Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Romney pleads for understanding...

By Dadman
It's truly a shame he had to do this. If you missed his I'm-not-a-horned-Satanic-Mormon-cult-member speech today, here are some excerpts:
Freedom requires religion just as religion requires freedom. Freedom opens the windows of the soul so that man can discover his most profound beliefs and commune with God. Freedom and religion endure together, or perish alone...
This great moral heritage (of American values), is shared and lived in my religion as it is in yours. I was taught in my home to honor God and love my neighbor. I saw my father march with Martin Luther King. I saw my parents provide compassionate care to others, in personal ways to people nearby, and in just as consequential ways in leading national volunteer movements. My faith is grounded on these truths. You can witness them in Ann and my marriage and in our family. We are a long way from perfect and we have surely stumbled along the way, but our aspirations, our values, are the self-same as those from the other faiths that stand upon this common foundation. And these convictions will indeed inform my presidency.
We separate church and state affairs in this country, and for good reason. No religion should dictate to the state nor should the state interfere with the free practice of religion. But in recent years, the notion of the separation of church and state has been taken by some well beyond its original meaning. They seek to remove from the public domain any acknowledgment of God. Religion is seen as merely a private affair with no place in public life. It is as if they are intent on establishing a new religion in America — the religion of secularism. They are wrong. The founders proscribed the establishment of a state religion, but they did not countenance the elimination of religion from the public square. We are a nation 'Under God' and in God, we do indeed trust..
We should acknowledge the Creator as did the founders — in ceremony and word. He should remain on our currency, in our pledge, in the teaching of our history, and during the holiday season, nativity scenes and menorahs should be welcome in our public places. Our greatness would not long endure without judges who respect the foundation of faith upon which our Constitution rests. I will take care to separate the affairs of government from any religion, but I will not separate us from 'the God who gave us liberty.'
In such a world, we can be deeply thankful that we live in a land where reason and religion are friends and allies in the cause of liberty, joined against the evils and dangers of the day. And you can be certain of this: Any believer in religious freedom, any person who has knelt in prayer to the Almighty, has a friend and ally in me. And so it is for hundreds of millions of our countrymen: we do not insist on a single strain of religion — rather, we welcome our nation's symphony of faith.
Will this be enough to satisfy all the Mormon-haters out there? Probably not. They are no doubt going to live their bigotry irrespective of who Romney is as a person or what he might say in a speech. But this speech might be enough to earn him the Republican nomination. Time will tell.

Comments (27)

Brian
I have only heard snippets but it didn't sound like 'pleading' so much as 'laying it out with a take it or leave it kinda thing'. Which I gotta say is extremely effective.
mtnlurker
I like Romney though I am an atheist. Orin Hatch, this morning on Bill Bennett's Morning in America radio show said we need a good financial mind in the president's office. Romney has a great track record there. As far as his speech, the most important thing he said was that Church and State are separate for a good reason. I am not a secularist but I don't want a church running this country.
Dadman
You're right, the tone was not one of pleading, but that is essentially what he is doing. This speech was intended to allay fears many people may have about his faith and increase understanding with respect to how his faith will inform his life as President. Clearly, this is a political move in the tradition of JFK back in 1960. I think Romney pulled it off rather well...
Dadman
I agree with you mtnlurker...except on the atheism thing. ;)
Andy
Dadman: Okay...I don't know the makeup of visitors to this blog, but I think that I am probably as able as anyone to explain this Romney-the horned satan-cultist as anyone. I could be wrong, but it wouldn't be the first time. I will try to be brief. Let's get one thing out of the way at the outset. You wrote: "But this speech might be enough to earn him the Republican nomination. Time will tell." I doubt that it will. Don't get me wrong, this is the first time I have heard a candidate for President speak frankly about faith and it's place in our nation in a long, long time. But Romney runs very low in the Republican polls. His speech was impressive, and I truly respect him for it...but I respected him before this speech. I am very familiar with the Republican base (right-wing Christian conservatives), and I can tell you that this whole "I'm a Christian, and I'll never vote for a goddamned Mormon" thing is way overblown. The media goes out there trying to make news and promote their agenda. Sure, there are bloggers, and some moonbat snake-handlers with an agenda that try to make this seem like an enormous problem. The media has reported this as a big problem...but it is not. Romney has gained the endorsement of several high-profile right wing Christians, and these incessant stories about "how will the LDS sink Romney?" are media inventions. If Romney is not the Republican nominee (which I believe that he won't be), it will not be because he is a Mormon. There will be other factors that turn off primary voters to Romney. I have my own problems with the guy...but not the church that he attends. You wrote: "Will this be enough to satisfy all the Mormon-haters out there? Probably not. They are no doubt going to live their bigotry irrespective of who Romney is as a person or what he might say in a speech." I could not agree more. But you make it sound like there are a lot of "Mormon-haters" out there. I really don't think so. But if there are...so what? Just as lovingly as I can say this...it does seem to me that many churches have a persecution complex, and are prone to view people that very much disagree with their doctrine as "haters." Baptist Haters, Catholic Haters, Mormon Haters, etc. You know, Jesus did tell us that the world would hate us, because it hated Him. I think that too many adherents wear their feelings on their sleeves...WHO CARES?!!!!! I am a protestant Christian with life experience in the Southern Baptist, and Pentecostal churches in the south and west. That is the accepted "base" of the Republican party. I don't attend any church now, for a variety of reasons, but I would call myself a right-wing, protestant, libertarian Christian. I can tell you authoritatively that an overwhelming majority of protestant Christians do not consider the religious faith of a political candidate when they vote. Jeepers, just look at our recent Gubernatorial election in Louisiana. Bobby Jindal (a Catholic...remember now, Roman Catholicism is considered a cult by the same crowd that labels Mormonism a cult) garnered support from every major Southern Baptist Pastor, Pentecostal Preacher, and even a few snake-handlers. He got that support for one reason...he was the best man for the job. Huckabee has become the new darling, but I would no more vote for Huckabee (even though his religious faith more closely mirrors mine) than I would for Kucinich in a primary. I wouldn't vote for him in the primary because I live 45 miles from his State and know what a piss-poor job he did as Governor. The man is incompetent in many ways. But if he becomes the nominee, I will be there at 7 am when the polls open. I am planning on that day to vote for Hillary (for US Senate)...if you know what I mean. :) I am trying here to propose that this whole "Mormon-hater" thing has been overblown by the media. Okay, out of the religious faith stuff...On election day, Nov. 2008, if Romney has managed to become the nominee...no Southern Baptist, Pentecostal, Nazarene, foot-washing snake-handler is going to stay home and let Hillary become President without a fight. Romney had an uphill battle to fight at the outset, and I really don't think his Mormon faith has hurt him with the voters. I have a cousin who is an attorney in Boston. I asked him several years ago how in the world liberal Massachusetts elected a Mormon as Governor. He looked at me sort of bewildered and said, "well, I don't think he talked too much about being a Mormon...but he must have been a liberal one." Romney's problem getting the nomination will have much more to do with his record than his religion.
Andy
Something that I probably should have said... I don't really think that the voting public ever expects that an elected official will really adhere to the doctrine of his church in policy decisions, because religions (except for Islam) don't really require adherence. Heck, if Catholicism required adherence to the Pope...Ted Kennedy, Mary Landrieu, dozens of other US Senators, and Sean Hannity would be denied communion. If the Southern Baptists required adherence to the doctrine, Jimmy Carter, and Bill Clinton would be escorted out of the Sunday School Class by the deacons. If the LDS church required adherence to doctrine, Harry Reid would be "Ex'd." I think that the voting public for the most part looks at the character, consistency, and capability of a candidate before deciding...at least I hope so.
Dadman
Andy: Perhaps the notion that many conservative evangelicals and conservative Americans will not vote for Romney simply because he is a Mormon is over-blown as you put it. I don't know. I've seen several polls that suggest the 'Mormon-hater' issue is a significant one, but I'll entertain the idea that it is largely a media invention. Some Mormons, admittedly, do have a bit of a persecution complex, but I would argue that it is at least somewhat justified. Baptists, for example, don't have to contend with popular programs such as Big Love that implicitly throws all 'Mormons' into the plural marriage basket. Nor do they have to contend with recent films like September Dawn that portrays an important Mormon leader as a blood-thirsty, insane religious extremist who murdered people in cold blood. Rumor has it that Dan Brown's (The Da Vinci Code) next novel will focus on Mormon temples and if he gives the Mormons the same treatment he gave the Catholics, well, it's not going to be good. Throw in John Krakauer's recent book, Under the Banner of Heaven, that makes the argument Mormonism is founded on a legacy of violence and vengence that infects it even to this day. I've seen co-workers and neighbors who are not aware I am LDS reading his book. Just a few months ago thousands of anti-Mormon DVDs were hung on the doors of Latter Day Saint homes here in Arizona and elsewhere across the country. If you peruse your local Christian bookstore you will likely find dozens of titles devoted to denigrating the LDS faith. A search of amazon.com will yield the same. A Google search will lead you within second to dozens of anti-Mormon websites. The examples of anti-Mormonism are countless and such pursuits seem to be a freaking cottage industry in some evangelical circles. So no, Andy, I don't agree with you that there is any kind of parity between Mormon-haters and Baptist or Catholic haters (for example). I think the Mormons get a larger dose of the hate and bigotry than most Christian denominations. That doesn't mean other faiths go unscathed, but Mormons get a very large dose of it. Romney's campaign has brought some of it to the forefront...
Andy
Dadman: I will agree with you that Romney's campaign has brought this Mormon issue to the forefront, but the issue is very complicated. "Christian" is a catch-all word in our world. It is my understanding that Mormons, Roman Catholics, Protestants, snake-handlers, and some nut-job neo-Nazi groups claim "Christianity" as their faith. That really complicates things for a thinking person. It is not possible to calculate how many thousands of books, films, news articles, and public speeches have mocked "Christianity." That hits us all. Then within those claiming "Christianity" as their faith it is not possible to calculate how many books, films, news articles and public speeches have mocked either Mormons, Roman Catholics, Southern Baptists, Fundamentalists, snake-handlers, white supremacist moonbats, etc. If you added up the numbers, I would bet you everything in Cosmic's 401-K that Mormons have taken fewer hits than you think in comparison to "foot-washin' Baptists," or them "minnow-munchin', bead-readin' Catholics," or them "tongue-talkin', devil chasin' Pentecostals". Heck...they have been dealing with this forever! And, many in those movements resent the persecution. But that is counterproductive. No movement with a chip on it's shoulder ever progressed it's purpose. Like I said before...WHO CARES? In my adult life I have learned to only be concerned with the opinions of people that I truly, truly, truly respect. Do you respect this Dan Brown character...or this Krakauer dude? Do you fear them, or the people hanging DVD's? WHO CARES? I would really like for you to ask yourself that question, (WHO CARES?) and I know that you will answer it honestly within yourself. Heck...a lot of Christians fear the Mormon missionaries coming around on Saturday morning...but not them so much as the Jehovah's Witnesses...they come really, really early. ;) I really believe that a persecution complex is unhealthy, because everyone is persecuted for their faith. Jeepers...how bad would it be to be an atheist?...talk about being the odd man out in this world...think about it. Regardless of the fact that I may have just blown Cosmic's retirement fund with my wager...I will stand firmly on my assertion that Romney will get almost all of the conservative vote if he gains the nomination. Heck, redneck Bible-thumping heartlanders might hate Mormons...but they really hate Hillary...they really, really hate her. Gotta eat dinner...
Dadman
I don't have a persecution complex and I don't believe the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, as a whole, does either. But persecution is certainly part of their past and to some extent their present. Who cares? Well, I'm not sure who does. My boss? My neighbor? My sister? The prospect of someone I care about and respect being told a whopper about my faith and believing it gets way under my skin. I care about truth, fairness, accuracy, and intellectual honesty. Much of what is said about Mormons tramples all over those ideals. That will always bug me. I will always care about that...
CosmicConservative
I don't talk about religion much because I'm not a religious person. But the Cosmic Wife and Daughter are. Both are sincere, devout Catholics. I can't speak for the bigotry and ridicule that Mormons get, but I can speak for the bigotry and ridicule that Catholics get, and let me tell you, it is a lot more than you think. It is common in urban areas to encounter pamphlets and leaflets that claim the Catholic Church is satanic. In downtown Shreveport when we used to live there, these things were all over the place. I have had people tell me that Catholics are pagans because they practice idolatry and pray to Mary. The reason JFK had to make the speech he made is because Catholics have always suffered from these sorts of claims. Add to that the concept that Catholics are "supposed" to believe that the Pope speaks directly for God, and it is not hard to see why someone would raise the concern that JFK would be taking orders from the Pope. I know that Mormons get a lot of grief. But Andy is right, there's a lot of that going around, and Mormons are not the only target. Are they the biggest target of the "mainstream Christian sects"? Perhaps they are, but I don't think they own that title by nearly the margin you think they do.
Drax
It doesn't take a whole lot of "I ain't gonna vote for no damn Mormon" to either stay away from the booths or vote for someone else to swing an election.
Dadman
Yes, I'm full of excrement and that explains why Romney, in 2007, had to make a speech to allay people's fears about his faith. Such a speech would not have been necessary had he been virtually any other faith on planet earth... And I never claimed the Mormons 'owned' the persecution title, just that many, many people with many different agendas literally make a living out of bashing Mormons. It's just a fact. Is more Mormon bashing going on these days than, let's say, Catholic bashing. I don't really know, but my gut says yes...
CosmicConservative
The only other faith I know of that led to another candidate doing a similar speech was the Catholic faith. 1960 isn't that long ago. I conceded that Mormon's may get more grief than other Christian variants, I just said that other religions also get grief. I had no idea how much grief Catholics got until I married one. I certainly did not say you were full of excrement. All we are saying is that some other faiths get more than you may realize. So some of us sort of understand what you are saying. That's all.
pace
Andy: "Jeepers…how bad would it be to be an atheist?…talk about being the odd man out in this world…think about it." Yes, it's not difficult to imagine an atheist or agnostic in that situation - having to qualify whence he or she receives his or her moral direction. It is unfortunate that Romney is being put in a position where he feels he has to do this, but at least his holding of some faith allows him to even be running for office. I believe that atheism pretty much precludes a credible run at the presidency in this country. The media networks are obviously exploiting the 'issue' to further their agenda.
Dadman
I agree with you, pace. Atheism is a much greater handicap than Mormonism...
Drax
It's a wonderful country. If you're an athiest, then, you're going to be assailed by some of the "faithful" as not being trustworthy to hold such an important position. If you're a Mormon, some non-Mormons are going to question your beliefs. Hey! What about a Christian Scientist? A Buddist? A Muslim, perhaps? Why on earth does it surprise anyone that people question the moral foundations of those of other faiths?
pace
Well, I just hope that the majority of people on your team are able to see through the BS and realize that in the context of the challenges facing our next president, his particular brand of Christianity is really of little consequence. A more important question of these candidates, is how do they, or how will they exercise the tools that their faith or life philosophy equips them with.
CosmicConservative
Dadman, that's why the best choice for any really critical decision-making position of leadership should be filled by a rational agnostic. ;)
Dadman
Everyone is a rationale agnostic. Whether you're a religious person or an atheist, no one really KNOWS what the truth is. It's purely a matter of faith... If you ask me if I know God exists I will tell you I don't know for sure, but I hope God exists. I have faith God exists. An atheist might say they believe God doesn't exist, but of course they can't be certain. It's late. I'm rambling. I just think agnosticism - not knowing for certain one way or another (my defintion) - is a very common state of mind for both believers and atheists...
CosmicConservative
Thats good, then we should have a large portion of the population from which to find good leaders. That's so comforting that I think I'm going to go to bed now. ;)
Drax
I can't fathom a person of faith not being sure that God exists. That is thin faith indeed.
Dadman
Drax: I am drawing a distinction between faith and sure knowledge. They are not the same thing. But faith can be a strong motivator, strong enough to inform all that we do in life, shape our behavior, and influence every decision we make. Maybe it's semantics, but I can't honestly say that I KNOW beyond all doubt that God exists, but I believe so strongly that He does that I have dedicated my life to that proposition.
Drax
Forgive me if I appear lost. I have always considered the "leap of faith" to BE the substitution for "sure knowledge." I would hazard a guess that, except in moments of weakness, you would be in the vast minority of the faithful who were not utterly convinced that God exists and were pretty dang sure that they had picked the one religion/denomination which represented Him perfectly. If that isn't the case, I am utterly flummoxed as to why one would 1) BE a "person of faith" (in what...if you're not utterly sure?) and 2) worship the particular version of the deity that their religion presents.
Andy
Dadman: Okay...a man with an experience is never at the mercy of a man with an argument. Having never been a Mormon, I can't really know what it is like, so I'll have to take your word on this one Pal. I trust your insights on the Mormon community at large, and it's state of mind regarding persecution (for lack of a better word). And, I appreciate the insights. I just want you to know that it is in no way a universal distrust among evangelicals. There are not a lot of Mormons where I live now, but I did live for 4 years in a place where there were. Their personal conduct said far more to me about their faith than some anti-Mormon pamphlet. I'd bet you that your co-workers, neighbors, family etc. look more deeply into your life than your doctrine...whether they agree with it or not. Thanks again for the insights.
Dadman
Drax: Sorry to flummox you, but faith and knowledge just aren't the same thing and religion, including atheism, both rely on faith. Perhaps I am in the minority (I personally don't think so), but I consider it intellectually dishonest to proclaim sure knowledge that God exists or doesn't exist. But faith alone is a powerful thing, powerful enough to change and chart a life, and the more one exercises faith, I believe, the more one gets closer to a 'sure knowledge' that God is real.
Dadman
Oh...I am confident in my faith, but faith is truly a journey with peaks and valleys. I believe rising to the challenge of being faithful in this crazy world brings about personal improvement and refinement not only for ourselves but those around us. I believe CHOOSING to be faithful and hopeful and doing God's will (which I believe is fundamentally loving and seving others) is the reason we exist...