Patriots win gift game...
By CosmicConservativeWell, I watched most of the Patriots-Ravens game last night. I saw all of the fourth quarter, which is where all the fun seems to have happened.
There will be all kinds of claims, counter-claims, sour grapes and accusations of poor officiating, but in the end the outcome of this ball game seems to have come down to an ill-fated time-out called by Defensive Assistant Coach Rex Ryan (the son of Buddy Ryan, the defensive coordinator credited with the '85 Bears defensive dominance).
On a fourth and 1, with the Patriots down 4 points near mid-field with less than 2 minutes in the game, Brady took a quarterback sneak and appeared to be stuffed at the line of scrimmage, but the officials ruled that Ryan had called timeout before the play. On the next play, the Patriots were stuffed again, but the officials ruled that the Patriots had committed an offensive illegal motion before the snap, and again ruled the play was dead, moving the Patriots back five yards and turning the fourth and one into a fourth and six. The call was a good call, with the motion clearly visible on replays. But I think everyone watching the game immediately thought "Well, that just gives Brady a chance to throw the ball." Finally Brady was unable to find an open reciever and scrambled eight yards for a first down.
That sequence of plays was pretty crazy to watch. If the Patriots do go undefeated, the '72 Dolphins will claim that they were gifted with this game and so their undefeated season doesn't count. That timeout call will likely become one of the most infamous timeouts in the history of the NFL.
There were other plays in that final drive that Ravens fans and Patriots detractors will claim were run or called in a way that unfairly favored the Patriots. On another fourth down call deep in the Ravens territory a defensive holding call was made on the Ravens secondary. Because the official called the wrong number of the player, many people are saying the call was a bad call, but the replay clearly showed that the receiver was being held, in fact the receiver was held for several yards, it was a pretty blatant holding penalty really. But because the first down was gained by a penalty instead of a completed pass, people will claim it was a bad call.
Finally the winning touchdown was made in the corner of the end zone and the receiver was moving the ball as he stepped out of bounds. Two of the announcers gave completely different analyses of the call, one said that because the ball was being moved from hand to hand, the ball was not in control, and therefore was an incomplete pass. The other said that becasue the player never lost contact with the ball and the ball never jiggled or looked like it was bouncing between his hands, that the ball was in control and it was a good catch.
My personal opinion is that it was a good catch, I've seen far more questionable catches ruled as good catches both in the end zone and on the sidelines. In fact it looked pretty routine to me. I think it was a good call. It was reviewed and upheld, but people will still claim the NFL referees are being paid to keep the unbeaten streak alive since it brings money to the NFL coffers. (The argument being that the closer the Patriots come to an unbeaten season, the more viewers will watch the games, meaning the NFL can charge more for advertising).
There is no doubt that this was a tough game and in the lexicon of sports it is definitely one that the Patriots "should have lost." But they didn't, and the Ravens may have a point that the Patriots got very lucky, but that's how the game goes sometimes. I agree that the Patriots got lucky, but that is simply part of the game. To have an undefeated season is going to require a lot of really good football playing, and a little bit of luck. The Patriots got their little bit of luck last night, now we'll have to see if they continue with the really good football playing. If they play next week the way they've played in the past two weeks, Pittsburgh is likely to win by more than two touchdowns.
Comments (2)