And he's currently leading Hillary in every national poll and is at least tied with McCain in every projected Presidential election. The Iowa futures market had him as the favorite to win the Presidency, with McCain slightly behind and Hillary trailing badly.
What a country, eh?
Andy
Cosmic: You sure about that? http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/03/19/AR2008031900764.html
CosmicConservative
Andy:
Things change pretty fast I suppose. As of a few days ago Obama still had a pretty good lead and was neck-and-neck with McCain in the general election.
I don't trust the WaPost polls that much anyway... but assuming these are accurate it appears that both Hillary and Obama have suffered a loss of public confidence in the past week.
Hope that keeps up.
Andy
Yep...could be upside down by this afternoon. But I do think that McCain is looking a lot better to the public at large as these two midgets wrestle it out.
Drax
How much longer can Obama be "examined" without everyone "examining" him being accused of being a racist. He's been handled with kid's gloves from the beginning because he's black and I really don't see that overall trend completely subsiding. (Ferraro was right...Any white man with his "resume" would never, never, never, never, never, never gotten as far as he has...)
CosmicConservative
Actually I think Obama has been stumbling over the race thing for the past week. His latest gaffe was in first describing his doting grandmother as a closet racist, and then saying that such attitudes are those of a "typical white woman." I actually think that last bit is going to hurt him more with white women than his church thing. In the general election voting for John McCain or someone who has publicly labeled all white women as being closet racists, I think McCain is going to get more than a few of their votes.
pace
The primaries have been pretty tame compared to how things will go down in the final run up to the general election, I suspect. Hillary and Obama have each given the Republicans plenty of material to work with, and I don't believe that McCain and his people will be any less willing to use it than Bush and his supporters were in 2004.
Of course, McCain isn't exactly squeaky clean either. Expect plenty of skeletons to be dug up and gaffes to be replayed by both sides once we hit the home stretch. It's going to get real ugly for Obama if he wins the nomination, and there are certainly questions about his constitution for withstanding such attacks. What did he say recently; that the whole thing with his pastor 'shook him up' or some such? He needs to temper his honesty a little, and return to his previous outward calm and polished delivery if he wants to restore confidence in himself. Nobody wants to see a presidential candidate so easily 'shaken up'.
And if it's Hillary running against McCain, then her machine will go into smear overdrive, and I expect it will turn out to be one of the dirtier races we have seen.
Drax
Pace: "Temper his honesty?" Maybe "choose more carefully when to be honest," but not "temper" his overall honesty.
He has been a member of this Israelite hating, America hating, White Hating church for twenty years, baptizing his children there, getting married there, and calling the (former) pastor his "mentor" and one of the "most important influences" in his life.
Yet, he didn't know the vileness which spewed from his mouth...from the pew...on the radio...on television?
He joined the church because it was an INFLUENTIAL church in the black community. He NEEDED that influence because he, as a half-white person from Hawaii, didn't have any credibility in that community. Belonging to that church gave him (and continued to give him for decades) that credibility (which, of course, translates into VOTES).
THAT is the "truth." Really, there are only two possibilities, aren't there? 1) He believes what is being taught from the pulpit and that's the reason he has remained a member of that church for twenty years, or 2) He doesn't believe what is being taught from the pulpit, but remained a member of that church for twenty years for some other reason, the "other reason" only possibly being "ambition."
This is "truth" he can't tell. He has to come out with that ABSURD speech where he (a Harvard Educated, U.S. Senator with a Harvard Educated Lawyer for a wife) who is a member of this racist church dares to PREACH TO US about "race relations?"
But, one can't be around that kind of thought without being infected by it to some degree, can one? We saw it in his wife. (The first time this Harvard Educated Lawyer and wife of a U.S. Senator was "proud" of the U.S. was when more people voted for her husband than Hillary...) We saw it with Obama even after his speech. ("Typical white woman.") This is an insidious indoctrination which infects even the most intelligent and highly-educated of people.
AND HE TAKES HIS KIDS THERE.
That's the "truth."
Sickening. He isn't deserving of being a parent, much less President of the U.S.
pace
Drax,
I will try to address the discrete statements made in your response.
First you said, "He has been a member of this Israelite hating, America hating, White Hating church for twenty years..."
That seems quite a deduction from the few speeches of Reverend Wright that we've seen quoted in the media. But ok, if I ignore the hyperbole for a moment then the questions I have are as follows: Can one or two pulpit monologues be considered a fairly representative sample of over 'twenty years' of church services? Should a member of a congregation reasonably be considered to be in complete agreement with the politics of his pastor? Is the primary reason for membership in a church usually its pastor, or are there other considerations such as the constituent community?
Next you said; "Yet, he didn’t know the vileness which spewed from his mouth…from the pew…on the radio…on television?"
Here's what Obama had to say about that; "Did I know him to be an occasionally fierce critic of American domestic and foreign policy? Of course. Did I ever hear him make remarks that could be considered controversial while I sat in church? Yes. Did I strongly disagree with many of his political views? Absolutely..."
Then you said; "He joined the church because it was an INFLUENTIAL church in the black community. He NEEDED that influence because he, as a half-white person from Hawaii, didn’t have any credibility in that community. Belonging to that church gave him (and continued to give him for decades) that credibility (which, of course, translates into VOTES).
THAT is the “truth.â€
That reads more like opinion. I have not read much in the way of credible historic insight into why Obama joined this particular church. I suspect his motivation was much like anyone else - that it was primarily geographically or demographically convenient. You clearly have a strong opinion otherwise, but calling that the 'truth' is a little ridiculous.
You then stated that there are only two possible scenarios why Obama would have remained with that church. Not being much of a black and white thinker myself, I would say there are several other conceivable possibilities. Here's one that comes to mind; "I enjoy the company of the people in this congregation. I share most of their values and enjoy participating in the community. The pastor occasionally spouts some nutty stuff which I disagree with, but he also delivers the word of Christ in a way that gives hope to people. I'm not going to disown an entire community because of one man's political views."
I happen disagree with the political views of the CEO of my company, and I've heard quotes relayed which I strongly disagree with. However, I enjoy the work I do there and the company of my co-workers. I realize that any organization is larger than a single individual.
As for Michelle Obama's comments. They didn't resonate with me the same way they ostensibly did with yourself and other Republicans. Certainly I was concerned with her apparent reckless display of hubris, but do I think that she is ashamed to be an American? No, I do not. Do you really believe that she is, Drax?
As for your parting comment; I wouldn't presume to comment on Obama's deservedness of parenthood, any more than I would yours or McCain's, or any other person whose personal life I have little or no insight into. Let's not forget that it is the left-wing blogosphere that spews the vile, inflammatory rhetoric, and hate.
CosmicConservative
Pace:
Drax can certainly speak for himself, but I will address a few of your comments/questions.
As far as whether I believe that "reverend" Wright is an America-hating, racist hate-monger, yes I most certainly do. Trent Lott has been labeled that and worse because he made a comment at a party for Strom Thurmond on his 100th birthday stating that he wished Thrumond had been President. The backlash to that single statement, with NO HISTORY of racism in Lott's public speech, voting record or personal history, was enough to force Lott into early retirement.
What Wright is on record as saying was far, far worse, far more frequent and far more racist. So if the Left can say that Lott is a racist for one clumsy attempt to give a compliment to a dying old man at his 100th birthday party, I can certainly form comparable opinions based on comments that Wright screeched from a pulpit as a voice of moral authority in repeated instances and who was proud enough of them that he put them on a "best of" DVD that he then SOLD to make money for his church.
So yes, I think it is completely reasonable and fair to call Wright a racist, anti-American, seditionist, nut-job. And there is ZERO doubt in my mind that Obama knew this and still attended the church.
So that takes us to the other question... Why, knowing this, did Obama attend the church?
Now I'm not a black and white thinker myself, but I can't think of many answers to this question, and the answer you gave ignores the fundamental question of when a person has a moral obligation to remove themselves from an untenable situation.
Here are the options:
1. Obama agrees with Wright.
2. Obama does not agree with Wright, but needed the political capital attending that church gave him.
3. Obama does not agree with Wright but attended the church because he liked some of the folks who attend that church.
4. Obama does not agree with Wright but attended the church because of its proximity to his house.
Frankly Pace, the only remotely acceptable one of those options is #2. #1 means that Obama is just as racist and hate-filled as Wright is. I certainly hope that is not the case, but it is within the realm of possibility. I will give him the benefit of the doubt though and say that he is not. Even though I suspect his WIFE harbors some serious sympathies with reverend Wright.
#3 simply means that he's morally challenged and takes the easy way out when confronted with a moral decision. Not exactly what you think of when you hear the word "leader". If Obama is 1/20 the "leader" he is supposed to be, he would have left that church, or worked to have such a racist mouthpiece removed from the pulpit. He did neither, so if he stayed and raised his kids in that church because he was chummy with some of the folks there, he not only did his children a serious disservice, he similarly shortchanged the entire congregation. Not the sort of behavior I would call "Presidential."
#4 is pure and simple laziness, coupled with the same moral cowardice of #3.
So for Drax to have assumed option #2, in my opinion, he was giving Obama just about all the benefit of the doubt that he could. The other options are all far worse than the option that Obama is a typical opportunistic politician doing what he thinks is necessary to be elected.
Michelle's comments resonated with me about the same way they did with Drax. My personal opinion is that if she has "never been proud" of this country until her husband became a serious Presidential contender, then she's got some SERIOUS issues, and as I said, that makes me suspect that she harbors some significant sympathies with Wright. My personal opinion from what I've seen is that she was probably a significant reason for Obama's continued presence in that church.
Now I have repeatedly said that I do not think Obama is suitable President material. But neither is Hillary. In fact there probably aren't ten people in this country who are. The Presidency is one of those jobs that nobody is really qualified for until they've done it for a while. Based on what little past history we have of Obama I am seriously concerned about what sort of President he will be. However, I've seen a couple of men grow in that office, and maybe he will too.
But as far as this Wright thing is concerned, I think it is far more troublesome to Obama and the Democrats than they have yet come to understand. I am suspecting that we have now seen the tip of the Obama iceberg, and we've got another 90% of revelations to come.
Drax
Pace: Thank you for a civil respsonse, something which I'm quite unused to from most liberals (if, indeed, you are one). CC addressed most of your response to me better than I could, so, I'll just address some specifics:
I said: "He has been a member of this Israelite hating, America hating, White Hating church for twenty years…â€
You said: "That seems quite a deduction from the few speeches of Reverend Wright that we’ve seen quoted in the media."
Do you seriously contend that Obama didn't know what this man was about? He was probably the most influential black minister in Chicago. He was frequently on national talk shows, where he espoused his views and attempted to defend them.
Some of the scenes of his more disturbing sermons come from a tape that he created and distributed. Are you seriously contending that the views contained in that tape, which was intended for public consumption, didn't reflect what he believed and preached?
Come on.
You continued: "But ok, if I ignore the hyperbole for a moment then the questions I have are as follows: Can one or two pulpit monologues be considered a fairly representative sample of over ‘twenty years’ of church services?"
Are you seriously contending that this man who has gone on national television expounding his views has only given one or two sermons such as this?
I guess one could convince one's self that someone who displayed such anger and hatred in his recorded sermons only spoke about whites, Jews, and America on a few, isolated occasions if one really tried to.
"Should a member of a congregation reasonably be considered to be in complete agreement with the politics of his pastor?"
When those "politics" are preached from the "pulpit," and those "politics" are "Hate Whites," "Hate Jews," "Kill the White God," "G.Damn America." and you're an elected official for the State of Illinois, then the USA..well...yes. If I ever walked into a "church" where I was told to "Hate Blacks" to "Hate America" I would get up and walk out...but not before I gave the "preacher" a loud piece of my mind. I sure in HELL wouldn't bring my kids to such a place of hatred.
(By the way...how many times are acceptable to you to have YOUR preacher say "Hate Jews, Hate Whites, Hate America" before YOU get up and leave?)
"Is the primary reason for membership in a church usually its pastor, or are there other considerations such as the constituent community?"
Everyone has their own reasons to join a church, the main one, hopefully, is spiritual teaching, i.e., learning from the elders of the church. They are the ones who are supposedly immersed in learning the religion they are preaching while the rest of the congregation rely upon them for that teaching since they actually have to earn a living NOT immersing themselves in learning the religion of that church.
Sure there are other considerations, and, in this case, the PRIME consideration is to be in and around Wright's circle of influence, a tactic which has put Obama in the U.S. Senate and running for President.
I said: “Yet, he didn’t know the vileness which spewed from his mouth…from the pew…on the radio…on television?â€
You responded: "Here’s what Obama had to say about that; “Did I know him to be an occasionally fierce critic of American domestic and foreign policy? Of course. Did I ever hear him make remarks that could be considered controversial while I sat in church? Yes. Did I strongly disagree with many of his political views? Absolutely…â€
That is saying absolutely nothing. A "fierce critic?" He said that the US created the AIDS virus. "Controversial?" He said "Racism is the American way." "God Damn America."
Obama is trying to have it both ways, not "disowning" Wright so to alienate the blacks while giving mild and meek rebuff to Wright to try to woo back the Whites.
I suspect that he styles "a dialogue on race" as the ability to talk out of both sides of his mouth.
I said; “He joined the church because it was an INFLUENTIAL church in the black community. He NEEDED that influence because he, as a half-white person from Hawaii, didn’t have any credibility in that community. Belonging to that church gave him (and continued to give him for decades) that credibility (which, of course, translates into VOTES).
THAT is the “truth.â€
You said: "That reads more like opinion. I have not read much in the way of credible historic insight into why Obama joined this particular church. I suspect his motivation was much like anyone else - that it was primarily geographically or demographically convenient. You clearly have a strong opinion otherwise, but calling that the ‘truth’ is a little ridiculous."
Obama has been on a path to the Presidency from an early age, making connections which would benefit him in this pursuit. Are you serioulsy contending that his choice of CHURCH was not driven primarily, if not entirely, by political motivations?
Is it your serious contention that Obama, who has been attempting to walk up the political ladder from an early age, did not research the church that he would be attending, who went there, what it stood for, how influential it was?
You said (to my black/white, "only two reasons to go to that church"): "Here’s one that comes to mind; “I enjoy the company of the people in this congregation. I share most of their values and enjoy participating in the community. The pastor occasionally spouts some nutty stuff which I disagree with, but he also delivers the word of Christ in a way that gives hope to people. I’m not going to disown an entire community because of one man’s political views.â€
Again. Are you seriously contending that these "nutty" outbursts are isolated incidents? Are you seriously contending that the "word of Christ" are being uttered there in any fashion that any mainstream Christian would recognize?
Again. Are you seriously contending that he would "disown an entire community" by choosing a DIFFERENT black church? Or, since he's 1/2 white, maybe even a white church? After all, there are nice people at all of them, aren't there?
You said: "I happen disagree with the political views of the CEO of my company, and I’ve heard quotes relayed which I strongly disagree with. However, I enjoy the work I do there and the company of my co-workers. I realize that any organization is larger than a single individual."
You are seriously comparing your JOB to a choice of which church you belong to? If, on your JOB, you heard your CEO utter racist remarks, how long do you think that he would REMAIN your CEO? OF COURSE we don't agree with many people we work with and for, but we are not subjected to RACIST HATE SPEECH at work, at least not for long, and, WORK, unlike the CHOICE of which church you belong to, is not entirely voluntary.
"As for Michelle Obama’s comments. They didn’t resonate with me the same way they ostensibly did with yourself and other Republicans. Certainly I was concerned with her apparent reckless display of hubris, but do I think that she is ashamed to be an American? No, I do not. Do you really believe that she is, Drax?"
I didn't say that, did I? I merely quoted HER. I would assume that a Harvard trained lawyer, knowing that she was going to speak on national television, actually INTENDED to say the words she said and MEANT them EXACTLY as she said them. Why would I not? This is not some un-educated woman who was caught by surprise and made some off-hand, and ill-formed statement, but a highly educated woman, TRAINED in the use of words, TRAINED in pubic speaking, PREPARED to speak WHEN she spoke, who said EXACTLY WHAT SHE MEANT TO SAY.
Why on this green earth shouldn't I take her at her word?
You said: "As for your parting comment; I wouldn’t presume to comment on Obama’s deservedness of parenthood, any more than I would yours or McCain’s, or any other person whose personal life I have little or no insight into. Let’s not forget that it is the left-wing blogosphere that spews the vile, inflammatory rhetoric, and hate."
Any person who takes their child(ren) to a place which inculcates them with racism and hatred is not deserving of being a parent. You may think otherwise, but I have no compunction about making this statement.
pace
Hey Drax,
All of the points you make go back to your fundamental assertion of Obama's rationale for selecting this church and his continued participation there. So I will not attempt to address them individually. I think I get your point.
Obama claims that Wright initially brought him and other members of the congregation great inspiration and hope, and I don't doubt that. But I am also sensible to the fact that the desire for political ascension very likely played some factor in Obama's attendence. I don't know for a fact to what degree, any more than you do.
Reverend Wright is certainly a nut. He's also not peculiar in that regard as far as high-profile religious figures go, yet people still keep on attending their churches. Yeah... it's disappointing to me that Obama would remain in attendence, but by most accounts it seems that Wright got particularly militant toward his retirement. If Obama had left this church a few years ago, I suspect that Republicans would be cynically noting his abrupt change of heart immediately prior to running for President. Much like many Democrats are wondering on McCain's switch from Episcopalian to Baptist. Politically motivated? Not our guy!
Clearly, I am going to view this less cynically than you, by virtue of our political leanings. I suspect that few Republicans are decrying McCain's actively seeking an endorsement from Minister Hagee. Someone who isn't short on 'hate' himself.
I absolutely understand the desire for Republicans to make a big deal out of this. Obama has been given a relatively free pass on scrutiny by the press, and was perceived by the general public as being relatively clean until quite recently. He's a politician at the top of his game, and as such I have absolutely no doubt that he has a few more skeletons buried somewhere under 6 inches of dirt. It's a good thing from my perspective. He can start to deal with it now, and formulate a strategy for responding to the inevitable attack ads. Plus, it might toughen the guy up a little. That is actually my main concern with Obama right now - whether he has the 'stomach' for the job.
Drax
What I don't understand is why Democrats aren't "making a big deal" about this. It is important.
Does Obama believe as his preacher preached? How does his voting record and careless statements jibe with being filled with hatred for the U.S., for whites, and for Jews? (Well, he has a chief military advisor who apparently thinks that Israel is "the problem" in the Mid-East...; he thinks his "racist" grandma is a "typical white woman"...; He allows placards calling the U.S. the "real terrorists" to litter his public appearances without comment... just for starters...)
Hillary may not be trustworthy, may not be worthy of the office, may be ethically challenged in more ways than can be easily recounted...but I don't think that she actively hates America, any particular race, or the Jews, so I would think that Democrats would WANT to get to the bottom of this, since one of the two is going to be the Democrat nominee for President and, perhaps, the President of the U.S. It would seem an important piece of information to have about the potential future leader of the U.S.
I would be utterly flabbergasted to hear McCain even MENTION this issue except in the most off-hand of manner. It simply isn't McCain's style (or, frankly, the style of most Republicans who, for the most part, think they can actually win on the issues.) Hopefully some "surrogates" will "Swiftboat" (using the term as it should be...bringing out the TRUTH about the candidate...not how liberals have turned the term into a curse word) him if he is nominated.
CosmicConservative
Drax, I think the issue here is whether this is the tip of an iceberg or not. I suspect that there is more gold in these veins if the Clintons or Republicans want to mine it.
I would be digging into Michelle's associations too. But that's because I'm just a nasty Republican dirty tricker...
Drax
CC: I really think it goes much deeper than is being examined (or will be examined) by the press.
The question isn't simply: "Is there more of this kind of racist, anti-Semitic, America hating kind of association in Obama's past?" Instead, the question should be: "Just how common is such hate speech coming from the pulpit of black "preachers?"
White is/was a NATIONAL figure, being interviewed about his racist views many times on national television prior to this latest flap (Hannity interviewed him in March '07, I believe). What he was and what he stood for (read "black separationist") was common knowledge to anyone who bothered to look, yet he has a HUGE following, not only in Illinois, but nationally.
The Sharptons, the Jacksons, the Whites are the "tip of the iceberg." Black churches COMMONLY mix politics and preaching and black "reverends" are COMMONLY radical activitists in the "black community."
This is why we can find almost NO black religious leaders who DENOUNCE White. At best, some of them say that he is just trying to "shake things up," or some such nonsense, minimizing his racist and hate-filled speech, and, in doing so, excuse that of the hundreds of OTHER black "preachers" who do the same across this nation.
These people make their living by ensuring that there IS black/white discord. If the "black community" actually woke up tomorrow and said..."Wait a minute, let's look at the facts...Supreme Court Justice, Govenor, Mayors of some of the largest cities in the country, Senators, Cabinet Members, Chairman of the Joint Chief of Staff? Maybe there isn't that "great racial divide" that my PREACHER has been telling me about all these years?" If that happened, the maybe, just maybe, we could get past this mostly self-inflicted "racism" that the "black community" complains so bitterly about.
Certainly, there's racism...no matter how you look at it...black racism against whites, whites against blacks, blacks against blacks, etc. etc. etc. That will almost certainly never completely subside.
However, when it is PERPETUATED by the "black community's" PREACHERS, it will take much longer.
CosmicConservative
Drax:
I have so little knowledge of what goes on inside any church besides the one my family attends that I can't really say whether the problem is nearly as pervasive as you say. It probably is. If it is, and Obama's connections reach out to other similar "reverends" in the black community, I think it's going to be very bad politically for him.
Comments (16)