Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

How do I draw?

By Dadman
Well, I draw like this when I want to spend a little time with an idea... flyingcartoonist.jpg Cosmic asked me in a previous posting how I draw. I will try to answer the question. Cosmic may be the only one who cares, but it is an interesting exercise for me given that 'how I draw' is not something I spend a lot of time thinking about. I just do it...you know, like the Nike commercial... I should tell you upfront that I have very little formal training in drawing so my 'process' may not be, and likely isn't, ideal. It has worked for me, however. I will try to focus on how I draw when my goal is to create something special, or something I know is going to be published by a paying customer. Before putting pencil to paper I have, at the very least, a rough concept in my mind of what I'm trying to accomplish visually. I work out some ideas in my head about the drawings main characters (size, emotion, action, etc.), I visualize perspective, composition (how will the drawing's characters and other elements be arranged on the page), light sources, and text (when creating editorial cartoons). Sometimes if the visual problem is something I haven't dealt much with before (like drawing a golf cart) I'll do some very rough practice sketches that include the visual elements I want to include. Real artists call these 'studies' I believe and I sometimes use them when my goal is to render something entirely new. Of course, some of my drawings I like the most - like the one I've posted above - flow out of a less deliberate, more organic process that essentially starts as a doodle, but ends up being quite a bit more. Typically, I render my initial drawing in pencil (on smooth bristol board) and do quite a bit of erasing and reworking as I go. I believe the magic, and challenge, of art is found in how the artist's mental vision is ultimately translated to an image on the page or canvas. The best artists are the ones that do this with utter ease. Incredible images just seem to flow out of them like just another breath. I've known people who can do this. Some people think I'm one of those people, but in reality I'm not even close. I often have to work hard to get a drawing 'right'. It's maddening. But, if I persist just a little while I can usually achieve my visual goals. I guess many people can't (like my wife) no matter how long they struggle with a visual problem. A few words about getting it 'right'. This, of course, is the ultimate challenge of creating an aesthetically pleasing drawing. I think this part of the process is my strength. My strength is also drawing big, goofy, lumpy, cartoonish characters that are not constrained in any significant way by reality. My characters are typically very exaggerated (notice the large butt, Cosmic ;) ) and fanciful. Ask me to conform to reality and I will usually produce an attempt at reality that still looks very much like a cartoon. Curses. This is one of my limitations that annoys me a great deal. I think some formal training could fix it, but that's another story. Anyway, back to getting it 'right'... One of the things I like about the above drawing is its detail. Although exaggerated, it seems to work. I like the big dude's organic lumpiness. I like his eyes, his ears, his arms, hands and feet. I like his tennis shoes and watch. I like the little dude's propeller cap and wing tip shoes. I spent a lot of time on the textures and shadows which are both critical elements (in my opinion) to achieving a result that other people will recognize as aesthetically 'good'. Now, back to process. Once I have sketched out in pencil I start the 'inking' process. Many professional cartoonists use brushes and india ink to ink their drawings. I prefer black Sharpies - from the very fine tipped to the broadest tipped. I ink the outline of the characters first using a 'broader' tipped Sharpie. You will notice above that the exterior lines of the characters are a little bit thicker than the interior lines. Then I move inward with finer tipped Sharpies to take care of the details. Once the inking is done I erase any residual pencil marks. A word of caution - inking can be very tricky because it is permanent and detailed ink work is not completely worked out in pencil first (at least not the way I do it). I've ruined more than one drawing with a botched ink job. If I color a drawing I will typically use an ink wash, colored pencils, and sometimes water color. It's rare for me to color my drawings, but I think I may give it a try again, but next time I'll color my stuff using a computer and Photoshop. Usually, I'll render a drawing from start to finish in one sitting. It is VERY rare for me to do a drawing in fits and starts. Part of that, maybe, is due to the fact I tend to get 'in the zone' when things are flowing well and I like to ride that feeling until the work is done. Some of the editorial cartoons I did took hours to complete from concept to finished product, hence the reason the cartoon deadlines were mucking with my weekends. The secret of competent drawing, I think, is having the ability to render effectively what's in your mind or what you see right in front of you. Artists really do 'see' things differently. They see color, shadow, contour, light, dark, texture, perspective, composition, etc. and are able to capture those things when they put their pencils to paper. While artists have to be technicians to a certain extent to do what they do, I believe the most important part of their craft is embodied in the artistic intuition, talent if you will, they bring to the process. Artists don't just see their subjects, they feel or intuit them and that makes all the difference.

Comments (40)

CosmicConservative
I don't know "art terms" so I'm sure I'll use a lot of incorrect terminology... but I think you'll get my drift. One thing I've always noticed about your artwork is that you use a "speckling" technique to do a lot of your shading. Most of the art books I have perused in the store suggest "hatching" and "cross-hatching" as shading techniques. I don't recall ever seeing one suggest the speckling technique that you use. You are so right about texture. If there is one thing that I know I am completely incapable of rendering, it is texture. I love the big goofy guy's shirt, you can almost feel the texture. The next thing that I really like in this and other drawings of yours is the use of highlights. I guess that comes from contemplating the light source before you start to draw, but to me the ability to place highlights where they enhance the image is pure wizardry. When I try to use highlights, my drawings end up looking like they just have holes in the coloring. With your affinity for, and skill with, drawing big, goofy characters, you really should consider illustrating a children's book. You would probably win an award for it. Another thing I really can't manage is hair. When I draw hair it just looks like scribbles. In case you didn't see it in the previous art post, here's a drawing I did on the computer today. leap.bmp It's supposed to be of one of my D&D characters. As you can tell it lacks shading, texture and highlights... Of course, I did the whole thing on computer using the Windows "Paint" program, so it's not like I had a lot of tools to work with... But it bears a passing resemblance to the sort of doodles I do on paper with pencil... Of course I only spent about 20 minutes on it, if that long. That's part of the problem, I don't think I have the patience to do it "right." (By the way, he's not "holding" the knife/dagger strange, he's actually in the process of throwing it, so it's supposed to look like it's coming off his fingers on its way to the target.)
Dadman
I should say I am very 'old school' when it comes to drawing. I draw the old fashioned way - by hand with pencils and erasers. At this point I have only used computers on occasion to color my stuff...
CosmicConservative
When I was doing the cartoons for Softdisk, we didn't have a decent scanner (it was early on in the days of scanning technology, I still own one of the very first commercially available home scanning devices, called a "Thunderscan" which was a cartridge you installed in your ImageWriter I printer...). Anyway, since we didn't have a scanner, I pretty much had to draw and color on the computer. I used to use a program called "SuperPaint" to do them. On the Macintosh, of course. I still think "SuperPaint" was the best, most intuitive graphic program I ever used. It was ideal for the sort of image I posted above. In fact I probably could have done that one in half the time with SuperPaint. These days I use "Gimp" for my drawings, most of which are associated with D&D, either as maps or as character portraits. My pen, pencil and paper drawing is virtually all doodles done at work while on conference calls or such.
CosmicConservative
What, you're not going to critique my acrobatic knife-weilder? ;) That's one of the benefits of sucking, it's just too easy to critique it, so it's no fun. :)
CosmicConservative
Oh, and thank you very much for taking the time to post that drawing and describe your artistic process. I very much appreciate it. And I love the drawing.
Dadman
I don't like to critique the work of friends. I hear it pisses them off. ;)
CosmicConservative
Not all of them. Seriously. And I don't mind tips either.
CosmicConservative
I mean I can critique it myself. I've already noted the monochromatic nature of it. I think the legs ended up being too thin and too long, but perhaps not... that could be stylistic, but since it wasn't intentional, I probably can't call it stylistic. The "high" leg is funky looking, like it's not coming off the hip the way it should. I didn't have time to try to tweak it, and "Paint" isn't a good program for that sort of editing, so I just left it that way. The hands of course. Just blobs with sticks. I think the arms are too thin and the face is too wide. Also the eyes need to have some sort of detail to them, right now they are just about three pixels each. Everything is too flat, there's no 3D feel to it. I could go on. I certainly wouldn't be kind to an editorial cartoonist who drew this way...
CosmicConservative
But, on the other hand, it actually is one of the better things I've produced. Seriously. And as is usual for me, it's not really art for art's sake I was going for, it was more to illustrate the personality of the character. The way I stated this for our gaming group is that this is pretty much the last thing a lot of goblins will see on this earth.... It was more to help visualize how I role play the character than to be art for art's sake. More pragmatic than artistic, which is fairly common for me.
Dadman
Okay, I'll take a stab a some critique. I hope I don't regret it... First, I think some of your own criticisms of the drawing are good ones. Let's look at each one of them a little more closely: It is monochromatic and that's probably because you used the fill bucket in the Paint tool you used to create it. Nothing in real life is monochromatic and when you draw that way it just looks phony. If you look at the shirt, pants or shoes you are currently wearing you should be able to see a veritable smorgasbord of color variations, texture, shadow, etc. A good artist knows how to 'see' and capture the visual nuance and detail of the world around us, including clothing. I don't like the pose of the character. It doesn't look natural. In reality, I think the head and shoulders of someone coming over a wall like this and tossing a dagger would not be parallel to the wall, but more perpendicular like a quarterback squaring up his shoulders and head in the direction of his target before releasing the ball. If I were trying to render an action drawing of someone coming over a wall and flinging a dagger I would do some studies of ninjas doing similar things to generate some ideas. This guy looks like he is involuntarily falling off a wall rather than leaping over one in full control. I can't see the hands well enough to comment on them. But hands can be very difficult; they still are for me quite often. The picture is quite small so it's difficult to see any facial details. In general, the face and hair look okay to me. The biggest issue for me is the flatness you mention. This picture doesn't 'pop' off the page because it lacks the detail work (shadow, texture, perspective, etc.) that is essential to creating an illusion of 3 dimensions on a 2-dimensional page. Variable line weights are also useful in creating an illusion of depth. The knife looks like a candle in this small picture. So this guy could be an brown-shirted East German falling off the Berlin Wall during the 'tear down this wall' celebrations. ;) Just a thought...
CosmicConservative
Heh, I love it. An East German dude, falling off a wall with his "Candles in the Wind" candle being blown out as he falls.... I can see it. The "flatness" issue is one of those things that really gives me grief. I can "see" the textures and colors in my own clothes, but I can't see how to duplicate that effect on paper, or on the computer screen. On the pose, I think you're right. I've been struggling with exactly how you would hurdle a wall, and I envisioned the wall as a pretty high one, so I sort of envisioned a "Fosbury flop" approach to clearing it. But actually the wall is there as a concealment device, not a barrier, so hurdling it doesn't necessarily have to be something that is at the limit of the character's ability to jump, so there actually are more posing options than I had thought about. That's exactly the sort of criticism I was looking for, I'll look for some examples of other means of leaping over obstacles. Then I'll doodle some and try to recreate it with a better pose. If that works out, maybe I'll try to work on the subtle details like shading and texture.... Thanks!
Dadman
Yeah...that's much better in terms of posing. Still lacking a little detail, though... ;)
Dadman
Um...in terms of posing I originally meant to say head should be perpendicular not parallel to the wall, and the shoulders should be parallel not perpendicular. I hate it when I make mistakes like that...
CosmicConservative
NP, I understood what you meant. I'll work on filling out the stick figure tonight, I need something to keep me from going crazy during the World Series opener...
CosmicConservative
So, a bit of fleshing out looks like this: falyn2.bmp
CosmicConservative
Heh, chew on this... falyngoober.jpg The joys of pattern fills and the smudge tool....
Dadman
Consider darkening the wall with shadow since it is opposite a full moon. It looks lit up and it shouldn't given the light source... Looks quite good otherwise...
CosmicConservative
Heh, as you were typing the "darken the wall" message, I was darkening the wall. See, now what it needs is highlights! Oh, and hands.
CosmicConservative
Also, I need to masculinize it somehow. He's looking too much like a chick...
CosmicConservative
A bit more info about Falyn... He's two feet ten inches tall, and is some weird mix of gnome and pixie...
Dadman
If you want to masculinize your character consider adding bulk to the upper body - larger arms, shoulders and chest. I can't see the face well enough to comment, but some beard stubble might help.
CosmicConservative
It's such a pain to fill it out more, I have to go anti-alias everything all over again..... sigh... But that's probably what I'll do. I like the stubble idea too.
Dadman
Lighten the edges of your character's clothing - especially the shoulders, torso and back leg. Since he is backlit, some of the light would bleed over the back edges of his shirt, pants, etc. while the front would remain in shadow. This detail will create a nice 3-D effect...
CosmicConservative
Sigh, I think the head needs to move a pixel or so to the right too...
Dadman
The top of the wall needs to be rougher and less like a straight line. No wall in real life looks like that, especially an old stone wall...
Dadman
I think I'll be quiet now... ;) Go listen to the new Eagles tune...
CosmicConservative
Yeah, I've been trying to figure out what to do about the wall too.. Here's a new version (I'm saving it over the last one so the one previous will look the same) falyngoober.jpg
Dadman
I think this is a huge improvement over the original iteration. Congrats!
Dadman
Oh, on the wall I would try to subtly round off the top of each individual rock using a paint tool or something - not too much, but just a little...
CosmicConservative
OK, that's enough, I really hadn't planned on doing all this, but maybe it was worth it... falyngoober2.jpg That's odd, it looks lighter, but I didn't lighten anything... OK, I darkened it again...
Dadman
Well, it definitely looks more like a real stone wall now. If/when you lighten the edges of your characters clothing given the backlight, consider doing the same for the edges of the stones... That moon is putting out a lot of light...
Dadman
This is a good example of how being fussy and patient with the details can really improve the quality of a drawing. Many just don't have the patience for it, though...
CosmicConservative
Well, I don't. And I know it's still a long ways from "art." But it's pretty cool. I'm going to be sure to bring it to the next session we play... Thanks for all the suggestions! Now.... the important stuff... GO ROCKIES!!!
CosmicConservative
So... does he look like he's jumping the stone wall? Oh, I already lightened the edges of his clothing a LOT. I guess it needs MORE. Sigh....
Dadman
To me it looks like he's leaping over the wall. In my view that is communicated by the posture of the character, the position of the feet and arms. He looks just like a hurdler...
CosmicConservative
Which shouldn't be a surprise since I took that stick figure directly from a google search for "High Hurdles". Here's the actual image I used as a basis. hurdles.jpg I guess that solves the mystery of why he looks like a chick, eh?