I should have responded to this one yesterday...
I like the comment, I think it's dead-on accurate and illustrates exactly why many reasonable people don't conclude that water boarding is "torture."
But this sort of 'toon drives me nuts. There's no artistic value whatsoever, it's a drawing of the U.S. Capital building, it could just as easily have been replaced by a photograph or some clip art.
Doonesbury used to do this (and probably still does, but I wouldn't know since reading Doonesbury these days is comparable to poking hot blades in my eyes), and it drove me nuts. It seems like such a cop-out for an artist to do this, but I suppose it has some value in providing a platform to make a statement that is generically attributable to one side of the aisle or the other without having to identify an actual target for the 'toon. You could argue that such a technique keeps the focus on the content instead of the alleged speaker.
But it still seems like a cop-out to me.
Dadman
I actually like the way Ramirez draws, so I think most of his cartoons have artistic merit. The question is does the art in any way enhance the message and in this case I think you have a point. Artwork is not actually necessary at all to make the point he wants to make. That's okay sometimes, but editorial cartooning is at it's best when the art and the message work together to make a salient point.
CosmicConservative
I like Ramirez too, which is one reason I don't like this sort of approach. I always felt cheated when Doonesbury would do four panels of the White House that looked like he had copied and pasted them with different word balloons.
Comments (3)