Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

I told you Watson was in deep trouble

By CosmicConservative
He's lost his job now.
LONDON, England (CNN) -- Nobel laureate biologist James Watson was suspended Friday from his longtime post at a research laboratory and canceled his planned British book tour after controversial comments that black people are not as intelligent as white people.
This is going to go on and on as long as peope have the energy left to beat him. Man, you would think a Nobel Prize winner would know which side of the PC line to stay on. I mean look at Al Gore. I guess the Nobel Prize was different 45 years ago...

Comments (15)

Tommy Jefferson
Science and facts be damned. Blasphemy of the state religion shall not be tolerated.
Charles
OK.. why don't we end this all here and now, could he be correct and due to our extreme politically incorrect environment, no challenge or verifaction? Why don't we scientifically prove or disapprove the point? Is nothing beyond exploration and validation? We could end this now and eons of bigotry and racism. What is the truth? Do Watson and Darwin have mankind's fundamentals correct, or are we at some circular reference point in the human genome?
Seer
The problem is that intelligence cannot be measured. Any measure of it is relative to the cultural norms and values that are used to make the intelligence test. So for a scientist to talk about intelligence, the definition of it must be very limited and academic - nothing that can be fruitfully debated in public discourse. Given Watson's proclivity for un-thought-out and clearly un-researched generalized judgments of people, it seems like a waste of time to debate his proclamations and it would be better to relegate him to the asheap of history where it appears he's headed. This really isn't about being PC or not, it's about personal bias being passed off as scientific results due to an over-inflated ego. He thinks his credentials will make him believed, no matter what he says. Unfortunately, credentials don't make up for lack of careful research, or fading mental faculties. I find it interesting that the commenter above put him in the same category as Darwin, whose theories were also heavily affected by his cultural biases and have been largely discredited - by careful observation and experiment - except as important milestones in the development of modern population genetics. Survival of the fittest is an assumption made based on patriarchal power-over ("might makes right") thinking that is not borne out by the latest research which shows the collaboration and community trumps "fitness" in nature, in almost every case. Watson - and the rest of us - would be well advised to learn from that discovery.
Andy
I think that the guy got in such trouble because of the way he presented his conclusions. It would be one thing to present IQ, or other testing data from broad samples of Africans, Asians, Caucasians and make a verifiable point about average intelligence among people groups or races. Where the guy messed up is when he said that (paraphrasing) anyone who has black employees knows that they are not as smart (or something like that). When I read that, I knew that he was toast. Sometimes really smart people can say some stupid things. That statement (if he really did say it) was just downright juvenile, and crude. I'm a white guy...pretty conservative, and tired of all the PC crap, but this guy really did dig his own grave. Right, or wrong, there is a classy way to make a point...he missed on this one.
H Arnold
And there is no "racism"....Racism is alive and well in America and the World... This is why these racist will be dealt with political and according to the law for now on. Until these types of people are not allowed to say or deal with the public or receive accolades or money for their thoughts, there will be a call for their immediate removal. This is America and Americans must realize we all must live here together and other than Native Americans, we are all immigrants either by choice or by force (slavery). This verbal nonsense by James Watson must stop!! If these non-scientific non-truths are not dealt with in a swift fashion, then his audience will look at his statements as truths and carry them on within themselves and their offsprings (Jena 6.) These people cannot be allowed to spread this propaganda in public or private. They are influential in the spread. That's why Watson's public speaking was canceled and his job eliminated. His so-called research is severely tainted due to his nonsensical rhetorical that has no basis in fact. His Nobel Prize as far as I and a number of us can concerned, should be in jeopardy also. It's like a so-called track star who lied for years that she did not take steroids and had to give the medals back....she was African American. America, there is a standard of play and racism is not the standard, in public or in private. Anytime a person who is rich,influential, owns a corporation or receives honorable awards says something or acts in a way that is racist, their actions and remarks will be monitored, investigated and acted upon by various constituents. There will be contact with the correct political constituents for appropriate action and appropriate removal. No longer will there be people sitting and waiting for the Bush Administration to take the appropriate action. There will be a change in America for now on, here and abroad because one can see an increase in racist behavior in U.S. corporations, athletics, education, sports, law, real estate etc. Beware, treat everyone fairly like you are suppose to.....if you cannot do that, then you will be held accountable.
H Arnold
Watson is a racist whose research is and may have been severely flawed in the past. There is no basis to his statements made recently. Watson thought he could say anything and spread these racist epitaphs anywhere. He found that this will never be accepted expecially coming from an American. There are now formations of individuals and groups in American who will not wait for the present administration to act. Racist actions (private or public), corporate hiring and promotion decisions, physical actions, speeches, presentations, symbols etc. will be exposed, examined, and then dealt with legally, politically and/or within the media.
Hernan Pisani
I feel sorry for the subdits of the PC tirany. Unfortunately facts are in favor of this kind of statements, is not necesary to be a racist to observe the extremely poor results of pure african societies along the history. Also there are cientific facts that support that ANY non well feeded human being, specially from 0 to seven years old has a strong probability to reach less developed intelligent coefficient (IQ) than well feeded people. This is the case of african people after many generations of starvation. Even though you can observe a lot of well feeded, brilliant black people in the first world, there is no pure black people society or country that shows significative signs of advanced development and social organization in peace. Sorry for relativist people, these are the absolute facts. I will like to see a different reality but... What this societies need is help, the problem is if they really want to accept it or if an absolute corrupted political environments will let it arrive to people that urgently need it.
joseph chen
All men are not born equal. The greatest difference is not in intelligence--the product of neocortex, but in compassion--that of prefrontal. Most human problems, today's and historical, have been caused by beastly individuals who have serious prefrontal problems. check it out.
CosmicConservative
Joseph: I have to say that the suggestion that people are "beastly" because of "prefrontal problems" is a claim that would require serious experimental backup. To me it sounds like typical feel-good liberal mumbo jumbo. From my perspective "most human problems" are caused by people who think their ideological beliefs are so superior that they can rationalize "breaking a few (million) eggs" to get everyone to follow that one "superior" ideology. That seems to me to be based on rationalizing their behavior, which I would argue is clearly the use of the brain's capacity for reason. These people don't think they "lack compassion" for others, quite the contrary, they think it is their superior compassion for other that leads them to pursue the "greater good" for all humanity. Human behavior is not nearly as simple as you paint it here.
joseph chen
CosmicComservative: "Compassion" is a tool for group servival and prosperity, the product of farming (ten thousand years ago) and consequently its enclosed, village style social lives. Prefrontal was created for it (honeybees also have a similar one), and therefore is the youngest part of human brain. Generally speaking it's nice for one to have a healthy prefrontal--it makes your life easier by allowing you to have good relationship with people and society. But to certain human races--predatory and/or parasitic kinds, having that part of brain is suicidal--for the simple reason that it hampers their predatory and paracitic capabilities, which, usually are their only means of making a living. Interesting thing is, the body of a child waits till he (or she) is around 5 or 6 before it decides wether to give the kid a good prefrontal or not. If the childhood is a constant conflict with other human beings an/or environment, the body will check the growth of his prefrontal, so that the kid will grow up a ruthless, merciless, sly kind ready for a hostile, adversarial world. Studies show that so called "virtual reality", e.g. computer games of ultra violent kind, could also create such children. They could grow up persons of no feelings. One important feature of people lacking prefrontal is, they tend to become criminals or dictators.
CosmicConservative
Joseph: Please direct me to some actual scientific basis for your claims. I still don't buy it. Comments like "Prefrontal was created for it" indicate to me a fundamental disagreement with my understanding of the biological foundations of evolutionary theory. Things aren't "created for" any purpose, they just happen and if they help, they are retained. Your assertions here sound like pseudo-science to me, the sort of things found in psychology textbooks as theories promoted by those who confuse ideology with reality. It "sounds" nice, but that doesn't mean it has anything to do with reality. Show me some actual science.
joseph chen
CosmicConservative: Prefrontal was "created" by evolution who selected it for individuals (and bees) to have and to retain when found helpful to them. Study of prefrontal cortex is a very new one, with the first significant finding obtained in 2001, University of Toronto; but related materials are everywhere, hope you can find some.
CosmicConservative
In science it is traditional to cite your references, not publish with a "hope you can find some" evidence to support the hypothesis. It still sounds like new age mumbo jumbo to me.
joseph chen
Sorry but I still think this place is for expressing personal opinions and beliefs, and not for scientific discussions. Besides it could become an affair between two people, unfit for a public forum such as this.
CosmicConservative
You make an assertion, you back it up. It's not my job to go prove your assertions Joseph.