weather proof. The one I have is like a souped up ski mask. I wish I could remember what it is called, but its design allows about ten ways to "rig" it so that you can combat successively colder temperatures comfortably. Gore-Tex is good stuff. 3. Coveralls. I am amazed at how much warmer I stay in frigid conditions when I don't have any cold air circulating through breaks in my clothing such as between pants and jacket. I wear a pair of neck-to-ankle coveralls that are not very bulky, but are weatherproof and well insulated (with Holofil, I think, which is a synthetic goose down replacement). Wear a good snow jacket over the top of a pair of Carharts and you'll be toasty warm just about anywhere. 4. Gloves. This is another area where people make the mistake of buying gloves that are too big and bulky. Usually all a big, bulky glove does is encourage you to take the dang things off anytime you need to do anything that requires the slightest amount of dexterity, such as get your car keys out and try to unlock your car. There's usually two ways people deal with this, one is to wear two pairs of gloves, a light leather one for dexterity and a big bulky one for cold protection, that way they can take the big glove off without exposing their skin to -40 air. Another way is to wear medium gloves with tighter fingertips, and have big bulky mittens to put your hands in when you aren't using them. Either way the real key is to keep your skin itself from direct exposure. I could probably offer more suggestions. When I used to ice fish I learned how to dress so that I could sit on the ice in frigid temperatures for hours at a time without serious discomfort.
Foobarista
If UB is like Beijing or other North Asian cities, there'll probably be an area where Russian traders set up shop. There, a typical Westerner can buy stuff that actually fits, and doubtless plenty of cheap cold-weather gear. (Mongolians are taller and heavier in build than many Chinese, so this may be less of an issue in Mongolia than it is in most of China) When I lived in Beijing, everyone thought I was Russian since I ended up mostly wearing Russian clothes, especially in the winter. They weren't the height of fashion, but generally well-made and rugged.
Dadman
Thanks for the pointers. So far I've been most impressed with the Sorels and North Face brands. I'm specifically looking at boots rated to -40 F.
CosmicConservative
Meetings finally over... whoooo... I'm a Sorel fan. Love those boots. Mine are twelve years old, and still just as good as they day I bought them (actually better, 'cause they're broken in). Which is something else. I know this may sound crazy for Phoenix, but have him break the clothes in before he heads out. Walk around the block a few times in the boots. (I always do that whenever I buy new boots or shoes). Do some exercises in the clothes, figure out how much range of movement he has. I learned some unpleasant lessons about such things the first time I went ice fishing and I almost had to disrobe entirely to use the restroom. (I know, TMI...) I'm not a big fan of parkas, btw. I think the ones I have tried on have had an inefficient bulk-to-comfort ratio. Meaning their bulk is usually not needed to stay warm, and it just makes it harder to move and get things done. Usually when I was ice fishing I was perfectly comfortable just in my Carharts, Sorels, ski mask thingy and a fairly light gore-tex jacket to keep the wind and spray off of me. I usually also had a hat with a brim and sunglasses to keep the sun and snow glare from killing me. In fact in many cases when the sun came out, I'd have to unzip my Carharts to let out some of the heat that built up. OK, I keep saying "Carharts" because everyone knows what "Carharts" are. Actually when I bought my ice fishing outfit, I could not afford Carharts and so bought a second-tier brand that is "just as good" called "Key" if I recall. Basically it's an insulated coverall that zips up the legs for easy boot access. Mine have proven to be just as good as the Carharts. BUT, I also bought a pair of "Redball" boots that were supposed to be "just as good" as Sorels, and they lasted one winter before I had to replace them. And that's when I bought the Sorels. This is going to sound crazy, but my personal experience has been that higher technology and less bulk has been far better for keeping warm than you might think. Spend the money on Gore-Tex, that stuff is AMAZING! Buy GOOD socks too, don't get the big thick socks, they tend to just compress your insulation and your feet. I've got a pair of thinsulate socks that are maybe a little bit thicker than regular cotton athletic socks, but they keep my toes nice and toasty. Just some thoughts.
Andy
Dadman: Don't throw anything at me... They don't ride bicycles in -40 weather, do they? I'm really curious how the mission work goes...mostly walking, I hope...plus public transportation maybe? Or in bad climates like that do they sort of invite people to indoor venues for rallies, etc.? I really am curious, if you know. I lived in cold country for a while (-15 is my most frigid memory). Wal-Mart snow boots worked pretty good, and Cosmic is right about thinner gloves. The ones that remind you of a foam NFL "we're #1 finger" are so bulky that you end up with them off as much as on. Hat, Hat, Hat! Don't know if it's true, but I once heard that 90% of heat loss is through the top of your head.
CosmicConservative
Andy: If you don't wear a hat, you'll lose 90% of your heat through your head. But most people do wear a hat. Problem is that they don't wear an EFFICIENT hat. And what strikes me as funny is how many people wear poor hats, boots, and other winter wear because they don't want to LOOK funny. They'd rather freeze their butts off than look like they're cold... I've especially seen this on ski slopes... And then they come in to the warm areas acting like they just blew in from Siberia when they could be warm and toasty all day long if they didn't prefer looking fashionable. It's like the kids who won't zip up their jacket at the bus stop because "it's not cool." Nope, it's not cool, but it's WARM! But you ask a very good question. Hey Dadman, how much walking and outdoor stuff is he going to do in that weather? And will he be able to use things like bicycles? If he's out walking all day, then I have to really reiterate my whole "look out for the over-bulky approach" because carrying a bunch of extra weight or having to work harder to make clothes work against each other is just going to make him sweat, and that will make him cold. I know you think I am crazy, but think OPTIMAL not MAXIMAL when considering how to outfit him. Which brings me to layers. I've mostly only talked about my outer clothes in the cold. And it has to get REALLY cold for me to break out the thermal underwear, but I can promise you this, walking all day in thermal underwear is something you have to work up to. If you try it without breaking things in and acclimating your skin to it, you can develop some amazingly unpleasant blisters or sores in the most inconvenient places. Layers, layers layers... Thinsulate vests over or under a coverall can do wonders to keep your core body warm, and if you are walking, your arm and leg motions tend to keep your arms and legs warm. Does the church have guidance for things like how to dress, based on input from the last group who went there?
Dadman
Well, I personally rode bicycles in temperatures darn close to -40F in Sweden, but I think in Mongolia the missionaries rely on their feet, public transportation (which I understand is typically PACKED with people) and/or taxis. It is within the realm of plausibility that my son might also ride horses in some of the more remote regions of the country. Native Mongolians frequently ride two-humped camels to get around, but I doubt the missionaries will be doing that. Camels bite. Overt proselytizing is evidently not allowed in Mongolia, however, missionaries are allowed to teach and preach if asked or approached. Much of the work they will be doing will no doubt go through Mongolian church members which number approximately 6000 at present. As I've said before, my son will also be teaching English classes to Mongolians, but will not be permitted to mention a word of religion during those classes. That's about all I know for now...
CosmicConservative
It still sounds like such a great opportunity to learn and experience life. Heh... the closest thing to that in our family was my daughter's six months at Disney World. And that just sounds like a bad comedy routine... ;)
Dadman
My son has lived a life of relative priviledge so I expect this experience is going to be eye-opening and life-changing in a good way. I worry for his safety, but I am learning Mongolia is a relatively safe place to serve a mission. The government and people are basically friendly toward Americans. America embodies the liberty and freedom they've just recently gained. Economic opportunity is a nascent concept. The primary risk he will face is the abject poverty that is so prevalent throughout the country and its attendant crime, disease, despair, etc. Alcoholism is rampant, as is public inebriation, and missionaries are frequently approached or victimized by drunks, panhandlers, and pick-pockets. Of course, this is true in many, many missions. Now that I've had some time to noodle on this mission call, I think I'm grateful he's going to Mongolia as opposed to a country like Brazil where crime and homelessness is also rampant, as are diseases like Denge fever. Anti-gringo, anti-U.S. sentiment is also quite prevalent south of the U.S. border in Mexico, Central and South America. Not so in Mongolia...
Andy
Dadman: Thanks for the info. You really rode a bicycle in sub-zero weather? You're my hero. That is interesting stuff. It is going to be truly life-changing for the boy for sure. But I'm a pansy. I would put in for a transfer to Orlando...it's not like the real US either.
Dadman
My son likes a good challenge and he's looking forward to this one. His background in distance running, I think, will help him get through this. To use a running analogy, this mission will be like a hard 15 mile run that at times will hurt and be unpleasant, but each step forward will also make him stronger and crossing the finish line will bring with it an enormous sense of accomplishment.
Dadman
Yes, I did ride my bike in sub-zero temps on roads slick with ice and snow. Wipe-outs were a daily occurence and were actually the source of a great deal of hilarity - my first winter in Sweden. During my second winter in country I bought a bus pass...