Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Welcome to Mars express: only a three hour trip

By CosmicConservative
Scotsman.com News - Sci-Tech - Welcome to Mars express: only a three hour trip Hat Tip to Instapundit.com.
AN EXTRAORDINARY "hyperspace" engine that could make interstellar space travel a reality by flying into other dimensions is being investigated by the United States government. The hypothetical device, which has been outlined in principle but is based on a controversial theory about the fabric of the universe, could potentially allow a spacecraft to travel to Mars in three hours and journey to a star 11 light years away in just 80 days, according to a report in today's New Scientist magazine. The theoretical engine works by creating an intense magnetic field that, according to ideas first developed by the late scientist Burkhard Heim in the 1950s, would produce a gravitational field and result in thrust for a spacecraft.
My thoughts? This concept violates our current understanding of the laws of the universe on a level comparable to perpetual motion machines. Meaning I am much more than normally skeptical and on the verge of calling this pure fantasy.

Comments (10)

Brian
You're right, of course. Still I can't help but remembering that our understanding of how the universe works is only a century (less) old. Our conception of how the universe works was fantasy two, three hundred years ago. We think we've got it right. So did the folks who knew the planets were fixed in cyrstal spheres centering on the earth. So, yes, utter bosh. But worth spending a modest amount of energy investigating.
CosmicConservative
OK, so let's invest a modest amount of effort into analyzing this claim. I'll do an old Einsteinian thought experiement. ;) First, the idea that powerful magnetic fields could pop you into another dimension would require magnetic fields far more powerful than anything we observe, or else the fields we do observe would be gateways already, and none seem to be. Including the dangerously powerful magnetic fields of Jupiter and the sun, not to mention neutron stars. So assuming that it is potentially true that a magnetic field can open a door into another dimension, the flux densities involved would almost certainly be fatal to humans, so how are we going to get on the ship? Let's assume you can overcome this conundrum and can survive the magnetic field somehow, how do you navigate the interdimensional multiverse so that you end up in precisely the universe that allows for the speed of light to be orders of magnitude greater than it is here, instead of, say, one where the speed of light is orders of magnitude less? That'd be a bummer, eh? Where's the cosmic road map? :( But let's assume you can actually survive the magnetic field and insert yourself into precisely the right universe you are looking for. How are you going to accelerate your ship to such incredible speeds? What will you use as a fuel source? How do you know it will work in this new dimension which we already know violates one of the most, if not the most fundamental laws we know of? Let's say you bring along hundreds of tons of plutonium only to find that plutonium is as stable in the new universe as iron is in our universe? :0 But let's assume you can actually survive the magnetic field and insert yourself into precisely the right universe and find some means to accelerate your ship to incredible speeds. How do you know where you are going, and how do you know that where you are going has any relevence to our universe? Perhaps the entire trip you take is completely orthagonal to the three dimensions of our universe and after 80 days of blistereing superspeed, you discover that you haven't moved an inch in our universe. I could go on and on. I suppose you could argue that investigating these claims is worthwhile because they just might turn up some weird thing that has to do with super strong magnetic fields, but that's already being investigated in fusion research, which is where we have created our most intense magnetic fields so far in fusion magnetic containment bottles. Scientists have already spent billions of dollars generating the most powerful fields that they can in order to contain fusion reactions, but none of them have yet popped into another dimension, and there aren't any breakthroughs I know of that are likely to generate magnetic flux densities orders of magnitude greater than what we've accomplished so far. And even if there were, the chances are much greater that such fields will be utilized in fusion reactors, not spaceships.
CosmicConservative
One more thought... Wouldn't it be a bummer if this claim is right, and just when we think we have a magnetic bottle that will contain a fusion reaction, we discover it wants to pop out of our universe entirely, taking our nice self-contained fusion core with it? Bummer. ;)
Cullen
My grasp on all of this is tenuous at best, but aren't super strong magnetic fields supposedly what the military was supposed to be experimenting with as a cloaking device in the Philidelphia Experiment? Which is, of course, logically bunk also.
CosmicConservative
I don't fully recall, but I think they were supposedly working on using "force fields" to bend light around targets to perfectly camouflage things like ships. Of course the Navy categorically denies any "Philadelphia Experiment" ever took place and will provide you with microfilm copies of the logs of the ships supposedly involved (The Navy Destroyer USS Eldridge and the civilian merchant ship SS Andrew Furuseth and those logs indicate that neither ship was in either Philadelphia where the Eldridge supposedly teleported from, nor in Norfolk Virginia, where the Eldridge supposedly teleported to. at the time the experiment supposedely took place (sometime in the fall of 1943). Since the Navy completely denies the event, we have to use the popular accounts of it which describe the technology supposedly used as "force fields." Taking that as a base, it is plausible to conclude that magnetic fields of some sort were involved, although "force field" is not a scientific term and is sufficiently vague that it could describe the utilization of any sort of mechanism that could provide a "field" which would range from sonic energy to gravitational energy and cover pretty much everything in between. Assuming that the Navy is lying and that some sort of experiment did take place, and that the experiment did include powerful magnetic fields, and that the experiment did successfully "teleport" a full-sized Navy Destroyer several hundred miles (luckily into an area of water, I guess) then it would seem that a propulsion system based on that technology would already be in place if it is only a five-year effort from theory to production of an actual engine. It is hard to fathom (sorry, pun intended) why we are still in the "theoretical" stage of this process if four generations of scientists have had a successful event to study already. But since the US Government cannot hide the existence of detainees held in foreign prisons for more than a couple months, I find it implausible to believe that the Government could have hidden a scientific breakthrough such as the Philadelphia Experiment supposedly describes for more than 60 years. Again, I find this entire story to be more than a little "April Fool"-ish.
Cullen
I don't believe the Philidelphia Experiment happened either -- other than in fiction. But I find it interesting that super strong magnetic fields are used as a kind of scientific panacea among conspiracy theorists and hopefuls.
Brian
I suppose you could argue that investigating these claims is worthwhile because they just might turn up some weird thing that has to do with super strong magnetic fields, but that’s already being investigated in fusion research, which is where we have created our most intense magnetic fields so far in fusion magnetic containment bottles. I only note that Clark Lindsey looked at the actual papers the Scotsman article was based on and found it - I paraphrase - possible. http://www.hobbyspace.com/nucleus/index.php?itemid=678 I myself do not consider it likely that this will pan out. But if a few very smart fellows want to chase this down, then we (as a society) can afford the money to let them do so. It can't hurt, and might via serendipity lead to advances elsewhere. Chasing down unlikely stuff is somethng that we're (as a species) good at. We have a unique culture where that mobs of smart guys can devote their lives to doing that; we've better off for it, in the end. And yes, you hit the nail on the head WRT to 'secret government conspiracy' crafoodle. If the Navy did what They said ... it would have been all over the news after the war was over.
CosmicConservative
Heh, here I am in the role of "man will never fly" reactionary... I have no problem with pursuing "crackpot" theories, because it is well known that some of the most outlandish theories of the past are now considered scientific "fact," but I do think that skepticism needs to be maintained in all areas of life, science in particular. My skepticism of this "hyperspace propulsion" is not a general skepticism of the power of technology, on the contrary, I am a technologist and I believe that technology is the solution to most of our problems, not the cause of them. And there is no doubt that we have a lot left to learn about space and time, anyone who thinks Eintstein finalized physics with Relativity would do well to go back and read the statements of scientists of the nineteenth century who claimed that Newton's efforts had "solved all the big problems, everything else is details". I guess one of my main problems is the "I wish it were so" syndrome I see in these sorts of stories. Yes, I too wish we could come up with a means to travel the stars in our lifetimes, or tunnel through other dimensions, or simply to blast through the "light barrier" in the same manner that we blasted through the "sound barrier." But there are subtle implications to such things that are not easily resolved and relate to fundamental physical things like causality itself. My main problem with the story is the "within five years" prediction that was made. I consider it to be wholly irresponsible to suggest that we would have a working engine of this sort in five years. My general layperson's concerns noted above are clearly enough in themselves to demonstrate that such a timeline is not credible. If you can't show me how you are going to move in an alternate universe, how can you even begin to tell me that you are going to be able to fly to a star eleven light years away? If there is some chance that intense magnetic fields can open a doorway into another dimension, my prediction is that propulsion will be one of the least important uses of such technology. Opening such a door will reveal a whole new understanding of the universe that is more likely to revolutionize our entire scientific foundation and will be more likely to lead to fundamental changes in our daily lives than it is likely to lead to vacations on Alpha Centauri. In fact we will be much more likely to find that travel in our own universe is pretty boring and trivial and there are far more fascinating universes out there to play in.
brian
My main problem with the story is the “within five years” prediction that was made. Mine too. But consider that the reporter (The Scotsman writer that is) isn't so much covering science news for the informed but trying to make copy the layman will read i.e. he's selling papers. Of coruse he punched it up - 'ats 'is job, laddie. I've talked with a few of those guys - most reporters who are reallly 'science' reporters are good - the fellow who covers Science for the SF Chronicle in particular. But you get a few assigned to the beat by a sadistic editor and .. katy-bar-the-door it's not pretty. They want a sound bite not 30 minutes of discourse.
Cullen
Related by not, this post just made me think of this ... Cosmic, have you ever been here: http://www.technovelgy.com/ ? Neat site.