Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Mormon Media Monitor

By Dadman
As soon as Mitt Romney's run for the presidency is over I promise to stop posting so much on 'Mormon' related topics. It's just that there is so much of it in the media right now. Of course, if he wins I can't promise anything...
DESERET NEWS - Mormon Media Monitor: Time to grade LDS coverage As an assistant professor teaching journalism at BYU, I've been spending my holidays grading news reporting, journalistic research and First Amendment legal analysis. It's now time to issue some grades for the news media's reporting for the past few weeks on Latter-day Saints and their beliefs — most of it prompted by the presidential campaign of Mitt Romney.
So who gets an 'A' grade?
"A" — The Christian Science Monitor for its editorial about how a large bias against a Mormon for president is the next barrier to fall in U.S. politics; a column by The Rev. Dr. Jack R. Van Ens, a Presbyterian minister, about no religious test for candidates in the Vail (Colo.) Daily; and an editorial in the Erie (Pa.) Times-News about not mixing religion and politics.
And here are the dunces...
"F" — I sure am glad that Dallas Morning News columnist Rod Dreher decided he has the power to decide who is Christian or not; Greg Marchant, an Indiana columnist who claims little knowledge of the LDS Church, shows even greater ignorance by giving credence to the bigoted rant of Lawrence O'Donnell; and if there was something lower than "F" I would give it to this column by Timothy Garton Ash, a columnist in the British national newspaper The Guardian, who leads his column by suggesting that various derivations of the word "Moron" could be used in place of the word "Mormon." It is the kind of "sophisticated" wit you would expect in the worst of high school newspapers.
I'll consider the source where The Guardian is concerned.

Comments (4)

Andy
Well, that does it for me dangit! I'm no longer going to pay attention to anything in the Guardian, or the Dallas Morning News. I'm going to trust The Christian Science Monitor (cough-cough), the Vail Daily, and The Erie Times-News from now on. ;) Romney stands a good chance. He's not my first choice (he's my second), but I sure will support him if he wins the nomination (with no qualms). He might get squeaked out tonight, but I think Huck has about run his string out. I haven't said much about this, but I live 45 miles from Arkansas. I watched as Huckabee supported, and often proposed very liberal initiatives in Arkansas. What really gave me the reds was when he pushed for a $2 per hour increase in the minimum wage (over the Federal minimum wage) in Arkansas. Arkansas is a real "low wage" state. Low wages played a great part in the revitalization, industrialization, and corporate investment in Arkansas. I realized right then that Mike is no conservative. I've got my problems with Mitt. But truthfully, nothing that The Christian Science Monitor (cough-cough), or some lib paper in Vail, CO is going to influence me. I suspect that I am in the majority of conservatives in that. You know...we think for ourselves. There are a bunch of anti-abortion, anti-gay marriage, anti-moral-erosion folks in Huckabee's camp right now. My great fear is that Huck has made Romney such an enemy (and vice versa) that when Huck does crater, his supporters will be left with such bad tastes in their mouths that the "to hell with it" attitude will set in...that would be bad. The thought of Hillary with her hand on the Bible next January is a frightening, sobering thought. I really think that both of these guys have done a disservice to their party generally, and to each other specifically (not my personal brand of Christianity). Romney...well, okay. Huckabee...hell, no way.
Dadman
Yes, Hillary with her hand on the bible (and her fingers crossed behind her back) is a sobering thought indeed.
Drax
Heh. I wonder if Huck's sudden dip in the polls has anything to do with his being labeled "the former pastor" by any and all in the MSM. I suspect it does.
Jessica
Hello- Since you have covered a bit of the recent happenings with Romney, and since religion and politics is such a topic right now, I thought you may be interested in this film coming out this month titled: “Article VI: Faith. Politics. America.” Perhaps it would make for a good article or something. The film was directed by Bryan Hall and Jack Donaldson. It is an intense discussion of the role of faith in politics. The title is taken from Article Six of the United States Constitution: "no religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States." If you haven’t seen the trailer I suggest you check it out: http://www.articlevithemovie.com/ Pretty powerful. Here some additional info about the film: The story follows filmmaker Bryan Hall’s experience as a Mormon during the 2008 Presidential race. While following the debates, Hall becomes increasingly aware of the escalating attacks against a particular candidate over his religion; Mitt Romney, who happens to also be a Mormon. Hall decides to investigate this issue and comes to realize that the issue of religious bigotry in politics goes far beyond his own faith. It has been the subject of intense argument from the earliest days of the American colonies. In the end, Hall makes the case for the need for religious tolerance in America; not just for his religion, but for all religions. Let me know what you think! (There is a complimentary screening taking place at BYU next week too!) Thanks,