Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Bowl Championship Cartel

By Dadman
It's tough being a BYU football fan. I would guess it's tough being the fan of any so-called 'mid-major' conference with teams who aspire to compete on the national stage, and perhaps one day compete for a national championship, but are prevented from doing so (for all intents and purposes) by an evil alliance of conference commissioners, university presidents, TV executives, and a complicit NCAA. This gaggle of snakes will do nothing to disturb the milliions upon millions of dollars that flow into their unscrupulous cartel each and every year. Now, this corrupt system is forcing more and more schools to seriously consider playing down to ensure their odds of undefeated seasons and lucrative BCS bowl bids.
SALT LAKE TRIBUNE - Effects of BCS more and more ridiculous In a loony season like this one, when a lot of top teams have stumbled not just once, but twice and thrice, and when only one non-BCS-league team stands above the others, maybe the EZ model (scheduling patsies) works. Those who believe that is the wave of the future quite pragmatically look at Hawaii's path - which was made easier when Michigan State asked off its schedule - and nod their heads in approval. It should be sad approbation. One more pathetic aspect to an antiquated BCS system, draped in the pageantry of college football, but meant to keep money funneling toward specific entities who make up a brokerage that is flawed, at best, and corrupt in its nature. School presidents who turn their backs on a playoff, in the name of an emphasis on academics, or on account of any other excuse, are hypocrites who sanction true championship competition in every other NCAA sport, in every other level of college football, except the one where it matters the most in the minds of the public. But, instead, what we get is a parade of evening gowns, a bagful of opinions and mathematical formulas dictating who should win and who should get a shot at even trying to win, based on appearances. And, now, we also get fear of real competition in the regular season - from the very combatants we love to see do battle with whomever, whenever, wherever possible - because it's not the simplest route. How sorry is that?
Nevada just backed out of its contracted game with BYU next year so it could schedule Division I-AA Grambling State. The game would have been a home game for BYU and I'm certain Nevada didn't want to start the season with a loss. Hawaii is going to the Sugar Bowl in spite of the fact they played two D I-AA schools this season. Schools from the Big Ten are notorious for loading their schedules with 'easy' wins. Of course, someone forgot to tell that to Appalachian State. D I-A college football needs a playoff and it needs it sooner rather than later...

Comments (16)

CosmicConservative
Hand feeling better? I read an interesting analysis of the BCS, but I can't find the article now. I don't think you would have liked it. Basically it said that the BCS is doing exactly what it was designed to do, which is to keep the Bowls thriving, and make as many of the Bowl games as possible as attractive as possible to generate ticket and advertising revenue. Determining a national championship simply isn't part of the agenda. The BCS frankly could not care less who the national champion was, they just want to get the highest number of alumni from the biggest schools into as many seats as possible to generate the maximum income. And it does that. It did raise some interesting questions about the logistics of a Division 1-A playoff system. Not that I think they couldn't be worked out, but I would have to agree that such a playoff system probably would not bring in as much revenue as the BCS system does.
Dadman
I totally disagree. I know there are BCS toadies out there, but none of them are real sportsmen. They are all stooges for one or more of the cartel members. I guarantee you if they can ever get beyond the immediate greed and create some kind of D I-A playoff system THAT INCORPORATES EXISTING BOWLS it will make as much or more money than the current system and generate a lot more excitment for what's happening on the field. My hand is only feeling slighty better. I don't recommend breaking your hand...
CosmicConservative
Well, to be honest I hadn't been considering breaking my hand, but I'll take your recommendation under serious advisement anyway.
Drax
I don't want a playoff series for college football for a variety of reasons: 1.) No matter how deep you go (and how deep do you go when you only can play ONE GAME PER WEEK for a playoff series....eight teams?) you're going to leave "worthy teams out" of the mix..and isn't that "the problem" as it CURRENTLY stands? 2.) The chance of career ending injury is so much higher in football than all other sports. Since there are only two reasons for a "playoff series" in college football, I can't see how this is something which is in the interest of the actual PLAYERS. (Those two reasons are: A) We, the fans, WANT IT, and B) The COLLEGES will make more money.) 3.) As it is now, EVERY GAME COUNTS in college football. You don't sit your good players when you're 10 and 1, knowing that 10 and 2 will still "get you in." This makes for a much more exciting SEASON for the fans and the players alike. (Just think about the last three weeks of this past seasons with #1's and #2's dropping like flies...) I think that the computer model needs to be spiked a bit so that strength of schedule is more important. (A 11-2 Conference Champ in the SEC is so much more impressive than an 11-0 Hawaii....) But, otherwise....NO PLAYOFFS.
Dadman
Humbug, Drax. 1)If 8 teams had a shot at a national title it would be a far cry better than 2 that are picked by a computer ranking system that is not immune to bias, 2) PLAYERS from non-BCS schools WANT to prove their competitiveness on the field. You see, it's not about money for those guys; it's about competition. The regular season could be shortened a tad to avoid prolonging the season too much with 2-3 playoff games, 3)every game would continue to count if your goal was to make the playoffs...and then the playoffs would ramp up the intensity. Think March Madness... BRING ON THE PLAYOFFS!
Andy
Drax makes some good points...some that I have thought myself. Dadman: Mid-major conference teams will probably never have a chance to compete for the National Championship. Short story...before the Tulane/LSU game this season, Tulane's coach tried to fire up his team by asking them in the locker room to raise their hand if they had been recruited by LSU. None of them did. He used that, and a passionate us against them speech, as a springboard to have a really good first half against LSU...then reality set in and Tulane got killed by LSU. The point is that Mid-major conference teams are not going to attract enough high level talent to be national champs. But we have Hawaii...In an 8-team playoff, Hawaii would have their shot at the national spotlight. But, the Sugar Bowl ain't bad for national attention as the system stands now. This is the Hawaii team that beat Louisiana Tech in Hawaii 44-45 in quadruple overtime. That is the same Louisiana Tech that lost to LSU 58-10, and to Nevada 49-10. A team like Hawaii does not belong in a National Championship playoff, but they would be there. Mid-major teams need to be happy with their moments in the sun...the bowl games that they are invited to. Like I said, the Sugar Bowl ain't bad. But I feel badly for Hawaii...heck I think Georgia is probably the best team in the country right now. Truthfully, if LSU and Ohio State both go out and look weak, GA could back into at least a split national championship in the polls. But I will give anybody an 8-deep playoff if you will give me the abolition of overtime. I hate overtime...always have...always will. I would much rather see a team 8-0-4, than 10-2 with two overtime wins in this stupid NCAA overtime system.
Dadman
Andy: It's the arrogant sense of entitlement that BCS players and fans have that I perhaps most despise about our present system. If you root for the Tigers I have to think the BCS looks great right now. Oregon, another arrogant BCS school full of arrogant BCS 'superior' athletes, took on BYU in the Vegas bowl last year and got waxed 38-8. This is the same Oregon team that was sitting near the top of the BCS rankings until Dixon went down. You see, Andy, sport is not about entitlements or determining champions based on what should happen. Sports should be about pure competition. Talent and athleticism should still be required to prove itself on the field of play. Oregon failed to do so against the slow, pathetic athletes BYU was forced to start last year. If you support anything less than proving you're a champion on the field of play than you are not a true sports fan in my book. You are a toadie for a corrupt system that systematically excludes other DI schools - it's athletes, its fans - based solely on conference alignment, but happens to include the team you pull for. As weak as Hawaii's schedule may have been this year, I have to support a team that goes 12-0 and beat the team who beat Oklahoma just a few months ago, a shot at a national title in a D1 playoff system. Afterall...on any given day. We need more cinderella stories on the D1 gridiron.
Drax
Why is Eight better than two? In either case, other "deserving" teams are left out. Every game wouldn't count anymore than every game counts in the NFL, once playoff, byes, and home field advantage are determined. (And, in college bowls...we won't have either byes or home field advantages....) They'll sit their stars once they've made the playoffs. (No byes because the colleges want the money from the games....and, with eight teams (or so) who are you giving the "byes" to? What model will be used for seeding?)
Drax
Oh. One final thing. The season determines who are the "two best teams" in college football. Playoffs just determine who is best on any given day. The more days there are, the more likely it becomes that one team will play "above its head" and win against a VASTLY superior team (based on all rational factors over the course of a season), leading to a result in which the CLEARLY inferior team wins the championship. Injuries, too, play a part. You just don't have much of those of any significance in other sports.
Dadman
I'm not prepared to make a detailed proposal on how a D1 playoff system might work, I'm just confident something could be designed that is much better than what we have now... To answer your questions.... Eight good teams fighting for a national championship would be vastly superior to two teams pitted against each other by a ranking system. As a sports fan this is so obvious to me that it's hardly worth arguing. Since it is quite likely that 2 losses could knock a team out of any playoff hopes, it is highly unlikely that anyone would be sitting their stars. Games would still count as much during the regular season, and losing early as opposed to late in the season might not afford you any benefit as it does today. I don't think a D1 football playoff would need to use any byes... I find the debate about this awful BCS system a curious thing. It's almost as if BCS supporters care more about preserving the status quo than they do about giving players a shot for glory on the field. Or they are content to maintain the status quo because their team is already part of the system. They argue against a playoff rattling off excuse after excuse seemingly oblivious to the fact that D1 football is the only sport in the NCAA without a playoff including all other divisions of college football. I just want more good teams to have a fair shot at reaching the pinnacle of athletic achievement. I don't know how anyone can argue against that.
Dadman
Oh...the term 'mid-major' was invented by BCS stooges to help create the impression of a caste system within the ranks of D1 football and justify the unfair exclusion of quality football programs in conferences not part of the BCS cartel... And over time as big money flows into the BCS schools and blue chip recruits see the handwriting on the wall, the system becomes self-propagating. It's pure evil...
Andy
Dadman: I root for LSU, and I'm not a big fan of the BCS. I was just trying to make a point about mid-major conference ability to recruit. Certainly everyone should have a chance to compete, but what do you do? Don't most major conference teams use their non conference games playing WAC, and Mid-America, and Independents already? That's when they get their shot. Call me a Toadie? Oh yea...well my brother can beat up your sister!
Dadman
In fact, Andy, it is virtually impossible for BYU to schedule home and home series with BCS schools. Many just don't want to play the Cougs in Provo fearing they will get beat. Keep in mind I bleed blue and I'm an advocate for BYU football. BYU won a national championship before the BCS cartel shut them and schools like them out. BYU is a competitive program full of dedicated, motivated and well-coached athletes. Last year they went 11-2. This year they sit at 10-2. They are undefeated in the Mountain West Conference for the past 2 years - that's 16 straight conference victories. Programs like BYU deserve a shot at another national championship on the field of play. It will never happen under the present system wherein a 1 or 2 loss team might get selected to play in the NC game over an undefeated Cougar squad. In such a scenario, and in the name of all that is good in sports, BYU should be given the opportunity to compete for a NC in a playoff system. Until that happens the way D1 college football champions are decided will be a corrupt joke in my eyes...
Dadman
Andy: Why do you think non-BCS schools have difficulty recruiting? It's the BCS of course. The best athletes don't want to play for a team that doesn't have a fair shot at a national championship. And it's a cold, hard reality that 'mid-major' coaches can't do a damn thing about. The longer such a system is in place the greater the disparity grows in terms of talent and resources between fat & happy BCS school and non-BCS schools. It makes me want to spit!
Dadman
Oh, I'm sorry about calling you a toadie. I get pretty hot under the collar about this topic. But those ESPN guys who talk up the BCS...those guys are giant toadies doing the bidding of the TV execs. Grrrrrrrrr...
Andy
Dadman: Thanks for clearing that up...now I understand your beef. No problem about the "toadie" insult...I have been called worse (and rightfully so). But I still think my brother can beat up your sister. ;)