Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Do you want fries with that?

By CosmicConservative
So I am starting to understand. After all the grief I, and others like me, have been taking the past few weeks due to our dislike of John McCain because of our criticisms of the presumptive Republican front-runner, I have realized that John McCain really is a conservative. He's a new kind of conservative. He's a McConservative!. How do you define a "McConservative?" Well, that's a conservative who supports the following things:
  • Reducing free speech rights if they conflict with a politician's desire to remain in office.
  • Over-regulating businesses to placate the latest doomsday fad adherents
  • Railing against tax cuts
  • Over-regulating businesses to placate the desire to punish greedy corporate villains who just make too much money.
  • Using the tissue of unborn humans in speculative research efforts
  • Taxing individuals receiving social security benefits derived from income that has already been taxed.
  • Telegraphing our interrogation limitations to our enemies so they can prepare for being captured.
  • Rewarding those who have entered this country illegally and are routinely breaking our laws to continue living here with favored treatment and offers of no-fault citizenship
Once upon a time holding views like that would disqualify a person from being called a "conservative." But now that we've got this new form of "conservatism" called "McConservatism" such people are suddenly welcome under the tent. We should all be thankful that the Republican tent is now broad enough to cover such positions. That's got to be progress.

Comments (8)

Drax
The "Republican" tent, as opposed to the "Conservative" tent has ALWAYS been broad enough to include "McConservatives." "Conservatives" no more make up the MAJORITY of the "Republican Party" than "liberals" make up the MAJORITY of the Democratic party.
CosmicConservative
Well, I just think it's great that we can all just get along.
CosmicConservative
I might be more agreeable to your position on this if I didn't have to suffer the disgust of listening to McCain repeatedly call himself a "true conservative" over and over again, quite literally ad nauseum.
Drax
Heh. Maybe he thinks he is...his definition being somewhat different than yours. Maybe he thinks what you call "conservatives" are actually far to the right of what he calls "conservatives." I think that many "moderate conservatives" think likewise.
CosmicConservative
Well, I suppose we could debate this too, but I think "moderate" is the end of the description of that perspective, not "moderate conservative." We'll never agree that McCain is a conservative. I simply don't believe that he can be described as one with the positions he's taken. I think there are more "conservatives" who think the way I do than there are "moderate conservatives" who think the way you do.
Drax
Well, can one be described as "liberal" if one is: Pro-life? Committed to the war on terror including Iraq and Afghanistan? For strict constructionist Justices? Against Ear Marks (and pork barrel in general)? For making the Bush tax cuts permanent? For a male/female Constitutional amendment for marriage? Against further erosion of the 2nd Amendment? I can't think of a liberal who holds those positons. Neither characterization fully describes McCain. He's for the war on terror but he doesn't agree with the way we treat some of the prisoners. He's against illegal immigration, but doesn't want to treat those who are here illegally harshly enough to force them to return to Mexico. I just think that, on the whole, on the BIG issues (especially the biggest -- the war on terror) he is convincingly "conservative." The other areas are ones we'll just have to suck up if he's elected President, which is becoming increasingly unlikely since the blogging and talk-show "conservatives" talk about McCain as if he's as liberal as Feingold or Kennedy when they should be talking his positive aspects up. You see, I DON'T believe that Clinton or Obama will see the necessity of keeping on course in Iraq, but will do EXACTLY what they say...bring them home almost immediately -- REGARDLESS of the situation on the ground. If they want to be elected a second time, they will have to. I also believe that they will select ultra-liberal Judicial nominees and the Republicans, unlike the Democrats, will actually vote on them...and pass them onto the bench. I also believe that they will force some version of universal health care down our throats...giving it to the "poor" and FORCING the rest of us to buy insurance regardless of our ability to actually pay for it. The Democrats are excited. We need to be excited as well. McCain, on the whole, is a wonderful candidate. Unlike some, I trust him. I tend to trust a guy who, after two years in a POW camp, when offered a ride home declines it because he knows he's being used. He would rather stay in that POW camp than be used by the enemy...for four more years. That's guts. That's integrity. The kind of guts and integrity which at CPAC had him directly confront the differences in his views and theirs. He didn't do what a "politician" would do and conform his views to theirs for their support. He stuck to his. That's what a LEADER does.
CosmicConservative
Just a couple of comments... Among self-described "conservative" Republicans (as opposed to "moderate" or "liberal") McCain is rejected by a majority in poll after poll and state after state (in the three contests this weekend over 50% of self-described "conservative" Republicans voted against McCain, roughly 30% of them voted for McCain). To put it another way, you are making an argument that is rejected by the majority of people you are talking about. It is just that simple. You may think McCain is a conservative, and McCain may claim that he's a conservative, but the vast majority of actual self-described conservative Republicans vehemently disagree with you. That's what an objective evaluation of the actual available statistics says. In this case, I agree with the majority opinion, McCain is no conservative. But, as the Republican nominee, he'll get my vote because you are right about one thing, he's to the right of Obama (by a LOT) and of Hillary (by a little). I have no doubt that even when McCain gets as much as 30% of the conservative vote in a caucus or primary, a large fraction of those are holding their nose and voting for him as the better of the three remaining candidates, NOT because they believe he is a conservative. As far as whether McCain is a "leader" that is not an issue I have yet addressed. But I will do so now. McCain has some leadership qualities, but he also has a lot of qualities that are not good qualities for a true leader. In fact his "maverickness" is specifically troublesome for a "leader" because if he were a true leader, then the party would follow his lead instead of finding itself diametrically opposed to him on issue after issue. Also, McCain has been trying to run for President for over 20 years. If he were truly a "leader" of the Reagan or even GW Bush mold, he'd have already been the nominee by now. So no, I don't agree that McCain is a "leader." Holding to a particular position in the face of opposition is only "leadership" if you eventually get the rank and file to agree with you on enough of those issues that it is clear that your "leadership" is influencing the party. Simply being in opposition to your own team is not leadership. It might be "guts" it might be "conviction" it might even be "right" but it's not leadership. If I were to rate McCain's "leadership" abilities I would put him slightly ahead of Hillary, but far behind Obama. When Obama makes a statement, his personality cult followers ADOPT that position, and defend it vigorously. They did the same thing with Bill Clinton. That's leadership in the purest sense of the word. McCain does not have much of that. In fact he mostly alienates his party on issues like that because of his arrogant and contrary nature. Bottom line, I give McCain high marks as a "leader" because he is willing to stand by SOME convictions in the face of opposition from his friends and enemies. But that's only one aspect of "leadership." I give him very LOW marks in actually being able to influence his party into adopting his own views. Which is the MORE important aspect of a leader. So his leadership is a mixed bag to me, and not nearly as good as I'd like to see in a President.
Drax
A leader sets forth his agenda and those who wish to follow him do so. That's what McCain does. The problem is that his agenda in some respects isn't one which "conservatives" will follow...but OTHERS WILL. It isn't that he can't "lead," it's just that he's going places (in some cases) that "conservatives" won't follow. McCain has been trying to be President for a while now. His failure to become the Republican nominee has NOTHING to do with his ability to "lead," but with the DIRECTION he would lead. Not enough of the "conservatives" would follow him so that he could get the nomination. The unique makeup of this (dismal) pack of Republican candidates has allowed him to become the front runner. (As an aside, I always have some difficulty with our nomination process. I could throw a dart into a pack of people in the Mall and come up with a better choice than many, if not most, of the people who are currently running. It is a DISMAL pack of candidates indeed, almost as bad as the Bush/Kerry choice. There's gotta be a better way of picking who runs the dang country...) I continue to be amazed at your assertion that Hillary is just a "bit" to the left of McCain, while Obama is "far" to his left, apparently ignoring entirely their respective voting records. (Of the 200+ votes they each cast on the same legislation, they only voted differently 10 times....) I guess she's only a "bit" left of McCain when she is: Pro-Abortion Anti-Iraq and would withdraw our troops regardless of the situation on the ground. Anti-tax cuts and wouldn't make the Bush cuts permanent. Pro universal and governmentally run health care. Pro gun control. Pro liberal Supreme Court Justices and blocks conservative ones. I would call those issues far, far, far to the "left" of McCain.