Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Space Based Solar Power gets another look

By CosmicConservative
I've posted more than once on power stations in space. A recent Pentagon study (Pentagon? why not the Energy Dept?) is pumping more energy into the idea. They are focusing on solar power stations but if we can put solar power generators in space, we can put nuclear ones too.
A Pentagon report released in October could mean the stars are finally aligning for space-based solar power, or SBSP. According to the report, SBSP is becoming more feasible, and eventually could help head off crises such as climate change and wars over diminishing energy supplies. "The challenge is one of perception," says John Mankins, president of the Space Power Association and the leader of NASA's mid-1990s SBSP study. "There are people in senior leadership positions who believe everything in space has to cost trillions."
I support this sort of thing for so many powerfully good reasons that I probably can't list them all. I'll just repeat the major two reasons I support this. 1. It is an almost infinitely scalable energy source. That means we can increase energy collection or production exponentially without affecting the earth much at all. 2. It drives our space exploration by giving us powerful economic reasons to develop space technology. Now, there is one potential long-term downside. Let's say we get rid of every power station on earth and replace them with space-based ones. Over time that means that we will be literally pumping trillions of watts of energy into the earth's biosphere. The great majority of the energy will eventually become heat, heat that would not be in the biosphere otherwise. This may be fine if the earth can shed the heat as fast as it is pumped in, but that is something I would want to study if we do proceed with space-based power stations. Just in case...

Comments (5)

Ed Minchau
"Pentagon? why not the Energy Dept?" One of the biggest logistical problems with war is getting energy to the guys on the front lines. Convoys carrying fuel are vulnerable parts of the supply chain, so if it is possible to beam power to the front lines, then that vulnerability is removed.
CosmicConservative
Ed: I absolutely understand and agree with that. However, if I were running this country I would have the Pentagon involved and maybe even driving such research, but I would have press releases on the subject coming from the Energy Department, in large part simply to disguise the military's involvement. But also because I think that even if the Pentagon is interested for very good and obvious reasons, it is still a U.S. Energy Policy issue and should be overseen by the Energy Dept even if parts of it are funded by the Pentagon. Civilian application of military developed technology should, especially in THIS country, be of paramount importance. I love the military, I respect the military, but this is not a country that is run BY the military, and I would reinforce that notion every chance I got.
Ed Minchau
Unfortunately space based solar power is something that falls into the cracks between government departments. The Energy department doesn't touch it because of the word "space", and NASA doesn't touch it because of the word "power". If it weren't for the Pentagon's involvement, then the government likely wouldn't be involved at all.
CosmicConservative
Probably true, but that seems solvable via executive direction to the Energy Department saying something along the lines of: "Hello! Put together a comprehensive analysis of space-based energy initiatives and get it on my desk next Monday!" Or words to that effect. When there is a situation where things "fall through the cracks" due to bureaucratic red tape, that's a failure of leadership to define expectations and monitor progress. I can't blame that on bureaucratic myopia. Hire some guy and give him the title of "Undersecretary of Space-based Energy" and soon enough he'll have his own bureaucracy and will be generating studies like this on a weekly basis.
Ed Minchau
I should point out that the Pentagon report was probably the most cost-effective report to ever be produced by the US government; they set up a blog and used that to take submissions. By visiting http://spacesolarpower.wordpress.com you too can contribute your ideas to the next phase of study.