Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Thoughts on a silent Hollywood

By CosmicConservative
Writers on sidewalks outside nets, studios The WGA rolled out pickets on two coasts Monday, after Sunday's last-ditch bargaining session failed to mark sufficient progress to prevent the first Hollywood writers strike in 19 years.
Other than the obvious "thank God!" response I have to Hollywood writers being on strike, I have had the following thoughts about the situation. 1. Why do they need writers on a talk show? Don't they need talkers? If Reality shows can go on without writers, why can't Jay Leno or David Letterman do interviews? Are they really at a loss for words if they don't have a bunch of no-talent hacks put them on cue cards? 2. One of the quotes I heard on the radio from some picket wielding buffoon was something like "the people who put DVDs in cardboard packages make more money off each DVD sale than I do!" Isn't that exact same situation true of American farmers? Haven't we heard for years that a box of Cheerios makes the average farmer about a penny, and the rest of the cost goes to packagers, shippers and retailers? If that is true, why aren't farmers on strike? Or why doesn't someone point this out to the apparently ignorant writer/striker? 3. If the writers are on strike, who is producing their strike slogans? If they are doing it themselves, doesn't that make them scabs against their own strike? 4. If the writers are on strike, who is writing the news? Are we getting scab-written news? If not, why aren't the newswriters on strike to support their fiction-writing brethren? Are they insensitive to their plight? Are they crossing picket lines to get into broadcast studios to write about the picket lines? If so, why aren't the getting bonked on the head as they do so? 5. Do Hollywood writers really think that middle America is going to sympathize with their plight when they see the writers pull up to the picket locations in their Hummers, Jaguars and BMWs? 6. Based on the quality of the average TV show I see these days, do these writers realize they could be easily replaced by your average middle-school class clown? The result would be generally as intelligent, comprehensible and grammatically correct as what we get from the current writers. Bottom line is that I just don't care about the strike. Even if I watched TV, which I stopped doing long ago precisely because of the incompetence of these strikers, I still wouldn't care about the strike because the only stuff I watch on TV is sports, how-to and nature documentaries. And none of those writers is on strike as far as I can tell. As far as I'm concerned the people who write garbage like "Desperate Housewives" can strike until their Mercedes are repossessed. I won't lose a wink of sleep over it. They are a bunch of over-paid, under-talented, hyper-liberal, agenda-driven, self-centered boobs in my opinion anyway. I could write the way they do with half my brain. In fact I'd HAVE to use half my brain, because my full brain couldn't stomach the drivel I was typing. Strike yourselves out of jobs you morons. The world will never notice.

Comments (5)

Andy
Cosmic: You are a real smart guy, so I am going to ask you this. I truly do understand the concept of "intellectual property." When the first file-sharing sites came out, I was really disturbed by it. If someone "owns" a piece of work, then they should be paid for the use of it. I confess ignorance here. Do the screenwriters own their scripts...giving lease to the production companies for their use, or do they just pick up a paycheck for hourly work...or a salary? If they just work for a production company or studio on an hourly, or salaried basis, then this whole thing is ridiculous...(that was stupid...it is ridiculous either way). But, it is not nearly as ridiculous if these people are independent contractors that reserve the rights to their work, and allow producers to use them for a fee. Like I said, I am really ignorant on this subject (as with most other subjects). It doesn't bother me one way or another. All I ever watch on television is Law & Order reruns, and sports. So reruns won't bother me...unless College Football goes on strike.
CosmicConservative
Andy: I really don't know. I know that in the software industry programmers are almost always forced to sign intellectual property agreements that give all rights to the marketing of the result of their labor to the company that employs them. I would guess that since writers are unionized, their collective bargaining has allowed them to gain more control of their intellectual property than software programmers, who are not unionized. But I doubt if they have managed to wrest total control of their product from their employers. I would guess that there is a mix of rights involved, and that contractually they are currently shut out of resell rights in perpetuity, which in recent years with DVD sales overtaking initial movie ticket sales in many cases (especially with direct to DVD movies) they feel that they are losing out on more income than they should. And they probably have a point. But I have to admit that I don't typically approve of the tactic of extortion, and I think union strikes are basically economic extortion. In a perfect world should writers share in the reselling rights in perpetuity for all forms of distribution? Perhaps, but in our world the laws of economics probably just means that if the writers get their way, it is just going to reduce the distribution of their product, not add dollars to their pocketbooks. And honestly, I just don't like them. I don't think they produce a quality product, I think they over-inflate their worth, and I think they are by and large agenda-driven liberals who rejoice anytime they drag our culture deeper into the muck and mire they revel in. But that's only my opinion. I suppose someone else could see it differently.
Andy
Cosmic: I love a guy that says "I really don't know." But the insights from your industry are interesting to me. The screenwriters may have a point, but my thought is: Go become a producer! If your creative mind is so darned creative and valuable, go and become the dude at the top. There are Queen Bees, and there are worker bees, and there are drones...and then there are the human bee keepers that profit from them all. I also agree that I don't care for network television at all...truly garbage. I was afraid that Monday Night Football was going to be canceled last night because Kornheiser wouldn't be able to advance a coherent sentence without his scriptwriters ;) But they played the game anyway...ya gotta love football.
CosmicConservative
When has Kornheiser advanced a coherent sentence in the first place? Doesn't that require a coherent thought? I think that is pretty much beyond him. But he's a lot better than having to endure Keith Olbermann... geez, I can't even listen to the commentary on MNF anymore, I literally turn the sound down and just watch the game.