Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Gay babies?

By Dadman
This should get our minds off the imminent demise of the Rockies (in game one at least). Check this out:
BREITBART.COM - Ad showing 'homosexual' newborn causes stir in Italy An ad campaign to counter discrimination against gays has stirred up passions in Italy, using a poster that shows a newborn with the word "homosexual" written on his wristband. "Sexual orientation is not a choice," reads the slogan on the poster that was going up all across the central-northern Tuscany region and was published in national newspapers Wednesday.
And then we have this from Sheryl Swoopes, WNBA MVP in 2006 after emerging from the closet:
I didn't always know I was gay. I honestly didn't. Do I think I was born this way? No. And that's probably confusing to some, because I know a lot of people believe that you are. I've been married, and I have an 8-year-old son. Being with a man was what I wanted. When I got divorced in 1999, it wasn't because I'm gay. I'm three years older than my ex-husband, and I matured a lot faster than he did.
So, apparently some people who are 'gay' do not believe they were born that way. Ultimately, I think the whole nuture vs. nature debate with respect to homosexuality is much more complicated than either side of the issue is willing to acknowledge. Many seem to be born with inclinations toward 'gayness'; many others seem to choose it as a way of life. Here we have another example of liberals shamelessly using dubious means to convince the world that some babies are just born Bette Midler fans...

Comments (14)

Andy
It seems complicated, but maybe not so much. I think that gay people are born gay. We all are born with tendencies and specific personality traits. Some of us are obsessive, driven, compulsive, lazy, addictive, etc. We work to overcome our inborn failings, but the tendencies are always there. I'm not calling homosexuality a failing that eclipses any other, but I know that some straight people, and some gay people consider it to be. I know personally a few gay Christians. That might sound funny to some, but they truly are gay, and truly are Christians. The ones that I know have made a conscious decision not to enter into the lifestyle, or participate in sexual relationships at all...with either men or women. They have given up on overcoming the tendency, and don't want to live a lie...which I find admirable. I have never thought that anyone chooses to be gay. Why would they? Who would subject themselves to the societal stigma, ridicule, prejudice, and often family excommunication on purpose? You'd have to be insane. I know some people think that gays are insane. I don't. I feel sorry for gays, and the unusual challenges that they face in life.
Dadman
So, I guess Ms. Swoopes doesn't know what she's talking about when she says she wasn't born gay. I understand what you are saying, Andy, but I still believe homosexuality is more complicated than just being born gay or not. Homosexuality is a lifestyle with it's own community, culture, mores, norms, etc. I believe there are some who simply choose to be part of it...
Andy
Dadman: Yes, in my simple black and white mind, Ms. Swoopes doesn't know what she's talking about. She was born gay, and had a tremendous personal struggle for most of her life with it. I could go into a long explanation of my experiences with gay people (some relatives, and some kids that have been close to our family), but it would not be productive. This is one of those subjects that people will not swayed on. My position on this evolved through many years of experience (not the arguments from either side), as I am sure that yours did. And as Leonard Ravenhill wrote, "a man with an experience is never at the mercy of a man with an argument." The only argument that I would raise is: Man...why would a guy want to have sex with a man...jeepers, look at us, and then look at women! (It's amazing that there aren't more lesbians)
Dadman
Ha! You're funny. I have a hard time believing Ms. Swoopes is wrong about herself. She knows herself better than I or you do, so I take her word for it when she says she was not born gay. Just to be clear, I think many people are 'born gay', or to put it another way, born with same-sex attractions. Perhaps the vast majority of gay people fall into that category. But I do believe some people choose to join the gay community and the gay lifestyle for reasons that have more to do with the way they were nutured and personal choice (e.g. dysfunctional families, abuse, etc.) than their genetic code. I believe there are complex psychological reasons some people are living a 'gay lifestyle' And because I don't believe all gayness is inherited, the Italian ad featuring a baby with a 'Homosexual' wristband strikes me as very disingenuous and deceitful. Homosexual advocates want the world to believe being gay is the same thing as having blue eyes when the reality is much more complex (as is all human behavior). Further, I believe the effort to make homosexuality a simple, either-or proposition is politically motivated to a large extent. I guess it's fair to say ads like the one in Italy bring out my inner cynicism...
Andy
Dadman: You can take Swoopes' word for it if you want to, but I don't buy it. Don't get me wrong...and I could see how you would, because I didn't go further. I don't think that homosexuality is an either-or proposition. I know personally people that have converted from homosexuality. Their testimonies are quite moving. But I just do not believe that they entered into homosexuality voluntarily. It was something that they had to come out of. It is a hard bondage. It requires (hope no one is offended here) the miracle-working power of Christ to break that innate desire. Okay...Forrest Gump says, "That's all I've got to say about that!"
Drax
When you can convince a homosexual to refrain from homosexuality and embrace hetrosexuality, it would seem to be something which isn't innate. When you can convince someone who was formerly satisfied with hetrosexuality to embrace homosexuality then it would seem to be something which is not innate. While there "may" be a homosexual "gene," I doubt it. The number of "homosexuals" seems to directly relate to the degree of acceptance of that behavior.
Andy
Drax: I share your understanding that society surely does accept homosexual behavior very broadly these days. But, I don't believe that you can "convince" a homosexual, or a heterosexual to switch teams, anymore than you could convince me to cheer for those miserable Boston Red Sox tonight. I just don't believe that heterosexuals can become homosexuals (long, boring, personal stories there). But I do believe that homosexuals can convert through the power of Christ. Maybe I wasn't clear enough in what I was saying...I am not advocating that you could ever "convince" a homosexual to become a heterosexual. That is a spiritual matter (not dealing so much with the reasoning mind, but with what we right wing redneck Christians call "deliverance"). And it does happen. Anyone can ridicule that if they want to...go ahead...hey I can "handle snakes," and "shout hallelujah" with the best of them (but I still never understood the NASCAR thing). Oh crap!...I wrote earlier that I had said all that I was going to about this...I was wrong (again)...okay, this time I really mean it...really...really.
Dadman
Andy: But as a matter of human behavior I KNOW that pretty much anything is possible. Homosexuality is not a genetic trait, it's human behavior...
Drax
Your logic seems to be somewhat circular. If you believe that homosexuality is innate...AND You believe that someone can be "converted" from same sex to other sex love through Christ...THEN The only conclusion is that God made a homosexual (something denounced biblically) only to have them "convert" at some later point. I believe that sex has emotional and physical components. I believe that, at some point, some "homosexuals" have their emotional voids filled by someone of the same sex when they could not have that void filled by someone of the opposite sex. (Or have not as a result of abuse, neglect, or whatever) The physical aspect is essentially mechanical, and, when the emotional aspect is fulfilled, the physical can soon follow. The more accepting of such "forbidden behavior" a society is the more likely that the physical follows the emotional. Further, I believe that, for many, the notion of "if it feels good, do it" is applicable...especially from the male side. And, when society is accepting of the behavior, and it "feels good," then more people "do it." And, yes. People do "convert" after many years of hetrosexual (and satisfying) love into homosexual love. Happens every day. Just as there are many married men out there who engage in hetrosexual love but have a hidden life of homosexual love...generally the kind that we find Craig supposedly engaged in...highly promiscuous and faceless...purely sensation "love." They just like the way it feels, so they "do it." Maybe there's some "gene" which tells people that they're homosexual, a gene which causes behavior which is in exact biological opposition to survival of the species. I just find it hard to swallow that it exists, especially in the numbers we are currently seeing in "open societies."
CosmicConservative
Drax: Be careful assuming that any behavior that does not result in babies as being in "exact biological opposition to the survival of the species." People have examined lots of behaviors and labeled them that way, including celibacy and altruism. Individual behavior and the impact that has on the overal species' survivability is far more complex than "if you aren't having sex, you aren't promoting survival of the species." I could come up with lots of hypotheses of how male "gay" behavior promotes species survivability. I could start with "it reduces the demand for females, which reduces overall aggression and promotes general stability in the population." For female "gay" behavior I'll just go with Andy and say "duh, have you seen guys vs. girls? What would YOU go for?" I'm sure that's a horribly un-PC statement and is likely to force me to give up my own Nobel Prize...
Drax
We can quibble words on that all day CC. When one has sex, one is satisfying the biological urge to procreate. When one does so with someone with whom that purpose cannot be satisfied (in general...not specifically) then, I don't know any other way to classify such behavior as being in opposition to species survival. Heh. One would "think" that, by engaging in such species extinguishing behavior, those who engaged in it would breed such a gene out of existence.... Seems not to be the case...
CosmicConservative
Drax: I don't think it's semantics or word quibbling. There have been lots of legitimate studies on behavior to attempt to explain behavior that is not obviously advantageous to the passing on of one's genes. There are lots of theories on such things, some of the silliest ones are the ones that try to predict behavior based on some calculation of genetic ratios of near relatives. The truth is that some species do things that are really strange that seem like they would harm the continuation of the species, yet they do it anyway, and the species survives. I have tried to stay more or less out of the "nature vs. nurture" debate because it usually becomes a religious one. My personal opinion is that we don't understand genetics, neurology or human behavior well enough yet to know.