Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Daily Toons

By Dadman
Let's stick to the real professionals. Today's toons are brought to you by Gary McCoy and Michael Ramirez. Enjoy.

Comments (33)

CosmicConservative
OK, I'll bite... Warning, do not continue if you don't want to be subjected to my need to analyze things in pathetic detail... The Gary McCoy one is what I would describe as a run-of-the-mill editorial cartoon. It's got a solid issue to hit, it's a polarizing one that will make conservatives laugh knowingly and will enrage liberals, so it's an example of an editorial cartoonist who knows his job and is doing it well. Cartoons like this will keep him employed a long time. But it's not going to win any Pulitzers. But it doesn't do much for me. In general my reaction to the content of the first cartoon is a grim chuckle. Which is fine, that's a good reaction to a political editorial cartoon. Now, as for the art. It doesn't do anything for me. I know that someone with artistic sensibilities (which we have multiple times determined I lack) will wax poetic about the genius of the simplicity and the beauty of the coloring scheme, but to me this is a classic example of what I meant by content being important in an editorial cartoon, not the quality of the artwork. I don't like the style, it's too loose and lippy. JC and AG look like holiday matriarchs on a cheap Christmas card, I almost expect to see them bringing out the cranberries. The picture of Al Gore could easily be relabeled "Martha Stewart" and nobody would bat an eye. Speaking of eye batting, that's more or less what these drawings remind me of. The color scheme looks like the artist only had pastel chalks to work with. I could go on, but I'll just leave it with the comment that this is precisely what I mean when I say that your art is light years beyond some I've seen. Now the second one. I like this one much more. I like the content, it's as subtle as a Mack truck. I like it when an editorial cartoon hits you with a sledgehammer. Subtlety has its place, but to me that place is somewhere else. I love the faces of the victims and I love the expression on Hillary's face. I love that the woman is giving the husband grief, not Hillary. There are two things I don't like, one is simply editorial and just a matter of taste, but the other is something that bugs me a lot in most editorial cartoons. The first is that Hillary should be wearing a salmon pantsuit. Period. No other outfit even comes close to capturing Hillary in this sort of setting. She always wears salmon pant suits when she's doing something "serious" because she apparently believes it softens the blow. The second thing, the one that really bugs me, is that the way Hillary is drawn is offensive beyond any need for the point of the cartoon to be made. The artist just had to make fun of her weight and particularly her thighs. I find this to be just as irritating to me as when they draw GW Bush as a little kid about knee-high to the adults. It's simply asinine. I don't like asinine. Although I DO asinine pretty well. But still, in spite of the asinine nature of the Hillary drawing, I really like the second cartoon. It made me laugh.
CosmicConservative
Oh, and I don't mind "sticking to the professionals." I thought we had determined that you qualified for that designation. ;)
CosmicConservative
I have to add this... Since MLK is saying "I have a dream" that should have been carried on to JC and AG. I would have JC saying "I lust in my dreams" and AG saying "I dreamed up the Internet" Otherwise I wouldn't have MLK saying anything. It makes it seem that the artist thinks nobody would know who "King" was without the "I have a dream" word bubble. I don't want to even go where that is leading...
CosmicConservative
Heh, so I looked up Gary McCoy on Google, and the first thing I see is him winning an award for Greeting Card illustration.... sigh...
CosmicConservative
OK, I won't do this to any other toons that are posted, "professional" or amateur. I had to get that out of my system though...
Dadman
Geez... I like them both. Both McCoy and Ramirez have very well defined personal styles - you can immediately recognize both cartoonist's work - and I think that is very important if you're trying to forge a successful career as a cartoonist. Ramirez is by far the better 'artist', but I like McCoy's bizarre, exaggerated style. Speaking of exaggerated style, caricature (which is the art of capturing the essence of an individual through exaggeration) is essential to rendering good editorial cartoons. If you can't draw exaggerated likenesses of your real life subjects you basically can't be a good editorial cartoonist. This is why I have absolutely no issue with the way Hillary is drawn. Her facial expression and, shall we say, girth are deliberate exaggerations of reality. Without it I believe the cartoon becomes less funny. I guess for you it would become just less asinine. Oh well. Editorial cartooning is a subjective art too...
Dadman
You know, it's really hard to believe you find the rendering of Hillary's butt in Ramirez's cartoon to be 'offensive beyond any need...' Methinks Cosmic might have a little crush on the junior senator from New York. :)
CosmicConservative
What I said is that the drawing is offensive beyond any need to make the joke work. The joke works just fine with a drawing that is proportionate to the other figures in the 'toon, neither of which is a svelte model. Drawing Hillary with a huge butt, and thighs the size of tree trunks is just mean and nasty. It may be an exaggeration, but it's an unnecessary one. I stick by what I said, I find it just as offensive as drawing GW Bush as a little kid. I don't find personal insults "funny." I don't think I ever have. I guess I've been the butt of too many sophomoric insults myself. I don't mind criticizing policy, criticizing positions or pointing out logical fallacies in people's arguments, but to me this 'toon essentially makes the following "statement."
"Hillary Clinton is promoting a health care program that is essentially the same as mugging the average American citizen at gunpoint. Oh, and she's got a big butt and bigass thighs too."
I just don't see the need, that's all, and yes, to me that's just pointless cruelty, no matter who the target is. Back to the McCoy 'toon. I really don't like the art at all. I think it's poorly drawn, and the color scheme is just bizarre. The joke is okay, and maybe this guy has some brilliant work somewhere, but this one doesn't really do anything for me at all. I won't do this sort of analysis on another one. I promise.
Dadman
I think I'll quit posting other people's cartoons too. I'm weary of it becoming the subject of debate...
Dadman
Cartoons are supposed to be fun...and hopefully funny.
CosmicConservative
Well, it's a blog, debate and discussion is more or less the purpose of it. As I said though, I'll suppress the urge to dissect most 'toons in the future. I won't say "all 'toons" because if anyone posts one that sparks international furor, I'll most likely comment on it.
Dadman
You seem to be extra critical of cartoons lately. It's mystifying. Whether you are aware of it or not (assuming you care one way or the other) when you pounce on things, as you did with my and now these cartoons, you discourage additional postings. Now, I know that is an emotional response to your criticisms, but I am an emotional being. I can't help it. I am posting cartoons that I personally like (or personally rendered) and you then proceed to tell me (and everyone who reads the blog) why you think they are (to use your words): offensive, sophomoric, insulting, mean and nasty. And that was just your thoughts on the relatively benign Ramirez cartoon. You're free, of course, to slam any or all of the cartoon I post on this blog (or any other posting), but I will do what I need to do to avoid the criticism and contention. I'm not looking for an argument when I post these cartoons. I'm just trying to give the blog's readers some exposure to relatively rare right-leaning editorial cartoons.
CosmicConservative
I think you have taken specific comments targeted at very limited aspects of these 'toons and have applied them to the entire 'toon. It seems that no matter what I say positively the only thing that you pick up on are the negative things. I think I was very positive about the Ramirez cartoon. It's like I put 50 pounds of praise on one side of the scale and 1 pound of criticism on the other, and the scale broke. As I said, I'm going to suppress such urges going forward.
Dadman
Fair enough. You had some good things to say about the Ramirez cartoon. But the criticism just seemed way out of proportion to me. Editorial cartoonists make a living out of exaggerating every aspect of their subjects, both their physical characteristics and their politics. THAT'S WHAT CARTOONISTS DO. Cartoonists that don't exaggerate virtually everything are called illustrators and it's a different discipline altogether (although some illustrators exaggerate their subjects too). We can debate whether or not drawing Hillary with a large backside is insulting, sophomoric, mean, nasty or any of the other terms you used. Obviously it was offensive to you. It wasn't to me. I know Ramirez's stuff well enough to know that large posteriors is a common exaggeration in many of the people he renders. The two holding up their hands are not exactly runway models. It's just something Ramirez does and in the case of Hillary it is frankly an exaggeration of reality. I don't think that is a personal insult, either. It is simply an exaggeration of reality - which is precisely what a good cartoonist is supposed to do. If you consider just the cartoons posted recently on this blog you will see exaggerated lips, noses, ears, hair, feet, head size, and yes, Hillary's butt and thighs. Do you find the other exaggerations of physical characteristics offensive or just the ones involving the physical characteristics of Hillary? So, like I said, the offense you claim to feel with respect to the way Hillary is rendered seems out of proportion to me. But you are entitled to your opinion. By the way, I think Jimmy Carter's lips are drawn way too big and I'm outraged (not). I think I'll continue to post cartoons though. I'm not sure why you have such a compelling need to pick apart cartoons lately, but if that's what you want to do then go for it. No need to suppress the urge...
Andy
Come on...Hillary does have a big backside, but I have noticed over the last year that she does seem to be more attractive in her public appearances (until she opens her mouth)...what was Billy Jeff thinking? Jimmuh Cartuh's lips are too big in the cartoon...but his teeth are too straight. Miss Lillian could have gotten Jimmuh braces with all the money that she and Billuh made from the sale of Billy Beer (I still remember the pyramids made from empty cans of that rancid stuff in the dorms). By the way Dadman, I don't think that CC has a crush on Hillary. I think he has a crush on CosmicWife. CC: Make sure that CosmicWife reads this comment, but delete this line before she does (just friendly advice from one husband to another).
CosmicConservative
Last year there was a flurry of anti-Hillary commentary on conservative blogs because a photo of her in college surfaced. Many of the blogs were crushingly cruel about her appearance. I thought she looked kind of cute, and said so. She looked like the sort of girl I dated in college, in fact she bore a strong resemblance to one particular girl I dated. I think I registered my dislike of the tendency to draw George W. Bush as a child as well, I hope that doesn't lead you to believe I have romantic inclincations towards him (although I do find Laura Bush to be attractive). To me there is a line that you cross in caricature, but maybe that's just me. Drawing Ted Kennedy with a big red nose is OK. Drawing G W Bush with protruding ears is OK. I think what crosses the line to me is when the drawing is not done to exaggerate a physical characteristic for the purpose of identifying the caricature's target, but when the exaggeration is done to humiliate or denigrate the person. Is it fair to say that I know when it is simple caricature instead of cruel intentions? Probably not, but as in the SCOTUS ruling on pornography, I may not be able to define it, but I think I know it when I see it. And when I see it, I find it sophomoric, or perhaps that's too kind. It's middle-school insult stuff. And it should not belong in adult debate, even of the cartoon variety. All that does is validate cruel behavior in other situations. I think it's pretty hard for a parent to teach their kids not to make fun of schoolmates when they are at home laughing at Hillary as "her Thighness". Or laughing at Bush as "Chimpy." Which is a very common thing I hear on blogs and talk radio. It's certainly not the sort of behavior I want to teach my kids.
Dadman
Relax. Ramirez's exaggerated cartoon of Hillary is not going to corrupt any kids. Ramirez did not cross the line; he is one of the most successful and respected editorial cartoonists in the business - well as successful and respected as a right-leaning cartoonist can be in the business. I don't condone or support name calling and personal cruelty even in politics, but that simply does not describe what Ramirez is doing in this cartoon. Not even close. His exaggerations of Hillary are within the boundaries of reasonableness and acceptable limits. It's an exaggeration that, in my view, help the reader identify the character as Hillary Clinton. By the way, why would it be okay to render Bush with protruding ears, like a chimpanzee, when we know the lefty blogs like to refer to him as Chimpy McHitler? I'm failing to see the distinction you are attempting to draw between one exaggeration and another. Gotta run now...
CosmicConservative
I said it was impossible to define, but that I knew it when I saw it. I also said that I might be wrong sometimes. You think I over-reacted to the drawing, I think you over-reacted to my critique. ;) Let's just say I'm hypersensitive to what I consider to be a specific intent to be cruel. I try not to be partisan in that sensitivity, I think I am equally sensitive when the target is Whoopi Goldberg or Rush Limbaugh. Drawing Limbaugh as a drug addict qualifies, as does drawing Whoopi as a whore. Neither is necessary to distinguish the target, those things are done to score points with like-minded ideologues. This is why, for example, I find it very difficult to listen to a lot of talk radio, and why I like Bill Bennett so much. I know a lot of conservatives who love Laura Ingrahim or Ann Coulter. Now I'm not saying that Laura is anywhere near as offensive as Ann Coulter, but I will say that I find Laura sophomoric and insulting enough in her elitist tirades that I frequently turn her off. She has been known to use the "her Thighness" moniker, for example. Making derogatory comments about someone's physical characteristics is, I think, simply rude. And it adds nothing to the debate, in fact it tends to make me think that the debater must have a pretty weak point to make if they are reduced to middle-school gossip instead of making valid points. Yes, I know that such things are the stock in trade of the political caricaturist. All you have to do is look in the NY Times to see Bush drawn as a chimp, as a child or as a village idiot. Who is the editorial cartoonist who thinks it is "clever" to draw Bush with a dunce cap? How sublimely clever that is. It's almost third grade intellect, but no doubt his audience sucks it up. "Heh... he drew Bush with a dunce cap. heh heh... that's funny because it's so true..." I hate that stuff. I hate it no matter who the target is. I guess a lot of it goes back to Reagan when he was being typically depicted as a brainless cowboy puppet all the time. Perhaps the pinnacle of the whole thing was reached when Garry Trudeau published "In Search Of Reagan's Brain" an entire collection of cartoons that depicted Ronald Reagan as completely lacking any brains whatsoever. The whole point of the effort was not to lampoon, it was to ridicule. It was not to satirize, it was to demonize. And I've been hypersensitive to such efforts ever since. I consider them to be the worst form of propogandizing, precisely because they appeal so directly to the baser human instincts that we all have. I prefer to think that my own disagreements with Hillary have nothing to do with the breadth of her thighs. And I like to think that if I wanted to be critical of Hillary, I could do so without saying, either literally or (pun warning) figuratively, "oh yeah fatty thighs?" I like to think my criticisms would have more merit than that. But, as you say, I tend to over-analyze these things.
Dadman
I think you like to debate things... You seem to be missing the very raison d'etre of editorial cartoons. The are, virtually by definition, caricatures, exaggerations, and propaganda. But let's try to keep this discussion focused. We are not talking about talk radio (I actually feel very much like you do about it), we're not talking about blatant mockery of another person's physical attributes, or what kids do/say to other kids in school. We're talking about a Michael Ramirez cartoon and whether or not he crossed the line. Obviously, it is a matter of personally judgement, but I have to think if you have an issue with this relatively tame Ramirez cartoon, you would have to extend your criticism to virutally ALL editorial cartoons. With few exceptions, editorial cartoonists make their targets look goofy, stupid, silly, moronic, deformed, etc. They do it on purpose. They do it with enthusiasm. They do it to make an exaggerated, propagandized, editorial comment. It's simply part and parcel of the trade. One of my most successful cartoons depicted a local politican dressed as Marie Antionette complete with an exagerrated nose, lips and man-boobs...oh yes, and a tiara. I think your boundary conditions would make it difficult for you to work as an editorial cartoonist. While I agree with you that Whoopi Goldberg portrayed as a whore for no good reason is out of bounds, tackling the issue of Rush Limbaugh's drug addiction certainly is not. He WAS addicted to drugs and I'm sure he's made comments about drug addicts on his program in the past 20 years. It's fair game as far as I'm concerned. Bush as a child, a chimp, or wearing a dunce cap? Well, that is the view of the cartoonist, but I tend to agree with you on this one. It seems the only purpose of such renderings is to denigrate. Now, if the press dug up a Bush academic transcript revealing he had failed 25% of all his courses in college, well, then the dunce cap cartoon would become pertinent to the conversation and a 'fair' device for an editorial cartoon. Ramirez's cartoon of Hillary is certainly exaggerated, but I know it could have been SO MUCH MORE exaggerated if it was Ramirez's intent be cruel, mean and/or nasty as you contend.
CosmicConservative
My problem with that is that when Ramirez went to draw Hillary, he either intentionally drew her with massive thighs and butt or did not. If he did, then I have to ask why he did so since I've seen tons of pictures of Hillary and I cannot say that it ever crossed my mind that she had massive thighs or enlarged buttox. Compared to Megan Fox, perhaps. But compared to any average woman of her age, I would consider Hillary to be, if anything, somewhat slim. If he just generally draws butts and thighs like that, then OK, but he did not draw either the man or the woman with grossly large thighs. Only Hillary. So I reached the conclusion that he did it deliberately. So then the question of why a caricaturist would pick Hillary's thighs to lampoon comes to mind. And the only reason I can think of is because cruel-intentioned right-wing commentators have unfairly criticized Hillary's thighs for years. Not because her thighs are actually grotesquely large, just because it somehow became a right-wing meme. So he is not caricaturing an actual attribute of Hillary, he is actually pandering to the right-wing perception of Hillary, which is another thing altogether. Now he's not drawing Hillary with big thighs because she objectively HAS thighs that deserve to be exaggerated, he is drawing them because he knows that his target audience will react much like the left-wing ideologue reacts to Bush's dunce cap. "Heh, look at Hillary's thighs. That's great! That's 'her thighness' to a T!" Now, do you really believe that Hillary Clinton has abnormally large thighs? Or an abnormally large butt? I contend that she does not. If she actually does have thighs that are obviously unnaturally large, then I stand corrected. I just don't think she does. Now, I suppose you could argue that for the caricaturist it is just as valid to exaggerate an imagined attribute if it resonates with their target audience. That argument eventually becomes an economic one. Will that make the artist more salable? Will it increase the value of their product because it resonates more deeply with their target consumer? Sure, it does. But I have to say I don't care that much for a lot of things that resonate with their target consumer. Like most of what's on TV for example. And for much of the same reason. I guess the bottom line of all of this is that I'm just an old fogey with an heightened sense of what should be appropriate in public discourse. I will admit that for me to rag on a political cartoon when there is so much unadulterated crap on the TV is a bit like complaining about the gnats in a hurricane. But I think if I were to post my opinion of, say, "Desperate Housewives" you'd probably have some of the same issues with my criticism of that. I don't think that Ramirez was grossly cruel or insensitive. I liked the cartoon. I thought it was funny. The good things in it vastly outweighed the two things I thought could have been done better. But the bottom line is that I still think that his conscious choice to draw Hillary with tree-trunk thighs was a case of him pandering to his audience in a manner that he would probably have a problem with if someone did the same thing to his wife. Or him. I think he'd say "what's that got to do with anything?" And that's where I am. What do Hillary's thighs have to do with anything? Nothing. So why draw attention to them? Because it panders to his base. There is no other reason that I can come up with for him to have done it. And that is why I criticize it. I don't like pandering to people's baser instincts. Really it's that simple.
CosmicConservative
Oh, to address the idea that I must have problems with most political cartoons, I will have to answer that in the affirmative. I do have similar problems with most political cartoons. But that doesn't mean I don't enjoy them. I liked Ramirez's cartoon. But that doesn't mean I don't notice things I don't like about them. There are few (if any) things in the real world that I don't look at and notice (and sometimes comment upon) flaws. That doesn't mean that the overall product is irredeemable. It just means that in the overall analysis of the thing, I can see the good things and the bad things. Sometimes the good outweighs the bad, and sometimes vice versa. I find Jessica Alba to be extremely beautiful. I think she's got sorta chubby cheeks.
Dadman
Sigh... He did it because he's an artist, a cartoonist whose job it is to create exaggerated imagery and caricatures of his subjects that resonate with his target population. That's his job. I do think, in terms of visual aesthetics, that Hillary's thighs and butt are larger than many women so that reality must come into play when creating the imagery. A cartoonist who fails to do so will fail to create a character that resonates as Hillary Clinton with those who view it - liberal or conservative. I guess you view that as pandering to baser instincts. I don't. I can tell you, as a cartoonist who has grappled with the problem of capturing the essence of a subject via exaggeration and caricature, that it's really more a matter of getting the image right. A rendered Hillary with a small or average sized butt would have failed to capture her essence. I can't believe I'm debating this... I assert that if you condemn this editorial cartoon you are going to have to condemn virtually all editorial cartoons because of the way they exaggerate subjects in unflattering ways. It's no wonder you can't have any fun. ;)
Andy
CC: I do understand your aversion to making fun of personal appearance. You know me personally, and can understand how caricatures with bird legs, big noses, narrow shoulders, and big heads could possibly be offensive to me. But the craft of cartooning does not involve photography, or portraiture. I guess there are some photo cartoon experts out there...and they are pretty funny...but big butts, big heads, bad teeth, and bird legs are fair game in that biz. I tried to draw a cartoon once...it was pretty disappointing...I thought it was good, but when your Mom says, "Well now...tell me about this," you know that it's crap.
CosmicConservative
Andy, I don't have a problem with exaggerations that are essential to the caricature. I guess where Dadman and I are disagreeing is in whether it is essential to a Hillary caricature to draw her with huge thighs and butt. I just don't think it is. I've seen thousands of caricatures of Hillary, and very few have accentuated her butt and thighs. She has plenty of distinguishing characteristics that make her eminently identifiable from her hairstyle to her face, especially her mouth. Since it is not necessary, I submit that it is deliberate, and the deliberateness is either intentional meanness, or pandering to people who want to be mean. That's all I'm saying. I don't like it either way.
Dadman
Don't get me started on this again...but you're just wrong on this one. Most cartoons of Hillary are not full body renderings from a rear position. If I find the time maybe I'll find some cartoons of Hillary done by other cartoonists and post them. Ramirez is tame. And most Hillary cartoons exaggerate her facial features so much she looks like a clown. Do you have an issue with that?
CosmicConservative
I've been looking at photos of Hillary and comparing them to the caricatures I've seen. There are really three elements that seem to be universal. One is the exaggeration of Hillary's pronounced cheekbones. Another is the exaggeration of Hillary's chin, the way it sort of sits like a slab on the bottom of her face. The other is her hair, mocking the Hillary 'do. Some draw her with widely staring eyes, others with little beady eyes. But pretty much all of them do the cheekbones, chin and hair. I think if you do those three, you pretty much nail Hillary. Many just hit the hair and the cheekbones, and put in buck teeth for some reason. I guess I never thought of Hillary as having buck teeth, but it's not an uncommon sight in a caricature for some reason. I tried to do an example myself, but I can't draw on the computer, and I can't get my scanner to work. Here's one I found that I think sort of demonstrates what I mean. Notice that she is drawn more or less proportionately from the waist down (when compared to the other characters) and you still know who she is. hillary_benign.jpg
Andy
CC: You have convinced me. I don't like the deliberate exaggeration of one's physical features in cartoons any longer (except for Cat Woman, or Wonder Woman). I am serious. It is pretty "low-brow."
CosmicConservative
Heh, Andy... There's no doubt that this is a silly discussion. But I'm home sick today and a silly discussion is just about what I need... I suppose it is a fool's errand to try and put some parameters around what is "suitable" and what is "rude" in a field that is essentially all about making fun of people. If I were taking Dadman's side on this I would probably say something like "So, Cosmic, what do you consider allowable and what is rude in an NFL tackle?" After all, the whole point of the tackle is to slam another human being bodily into the turf. I guess my position on this is sort of like saying "Of course you can 'hit' the running back, but you shouldn't call him names while you do it." So I can see Dadman's frustration. I don't expect everyone to come to see this my way. I just don't like it when I feel a certain line is crossed. That's all. Nothing more, nothing less. And I think that line is crossed when an artist makes fun of Hillary's butt and thighs. I just don't see how that is a fair target, she's in pretty good shape in my opinion. To me it's like drawing her with Popeye forearms. What's the point? How does it help make the point of the cartoon to draw her with massive forearms? But I do see Dadman's point. It's really absurd to try to draw that line between acceptable caricature and simple rudeness. I can't define it and I won't try to defend it anymore, Dadman's really on the "right" side of this argument. I can't intellectually support my position. But still, it rankles when I feel the artist has taken a cheap shot.
Dadman
Cartoonists are quaking in their boots all over the world! Perhaps Cosmic and Andy can team up and stop all the cartoon cruelty and nastiness in its tracks!
CosmicConservative
Dadman, I suspect you posted your reply before you saw my previous one. I concede victory to you on this.
Dadman
Ramirez was not making fun of Hillary's butt and thighs. He was making fun of her politics. The rendering was an attempt to capture her essence. How many time do I have to say it!!!!
CosmicConservative
One less time than you did. I conceded on comment #30.