My life and the 'toons!
By CosmicConservativeDadman has been giving me serious grief over my hypercritical analysis of some of the 'toons he's been posting. He has now accused me of being unable to appreciate 'toons at all. He wonders, for example, if I can "approve" of any cartoons.
Well, I have to respond to that, because I happen to have a very powerful association with cartoons throughout my entire life. In fact I can almost divide my life into periods based on the 'toons I was reading at the time.
Now, it is completely fair to say that I am a tough cartoon crowd. 95% of the cartoons I have read I either find unfunny or downright bad. Some of the greatest cartoons in history fit this category. Let's take a little walk back in time with Cosmic and his 'toons...
My earliest cartoon memories are of the following:
Peanuts
Li'l Abner
BC
All of those were brilliant 'toons. All of them eventually veered into banality. Early Peanuts cartoons were brilliant, fresh and downright funny. Later Peanuts were essentially derivative of earlier ones, or were simply boring. But for a long time Peanuts was a beautiful thing.
Li'l Abner introduced me to politics. And to Daisy Mae. The rich tapestry of the strip was the opposite of Peanuts, where the latter was minimalist and static, the former was lavish and dynamic. The denizens of Dogpatch will live on in my head until I pass away. Even the silly Schmoos...
But if I thought Peanuts was minimalist, BC made Peanuts look like a Michaelangelo painting. Some strips were no more than a head and a line marking the horizon. The minimalist setting was the perfect backdrop for the powerful, biting sarcasm of the strip.
But all of these strips were outshone by the great, shining strip of my youth. Pogo. To this day there has been nothing like Pogo. Walt Kelly was to cartoons what Leonardo DaVinci was to canvass. Walt created characters who lived on newsprint. There has never been anything comparable to the powerful satire of Walt Kelly, who could draw the Vice President as a german shephard and the President as a teakettle-shaped spider. Kelly employed different fonts to distinguish the different talking styles of his characters. He tackled everything from bible-toting hypocrites to the KKK (which he called the "kluk klams") His swamp included poetic discourse and hillbilly slang side-by-side. Pogo was the great comic icon of my early youth.
When Walt's fire faded I discovered a young cartoonist named Garry Trudeau. Yes, the same Gary Trudeau who married Jane Pauley and now spews out the lamest sort of partisan tripe you can find anywhere. But in the late sixties and early seventies, Garry Trudeau was a blazing beacon of ironic satire who lampooned both left and right. The denizens of Walden commune were sort of a cross between Peanuts and Pogo, neither minimalist, nor richly invested with the loving care that a pogo strip showed. But the characters had the same political savvy and were baby boomers like myself with many of the same issues, drives and cultural background. I read Pogo as an outsider, with Doonesbury I was an insider. For a decade Doonesbury was the unquestioned champion of the funny pages.
But Trudeau's partisanship grew and overwhelmed his humor. I guess if I were a moonbat liberal I would probably still find Trudeau funny, but I doubt it. I dislike mean-spirited humor no matter who it is aimed at, and Trudeau has lost the ability to satirize without being cruel. I can barely force myself to read his strip today.
But not to worry, as the Walden Commune broke up and the cast went their separate ways (and Trudeau met and married one of the most vicious partisans in the media) I discovered Bloom County. Now at first I considered Bloom County to be a poor man's ripoff of Doonesbury. The art was clearly derivative, and the jokes were sometimes surprisingly similar to many I had already read from Trudeau. But then Berkely Breathed hit his stride, and for a time his star rose until it shone above all others, including the fading Trudeau who was sinking to the west.
But the bloom began to fade from that rose too, and I was in despair, lost in a world of "Cathy" and "Garfield" each weekend, reduced to trying to decide if "For Better or For Worse" was on average an easier read than "Rose is Rose." It was a 'toon wasteland, a period of my life when I no longer looked forward to the funny papers.
Then, from out of nowhere, the master appeared. In the form of a six year old boy and his stuffed tiger, toon-dom was saved, nay, toon-dom was lifted to new heights, heights never even reached by the great masters of the past.
Calvin and Hobbes achieved cartoon perfection. For almost a decade (in my memory anyway, perhaps it was only a few years in reality) I had a daily dose of pure cartoon pleasure. Whether Calvin was getting sent to the principal's office in school, or was engaging in "transmogrifier" duels with Hobbes, every day was a guaranteed laugh, many a tear-wiping guffaw.
But that was before the 'toon apocalypse. Bill Watterson retired and now there is nothing out there that comes close to providing a steady dose of fun. Even the best 'toons provide maybe a chuckle per week, sandwiched between in-jokes or retread humor. There are some islands of quality amid the ocean of toon swill, but it is harder and harder to find them, and more and more are sinking beneath the waves.
I keep hoping a new savior will arrive, and a new chapter of my 'toon life will start. But alas, it does not seem to be happening. I find myself reading quirky web-comics that are funny because they have such a narrow focus. But even they are only funny a few times a week.
So, yes, I'm a tough 'toon audience. I only seem to appreciate brilliance in a 'toon. Mediocrity is not enough.
In today's 'toon world I simply can't find anything to compare to the great 'toons of the past. Perhaps I am missing one, and I hope so. But so far I have had to be satisfied with brief flares of humor in a vast sea of humorlessness. I keep looking for Watterson's successor. I tell myself that it is karma, that for my entire life as one fell, another rose to replace it. But for several years now, that has not been the case.
I guess it's not fair to compare "regular" 'toons with such supernovae from the past, but unfortunately, that's more or less what I do.
In a sea of "Cathy" and "Family Circus" and "Garfield" I can feel my sense of humor drowning.
There are a few bright spots, the tallest islands in the sea of mediocrity. "Dilbert" is one. On occasion "Rose is Rose" reaches heights of brilliance completely out of tune with its daily mundaneness. But those are exceptions, not the rule.
Perhaps the hardest thing is to see Doonesbury reduced from a brilliant bolt of satiric brilliance to a daily liberal primal scream. I suppose I could find something funny in that alone, if I had the proper appreciation for irony. But I don't so I suffer.
That's more or less my take on 'toon-dom these days.
Comments (9)