Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Supreme reason for voting for President...

By CosmicConservative
Therre are lots of reasons for voting for President. You can personally like the candidate, you can want to follow a particular party line, you can desire a change from the status quo, you can identify with one or a few major issues, or you can just flip a coin. But for the past couple of decades the single most important reason to vote one way or another for me has been to put the right people in the nine most powerful chairs in the world. And no, the President of the United States is not one of them. The nine most powerful people in the world are: John Roberts Antonin Scalia Clarence Thomas Samuel Alito Anthony Kennedy David Souter Ruth Bader Ginsberg John Paul Stevens Steven Breyer There is no particular order in that list, just as they came to me, so it should be no surprise that the "conservative" members came first. Now with the likely loss of the White House to either Hillary Clinton or maybe even Barack Obama, it is clear that whoever becomes President is going to try to stack the court with liberal justices. Let's say that we have an 8 year President and use the last several 8 year Presidents as a comparison. Most 8 year Presidents get to name about three SCOTUS justices. Bush is a bit below average because the liberals on the court are determined to hang onto their seats by their fingernails if necessary to keep Bush from appointing a replacement. It is unlikely that the conservatives on the court now will do any different if a liberal President is likely to replace them with a liberal. So it's likely that "President" Hillary would get to nominate two or three herself. The most likely candidates for retirement are: John Paul Stevens - age 87 Ruth Bader Ginsberg - age 74 Antonin Scalia - age 71 Anthony Kennedy - age 71 The rest are all in ther fifties or sixties and barring sudden illness, should be good for a while. The only name on that list that should strike terror into the heart of true conservatives is Antonin Scalia. Anthony Kennedy is a technical conservative, having been appointed by Ronald Reagan himself. Kennedy is at best a lukewarm conservative though, and with the retirement of Sandra Day O'Connor has taken up the role of fence-sitting self-appointed "conscience" of the court. I don't care much for him, and to have him replaced with a liberal would not necessarily be a drastic change to the makeup of the court. Especially since Souter was also appointed by a Republican and could well do what Kennedy did and start becoming the "swing vote" himself. But losing Scalia would be huge. Roberts, Thomas and Alito are all young and should be around for a while. Of course Scalia is sixteen years younger than Stevens, so there is good reason to hope that Scalia will be around for a while. On the other side, Ginsberg is not only getting up in years, but she has been reported to be having health problems, so it is likely that she would be retiring if a Democrat gets elected, as would Stevens due to his quite advanced age. Those are two of the most liberal members on today's court or on ANY court in American history. It is not likely that even Hillary Clinton would be able to replace them with similarly liberal replacements. Ginsberg used to be head legal counsel for the American Civil Liberties Union. She has proposed such crazy things as allowing girls as young as 13 to marry. She is "out there." So losing her would almost certainly move the court well to the right, even if a Democrat nominates the most liberal candidate that they are likely to be able to get through the Senate. Of course I want a Republican in office to get more conservative justices in the court, but unless something really unfortunate happens to the current members, I think there's a good chance that a Democrat will not be able to push the court far to the left in the next four years for sure, and perhaps even for the next eight years. Mostly what it is to me is a lost opportunity to replace Ginsberg and Stevens with conservatives. Had Bush been able to do that (and I had high hopes when he was running that he would) then I think the court would have been strongly conservative for a long time to come. But now its more about holding the status quo in my mind, not about packing it one way or the other.

Comments (3)

Andy
Cosmic: I am praying that Scalia will live to 120. I was listening today to arguments in the Indiana voter registration case, and to arguments a while back in some other case (can't remember which), and Scalia's question to the attorney in both cases was, "Does the Constitution give us the authority to rule on this at all, and if it does show me where?" Scalia is able to put the particulars of any case (sympathy for the damaged party...the possible good or bad that a particular law may bring about in the long term, etc.) aside and move straight to the heart of the issue..."Does this violate the Constitution...does the Constitution allow it...does it disallow it?" Thank God for men like Antonin Scalia. As a Libertarian, I don't have much respect for many on the SCOTUS...even some of them that are considered "conservative." The conservative camp normally votes correctly, but none have the unfailing reliability of Scalia. I have my favorite for President, but I'll take any Republican, because even a liberal Republican can be influenced by "the base" when it comes to Court nominees. The Federal Courts can save, or doom the U.S. at this juncture (to us a GHW Bush favorite). If a liberal Republican is elected, we stand a chance for survival. If a Dem is elected...I'm not so sure that I agree with you that they can't do too much damage in 8 years...but I sure hope that neither of us has to find out.
CosmicConservative
Well most of my hope that a Democrat can't do that much damage is based on the hope that Scalia survives. I admit it, I was once a SCOTUS fanboy. I loved reading Scalia's opinions. He could use words like blunt instruments or like a laser scalpel. And his reasoning was almost always airtight. Compared with other opinions I read I sometimes wondered how the other justice ever managed to get onto the court. Especially Ginsberg... Ug. But not so much any more... Now I just read the rulings and every now and then I'll read an opinion just because I have a strong interest in the case. Getting old and lazy I guess. But I will sure miss Scalia when he goes. What a brilliant mind, what incredible discipline and what unbelievable willingness to speak the truth even when it is guaranteed to anger virtually everyone who doesn't like the truth.
ams182764
IMO, the fact that the "The nine most powerful people in the world" are from an afterthought branch of the government with almost no constitutional definition is an indication that something is very wrong with our system of laws and government. To be fair, the founders had to get the constitution out the door without a continuation of the bickering and strife that could have split our nation right then and their. But they never have defined the supreme court. Instead of a lack of power following from this lack of definition, it has instead become unchallengeable and near absolute power. And why why why did anyone ever think a lack of term limits for such a position was a good idea? The root problem is that the supreme court is that powerful and unchecked to begin with.