Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Romo vs. Cutler, the great QB debate

By CosmicConservative
So I'm reading ESPN tonight checking on the Broncos after-game talk, and what do I see? A huge front-page story about the "young quarterbacks" in the NFL and who the "best" of the bunch is, according to a bunch of talking-head experts. So, with that category including such players as Tony Romo, Ben Rothlisberger and David Jarrard (all currently ranked 2 - 4 on the NFL QB rating list, and all of whom have their teams poised for a playoff run) who do you think the "experts" picked as the best young quarterback in the NFL? Jay Cutler, of the 6 - 8, recently eliminated from post-season Denver Broncos. No, I did not say "Tony Romo, of the 12 - 1 top-rated NFC Dallas Cowboys, nor Ben Rothlisberger, who has already won a Super Bowl. I said "Jay Cutler." Jay Cutler, a second-year quarterback who has won a grand total of 8 of his 19 NFL starts, and whose career QB rating is 88, and who has thrown nearly as many interceptions this year (12) as touchdowns (17). The rationale for choosing a quarterback who has a yards per attempt value of 7.75 over one who has a YPA of 8.5 seems to be that Jay has "all the skills" and is in an organization that "appreciates the role of the quarterback". Now, I am a Dallas and a Denver fan. I've been watching both of these guys since they became starters for their respective teams. I will admit that Romo has had his bad moments (5 interceptions against Buffalo, a botched field goal hold costing them a playoff loss against Seattle), but they have been few and far between. Cutler, on the other hand, has far more bad throws and game-losing decisions, and far fewer game-winning ones. Now, I do like Cutler, and I do agree that he's got skills. And he seems to be an intelligent and football-savvy guy. But he's 8 and 11, with a career QB rating of 88 and will only get to the playoffs again this year by buying a ticket. Romo, on the other hand, is credited with saving the Cowboys' season last year and getting them to the playoffs, and then leading the Cowboys on a record-setting year that is only (barely) overshadowed by Tom Brady's miraculous year. In any other year (with the possible exception of Peyton Manning's best year) Tony Romo is the hands down favorite to win the MVP award. Now I'm not saying that Tony Romo is an elite quarterback at the same level as Tom Brady or Peyton Manning. But I am saying that Tony Romo has been head and shoulders better than Jay Cutler from the first day that the two of them took their first snap under center. And it is a mystery to me how the "experts" can simply ignore the actual historical statistical facts of the matter and anoint Jay Cutler as the "next elite quarterback" when he has not yet shown any indication other than his "potential" that he is a better quarterback than Romo, Rothlisberger or Jarrard, just to mention three who are considered "young quarterbacks" and who all have more wins and a higher QB rating than Cutler. I'm a Denver fan. I want Cutler to be the next John Elway. But I simply can't ignore the significance of actual facts and data instead of amorphous and subjective "potential." When Cutler actually starts to demonstrate that he is able to realize his supposedly awesome "potential" then I'll give him credit for it. But until then, and as long as Romo, Rothlisberger and Jarrard continue to simply win football games while Cutler is losing them, I'm going to put the guys who have performed better in the actual role of starting quarterback ahead of Jay Cutler. When he earns the title "elite QB" I'll call him one. You can say what you like about Romo, but one thing you have to admit is that whether or not he ends up having an "elite" career, he is certainly having an "elite" season so far. Now, I have to think that Romo, Big Ben and Jarrard are reading ESPN too, and I bet it will just give them more incentive to keep on just winning ballgames. I remember when Joe Montana was considered "too small" and his arm "too weak" to be an "elite quarterback". Well, Joe showed us that the real elite quarterbacks are not the ones with the "potential" but they are the ones with the "will". So far Romo seems to have the will. Cutler's record so far is mostly "won'ts".

Comments (12)

CosmicConservative
Also, it was not long ago that Tom Brady, the current "greatest quarterback of all time" was routinely considered to be a caretaker of the New England Patriots dynasty, not a cause of it, while Peyton Manning, Donovan McKnabb and Brett Favre were considered the greatest quarterbacks of their era. It took this year where Brady is destroying all the existing records for Brady to finally get recognition as one of the best. For the record, I have been saying that Brady is the best QB in the NFL for at least four years now, ever since his second Super Bowl appearance. I have repeatedly compared him to Joe Montana as a quarterback who simply wins football games no matter what his supporting cast might be. I still think Romo needs some seasoning, but if he actually takes the 'Boys to the Super Bowl this year, and has a comparable year next year, then I think he deserves mention in the "elite" category. And unless there is a miracle in Denver and the Broncos rebound from this dismal season with a Super Bowl run next year, I don't think Jay Cutler should be in the same sentence with those other guys.
Drax
I'm sorry, but it is MOSS and STALLWORTH who are the impetus for Brady's insane numbers this year. He's definately a great one, but, Moss deserves the MVP award...hands down...no one even a close second. It is absolutely STUNNING how much a Hall of Fame receiver can turn a mediocre QB into a good one, a good one into a great one, and a great one into a legendary one. McNabb pre and post Owens. Manning with and without Harrison. Montana in KC versus SF with Rice. Aikman with and without Irvin. Brady has been able to win consistently with a bunch of really good, but no great, players, but hasn't even come CLOSE to the dominance of this year. Moss is the difference.
CosmicConservative
I agree that a great receiver helps the quarterback. Moss and T.O. are both in the top tier of receivers, although you would not have thought so for the previous two seasons. Both of them were languishing in systems without great quarterbacks and as much as a great receiver helps a quarterback, a poor quarterback hurts a great receiver. To me it is pretty simple. In order to put up the numbers that Brady and Romo are putting up this year (and Manning put up a few years ago) you have to have BOTH a great quarterback and a great receiver. When Moss and T.O. have had great quarterbacks, they have put up great numbers. When they've had normal quarterbacks they have put up normal numbers. It goes both ways. And I do think that Brandon Marshall is a great receiver. If he were playing with Romo, Brady or Peyton Manning right now, he would be having a career year. He's big, fast, runs great routes, has great hands and can take the ball away from double coverage. If you want my opinion between Marshall and Cutler, Marshall will be the first one in the pro bowl, not Cutler.
CosmicConservative
One more comment on Cutler. Of the current crop of "young" quarterbacks Cutler is looking to me more and more to be comparable to Eli Manning, not Tony Romo. Tony Romo owns the Dallas Cowboys. He owns the huddle. He's the playmaker on the field. He is the one who fires up the offense on the sidelines. He is always working the sideline, talking to T.O. or Witten or his offensive line. He's slapping them on the back and huddling with Jason Garrett between offensive series. He works the team and the team responds. Jay Cutler, in the times I have seen him, seems detached and oblivious to the rest of the team. The coaches have to go to him to give him plays. He shows little emotion and I can't remember seeing him slapping shoulders of his offensive line on the sidelines. Jay may have the physical skills, but the more I watch Tony Romo work the Cowboys, and work the huddle, and break from the huddle with a great big grin on his face even when they are facing fourth and seven on a game-deciding last second drive, the more I see that difference between the two, the more I think that Romo is the heart of the Dallas Cowboys, and the Denver Broncos have no heart at all.
Andy
Cosmic: Yea, you are right. It has been a long time since I have seen a guy come along that has convinced his team to "win with him" like Romo has. He's a real leader. He won't likely win it all, but his "stock" is high right now, so please, please don't buy any of it. ;)
Drax
Yah. Eli Manning has SUCH great weapons, eh? Romo did well last year, and, this year is doing better with the same team that Parcells built. So, we have Culpepper throwing up numbers only Manning and Marino even came close to touching....with Moss. Nothing thereafter. Less than nothing. (Gus Ferotte looked like a superstar throwing to Moss...) Rich Gannon with almost over-the-hill Tim Brown and Jerry Rice takes them to the superbowl and came one call away from winning. In 1995, Jim Harbaugh looked like the second coming of Bart Starr. Not so much after he stopped playing with Marvin Harrison. The list is endless of good quarterbacks becoming great so long as they had a great WR to throw to and returning to being merely good once they no longer could. Romo without T.O. wouldn't be doing anywhere as well as he's doing now. T.O. with Bledsoe instead of Romo didn't do as well. Put them both together any the sum is greater than its parts. When you can do something with nothing (or as close as you can get to nothing) then, that's impressive. Favre. Marino. Brady (although I really hate to call Troy Brown "nothing" as he is a true HOSS of a WR and Antoine Smith was a LOAD at RB).
CosmicConservative
Drax: I'm just going to point out that the biggest bucks in the game are paid to the best quarterbacks, which would indicate that the NFL brain trusts who put their dollars where their mouth is think that of the two (great quarterback vs. great wide receiver) they vote "quarterback" quite convincingly with their pocketbooks.
Drax
Oh, I agree. The QB is the most important position in the game and the one which takes the most intelligence to play well (although many offensive linemen would disagree.) The point, however, wasn't whether or not the QB was the most important position in the game, but whether or not Moss is the reason for Brady's DOMINANCE this year. Not whether or not Brady was "great," (as he surely is...winning three SB's with good, but not great, WR's and RB's)...but which of the two of them was the "difference maker" in NE's insane run of dominance and undefeatedness this year. I say Moss hands down. Not even close. Brady is Brady. Moss is Moss. Put a great QB and a great WR together....and you have something like what you're seeing right now. Add in yet another VERY good receiver and a VERY good TE and a better than average RB....the WEAPONS that Dallas has, that Denver does NOT have...and we see what we see.
CosmicConservative
OK, after today's game, I have to admit that Romo is just a hack.
Drax
Heh. Philadelphia's a good team. Brady didn't look so good against the Jets either.
CosmicConservative
I actually thought Dallas was going to lose that game, but not as badly as they did. I expected a 27 - 20 score or something like that. Dallas has looked vulnurable for weeks. They have won games that they could easily have lost against teams they should be blowing out. Up until now I would say that Romo has been the guy keeping them in the win column, and I guess everyone is going to have a bad day from time to time (Brady didn't throw a touchdown pass either) but based on the stats and recaps I've read, Romo was really unprepared and made a lot of bad decisions. If he plays like that against Green Bay or Tampa Bay, the Cowboys are not going to go far in the playoffs.
Drax
I watched most of the game. Really, Romo was just off a bit and was being pressured by Philadelphia (who have nothing to lose by playing man coverage and rushing 3 or 4 every down). He may have hurt his thumb by hitting someone on the helmet in the 3rd quarter, but was not having a good game from the beginning. Everyone has a bad day now and again. Frankly, Romo had them going a couple of times in the 4th quarter where they might have been able to pull it out like he's done a couple of times. On the first drive, someone moved, and the false start hurt too much to complete the drive. On the second, the offensive line gave up a sack which caused a long pass to T.O. which was intercepted when T.O. fell down on the route. The difference between a win and a loss is frequently just "thaaaat much." THIS time (unlike the other come-back games) the football gods didn't favor Dallas. It happens.