Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Religious, racial and gender intolerance in the USA

By CosmicConservative
What an interesting election we have brewing. On one side we have the two seeming frontrunners being a Mormon and an evangelical Baptist minister. On the other side we have a black man and a woman (I know Edwards technically beat Hillary in Iowa, but I just don't see Edwards as truly being as formidable as either Hillary or Obama). If Romney wins the Republican nomination, I have no doubt that there are a number of evangelical Christians who will absolutely refuse to vote for a Mormon, especially a Mormon they believe is not really serious about abortion. I am quite convinced that many of them will stay home and essentially wash their hands of the election and say it was out of their hands because all of the candidates were unacceptable. This could very well cost the Republicans the election. If Huckabee wins the Republican nomination, I have no doubt that there are a number of secular conservatives who will absolutely refuse to vote for an evangelical Baptist minister who they view as being bosom buddies with "God sent the hurricane because of the gays" Jerry Falwell. I am quite convinced many of them will stay home for the same reasons that the evangelicals will stay home if Romney is nominated. If Hillary wins the Democratic nomination, I have no doubt that there are a number of voters of both parties who will absolutely refuse to vote for a woman for President. A Hillary nomination is just about the only thing that will make a significant number of Republicans who would rather not vote for Romney or Huckabee hold their nose and head to the voting booth and pull the lever for "anyone but Hillary." So Hillary has two knocks against her, and being a woman is really the least of those. The other one is that she is Hillary, and that is more than enough for a whole lot of people to do anything to keep her out of office. So that brings us to Obama, a black man. There is no doubt that there are "Republicans" who will not vote for a black man. It is a major embarrassment to me that it is true that my party currently is considered "home" for racists more commonly than the other party. But I have to admit that to be true. But the question is not whether Republicans would not vote for a black man, but whether Democrats would not vote for one. Because Republican racists are not going to vote for a Democrat anyway, so those are votes that Obama is not losing. The question is how many Democrats are bigots who will not vote for a black man. And I am sure there are some, but I don't think there are enough to make a difference in a national election. Or to put it another way, I actually believe that there are more Democrats who will not vote for a woman than there are Democrats who will not vote for a black man. Which means that Obama is really the most viable candidate in either party right now. His candidacy will energize Democrats and will pull in some liberal Republicans who are caught up in the personality cult which is growing around Obama, but he will lose very few votes due to being a black man. So that seems to be where we are in this country today. Being a black man is the least damaging attribute when compared to being Mormon, evangelical or a woman. Is that progress? It does make Obama the current favorite to become our next President. Seriously.

Comments (10)

Andy
Interesting take, Cosmic. What I am taking away from this (if you are right) is that the Republicans need to nominate a non-evangelical, non-Mormon, white man to have a shot at winning. I could be reading you wrong, but I think that's their best shot...at least for now.
Boyd
And that would be McCain or possibly Giuliani. Sadly, the Fredster doesn't seem to be garnering much support. And while I'd hate to have to vote for any of the current crop of candidates (of either party) other than Thompson, I'd have no choice but to support whoever ends up being the Republican nominee - even if it's Paul (yeah, that's a joke).
CosmicConservative
Not exactly Andy. What I'm saying is that for an evangelical Christian to run for President as a Republican, they will have to run on more traditional conservative values and not run as an evangelical Christian. The Mormon thing is tougher because Romney is a perfect example of a Mormon who has always been mainstream, he hasn't run on his faith, he has run on the issues and his record. The fact that his faith is being used against him when he's never used his faith as a way to validate his own candidacy is particularly troublesome to me. I am afraid that after seeing the Iowa results I am coming more and more to Dadman's view on this whole Mormon bigotry thing. Reagan, and GW Bush to a lesser degree, were able to convince evangelicals to vote for them. GHW Bush, not so much. Right now it looks to me that simply being a Mormon is going to turn away a large number of evangelicals, and I think that's not only bigoted, I think it's counter-productive and self-defeating. I know several evangelical Christians and some of them are truly one or two issue voters, and if they don't feel they have those issues firmly addressed by a candidate, they won't vote for them, regardless of the consequences being a far worse candidate being elected. In one case I pulled out the "lesser of two evils" argument and was told "The lesser evil is still evil." I don't know how you combat such myopic political reasoning.
Andy
Cosmic: Got ya! Good food for thought. Dadman: yeah, yeah, yeah...... By the way, I HATE OHIO STATE.
Drax
We'll see how many of the evangelical Christians don't vote for Mitt. Right now, I don't see anyone beating him for the nomination. I suspect that whatever misgivings they might have about Mitt (for whatever reason...) will be forgiven when they are confronted with a vote for Obama or for Romney. They will have had nearly a year of his dissection in the glare of the spotlight and will overcome whatever fear of Mormonism that they may have (all but the most idiotic of them), just as most of the red-neck, democratic bigots will hide their hoods and pull the lever for Obama. There won't be but two choices. Unless Bloomberg joins the fray...
CosmicConservative
I just don't get Bloomberg's situation. If he does join the fray in March like he says, he will be at a severe disadvantage just because so many primaries and caucuses will already have pledged delegates to other candidates. For him to overcome that is very hard to see.
ams182764
I could bring myself to vote for Huckabee against Hillary. I've suspicions that he's probably anything but conservative fiscally, and that he's weak on foreign policy, but he'll at least have to pretend not to be a socialist. It comes down to a choice of damaging our country fast or damaging our country slow. It's not worth "teaching the party a lesson" in this case, against these opponents. (But, grumble grumble grumble ....)
CosmicConservative
If it's Huckabee vs. Hillary I would vote for Huckabee too, but not just for the reasons you list, I do believe that party trumps person in most cases, so it would be a significantly bizarre situation that would cause me to vote for anything but the Republican candidate for just about any elected position.