Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Ultimate Global Warming Challenge

By Dadman
Heh. The folks at junkscience.com are offering a reward of $125,000 for anyone who can prove scientifically that humans are causing global warming. Here's the challenge:
$125,000 will be awarded to the first person to prove, in a scientific manner, that humans are causing harmful global warming. The winning entry will specifically reject both of the following two hypotheses: UGWC Hypothesis 1 Manmade emissions of greenhouse gases do not discernibly, significantly and predictably cause increases in global surface and tropospheric temperatures along with associated stratospheric cooling. UGWC Hypothesis 2 The benefits equal or exceed the costs of any increases in global temperature caused by manmade greenhouse gas emissions between the present time and the year 2100, when all global social, economic and environmental effects are considered.
Darn, if I didn't have so many work and family responsibilities I would get right on this. I like the hubris of this 'challenge'. I think it gives your position significant credence when you're willing to put those kinds dollars up for grabs. As an aside, junkscience.com has been trying to get Al Gore to publically debate an expert climatologist who doesn't concur with his 'climate crisis', doomsday vision of the future. Since Gore has refused to engage in any debate (Gore has publically said that anyone who disagrees with him is nothing more than a stooge for Big Oil; the debate is over) the gadflies at junkscience.com have produced this little video instead. It's a little long, but informative...

Comments (7)

CosmicConservative
I like this too. One of my MANY problems with the whole Global Warming alarmist hype is that they do things like say "Global Warming will kill XXX people". While completely ignoring the staggeringly obvious fact that COLD WEATHER kills FAR more people every year than hot weather does. Every rational examination of a global temperature increase of five or so degrees concludes that the number of people who die from heat stroke or whatever else you want to blame it on is GREATLY exceeded by the reduced number of people who will die of hypothermia. But this is completely ignored by the AlGores of the world because it doesn't fit the agenda.
Andy
Dadman & CC: That's it! I am reporting you both to The Goracle...watch your back.
pace
Some interesting commentary on the film on which this was based (The Great Global Warming Swindle). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Global_Warming_Swindle#Reception_and_criticism
CosmicConservative
Pace: This sort of thing just cracks me up. It's all politics, meaning that the principals involved simply say what they think will sway people to agree with them. Gore's polemic, "An Inconvenient Truth" is very accurately described exactly the way the IPCC head described "The Great Global Warming Swindle". He called it "a mixture of truths, half-truths and outright lies." That is about as accurate a description of the dogma that Gore is pushing as I can come up with. If this is so easily debunked, then let's see someone take the challenge and win the money.
pace
Yes, I found the following quote interesting: >Carl Wunsch said "I'm somewhat troubled that TV companies around the world are treating it as though this were a science documentary. It's not. It's a tendentious political propaganda piece... It's not a science film at all. It's a political statement. He might as well be describing 'An Inconvenient Truth'. I've seen the movie from start to finish, and it's pretty light on science.
CosmicConservative
I haven't seen it, by choice, but my daughter was forced to see it in her college HISTORY class. I do know that a large portion of the first part of the movie is all about how Global Warming is to blame for hurricanes like Katrina, with reams of photos of the devastation of New Orleans. Besides the obvious intent to manipulate the viewer's emotions, it is scientifically inaccurate. Every legitimate climatologist or hurricane expert I have heard talk on this subject says that Global Warming has no known impacts on hurricanes. In fact the latest research seems to indicate that higher temperatures lead to higher altitude winds which shear off the thunderclouds and actually suppress the formation of very large hurricanes. It may well be that the last two years of very low hurricane production are a far more compelling indicator of global warming than hurricanes like Katrina. But try to get Gore to admit that even today... And why should he? He won a nobel prize (I can no longer capitalize those words) for his fact-challenged polemic.
pace
You really should watch it, just to enable you to formulate counter arguments to the discrete claims Gore makes in the movie. I wouldn't say that a large portion of the movie is dedicated to natural disasters, but he makes clever (cynical) use of dramatic imagery to seed that idea in viewers' minds. And you'll get a kick out of his ice-cube observation..