Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Astronaut questions shuttle safety

By CosmicConservative
CNN.com - Astronaut questions shuttle safety in book - Jan 17, 2006 OK, so when the Shuttle program was announced back in the seventies, analysis of the safety of the program was done and the failure rate was calculated and communicated to the US Congress. Because of the lack of any historical data, varying methods of analyzing failure rates were used with results ranging from about 1 failure per 100 launches (the NASA Engineering team's estimate) to about 1 failure in 10,000 launches (NASA management's estimate). Outside analylsis was also done and the final figure I recall was between 2 and 5% failure based on historical figures of all rocket launches coupled with new and then untested technology. One of the key problems with the Shuttle all along was the acknowledged lack of a crew emergency safety mechanism. But its absence was not through oversight, but was due to the need to keep the weight of the Shuttle low enough that it could do anything useful at all. In other words, it was in the design and was an accepted risk from day one. The actual failure rate after 122 missions is 2, which is a failure rate just under 2%. So of all the methods tried, the one that got it closest was the historical comparison to other rocket launches. But the NASA engineers were not far off. So to anyone who has been watching the Space Shuttle critically, a 1.64% failure rate is no great surprise. I can't imagine that any Astronaut who has ridden the Space Shuttle is not aware of these numbers, so to suddenly express concern over the lack of safety of Space Shuttle launches is a bit hard to understand. But perhaps it will sell a few copies of the book, eh?

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.