Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

A Christmas message from the Archbishop of Canterbury

By Dadman
Followers of Christ need not believe in the virgin birth, according to Dr. Rowan Williams, supreme leader of the Anglican Church.
THE AUSTRALIAN - Anglicans need not believe in virgin birth The leader of the world's Anglicans has described the Christmas story of the three wise men as nothing but a "legend" and has said not all followers must believe in the virgin birth of Jesus. The Archbishop of Canterbury Dr Rowan Williams has picked apart elements of the Christmas story, including how a star rose high in the sky and stood still to guide the wise men to Jesus's birth place. Stars simply don't behave like that, he told the BBC during an interview. Dr. Williams said there was little evidence that the three wise men had existed at all. Certainly there was nothing to prove they were kings.
Now, I have no real issue with people challenging or disbelieving the historicity of Jesus Christ or Biblical accounts - that's what scholars and academians are paid to do - but I have a huge issue when individuals who are supposed to be Christian spiritual and religious leaders of large mainstream denominations start saying things that undermine the concept of a divine Christ. That's certainly not in his job description. This secularization of religious thought in so-called mainstream, orthodox Christianity is the driving force, I believe, behind the rise of fundamentalist evangelical Christianity in America. Considering where that voting block appears to be taking us in the upcoming Republican primaries I would argue that is not a good thing for conservatism. Try to have a Merry Christmas anyway...

Comments (25)

Andy
Crud, I guess I'll have to drop my membership in the Anglican church now (sigh). There is a huge split coming in the Anglican church within the next few years. Interestingly, it is the African Anglicans that are the leaders in the movement to re-denominate (for lack of a better term). I am really not close to many Episcopals, but I know that there is a surging sentiment "in the pew" in much of the US to pull out and follow African leadership...we'll see, I guess. Cosmic: I have to give you a huge "Amen" on this one. You are so dead-on right. As a Christian, I expect secularists, scientists, scholars, philosophers, etc. to to question my faith. But my faith has very few tenets really...The deity of Jesus...His virgin birth...His sinless life...His death on the cross...and His resurrection from the dead. When The Archbishop of Canterbury even intimates that belief in one of those tenets is not necessary to call oneself a Christian...well, something is really, really wrong in the Anglican church. So this blonde walks into a bar with a spider monkey on her shoulder...oh, never mind. ;)
CosmicConservative
Andy, I suspect you have a whole lot more tenets than that. The divine creation of the universe. The fall of Lucifer. The infallibility of God. The perfection of Jesus. Not just that Jesus died and was resurrected, but that he HAD to die to atone for your sins. I would be surprised if you did not share any of these tenets (and a lot more I could come up with if my eye wasn't hurting like a hot knife was sticking in it).
Andy
Cosmic: Okay...sure there are many Biblical sub-categories, but Christianity (at least my kind) really just revolves around Jesus himself. Creation, lucifer, (this one confuses me a little) the infallibility of God (do you mean the infallibility of The Bible?), are subtexts really to the simple doctrine of Christ. God incarnate, virgin born, sinless in life, crucified, and resurrected from the dead. Those really are the tenets of "my" faith...can't speak for anyone else.
Andy
Dadman: Sorry! I am going to have to look at that top line closer in the future.
Andy
Cosmic: I forgot...sorry about your eye hurting so badly. Get better.
CosmicConservative
Andy: My point is that the tenets you list are dependent on a whole lot more tenets you did not list, but that are just as much a tenet as the ones you did list. I listed the infallibility of GOD as a tenet, not the infallibility of the BIBLE. I know that there are some faiths who believe the Bible is the infallible, divinely inspired word of God. But there are plenty of Christians who don't believe the Bible to be infallible. When I meet someone who does believe in the infallibility of the Bible, I usually ask them "OK, where are the dragons?"
Dadman
Ironically, these Anglicans are still considered 'Christians' while Mormons - who would defend the divinity of Christ to the death (figuratively and perhaps literally under the right circumstances) - are constantly being accused of being non-Christian. This proclamation of Dr. Williams is one reason I have so little regard for what is considered 'orthodox' Christianity and so little regard for those of the 'orthodox' persuasion who accuse my faith as being false and un-Christian.
Andy
Cosmic: I understood exactly what you meant. I'm a simple guy with a simple faith. I have just never heard any argument about the infallibility of God...jeepers, if He is a "Supreme Being, Creator of all things, etc.," well then of course He is infallible. I believe that people try to make Christianity too complicated. It really is a simple faith...at least my brand of Christianity (made to order for simple-minded folk like me). Sure, a doctrinal statement of every facet of Christianity would contain gazillions of qualifiers, tenets, conclusions, etc. So...UNCLE! So, this blonde attorney walks into court with a parakeet on her head...oh never mind. ;)
Andy
Dadman: That is the point that I was trying to make. The divinity of Jesus is one of the VERY FEW "vital" legs that Christianity stands on. I'm not The Judge of this Rowan Williams character, or his "Christianity." But my understanding of Christianity would sure not allow me to follow his leadership. And I think that a multitude of Anglicans will reject it. In fact, they already are. Multiple millions have defended "to the death" (literally) the divinity of Christ. Like I said...there are just a very few pillars that support our faith in Christ. I know I might piss you off here, but real "faith" never resents accusations, rejection, or persecution. So, this blonde, one-legged attorney hobbles into a bar with a fake mustache on her forehead and a Budweiser beer bottle label stuck to her rear end...oh never mind. ;)
Dadman
Well, you just can't win can you? If I receive all the anti-Mormon ranting with zen-like love, acceptance and indifference I'm still saddled with faith in a false religion. If I get my hackles up, well, I don't have 'real' faith. I'm human and getting accused, rejected and/or persecuted for THINGS I DON'T EVEN BELIEVE IN bothers me. Imagine being told that the Christ you believe in is Satan incognito and then getting stoned for it. Your reaction might be...'hey, wait I don't believe that so if you hit me with another rock I'll deck you." Or something to that effect. ;)
pace
I have no idea what Archbishop Williams believes, but I suspect that his liberal description of the origin of Christ represents a conscious effort to try to minimize the degree to which his church is becoming marginalized amongst native Britons. They are an increasingly secular people, and while I believe the majority are mostly ambivalent toward Christianity, even the devout who subscribe to literal Biblical interpretations seem to me to be diminishing in number. Certainly in this country such a statement would result in the pontiff hastily offering an apology for his ostensibly 'misinterpreted statement'. I am curious to see whether that happens in this example, but I would not be at all surprised if he keeps stumm.
Andy
Dadman: Okay...I understand your frustration better now. I was just trying to make the point that any person of faith has to deal with (and expect) misconceptions about their faith. Heck, I have had Roman Catholics tell me that I am headed to hell because I am not a member of "the Church," and don't take the communion at mass and confess to a priest. I have had Baptists tell me that I am eaten up with demons because I believe in speaking in tongues, prophecy, interpretation of tongues, and divine healing. I have had Pentecostals tell me that I am eaten up with demons because I don't believe that drinking, smoking, watching movies, or wearing mini-skirts will send you to hell. (I actually look pretty good in a mini-skirt) ;) It doesn't bother me. They "are" where they "are" in their spiritual search. You asked, "Well, you just can’t win can you?" Well, yes you can. Millions of Christians have been boiled in oil, thrown to the lions, knee-capped, beheaded, raped, blown away in their churches as they prayed, etc. because of their faith. These are real persecutions...the kind that I thank God I have not had to face, and pray that none of us will. It's all about Jesus man...after the first 30 lashes, He probably thought "go ahead, give me 10 more." Bad press, and people misrepresenting your faith are like "the cable going out" compared to what He suffered. He would say "Go ahead, throw another rock." As I said before, I am not a Mormon, and can not really understand what you are going through. Of course, I am sure not Jesus, and can not understand what He went through...just grateful every moment of every day that He did it.
Drax
Sounds like a revival of Gnosticism to me. So....is the virgin birth one of the "literal truths" of the Bible, or one of those famous truth revealing Parables. Depends on who you ask, I suppose....
Dadman
Andy: I'm not really going through anything except some elevated frustration...similar to Ken Jenning's I would guess (see my other post). I am not taking on the mantle of persecution, or at least that is not my intent. I am more than willing to be criticized, ridiculed, even stoned for things I strongly believe in. I've dealt with it with a smile on my face for nearly 30 years. I formally represented what I believe in fulltime for two years in a foreign country. During that time I was spit on, cursed at, and on more than one occasion physically assaulted. I have no issue dealing with the downside of a professed faith. I completely grok the reality that many people of faith (not just Mormons) have been severely persecuted throughout history. Atheists too. Persecution goes around in ample portions for many different groups of people. What I am weary of is the ubiquitous mischaracterization of the Mormon faith that is prominent in the media right now - from the right and left. I'm weary of being criticized and ridiculed for things I don't even believe in. It's an exercise in frustration right now. That's all...
CosmicConservative
Well, the pertinent question to me is whether Mormon's are getting an unfair examination simply because a Mormon is running for the White House. There is no doubt that Mormons are getting a greatly increased examination. But is it an unfair one? I am sure that Mormons think it is. And of course it's "unfair" in the sense that it is never "fair" to promote bigotry and prejudice. But in the overall scheme of similar examinations of other faiths, is it unfair? That's a tougher question. In some respects it is just their turn. Let's wait for the first Scientologist to run for President and see how that compares. I would bet that a lot of Baptists are feeling persecuted by the attention that Huckabee is getting now. Personally I think you got it right originally Dadman, judge the man, not the religion. You should be able to judge whether Romney (or Huckabee or JFK) is going to be led by the nose by their religious "leaders" based on their public history. I would say that between Huckabee, Romney and JFK, Huckabee is the one that strikes me as most likely to let his religious tenets drive public policy. Not Romney. And Huckabee is getting serious grief for that. Go read Peggy Noonan's Wall Street Journal editorial on the subject. She says he's downright frightening.
Dadman
The treatment Mormons and Mormonism are getting right now is a mixed bag. Same as usual I suppose, except that now it has been elevated out of relatively obscurity into the focused light of national scrutiny and debate. Mormons are frankly more comfortable being just this side of obscure. Everytime I mention on this blog some of the 'unfair' treatment Mormons and Mormonism are getting right now in the MSM (and elsewhere) I am resoundingly reminded, mostly by Andy ;) , that millions of Christians have been murdered in the most horrific ways, that my annoyance is an indicator of a weak faith, that Jesus endured so much more, that Baptists are persecuted too, etc. All of it true, of course, but not really pertinent to the simple point I, as a Mormon, am trying to make - that the elevated scrutiny and mischaracterizations of my faith in the context of a presidential campaign are frustrating and annoying. It's a very simple thing I'm saying, hardly worth debating from my point of view. I don't believe I've ever characterized what is going on as 'fair' or 'unfair' because I know virtually anything is to be expected in politics. All seems to be fair game these days. But understanding its inevitability doesn't make it any less annoying...
CosmicConservative
I don't think you and I have been disagreeing on this Dadman, on occasion I try to post a comment that bridges the gap in the conversation. Religion is a very difficult subject, and I know intellectually how the debate can be difficult to endure, but I do not have the emotional investment in it that you or Andy have. And to be completely honest, when agnostics are singled out for ridicule (and they are, the most common attack on agnostics is that we are "cowards, who don't want to acknowledge the power of God") I mostly could not care less about it. I have long ago decided that other people's opinion about my faith are merely that, other people's opinion. If there is a God, I am quite certain that he won't be basing his judgment of me on the attacks of his subjects on Earth. It is instructive to me that we have never had an avowed atheist or agnostic run for President. Every single President has professed to be a faithful religious person, and all of them have prominently featured visits to their church in their campaigns. Would an atheist be getting more "unfair" scrutiny than a Mormon? I think so. I think an atheist would be viciously attacked if one ran for President. Agnostics would be treated a little better, but I would still expect an agnostic to find it very difficult to deal with the attacks of the religious folks. But maybe I'm wrong. Maybe an atheist would not be challenged. But my guess is that an atheist is far more likely to be called an agent of Satan than a Mormon.
Dadman
I agree with you. But, again, I'm not making the case that only Mormons are persecuted or scrutinized. I'm just telling you how I personally feel given the increased national scrutiny, mischaracterizations, and ridicule. It's annoying...
Andy
Dadman: Yea, I know you are frustrated, and annoyed. I experienced ridicule and mockery from family, and people that I thought were friends when I "went charismatic" many years ago. "Them pew jumping...tongue talking...halleluia shouting...holy rollers" It wasn't fun. It was confusing, and pretty disheartening. It took many years of patiently living my life, practicing my faith for them to not view me as "weird," or in some kind of a "cult." I promise you pal, when you express that frustration in the future, I will keep my trap shut about the sufferings of others. I've just been trying to give you a "buck up" pep-talk. Sorry if it didn't come across that way. I don't like it when people that I like and respect are "down in the dumps" about anything.
Dadman
And it's even less fun, Andy, when familial mockery moves to a national stage, when all of a sudden every talk radio jock, political pundit, news anchor, op-ed pontificator, candidate, etc. is expressing their misinformed opinion of your faith to audiences of millions. Like I said before, what is going on as a result of Romney's bid for president is not the normal stuff. I've been through the familial adjustments and my experience has been much like yours. It's easy to talk past one another when blogging back and forth. I think part of the disconnect has been that I am sharing a very personal experience in terms of how it FEELS when discussions of your faith are forced into the national spotlight of a presidential campaign, when mischaracterizations are flung about as if they are fact via virtually every media outlet. I'm not talking about normal ambient levels of ridicule or mischaracterization that Mormonism, and many other faiths, cope with every day. I have no issue with that. I'm talking about something clearly different. I guess I've gone on about this because I've received very little indication that anyone gets what I'm trying to say: Romney's presidential bid has elevated and intensified scrutiny of my faith in ways that are often PERSONALLY frustrating and annoying. It seems like a simple, understandable, easy-to-empathize-with perspective, yet it has generated tons of point-counterpoint discussion. Just know this, if a charismatic ever runs for president, I'll be there for you when the lies and mischaracterizations of your faith hit the fan. ;)
Andy
Dadman: You make a darned good point. I really do understand where you are coming from (at least on an intellectual, though not experiential one). Hey, I'm glad you've got my back, pal. But don't worry about it. If a charismatic ever runs for President, I won't be supporting him...those people are nuts!
Andy
Dadman: Come to think of it, a charismatic Christian has run for President...Pat Robertson back in '88. I remember the Saturday Night Live skit of Bob Dole telling Robertson "...if you can heal people, reach over here and heal my hand...I'll vote for you myself if you can do that, dammit!" There were other laugh-riots at the expense of charismatic Christians at the time. But for sure, it was not at the level of this current Mormon-bash going on...of course there was not nearly as much "media," and the internet was a baby back then. By the way, I didn't support Robertson. I think he is a good man, but I really don't care much for his style, and knew that he would lose big-time in a general election. Bush had the money, the clout, and the party was pretty well united behind him.
Dadman
You're right. Robertson was and still is the brunt of way too many jokes. If it's any consolation to you it bugs the beejeebers out of me when Robertson is ridiculed for his faith, although some of the things he's said within the context of political discourse can make one raise an eyebrow.
Andy
No doubt, Dadman...Robertson has a way of "stepping in it." As I said, I don't like his style. But truthfully, many that are more aligned with my Christian views than traditional Christian leaders, do seem to have a habit of "stepping in it," giving fodder to critics (and rightly so). It does raise an internal argument in my soul..."What's up with these people, dangit?" "Just shut up and exhibit the love of Christ, for Christ's sake." :)