Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Autism awareness

By CosmicConservative
As the parent of a high-functioning autistic son, I am hyper-sensitive to stories on autism. In the past few weeks I have seen what can only be described as a "media blitz" about autism. There are stories about autistic adults, autistic children, parents of autistic children, supposed links between autism and the MMR vaccine given to children at the age of fifteen months and stories about the "joy" of being a family with an autistic child. I won't comment on that last one, except to say that I can only imagine that autistic individuals are as individual as non-autistic people and there is not much value in reporting anecdotes instead of data. All such stories do is make families whose autistic experience is NOT "joyful" feel guiltier than they already do, which is to say the guilt goes from white-hot into the ultra-violet range. I'm not entirely sure why autism is suddenly the beneficiary of this media blitz. I will say that I have actually found some stories that have provided me with additional information and (hopefully) opportunities to help our situation. Perhaps autism will finally start receiving the funding and social network support that families need to survive. I sure hope so. I do hope people without autistic family members are reading these stories with the same critical eye that they apply to other stories. The media tends to try to deal with things like autism by looking for the "positive human interest" story, and so you end up with stories like the autistic boy who was "allowed" to play in a basketball team when the game became meaningless and who scored a dozen or so baskets in a row. What most people read in a story like that is "Oh, how heartwarming, that boy is really something." What I read in a story like that is "Typical situation, the autistic boy is on the team for some PC purpose, is more or less ignored as a team member for the entire season, is finally put into a game when the game doesn't mean anything by a coach who finally feels an urge to "coach" the boy only when it won't affect the win/loss column and then everyone swoons when the boy doesn't drool or wet himself on the court. What a wonderful story."

Comments (5)

Andy
Cosmic: Yep! My "very mildly" autistic son is almost 12 years old now. He is almost my size, and still can't tie his own shoes. Bathroom time is still an adventure. But we are very fortunate. He is a sweet boy. He is quiet and introverted in many ways. He is not hard to manage now. He actually called today from school and left a message on my answering machine. It was unthinkable a few years ago that he would be able to put a full sentence together and have the presence of mind to end the message with "thanks, I love you." He gets better year by year. But I know that our experience is the exception. He started Soccer practice today (that's what the phone call was about). He finally wanted to sign up for athletics. I was thrilled. I know about as much about soccer as I do about quantum physics. Well, I know that they are both very "boring" subjects that may have valuable outcomes. The teamwork, and running won't hurt him at all (plus the fact that he is ambidextrous might work well with soccer...we'll see). You are right about the media approach to autism. It is kind of like their approach to Downs Syndrome, or Leukemia Kids. The media shows the "glowing" moment in the sun for these children. They don't show the other 99.99% of the situations that handicapped children, and their parents face. I know (kinda) where you are coming from in your disdain for the medias' coverage of this subject. Do you think it would be better if the media just ignored the subject altogether? Or does the "heart-warming, fuzzy, feel-good" coverage in the media push our society to try to find cures, treatments, or at the very least "compassion" for autistic people? Dang it...why did you put this post up?
CosmicConservative
Yeah, I probably should steer clear of this subject, I make every effort not to get too personal on this blog because I don't care to bare my soul to many people, much less Google's infinite archives... My problem with these "glowing moment" stories about autism and other conditions is that I think they are actually counter-productive to the goal of educating people about autism. When that's what people hear and see about autism the impression they get is "well, isn't that a special moment." And they go away thinking that autism may not be all that bad, if such glowing moments can come from it. Why, autism must not really be that difficult at all. In my experience dealing with autism has been a challenge that is best left undescribed because there's no real point to such personal revelations, they only come across as self-indulgent or self-pitying and neither does any good for anybody. I just think it generally downplays the difficulties families actually deal with. My personal opinion is that if the "average" family actually realized what families with autistic individuals have to deal with, they would be very sobered by the realization, not entertained by it.
Kevin in WI
Andy and Cosmic, I am constantly amazed at how small this world can seem at times. I am the father of an 11 year old girl who is high functioning autistic as well (Aspergers to be precise). Our daughter also has ADD, which compounds things (although medicine definitely is helping with that). She did soccer this last fall for the first time. She played on a 3rd/4th grade team, even though she was in 5th. Its tough watching your child struggle out there all season when all of the other kids get it but she doesn't. Andy, it's interesting that you mentioned bathroom time. Our daughter is challenged by that stuff as well. Those are the things that most people don't think about when they think of Autism. There are always reaons to count your blessings though. When my daughter was in Pre-K (early childhood development classes) to "catch up" and get ready for kindergarten, one of the girls in her class was severely autistic. The sheer compassion, strength, and determination her parents showed was inspiring. I always think of that girl when I start feeling sorry for my daughter and feel my life is difficult. I think that, even though most kids that are autistic are high functioning, the media will always focus on the "classic" severely autistic kids. That's easiest to categorize or stereotype, and that's just what the modern media does.
CosmicConservative
It is a small world indeed. And a capricious one. Let me just say that I had always been suspicious about religion, but my belief in the overall indifferent and capricious nature of the universe had mostly been an academic analysis up until then. It has since become a visceral one.
Andy
Hey Kevin, Thanks for the heads-up on soccer. I went to my sons' practice today. I tried to watch discreetly, but he saw me. He thought it was time to go home...sigh He did really well. He can run with all the other boys, and can kick the ball where he wants to (with either foot). The only problem is that he ended up playing for the other team twice...he's gonna need some instruction on that (obviously). The coach was really cool, and patiently got him back on his own team. This is going to be interesting.