Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Peggy Noonan on Bush and the G.O.P.

By CosmicConservative
I am not completely in disagreement with Peggy Noonan here. I have repeatedly told both conservatives and liberals that I am no fan of GW Bush. I backed his actions when they were right, and opposed them when they were wrong. And on balance I think he was wrong on at least as many things as he was right on. Mostly his desire to be liked by his enemies was his undoing. And I do believe that his actions led to the Republican Party coming apart at the seams. And to top all of that off, he spent absolutely zero time trying to build a party legacy that would survive his two terms. In a sense I consider GW Bush to have been profoundly irresponsible as "leader" of the G.O.P. But Peggy, as always, says it better. Read the whole article, she has observations about all the candidates.
Declarations - WSJ.com On the pundit civil wars, Rush Limbaugh declared on the radio this week, "I'm here to tell you, if either of these two guys [Mr. McCain or Mike Huckabee] get the nomination, it's going to destroy the Republican Party. It's going to change it forever, be the end of it!" This is absurd. George W. Bush destroyed the Republican Party, by which I mean he sundered it, broke its constituent pieces apart and set them against each other. He did this on spending, the size of government, war, the ability to prosecute war, immigration and other issues.

Comments (4)

Andy
Cosmic: I read the article this morning by Peggy. Not much to argue with really. Bush drives me crazy in many ways. I love the guy's commitment, but often hate what he is committed to. Peggy says that Bush destroyed the Republican Party. The truth is that it was not a strong, cohesive group when Bush became President. And he sure didn't do much to fix that. The Democrats are in the same boat, as she points out. Speaking of Bush, you wrote: "And to top all of that off, he spent absolutely zero time trying to build a party legacy that would survive his two terms." Yep! The guy has never cared about how he would be viewed by people in the future. In a way it is refreshing after a decade and a half of Bubba. That is one reason that I respect him. So, I wonder how Reagan viewed his time in office. Did he spend any time trying to build a party legacy that would survive his two terms? Or did he just do what he believed to be right? He took the liberal GHW Bush as VP...and did not support more conservative challengers when GHW ran for President. I suspect that Reagan just did what he thought was right. Because of complete commitment to his ideals he is revered today...but I would bet it never crossed his mind. He's not the only one...Churchill...Thatcher...Roosevelt...King, etc. And I suspect that Bush does what he thinks is right (even though I disagree with a good bit of it) without regard for his legacy. The GOP may be dead. Bush may have destroyed it. But that may not be such a bad thing. Reagan's successes were due to the support of a Republican minority, a minority of Democrats, a majority of Independents, and of course to the fact that he was right. I've see what the Republicans have done while in the majority, and I am not impressed. The death of the GOP could well be the birth of something better. That might be Bush's legacy when historians write about it 50 years from now. My Grandkids might thank the guy for his wisdom (or lack of it). I sure hope so.
CosmicConservative
When I referred to a "party legacy" that Bush did not work on, I meant something different than his "Presidential legacy." What I am referring to is that GW Bush never put together a political succession plan. He never identified a political heir. He never spent five minutes making sure that his coalition would live beyond his election needs. I wonder sometimes if he even realizes the need for such a plan. In my business the lack of a succession plan is considered borderline incompetence. And we aren't running the country. I have no doubt that Democrats will prove to be as incompetent as Republicans have been. In fact I would say that they have a pretty good head start in the past two years. It would not surprise me at all if Hillary or Obama gets elected that the Democrats get booted out again in four years. Republicans aren't dead, they are just tired.
CosmicConservative
Oh, you asked if Reagan worked on a party legacy. Yes he did. He considered that to be one of his most important jobs as party leader. He instituted what became known as the "Eleventh Commandment" in Republican politics, "Thou shalt not publicly criticize other republicans." He also worked very hard to build a permanent "feet on the street" machine to get out the Republican vote and he made every effort possible to bring evangelicals into the party process, instead of taking them for granted like Democrats take minority voters for granted. Reagan's worst mistake in that area was that he was more or less stuck with G. H. W. Bush as his successor. He picked Bush as VP to shore up his East Coast flank for his first election against Carter, and couldn't really drop him in 84 (although I wish he had). G. H. W. Bush had many of the same failings as his son, and he allowed the Reagan coalition to dissolve while choosing very poorly in his own VP pick (Dan Quayle) which further eroded the Republican ability to hold on to any coalition. But Reagan understood it. He understood that political parties are living things themselves that need to be fed, watered and cared for. Bush may realize that, but you certainly can't tell from his actions. Clinton, on the other hand, does realize it. That's why people still call Bill Clinton the real leader of the Democrat party. He built a machine, and that machine is still in place, still functioning and still driving the direction of the Democrat party eight years after he left office. And he is using that machine right now to get his wife elected. Now his machine is much more about power and winning elections than Reagan's which was at least equally concerned about ideology and U.S. geopolitical dominance. Bill and Hillary Clinton don't view ideology as a foundation of their principles, they see it as just another tool to use to win, hold and exercise power. That is what Bill Clinton has done to politics in this country, and that's what I mean when I say Bill Clinton's only demonstrable "legacy" is that he brought Arkansas style politics to Washington. He may not have done anything else, but he certainly accomplished that.
Andy
Cosmic: Got ya! I think we're on the same page. I think you reinforced the truth that Reagan didn't set up someone with his philosophy to carry on. With his Eleventh Commandment he prohibited himself from doing just that. But it may not have made much difference anyway. Sitting VP's are awfully hard to beat in primaries. Heck, look at Gore! You're thinking pretty clearly for a guy about to go under the knife. :)