Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Big Lie: We Can Solve It...

By Dadman
The Goracle has emerged from his hole in the ground and is back on the doom-and-gloom trail. According to Gore, civilization's days are numbered. The beady-eyed eco-prophet and his Orwellian-esque Alliance for Climate Protection have launched the 'We' climate advocacy campaign designed to radically change the way we live (although that's not how they frame their objectives)...
MSNBC.COM - Gore unveils $300 million warming campaign Nobel prize winner and former Vice President Al Gore launched a three-year, $300 million advocacy campaign calling for the United States to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions. The "We" campaign by Gore's Alliance for Climate Protection will combine advertising and online organizing with grassroots groups. It is aimed at educating the public about global warming and urging solutions from elected officials. ...the advertising campaign will equate the climate-change movement with other grand historic endeavors, like stopping fascism in Europe during World War II, overcoming segregation in the United States and putting the first man on the moon.
The campaign's website is www.wecansolveit.org One of the most offensive aspects of Gore's rhetoric and those that drink his kool-aid is this idea that tossing our incandescent bulbs, or buying a Prius, or burning my corn oil instead of eating it is somehow morally equivalent to defeating Nazism and Japanese imperialism. It simply isn't and framing the argument in such a way in monumentally disingenuous. I believe Gore does this on purpose to drive home the false premise that we are facing a 'climate crisis', it's a matter of life and death, and it's our fault (primarily America's fault). Once you've convinced the world of these three things draconian levels of government control over our lives and our economies begin to seem reasonable. We've almost reached that point... I continue to believe the idea that we can somehow modify the global climate is nothing short of a big lie. We can no more change the climate of this planet than we can stop the subduction of the continental plates. It's amusing Gore waited to announce this campaign until one of the coldest winters in recent memory had officially ended...

Comments (49)

Boyd
I have to confess, I just bought a Prius, but in my defense, the catalyst for that decision makes my choice highly defendable ... defensable ... whatever. Here in Virginia, if you get "Special Clean Fuel" plates on your car, you can drive solo in the car pool lanes (with some exceptions, but I don't use the roads the exceptions apply to). I got tired of being stuck in rush hour traffic on the Dulles Toll Road watching the cars zoom past me in the HOV lane, so I decided to buy a hybrid car to use for commuting. While my fuel costs are less than half of what they were when driving my Explorer (which I still own), it's still more expensive for me to buy the Prius and pay for the lesser amount of gasoline. So I didn't do it to save money. I don't really care if I use less gas (other than the costs, which I already addressed). I just want to drive in that HOV lane. Which I do. Laughing. At those other poor shlubs poking along in the backed-up traffic. Oh, and I was surprised at the Prius's amenities. As a gadget-hound, there's plenty of stuff in the Prius to stroke my geekiness, such as automatically connecting to my cell phone via Bluetooth when I start the car. I still giggle whenever I think about it.
Dadman
Nothing wrong with a Prius. Just don't buy into the nonsense that you're saving the world...
CosmicConservative
I get particular amusement from people who buy electric cars and think they are "saving the world." I guess they think electricity grows on trees. Something like 70% of U.S. electricity comes from coal-fired power plants. Another huge chunk comes from natural gas. Hydro-electric, wind and nuclear combined are less than 20%. So for the most part, if you are driving a Prius or another "hybrid" car, all you're doing is moving the CO2 you generate from the street to the smokestack. And since the Laws of Thermodynamics more or less dictate that changing energy from one form (heat) to another (electricity) to another (mechanical) loses efficiency in every step, each mile a Prius drives actually puts more CO2 into the air than a well-designed gas driven car (like a Toyota Corolla) which converts heat directly into mechanical energy in the internal combustion engine. And that's not even talking about the serious environmental consequences of running around in a vehicle with two dozen lead-acid batteries full of sulfuric acid and, well, LEAD that all need to be disposed of. In fact the dirtiest little secret of hybrid electric cars is that it is economically unfeasable to replace the batteries when they wear out so the great bulk of these cars are going to be junked, and all that lead and acid is going to end up in landfills or worse. In effect they are 'disposable cars.' This is a typical consequence of "feel good" solutions to real world problems. As far as Al Gore and his global crusade is concerned, the volume and credibility of dissent is growing daily. It snowed at my house this morning, and we are expecting more snow this week. The temperature in Denver this morning was 22 degrees, and they are predicting snow in Denver. This has been the coldest, snowiest winter in the last twenty years throughout Colorado and much of the West. More and more I am hearing people snicker when they talk about Al Gore and his quest.
Andy
Cosmic: I'm no science brainiac (obviously), but I have heard often that every "ice age," whether major or minor, is preceded by a rapid "warming" period on the planet. It looks like the "global cooling" crowd back in the '70s might have been right. Buy a snowblower, and tell the Rockies to put a roof on Coors Field.
Boyd
I care not about moving the source of energy (and its waste) around from one place to another. I only care about being able to drive in the carpool lanes. :)
Kevin in WI
I think that the fact the fact that the Goracle had to undertake this propaganda campaign is that he realizes that: 1. The American people aren't really buying it. 2. REAL science to beginning to win out. I think that time, plus constant media alarmism, will strengthen these facts until "Global Warming" is thought of by the average American the same way the macro-economy is: Its just an awful mess and "someone" should do something. But,I don't see a problem in my life, so I'm not going to worry about it enough to change MY habits or plans.
Dadman
The problem is when politicians and legislators begin buying into the lie. They have the power to enact laws, regulations, restrictions that can have an immediate and profound impact on the way we live and our quality of life. This is one reason it is so disturbing when I hear McCain speak of reversing climate change, or when I learn Newt Gingrich has signed up to support Gore's latest propaganda crusade.
CosmicConservative
I agree with you on this one Dadman. The rush to judgment on this by politicians is one of the most frightening examples of the abuse of authority in goverment that I've seen in a long, long time. If even half of the proposed legislation to "combat Global Warming" were to pass, the world economy would come to a screeching halt, and the "Great Depression" of the 30s would no longer be used as the historic example of global economic despair. Which, I have to say, seems to be exactly what a significant number of these folks want.
bernie
Why doesn't the Gore website allow e-mails? Could it be that they would be flooded and globally warmed over the coals by a deluge of e-mails that disagree with their foolish premise and conclusions?
Dr. Malcolm Betruger
These eco commie Nazis only exist because of the sheer volume of "useful idiots" mass produced by libs in the education sector. Compare Venus and Earth's C02 atmospheric volume. Venus = 96% C02 Earth = .038% C02 After a century of Economic growth, C02 doesn't even account for 1/10% of the atmosphere. When we compare the correlation of the effects of solar radiation vs C02 levels on artic temperatures, C02 is almost inconsequential, while solar radiation is directly related. These mongoloids don’t get that the sun has cycles, and the highest recorded temperatures occurred during the Middle Ages, during a high period of solar radiation. Hopefully we will have evolved further than our homo moronic ignorectus liberal foes before the sun actually starts to swell up and burn the earth to a crisp. They’ll still be running around like Chicken Little praying to statues of their eco commie Nazi al gore god, trying to breath as little as possible.
HERMAN A. GARRETT
When I was a child scientist said that the earth was getting closer to the sun and one-day it would crash into the sun and burn up. Since that didn’t happen, we can burn the earth a little at a time especially, if we can scare the hell out of people and make millions in the process. Converting freon ( R-12 to R-134 ) drove the price of R 12 from 99 cents a can to $30.00 a can. When politics got into it with the ozone scare, it made millions for big companies. The global warming study did not have a weather scientist on it but general electric had a reprehensive. Prove me wrong!!! NASA is in charge of some of the atmosphere research and on a TV program the spokesman said that it takes 125 to 150 years for earthly actions to reach the ozone layer. At the end of the NASA television program the question was asked, ”what if you are wrong”? The answer was,” we will formulate another theory”. I can go along with that. The methane emissions from both ends of cattle and sheep are causing so much concern in government that it has ordered researchers to find ways to cut down on the emissions from livestock, which account for about a quarter of the methane – a greenhouse gas 20 times more powerful at driving global warming than carbon dioxide. We must hurry because, based on the facts given, I concluded that a mule farted in Georgia during the civil war and blowed a hole in the ozone layer 800 miles above the north pole.
paranoidial
Warming was the best thing that happen to the earth in the 800's - 1,000's. Crops flourished, positive change occured and ogres went bye-bye. that warming was made by God. This new warming is by Gore's mind. (he did invent the internet after all.) And I hope everyone remembers that Gore was the lacky that was put forth to steal our souls, money and brains. Loss of soverignty fit in there somewhere.
youpeopleareinsane
I can not believe the lack of knowledge and obscene amount of ignorance displayed on this subject. Maybe you all should look a little deeper into the science and you will find out that Global Warming is real and needs to be addressed, not for you, not for me, but for everyone who is going to be here after us. Americans are buying into it...as they should. You all are just wrong and quite insane.
CosmicConservative
So, Youpeople... The problem is that our position on this subject IS BASED ON THE SCIENCE instead of being based on a powerpoint presentation put together by a politician who could not even carry his own state in a national election. Just so you know, it's May 13 and I've got a foot of snow in my yard. Global Warming? Not so far as I can see it.
Drax
youpeopleareinsane: Sheesh. Cite one souce (one...singular) from a reputable scientist on Global Warming which doesn't have many other reputable sources which refute it. Just one. That would be a start on any "dialogue"on this subject. Failing that, accept the following two premises: 1.) Whether Global Warming is even OCCURING is not a matter of settled science. (Science is based on FACTS...not "consensus....") 2.) IF Global Warming is occurring, the question of its CAUSE is further unsettled. Man, Sun, some other factor yet unknown? There's a REASON why the posts here may rankle you and that's because the people who routinely write here are INFORMED not INDOCTRINATED. We accept as a premise that Global Warming MAY be occurring. We accept as a premise that it MAY be caused (in part) by Man's activities on this planet. But, before we take drastic, life-altering, economy-altering, country-altering steps to counteract what "might" be happening and which only "might" be caused by Man's activities, we'd like something which even remotely resembled PROOF.
CosmicConservative
There is virtually zero chance that Mr. "Youpeopleareinsane" is ever going to come back and read these rebuttals. As with most zealots he's not interested in dialog, just demagoguery.
Drax
CC: That's one of the most disturbing things about the liberal mind-set...not necessarily what they "think," but that they refuse to even accept the notion that any other view of the world has any credence, indeed, anyone who holds a contrary point of view is not only wrong, but is evil, and, therefore, has no thoughts worthy of consideration. This is the result of several DECADES of thought indoctrination in our public schools and, even moreso, in our halls of "higher education." What is being taught (and, even as important, what is NOT being taught) in our schools boggles the brain of any person who has anything which resembles a critical mind.
CosmicConservative
Three options: "Wrong", "Evil", "Insane". Liberals tend to push all of these, even citing "scientific evidence" to "prove" that conservatives are mentally defective. It's a favorite pasttime of theirs. Conservatives tend to think of Liberals as either childishly naive about the world, or else as closet socialist/communist totalitarian drones. Both sides could do a lot to improve their opinion of the other. But at least conservatives don't try (yet) to criminalize liberalism, or define it as a mental defect.
Dadman
There are really two questioins and they need to be separated and addressed individually. First, is global warming real? Well, it just might be. I would not necessarily dispute that, although some of the data are conflicted. The second question is the more important one I think - what is causing global warming? The Gorale's legions, and folks like 'youpeopleare insane' seem to be convinced (why, I'm not sure) that humans are causing global warming that is potentially catastrophic and that we can actually do something to 'address it'. They seem to discount the earth's history of natural warming/cooling cycles claiming that what we may now be experiencing is somehow different than the warming that ended the last ice age. With respect to this second question the science is much less clear and definitive. The correlation between human activity and global warming is tenuous. Our activities may be doing nothing to warm our world and it is far from clear that any impact we may be having is potentially catastrophic. This is a scare tactic of the Left, pure and simple, designed to force the hands of politicians. Further, there is little or no evidence the 'drastic action' advocated by climate crisis alarmists would have any impact at all on our complex global climate. Global warming might be real, but all the rest is a bunch of nonsense...
SOLOMON AZAR
Today on june 9th 2008-I was deleted by wecansolveit.org- the organization looking for alternative energy for america has deleted me- the man who solved the energy crisis- why- because i say I am a messenger of god you want your cake and eat it too- you want life exactly the way you want it and not told by another you dont pick your messengers- they are chosen- i had enough- i have now endured 13 months on this net being deleted by every arrogant organization run by humans and just regular folk like you who have always ignored my messages since my time upon the net- well i am done with your stupidity- let your oil prices go up- let your food prices go up- watch your economies crumble- see your jobs lost- get rid of all your pet animals as you cannot feed your family and pet dog as so many are giving them to the pound- I have come openly with a solution 13 months ago only to be ignored- now a gluttonous world playing on the internet shall all learn how primitive man is and must be civil to one another- instead of shunning someone bringing forth a solution- in the months to follow- you will learn there is no alternative fuel- panic mode will set in very soon- when you understand clearly how important energy is- i guess your arragance will stop and just implement my scientific deeds - as for my messenger duties- it will make sense in time- all is well- but it will only get better after your destruction- i am sorry i have to say this- but it is I who has now watched you completely ignore and ridicule a man of god- as always you will learn the hard way- time will tell solomon azar
bob
the points you guys are making are correct but short sighted. you have to understand that the world does go through cooling and heating periods, but this one is much more rapid than any other. Secondly, hybrids are better than gas cars for the environment because they require no charging from another carbon-emitting source (coal or gas fueled house, for example.) However, electric cars are highly beneficial if used with a wind or solar power source. Every major scientist in the world agrees that global warming is a major problem and a threat to the human lifestyle as we know it. The world's poorest people will be effected by this, not to mention animals and ecosystems. There is a huge amount of evidence for this claim, and saying that it isn't true is simply ignorant. I am begging everyone on this sight not to close their minds to new information and scientific evidence, because it will take efforts from everyone in the world to make an impact on this issue, not just the blue half of the map.
CosmicConservative
Bob: OK, just some quick refutations of your assertions: 1. This cooling and heating period is somehow unique in its speed. This is not supported either by the ice core records nor the historical record. Temperatures plummeted in just a few years during the "little ice age" and rocketed upwards during the "Medieval Warming Epoch." Your assertion is just that, an assertion. 2. Hybrids "require no charging from another carbon-emitting source". What the heck do you think you are talking about? Hybrids are either charged by electricity from the grid, 80% of which is from carbon emitting sources, or from the gas engine itself, which is also carbon-emitting. What "non-carbon-emitting sources" do you think hybrids use? Harry Potter's magic wand? 3. Electric cars are highly beneficial if used with wind or solar power? Sure, I'll buy this, when wind or solar power becomes more than 2% of the electric power supply in this country. This is pure fantasy stuff. 4. "Every major scientist in the world agrees that global warming is a major problem." Your ignorance of how many, and how prominent, scientists challenge global warming dogma is not my problem. Go do your own research. You can believe Al Gore all you like, that doesn't make it true. 5. "The world's poorest people will be affected by this." Prove this. The reality is that in the past several hundred years the world's poorest people have been precisely the ones who have benefited MOST from warming periods. But somehow THIS alleged warming period is supposed to be the exact opposite of every other warming period humans have ever experienced. 6. "A huge amount of evidence" like the alleged increase in hurricanes which did not materialize, like the fact that 1998 is still the hottest year on record, like the fact that the earth has cooled a record .5 degrees in the past two years. What you mean is "huge amounts of evidence that you will accept." 7. You talk about closed minds, and you are absolutely oblivious to the fact that the only closed mind on this subject here is yours.
solutionsnothype
Here's something else that cracks me up about the greenies. They yack on and on, with no understanding of energy thermodynamics, and point to solar and wind. If solar and wind were truly economically viable solutions for baseline power, wouldn't it seem logical that the big bad, fat cat executives down at the power company would prefer both solar and wind to coal, gas, oil, nuke, whatever? I mean, while they are down at their corporate offices lighting their cigars with $100 bills and schemeing about how to screw the little guy, don't you think they'd prefer to have a power source that you don't have to pay any money for the fuel source?? If the fuel is free, and the technology still can't pull it's weight in a power sense, that tells me it 'ain't there yet.' Besides, once the solar winds slow down and we start getting tagged with deep cosmic rays again, thus increasing cloud cover and lowering the earths temp, solar power will REALLY be up a creek.
coincidentally, another guy named bob
-As an independent I think many conservatives are really discrediting their arguments against Global Warming, when they refer to liberals as "foes" and then vilify them by describing their nefarious past-times. - In addition many of your contributors have made comments that are frightfully delusional, for instance the fellow who describes the educated class of this country as "mongoloids" , a term that hasn't been politically correct since the 1930's, goes further to discredit himself, the mentally retarded, and those of mongolian descent, than he does to discredit global warming. -Politicizing a scientific debate is dangerous to begin with. And it appears that no one contributing on this site is a scientist, and that many of the opinions, facts, and statistics are borrowed from resources that are completely un-cited. People who remain unconvinced by these arguments are then subject to acrimonious name-calling. This is not a healthy debate, and will not change anyone's mind. -If anything is going to be accomplished on this web-site, then the work of credible scientists who believe in global warming needs to be analyzed, and brought into the conversation. -I apologize if I have offended anyone, as my goal is only to suggest ways that could make this debate more fruitful and enlightening for those of us who have still not fully made up our minds about climate change. I look forward to all of your responses to my opinion within the coming days.
CosmicConservative
Another Bob: OK, I'm not a "scientist" but I do have a degree in Physics. Most of the contributors to this site have at least one college degree, most of them in something other than liberal arts. I'm pretty confident that my regular contributors are on solid scientific ground with pretty much everything they said about global warming. Are you actually accusing conservatives of "politicizing a scientific debate?" when Al Gore has quite literally made a (very lucrative) CAREER out of politicizing Global Warming? Anyone who could objectively look at the "debate" would conclude in a heartbeat that the "politicization" of the debate is almost entirely on the LEFT where you have people passing actual LAWS based on the claims of "Global Warming Science." So spare me your lectures on this subject. It has been my experience that the great majority of acrimonious name-calling in this debate is coming from those who believe in AGW, not those who challenge it. When is the last time you heard a Global Warming Challenger accuse a Global Warming Advocate of committing actual "crimes against humanity?" This is a common charge from the Left. Believe me Bob, I have analyzed the work of scientists who promote their Global Warming claims, and I find it lacking. I find it lacking for these and other reasons: 1. All the supposed evidence in ice cores and plant fossils that is supposed to show a link between CO2 and warming periods actually shows that the warming virtually always COMES FIRST and then the CO2 levels rise. This is demonstrated quite vividly by many of the very same graphs that these scientists use to "prove" the link between CO2 and Global Warming. Yes there does seem to be a link, but in my opinion these scientists are somehow reversing the rules of causality. 2. I know what the impact of C02 is in its actual thermodynamic properties for increasing heat in the atmosphere and it is MINISCULE compared to things like water vapor. In fact I know exactly how the computer models are written to CREATE a completely UNPROVEN "catalyst effect" which is SUPPOSED to cause the water vapor to increase. There is ZERO empirical evidence to support this claim, yet it is FUNDAMENTAL to the whole AGW "science" since it is that catalytic effect which is supposed to "multiply" the effect of CO2 on atmosphere. 3. It's been over ten years since Al Gore and his ilk predicted as much as a 20 foot rise in seal levels IN TWENTY YEARS BOB!!! And the sea has not risen significantly in that period. Now they are saying that we'll see sea levels rise that amount in the next fifty years or so, and yet at the same time the earth's temperatures have actually COOLED in the past three or four years. In fact 1998 is STILL the hottest year on record. 4. I tend to look at the sun as the primary soruce of heating on the planet earth because, you know, the sun provides ALL of the heating in the first place. It seems to me, and research backs this up in spades, that earth's temperatures are PRIMARILY IMPACTED by solar heating and cooling cycles. And in the past five years the sun has entered an almost unprecedented period of quiescence. In fact there are now some very credible scientists warning that if the sunspots don't return soon, we might see another "Maunder Minimum" scenario where global temperatures could drop dramatically in just a few years. This has happened before. So Bob, don't presume to lecture me on my or my contributor's knowledge of Global Warming. I think we've got our facts pretty well straight for the most part.
omniglobal
So much discussion on the issue of climate change is conducted in a vacuum, and in the spirit of competitive 'Me versus Thee'. This is not the appropriate approach to such a potentially profound issue. Rather, it must be approached at the most fundamental and lowest common denominator, factual level in order to first determine it's veracity. Fact, logic, and rationality must prevail in the deliberate absense of emotionalism, egoism, etc. In that spirit, I offer the following observation: My benchmark on the question of the relative and proportional effect that mankind may or may not have upon the environment: Prior to the advent of the steam engine at the inception of the industrial revolution, humanity's contribution to air pollution, and thereby carbon dioxide levels, consisted primarily of small scale wood fires. Virtually nil in terms of pollution. Since then, our contribution to air pollution and CO2 in particular has increased at an ever increasing rate. Roughly 200 years later humanity operates billions of internal combustion engines, thousands of fossil fueled electrical power plants, and countless other sources of CO2 and other pollutants. These sources are pouring literally billions of tons per annum of substance into the atmosphere that otherwise, 200 years ago, would not have been present. How could it be otherwise when we are consuming (combusting) ~87 million barrels of petroleum per day, that did not exist 200 years ago (and that's just the U.S. consumption, not the world total by any means). I wonder how that might compare to the total pollution of a modest volcano eruption (?) If you take a look at a space photo of the earth and it's atmosphere, you'll observe how shallow a corona the atmosphere is, particularly relative to both the diameter and landmass of earth. In consideration of the obvious degree of change, and relative to the short time frame of approximately 200 years, I cannot see how mankinds presence / activities would not have a significant impact on the earths atmosphere, in all probability to our own detriment. This has been demonstrated to be the case relative to pollution of the Great Lakes, large rivers, ocean bays, coral, the whale and fish populations worldwide, toxins in and genetic mutations of fish, frogs, and birds. I fail to see why anyone would want to presume the same could not be true of the atmosphere. As to one writers reference to the absolute CO2 content in terms of an absolute percentage: The absolute percentage is not what is relevant; background levels (pre industrial revolution) were in the mid 200 ppm by most accounts. Now we are up to nearly 400 ppm. We do know CO2 is 30% higher than it has been for the past 650,000 years. The biggest contributors are industry and transportation. Please see the highly relevant study at the link below: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/4467420.stm I am not in the least partisan about anything. I just think we all need to get away from the 'we believe / they believe' mentality and deal in bedrock information. Also, regardless of any correct answer to the human contribution conundrum, it is beyond any reasonable doubt that if we clean up our act relative to the atmosphere and the environment in total, that we would do nothing but benefit ourselves, people with asthma and allergies, fuel source comsumption as well as consumption of other resources, and economic benefits in the process. A win / win / win proposition overall if we go about it properly without undue political interference. J.
CosmicConservative
Omni: Your post is very well written, and very polite, but it is factually incorrect in several areas. Here are a few key ones. 1. The notion that humans have been pouring billions of pounds of CO2 into the atmosphere more than during pre-industrial days is a point I will concede, although I believe wood fires and slash and burn farming were putting a lot more CO2 into the air than you think prior to the internal combustion engine. But that's not the question that needs to be asked. The question is whether human activity produces more CO2 than natural activity and that answer is a strong and decisive "no." One volcanic eruption can pour more CO2 into the air than years of human CO2 production at today's rates. There is plenty of evidence in the ice core and other sources that CO2 levels have been MUCH higher than they are today due to strictly "natural" activities. So it isn't enough to say that humans are generating more CO2 therefore we must be having a negative impact. You have to PROVE that impact and that has not been done. 2. There is no doubt that human activities on this planet are having a detrimental impact on the natural world. But if we are going to "save the world" there are plenty of obvious, proven areas where human activity is having a seriously detrimental impact NOW that can be PROVEN. Let's start with fisheries depletion, or rainforest clearing as the two most obvious examples. Another more insidious impact humans are having is the reduction of topsoil levels worldwide. ALL of these are proven impacts that we KNOW will cause serious damage to the earth and most likely to human food supplies. Focusing on the POSSIBLE impact of an UNPROVEN thing like CO2 production the way we are is not only foolish in itself, but it has dangerously deflected attention from those true environmental disasters that are happening TODAY.
omniglobal
Thank you. I appreciate the promptness, content, and tenor of your response. In the course of such discussions it is daunting to attempt to be encompassing of absolutely every relevant point. Therefore I may at times fail to be inclusive of points which I would truly have preferred to wrap into an articulation. Kindly bear with me if I occasionally addend and amend my remarks. As to the question of CO2: From yours above: "The question is whether human activity produces more CO2 than natural activity and that answer is a strong and decisive 'no'". I must differ with you on this question / answer by a few degrees. Firstly, the question is not whether or not mankind generates 'more' CO2 than natural sources. The question is to what degree do we create a piling-on effect on top of all natural production. The earth and it's atmosphere it is well established go through many and various cyclical changes, even though the details of exactly their nature may be somewhat obscure. If natural production, in it's cycle, is at a crest point, and we add billions of ton on top of that, the possibility of triggering an upward spiral of escalation that creates a mega-cycle which takes centuries rather than decades to dissipate is a real possibility. Something else that doesn't seem to crop up in these discussions is that there is a significant differential of effect between any singular event of modest and limited duration, as opposed to a continuous stream contiguous over an extended time period. It would seem that, scientifically, the thermal capture / retention effect of CO2 high in the atmosphere is well established. That high(er) levels of CO2 disallow re-radiation of cumulative sun thermal energy back into space. The science of climactic cycle is not so well defined, however, it is accumulating foundational information at an ever-increasing rate, and the information, circumspectively, would appear to support the general conclusion that some form and degree of climatic evolution is occuring. It seems to me that it behooves mankind to negate any role we might possibly play. Non-contributory natural cycles are utterly beyond our control, but, considering what we know about natural equilibrium, the obvious thing to do is to exclude ourselves from the equation, then sit on our hands so-to-speak and continue to just observe. I actually do not burden humanity with blame / recriminations for any contributory corrution of the environment. Rather, it should be viewed as a natural learning curve. You see, mankind existed on earth for tens of thousands of years before coalescing the critical mass kernal of accumulated knowledge necessary to then begin to step out and step forward to progress in his quest to make his existance more palatable, comfortable, and assured. We are in fact just over the threshold into a new era never before known to man in recorded history (not allowing for believers in Atlantis). Viewed in retrospect, the learning curve over the past few hundred years, particularly the last 200, has been nothing less than breathtaking . The path ahead is frought with potential pitfalls. Mankind is presented with challenges on every front. From population to all forms of pollution / corruption of the environment, to food production to energy source to social assimilation and prospective international integration, to preservation of the natural wildlife ecosystem. But I have little doubt that all could be effectively dealt with in due course and time; What does concern me is the will, willingness, and cooperative spirit necessary, particularly on the global scale. I heartily endorse every one of your citations of known insidious sources of pollution / corruption of the environment. Some are gradually being addressed, others not yet or not sufficiently. As an aside but relevant to outcomes of the present pollution debacle: In our time (not exclusively), many around the globe find fault with the United States and it's thusfar dominant role in virtually all aspects. My intent here is not to laud or excuse the U.S. in any way or for any purpose, but rather to set a proper context. As far as anyone knows, we, as individuals, are concieved, gestated, and born, not by our own choosing but seemingly random. We choose not what era into which we are born, what family, what country, what cultural context, what religious context, etc. (religious persons need not jump on this, I am not attempting to make any theological statement). Every ship has a bow, a midships, and a stern. None choose their position or role, yet they are what they are non-the-less. Similar is true of the origin, destiny, and histories of nations, particularly those of greater freedoms. No one in the year 1700, or 1800, or even 1900, would ever have dreamed that the United States would be what it has evolved into, for good or ill. The fact is, however, historically, that the U.S. has befallen to it to play the role of the bow of the ship. This is not to say that no human intent has played any role what-so-ever, but no role-players individually or in concert collectively could possibly have brought about the aggregate outcome of where we, the U.S. and the global peoples, are today. Asia and various other regions constitute the midships, and the so-called 'third-world' bring up as the stern. So be it. This history is not a conspiatorial script. It just is what it is. It evolved rooted in a myriad of circumstantial elements and impetuses. What concerns today is the path into the future and how it may be affected and / or impeded by stale prejudices rooted in a past which cannot be amended or corrected. This prevails even within the borders of the U.S., never-mind the rest of the World. The citizens of the U.S. need to awake and arise from their apathy and comfort spoiled lethargy and restore honor and forth-right-ness at all levels of society. From being frank and direct and corrective about negative, uncivilized behaviours at any age (especially children), to the corporate world and their scheming to rope the general populace into debt so they can increase profits, with full knowledge of what they are doing, and skimming huge sums out of corporations about to fail under their stewardship, to the political arena of telling people only what they think the populace wants to hear and doing entirely otherwise once in office. All these things are symptomatic of a society wide, and deep, loss of honor and ethics, and even etiquette. The above is what is at the root of American difficulties, inclusive of international relations and respect, as honor has taken a back seat to objectives and eroded to the point of being virtually unknown or unrecognizable in the transactions amoungst men of our day and age. To put it simply in an age old phrase: 'Shame on them !' But shame they know not. They just plan their next subterfuges, be they economic, social, or political. Shame on them !, for acting with such utter disregard for the welfare of their fellow man, acting soley for monetary profit rather than for the common good ! And to wit, I am NOT religious, or political. I follow only reason which is dictated by the realm of our existance , the lessons of history, and the common sense that even though we are all truly solitary individual beings in the ultimate analysis, we are still all better off working for, contributing to, and warmly embracing any and all things which constitute our common good. Cheers.
Drax
I don't think that there is any question that Mankind adds to the CO2 that nature produces. That's really a kind of "Duh," mental exercise, isn't it? Instantly remove Mankind from the equation and the total CO2 produced will be less than it was prior to that instant. Thus the "Duh." That, of course, doesn't really mean much does it? The question is how much CO2 would nature have produced absent Man's presence in comparison to how much CO2 nature produces with Man's presence. As CC noted, we have geological records which answer, in great degree, this question, i.e., there have been times in the past absent Man's significant CO2 creating presence which have produced a higher percentage of CO2. Further, we have to ask ourselves a couple of questions on the risk/reward table as a matter of the future survival of Mankind: 1) While it may not be a settled matter, is the risk of "global warming" is a sufficient threat that we should take reasonable and rational steps to reduce the potential of causing it IF the proponents of "global warming" even APPROXIMATE being "right?" 2) Assuming there is no global disaster of whatever kind, at some point, ALL of Earth's non-renewable resources will be used up. At some point, the sheer number of people on the planet will become too numerous to feed. When that will occur is immaterial. It WILL occur. With that thought in mind, do we take steps which require a high state of technology and of energy consumption which might lead to extra-planetary settlement or just sit here until the Earth is a hollow shell full of starving people? Putting these two questions together leads me to the conclusion that, regardless of who is "right" or "wrong" in the "global warming" argument, we should take rational and reasonable steps to reduce our CO2 output WHILE doing what we can to increase the level of technology and energy output so that we might one day actually be able to leave this planet before it leaves us. But, that's just me.
CosmicConservative
OK, you say that the science of the impact of CO2 in heating the atmosphere is "well established." Indeed it is. And it has been established to be miniscule compared to other gases in the air, primarily water vapor and methane, both of which have impacts which are orders of magnitude higher than CO2. In fact the direct impact of CO2 on atmospheric heat retention is so low, that the global warming models have introduced a "multiplier effect" to produce the results they get. This "multiplier effect" has NEVER been proven scientifically, it is STRICTLY an artifact of the models. Secondly, the link between CO2 and warming is well established, but the link clearly shows that in the past CO2 rises have FOLLOWED temperature rises, not preceded them. In other words CO2 rises in the fossil record appear to be the RESULT of warming, not the CAUSE of warming. Most of the rest of your post smacks of modern Luddite-ism and anti-Corporate bias. You can ASSERT that modern Americans are lazy, self-absorbed and ignorant, but that does not PROVE any of the above. I challenge all of those notions. You also say that it behooves humans to somehow exist without having any impact on the world they exist IN. This smacks of idealism of a level that brooks no discussion. Common sense would seem to indicate that it is not possible to live in the world without impacting it, especially at the population levels we have today. That sort of thinking leads directly to proposing population controls and draconian legislation that risks returning humans to a stone-age existence. Here's the deal Omni. I love the world. I love the environment. I believe that humans should do everything WITHIN REASON to protect as much of the natural world as is possible. But what is "within reason" is precisely what is debatable. I live in the mountains in Colorado. I hike, fish and used to hunt extensively. I believe that humans are PART OF the natural world, not some sort of infection that is destroying it. Humans are, in my opinion, the MOST IMPORTANT life on this planet, for a variety of reasons. The most important responsibility we have on this planet is to provide a living environment that is suitable for HUMAN BEINGS. In fact I would even go so far as to say that there is very little reason to protect the earth at all except for the fact that HUMANS live on it. When another intelligent species evolves, I'll throw them into the mix, but I am not a PRESERVATIONIST. I believe that the world goes through changes, some of them quite severe, and that the impact humanity has on the earth, although considerable, is not REMOTELY comparable to the impact of a single super volcano, or asteroid collision or glaicer-thronged ice age. It is my personal opinion that humans are doing our best to be as responsible about the earth as we can be. Things have changed dramatically in the past fifty years in terms of human awareness of the environment. Since 1960 the United States has dramatically cleaned up the environment, and I expect that will continue into the future. Our current use of fossil fuels is a geological eye-blink. Within fifty years I expect fossil fuel use will likely decline dramatically. Within 100 years there will likely be very little need for fossil fuels at all. This is a problem that TECHNOLOGY WILL SOLVE because cheaper and cleaner energy technology WILL HAPPEN. A hundred years ago the major cities on this planet were facing an environmental crisis of gargantuan proportions. Experts predicted that large cities like New York would have to be evacuated entirely. Entire eco-systems around cities were being wiped out. The crisis threatened the very cultural basis of western civilization. The crisis was horse manure. Cities were generating so much horse manure and were so unable to deal with it that people in New York City were complaining of health problems. Businessmen complained about not being able to walk to a meeting without getting horse manure on their suits. The manure was washing into the sewers and entering the ecosystems where it was killing all the local fish. This was a HUGE PROBLEM. It was solved by the internal combustion engine. And now we have a similar problem with the internal combustion engine. It will also be solved by technology. Without draconian legislation that forces me to live in a cave.
CosmicConservative
Drax: A couple of thoughts on your post. It is not clear to me that it is inevitable that humans will "use up" our non-renewable resources. According to the estimates I've seen, if you include oil sands and oil shale in the available oil reserves, we have enough oil to satisfy current consumption needs for a thousand years or more. It is likely that in the next fifty years we will have energy technology that makes most of our current coal and oil power plants obsolete. In fact you could argue quite well that we have had that technology for fifty years in the form of nuclear power plants, but that we were unable to pursue them because of the misguided, ill-informed fears of precisely the same people who are now generating global hysteria over coal and oil power plants. Sometimes I just have to shake my head and laugh at the cosmic irony of the world... Anyway, if we do replace our cars with electric or hydrogen fuel cells, and our power plants with wind, solar, nuclear and fusion, then it is highly unlikely that we'll ever run out of oil because consumption will drop to the point that by the time we run out, we'll be importing all we need from extra-terrestrial sources. I try to explain to people what a transformative event an actual economic, feasible fusion power plant will be. I sometimes think that there aren't a hundred people in the world who realize what will happen when fusion power becomes commonplace. The whole world will change. Geopolitical realities will shift dramatically. Geoeconomic systems will be completely reshaped. Countries like Saudi Arabia will no longer have anything to export. On the other hand, with practically free energy, Saudi Arabia will be able to desalinate billions of gallons of water and convert the desert into farmlands. Energy is everything. Fusion, especially in the form that is powered from simple surface WATER supplies, changes energy, and therefore changes everything. Fifty years after fusion is finally feasible, you will not recognize this world. It will either resemble the Earth of Star Trek movies, or else it will be thrown into violent, destructive world war. But it will be completely different. People will look back at the global warming hysteria as a charming and humorous historical footnote.
Drax
I'm unconvinced. I continue to look at it in a risk/reward frame of mind. With the emerging nations consuming more and more as they become industrialized, the industrialized nations birthing hundreds of millions of more mouths to feed, the ability to provide energy and food for this ever-increasing appetite WILL diminish UNTIL technology "maybe" catches up. I HOPE that technology catches up before we reach a point that it doesn't matter, but I wouldn't risk the human race on that HOPE. Instead I would do just as I said...take rational and reasonable measures to reduce the CO2 output as a hedge against "global warming" and put as much money and research into finding a way off this rock before it's too late. If I'm wrong, then what's the harm? Conversely, if you're wrong...
CosmicConservative
The "If I'm wrong, what's the harm" argument is one of the worst arguments ever made. That's the argument that religious people use to try to convert people to their religion. Besides, there isn't a whit of difference between your approach and my approach with the possible exception that my approach puts a lot more emphasis on developing the actual technology that will make CO2 spewing engines obsolete as quickly as possible. I have no problem with cutting back on consumption, in fact I've done exactly that in my own life. I just consider that to be the normal market approach to the reality of dwindling resources so I don't try to "solve" it since it will solve (and is solving) itself. In other words, I think the world is doing precisely what you suggest Drax, only they are doing it without being forced into it by global governmental fiat. And technology will catch up. In all of human history the safest bet that has ever existed is that technology will solve a problem. It always has.
Drax
I agree that the world is, due, in great part, to market forces, doing exactly what I suggest that it do. However there are some on both sides of the argument who argue that we should not do so. Some "global warming" proponents would seem to argue that (and some actually do) the world would be better off without Mankind, or, at the very least, a Mankind who has the carbon imprint of a caveman. Some "global warming is a fraud" proponents argue that we should completely ignore the potential for global warming, letting the "invisible hand" guide us exclusively without any restraining interference by the State. As to the "worst argument..." Sorry. It's a "risk/reward" argument. It may bear some relationship to a similar "risk/reward" argument made by some who wish to influence someone to accept a particular Godhead, that doesn't minimize the validity of the ARGUMENT. Unless you dismiss out of hand the possibility of ManMade "global warming," or dismiss out of hand the possibility that population pressures and energy needs might outstrip our ability to cope, then a such an "risk/reward" evaluation is NECESSARY. One may come to a different conclusion AFTER making that evaluation, but any rational person will make that evaluation.
CosmicConservative
OK, now for the fun part. Arguing about the argument. Heh.... this takes me back. OK, just 'cause I'm bored waiting to go pick up the Cosmic Wife from the airport, I'm going to demonstrate why your argument is invalid. You say: "If I’m wrong, then what’s the harm?" OK, so what is the harm if you are wrong? At the very LEAST there is the lost money, time and energy in pursuing a pointless endeavor. Add to that the Law of Unintended Consequences and pursuing a pointless endeavor may have actual real-world negative consequences. What kind of consequences? Who knows, that's the nature of unintended consequences, they are unpredictable. Your argument semantically tries to present your side as having ZERO downside, when in fact there is a clear downside, although we can argue what the degree is. OK, now the "Conversely, if you’re wrong…" OK, say I'm wrong, and that we do have the risk of running out of fossil fuels and may not develop a replacement technology. All that means is we hit the "wall" in a shorter time, but we still hit the wall. In fact, in a macro-cosmic perspective, the potential existence of a few more generations who live before that wall is hit is pretty immaterial to anyone but those few generations, isn't it? So the "harm" in my approach is that we'll hit the wall sooner, which will likely have the impact of ramping up our contingency plans. In fact, you could even argue that aggressively running out of oil will provide powerful incentive to replace it, where reducing the use of oil will provide some incentive to delay the pursuit of replacements. You pretend your argument is binary, that there is one "good" and one "bad" answer. That is not remotely true. Both sides of the argument have a near-infinite variety of potential outcomes, and frankly neither you nor I are smart enough, or knowledgeable enough to "know" which one has the more positive impact in the long run.
Drax
The risk/reward test is one which is used in every walk of life. In the law, it is set forth by Restatement of Torts, a risk/benefit analysis of a product/activity compared to the utility of the product/activity and the cost of prevention of injury -- among other factors. In other words, the law uses a risk/benefit analysis to determine what standard of care someone must adhere to, i.e., if you store dynamite on your property, it doesn't matter WHO is at fault for the explosion...you pay. This is because the known potential RISK (death, potentially many deaths) is so great that it ALWAYS outweighs the benefit of dynamite or the cost of preventing the explosion. Accordingly, when it explodes, the landowner is held STRICTLY LIABLE, i.e., he has NO defense. The same risk/rewards analysis when put to storage of a less dangerous item would result in a lesser standard of care to be required, or, at the very least, allow a defense to be presented. That is what I'm saying. If the "global warming," "population explosion," or "we're running out of resources" advocates are correct then the potential harm is the possible extinction of the Human Race. That's a pretty big potential risk, and, as such, REQUIRES that, UNTIL those people are DISPROVEN, steps be taken to prevent that outcome. It's not as if we have Bible thumpers standing on the street corner screaming "The End is at Hand!" There are hundreds and thousands of reputable SCIENTISTS who are advancing these theories. As you say, neither of us are smart enough to know the answer. I'll go even further and assert that NO ONE is smart enough to know these answers. (Well "smart" isn't the right word, I don't think. Perhaps it's just that no one KNOWS ENOUGH yet...) And, when you don't know...with the potential risks so high...I tend to think that PRUDENCE is the order of the day.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I couldn't disagree more. In fact I see you using some of the same exaggerated rhetoric that the Global Warming advocates use. "Extinction of the human race" indeed. Such statements are not really debatable because they are simply assertions of an emotional belief. Believe me, no matter what happens in the future, the human race is going to be VERY hard to drive to extinction. Using such terminology does in fact put you in the same company as the "bible thumpers." Last time I checked, it is not up to people to DISPROVE wild assertions. If I say purple dragons are going to invade the earth and eat all the humans, it is not up to YOU do disprove that, it is up to ME to prove it. Thus it has always been, and always should be. The truth is that Global Warming has not been PROVEN, and in fact is on just as shaky scientific ground as the Global Cooling scare of the 70s. In fact the earth has cooled significantly in the past decade, with the largest single year drop in temperature ever recorded in 2007. All of this coincides (as would be expected) with the solar sunspot cycles, and it is no coincidence, imho, that the recent cooling coincides with a dramatic decline in sunspot activity. In fact there are more and more solar physicists and climatologists who are warning that we are far more likely to be facing a new ice age than we are to be facing the "extinction of the human race" due to a few parts per million increase in CO2 levels. So my rebuttal to your assertions about the "risk/reward" analysis is that you are enormously exaggerating the risk, and are enormously minimizing the reward. The truth is that every previous period of global warming on record has coincided with a huge increase in human productivity, leisure and economic activity. There is a reason for this that can be understood with a quick look at any globe. The way the northern hemisphere is arranged, the WARMER the earth gets, the MORE arable land becomes available. Siberia and Canada are currently mostly forest and tundra. But if the earth were to warm a couple of degrees, the TWO LARGEST COUNTRIES ON EARTH would become suitable for growing vast amounts of grain and other foodstuffs. Which is exactly what happened in the middle ages and many historians believe and have published studies supporting the contention that the "Medieval Warming Epoch" (a period where temperatures were higher than they are today) was DIRECTLY RESPONSIBLE for the Renaissance. So spare me the prophecies of doom and gloom. Not only has Global Warming NOT been proven, but it has been EQUALLY unproven that if it WERE to happen, that it would be BAD. In fact it might be VERY good for the human race. It has been every other time on record.
Drax
I'm not an advocate for "global warming." I would have thought that was clear by now. Sigh. When you have thousands of scientists who assert that the future of the human race is at issue, I'm supposed to IGNORE that? Nah. I think I'll pay attention and advocate that we take reasonable and rational steps to prevent the doom and gloom that THEY proclaim. How far to go with those "reasonable and rational" steps depends on how RELIABLE those claims are. Currently the proponents of "global warming" haven't CONVINCED me of...well anything. By the same token, those who assert that their claims are nothing but fever dreams haven't convinced me of THAT either. Science can't even predict reliably weather patterns hours or days ahead. I find it difficult to believe that they can predict global weather patterns with such precision that they can reliably predict the "doom and gloom" that they are predicting. But, again. They MIGHT be right -- or close enough to right that it doesn't make any difference. That potential urges me to be PRUDENT and take reasonable and rational action to prevent that outcome. I HARDLY think this makes me a "bible thumper" on this issue. Sheesh.
CosmicConservative
Drax: Any "scientist" who asserts that the "future of the human race is at issue" should be drummed out of the scientist fraternity at the first opportunity. Such boundless exaggeration of reality is about as anti-science as you can get. Even if you believe the absolute WORST about Global Warming, you end up with a lot of flooded cities and loss of a decent chunk of land. That might lead to significant migrations of populations, and maybe (although highly unlikely) some deaths due to disease or starvation, but I doubt you can find a single credible scientist who would predict that Global Warming will "kill" even 1 billion humans, much less wipe us out entirely. By your logic we should have followed the recommendations of some of these VERY SAME scientists 30 years ago and dusted the north and south poles with carbon soot to capture more warmth to offset the coming apocalypse of "Global Cooling" that was then all the rage. Just think where we would be now if that logic had prevailed and we had TAKEN the steps those same "scientists" were pushing back then. So forgive me for not rushing to judgment based on these same people now saying exactly the opposite. By the way, I do think you have totally fallen for the algorentian lie that scientists have reached some sort of global consensus on Global Warming. All evidence I have seen is that whatever consensus there may have been a decade ago is coming apart at the seams as the first significant predictions of Global Warming Alarmists have had a decade to appear and have not done so. The sea has not risen. The hurricanes have not increased. The world has not entered a global drought. Yes, there are some indications that glaciers are still retreating, but last time I checked that has been true for the past ten thousand years. I know you are not a global warming alarmist, but it looks to me like you've bought some of their propoganda.
CosmicConservative
Just one more point. There is very little in this life that has as little impact on my view of the universe as the statement that "there is a consensus of scientists." The history of science itself is NOTHING if not a steady revelation of how scientific consensus gets overturned by inconvenient facts and data. "Scientific consensus" is a meaningless term. Science is not determined by consensus, and if it were, we'd still be worshipping gods who drag the sun across the sky in a chariot. The idea that scientists are smarter or have more common sense than, say, plumbers, is a convenient myth propogated by scientists. Scientists are no more, nor less susceptable to groupthink, peer pressure and downright ambition than any other human being. When your funding hinges quite clearly on whether you adhere to the current "scientific dogma" or not, it should come as no surprise that scientists adopt and accept things on faith and without basis just like anyone else. Just look at string theory if you don't believe me.
Drax
I guess you haven't been reading my posts. I am not convinced of either the FACT of "global warming" nor (it follows)of the CAUSE. I think that I stated this. Yep. I stated this. In this thread. Others are. Many thousands of others. Many thousands of scientists who make their life work the study of such things. Certainly (and thankfully) there is a large (and growing) number of equally reputable scientists (perhaps more so since they risk reputation and funding to take this stand). While I have not stated this in THIS thread, I have certainly stated it elsewhere on your blog. Do we take a head-count? Figure out which scientific argument is right by the number of adherents? Or, perhaps we should simply ignore one side of the argument just because another group of scientists disagree with the first group? You take your path; I'll take mine. And, yes. When, in the '70s a large group of scientists warned of global cooling, we needed to listen to them. And we did listen to them. Half-heartedly, of course, since that group was relatively SMALL in comparison to that which we face now over "global warming." The "science" surrounding that theory was relatively short-lived and (in scientific time-frames) quickly discarded. As stated in Time Magazine (1974): "Climatic Balance. Some scientists like Donald Oilman, chief of the National Weather Service's long-range-prediction group, think that the cooling trend may be only temporary. But all agree that vastly more information is needed about the major influences on the earth's climate. Indeed, it is to gain such knowledge that 38 ships and 13 aircraft, carrying scientists from almost 70 nations, are now assembling in the Atlantic and elsewhere for a massive 100-day study of the effects of the tropical seas and atmosphere on worldwide weather. The study itself is only part of an international scientific effort known acronymically as GARP (for Global Atmospheric Research Program)." While the scientists appear to have been wrong, 70 NATIONS took them seriously -- spending millions, perhaps billions on the question, as well they should have. We have to go with the information we currently have. Our POLITICAL leaders are POLITICAL leaders and HAVE to rely on our SCIENTISTS for the SCIENCE. Those charged with protecting us against such minor things as our potential destruction could just ignore thousands of scientists warning of it, I suppose. Not very sporting of them to do so, to my thinking.
Drax
Oops. This: "Certainly (and thankfully) there is a large (and growing) number of equally reputable scientists (perhaps more so since they risk reputation and funding to take this stand). While I have not stated this in THIS thread, I have certainly stated it elsewhere on your blog." Should be this: "Certainly (and thankfully) there is a large (and growing) number of equally reputable scientists (perhaps more so since they risk reputation and funding to take this stand) who are unconvinced of either the fact and/or of the cause of global warming. While I have not stated this in THIS thread, I have certainly stated it elsewhere on your blog.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I think you and I are much closer in both our beliefs about Global Warming and our tendency to want to have as little impact as possible on the environment simply as a matter of principle. But the thing that keeps me coming back to your arguments is not that you are reaching the wrong conclusion, but that you are taking the wrong path to get there. In my (not so)humble opinion. You keep stating that somehow Global Warming portends the extinction of the human race. This is pure and absolute nonsense. In fact there is a growing group of scientists who absolutely BELIEVE in Global Warming who are speaking out publicly against Al Gore and the alarmists for precisely that reason. Exaggerating the threat in order to score political points jeopardizes the actual science at work and the good, ethical scientists realize that. This is why when the U.N. committee predicted 20 foot ocean rises a group of scientists released a press release saying that the ocean rise was likely to be an ORDER OF MAGNITUDE LESS. Frankly the more anyone, including you, insist on using such dramatic, but obviously scientifically ridiculous, statements, I won't take ANYTHING they say on the subject, because they AREN'T CREDIBLE. Discuss the CREDIBLE threat of Global Warming and I'll listen. Talk about "extinction" or "destruction" of the species, and I'm going to call you on it. That is NOT the danger, and pretending it is is 90% of what I find abhorrent in the debate. So tell me what effort we should put into addressing the REAL risks of Global Warming, not the pure fantasy ones, and we'll have a much more pleasant discussion.
Drax
You see, where we take different forks in the road is somewhere around "potential results if they're right." You SAY (and others SAY) that the potential of "global warming" is nothing to worry about, and, to the extent there IS anything to worry about, not to worry about it because technology will solve whatever problems which currently exist or are later created. Others SAY that there is a clear and present danger that if drastic action isn't taken NOW that the potential IS the destruction of the human race by rendering the planet uninhabitable or by causing such upheaval that it may as well be. Both sides present what they believe (and have hundreds and thousands of scientists swear to) establishes their argument. Frankly, I tend to believe you and the others who SAY the first rather than those who SAY the second. But, I'm not CONVINCED either way. But, I LEAN towards the notion that Man is eminently capable of destroying the Earth, or at least making it uninhabitable. I've SEEN the air of San Diego, Los Angeles, Virginia Beach, Pensacola, the coast of France, Spain, Greece, Turkey, Italy...as we pulled in from air which wasn't so thick that you could spoon it with a spork -- into a place where you could. I've been treated to "smog alerts" in Los Angeles and issued surgical masks in Tokyo. I've had the pleasure of walking over rivers of open sewers in the Phillipines and Thailand where the destitute sat waiting in a boat until some sadistic tourist would throw a coin into that sewer so the waiting peasant would dive for it. And that was 20 years ago. I am utterly convinced that, left unchecked, Man will utterly render this Earth completely uninhabitable. Will that ruin come to pass through "global warming?" "Global Cooling?" (That's not entirely off the table either...) Overpopulation? Just dumping crap into the air or water until they can no longer support life? More nations become industrialized all the time and the industrialized become MORE industrialized and ALL of them create more and more people. So, forgive me if I'm not as convinced of the inevitability of technology solving all our ills in time and having a desire that we take reasonable and rational steps to ensure that we keep the worst of us from continuing to crap in our shared nest. (Technology hasn't SOLVED the CURRENT problems, let alone those which haven't yet occurred.) Technology may catch up. I'm fairly certain that it will HERE and in the countries which are at the top of the technological pyramid, but NOT so sure that that will trickle down to the less advanced in time.
CosmicConservative
Whether man can destroy this planet or not, a few tenths of a percent of CO2 increase is DEMONSTRABLY not going to do it. We have fossil record PROOF that the earth thrives under such conditions. Anyone who argues otherwise is SELLING YOU SOMETHING. No credible scientist would EVER suggest that our CO2 production is any serious threat to the earth. Not one. Our planet has had much, much higher CO2 levels in the past, many times. This is KNOWN SCIENCE. And during those periods, the earth did NOT suffer massive extinctions. Nobody has EVER made a link between CO2 levels and mass extinctions. Or if they have I have never seen it, and I tend to look for that sort of thing. Only political partisans or greedy crooks (of which Al Gore satisfies both simultaneously) would suggest otherwise. That is not to say that Global Warming may not be a serious concern that requires some effort and action on our part. What MAY be true to some degree is that Global Warming MIGHT flood some coastal cities, MIGHT drive some areas of cropland to draught (while opening up others), and MIGHT threaten our standard of living. Those are serious enough concerns to warrant our attention, and I have no problem with the sort of attention we put into "Global Cooling" in the seventies. Sure, spend a couple billion dollars on a 70 nation exhaustive study of the atmosphere and oceans. I'm all for that. But STOP making it a thought crime to challenge unproven science, STOP passing legislation that threaten the economic underpinnings of our society, and for HEAVEN'S SAKE, STOP THE LUDICROUS EXAGGERATIONS OF THE THREAT!
Drax
You say: "But STOP making it a thought crime to challenge unproven science, STOP passing legislation that threaten the economic underpinnings of our society, and for HEAVEN’S SAKE, STOP THE LUDICROUS EXAGGERATIONS OF THE THREAT!" I agree with all of that. Science should be SCIENCE not politics nor profit. However, this is where we diverge: "a few tenths of a percent of CO2 increase is DEMONSTRABLY not going to do it." What about more? Much more? What about that COMBINED with other atmospheric factors which did NOT exist in pre-industrial (even pre-Mankind) days? What about that COMBINED with the factors which caused those previous "high" levels (solar flare activity, volcanic eruptions, whatever...) I'm uncertain of the utility of comparing solely the CO2 levels in various epocs when there are so many other atmospheric factors which currently exist which did not exist at any other time in history....when the solar activity today isn't necessarily the same as it was then... But, we KNOW that the current levels are relatively "safe." We KNOW that, at some point, increased levels are NOT safe. What we do NOT know is at what point "safe" becomes "unsafe," or the degree of "unsafeness" hitting that point (then exceeding it since we can't "scrub" the atmosphere instantly) would entail. No one can adequately answer these questions. Accordingly, I continue to maintain that reasonable and rational steps should be now taken in an effort to keep us closer to where we ARE rather than allow the creep into potentially "unsafe" levels -- especially when we have so little control over the actions of OTHER industrialized nations (especially China -- still Russia) who may have other concerns than the environment in their minds as they expand their industrial base. I think that we, generally, agree that REASONABLE and RATIONAL measures should be taken to not "crap where we sleep." Our reasoning may differ, but I really think that our conclusions are virtually identical.
CosmicConservative
OK, so we've been pumping CO2 mindlessly into the atmosphere from millions (now billions) of internal combustion engines for several generations now, and CO2 levels are at roughly .038%. Which is about .01% more than it was before humans started the industrial revolution. Let's say we quadruple output for the next fifty years. That would add about .02% to the concentration making it roughly .06%. Reality is that we are likely to be reducing that, not increasing it, and at the same time the more CO2 that is in the air, the more plants take it out (which is why it hasn't increased more in the past fifty years). Plants are very efficient in removing CO2 from the air. That's basically their fundamental physical process. The bottom line is that humans couldn't add more than a few hundredths of a percent of CO2 to the air IF WE TRIED TO. There have been many experiments whose purpose was to show that CO2 is a "greenhouse gas" but since the effect is so small as to be virtually unmeasurable at atmospheric levels, the experiments are done with concentrations hundreds or thousands of times actual atmospheric levels. I'll let you be the judge of how good "science" that is. You say that we KNOW that at some level CO2 levels become unsafe. Sure we do, at levels that are thousands of times the levels in the atmosphere. That's the level that we KNOW CO2 is unsafe because it becomes suffocating to animal life. We don't KNOW that CO2 is unsafe at any level below that. All we have are computer models that are SPECIFICALLY PROGRAMMED to ramp up the temperature according to an artifical factor called the "multiplier effect" which is SUPPOSED to reflect how CO2 levels increase atmospheric water vapor. It is the increased water vapor that actually is supposed to cause the warming, NOT the CO2. That's because scientists know that CO2 has a MINISCULE impact on heat retention in the air. Anyway, I'm done with this. I've looked into Global Warming for decades, since it was first trotted out as the next apocalyptic scenario. I've seen how the computer models are written. I know what assumptions are being made. I know how little empirical evidence they have to back them up. I'm not going to convince you, and as we both have said, it doesn't matter anyway because both of us believe as a matter of principal that humans shouldn't foul their own nest. I'm all for minimizing the impact of humans on the "natural world." But I'm also all for truth and the scientific method, and I am frankly tired of Global Warming zealots trashing both of those.
Drax
" I’m all for minimizing the impact of humans on the “natural world.” But I’m also all for truth and the scientific method, and I am frankly tired of Global Warming zealots trashing both of those." Completely agreed.