Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

More on Miers

By CosmicConservative
Excellent column from David Brooks today. He has some really choice quotes from a column Harriet Miers wrote as the President of the Texas Bar Association. I have to admit, the writing he has chosen to highlight is pretty bad. It suffers greatly from sesquipedalian syndrome. It is common for people who are poor at presenting their case to resort to using overly long and obtuse words in an attempt to make their writing appear more intelligent. Heh, I am guilty of it myself more frequently than I would like to admit. Instead of taking David Brooks at his word, I decided to go read some of the columns myself. The download time is considerable, I assume a lot of people are doing the same thing I did. After reading a few of the columns, I can't entirely agree with Brooks' conclusions. Many of the columns are typical organizational platitudes with a lot of "I'd like to thank (insert name here) for their (insert adjective here) work on (insert program here). There is a lot of emphasis on pro bono work, and Miers seems very proud of the Texas Bar's attempt to promote pro bono work in Texas. When she writes about those efforts, she comes across as sincere and committed, and her writing is clear. On occasion Miers does fall into a convoluted wordsmithing pattern. I would say that was the exception and not the rule. This is not a defense of Miers, just an attempt to be fair about the columns themselves instead of picking and choosing an embarrassing sentence or three out of eleven bureaucratic missives that by their nature are vague and full of attempts to avoid controversy. It is not fair to suppose her written legal opinions would be of the same stripe.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.