Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

SCOTUS backs Bush admin on Nat. Sec. case

By CosmicConservative
Again.
WASHINGTON - The Supreme Court on Tuesday terminated a lawsuit from a man who claims he was abducted and tortured by the CIA, effectively endorsing Bush administration arguments that state secrets would be revealed if the case were allowed to proceed. Khaled el-Masri, 44, alleged that he was kidnapped by CIA agents in Europe and held in an Afghan prison for four months in a case of mistaken identity.
This will send the nutroots into conniptions for sure.

Comments (12)

Andy
The guy that brought this suit might be right. I don't know all of the details of the case, but when you live in a culture where every parent names every kid the same name, it is very possible that this guy was mistaken for one of the other 54 million Khaled el-Masri's out there. The other 53,999,999 should be on guard. Seriously, the SCOTUS seems to be viewing these cases with our national best interests in mind. The arguments about US citizens, non-citizens, privacy, etc. are many. Sometimes I just thank God that I am not on the Supreme Court, and sometimes I think I would sell my soul for a seat.
CosmicConservative
The nine members of the Supreme Court Of The United States (SCOTUS)are the most powerful nine people on the planet. They are far more powerful than the President. And they have no fear of losing their jobs for anything less than, maybe, committing murder on the job. However, in general they are greatly principled individuals who carefully weigh the best interest of the defendent, the plaintiff and the nation in most cases. When they don't (Dred Scott, Roe v. Wade) the impact is devastating. I always tell people that the most important reason to vote for President is to have some influence on the type of person who gets a lifetime appointment to one of the nine most powerful jobs on earth.
Rick Swartz
Just to figure out your comment on the case, if a government kidnaps you because you happen to be named Smith, transports you to some country you have nothing to do with, keeps you there and tortures you for a half year, finally figures out they made a mistake (Hey, who could of figured there could be more than one Smith!), finally dump you in the middle of Albania, then deny you any possible way of retribution, you would be OK with that? Or is it only OK because it happened to a non US citizen?
CosmicConservative
Rick: It is interesting to me that you automatically assume that the story of the individual is completely true, even the "tortures you for half a year" part. I'm pretty sure that particular part of the story is debatable. The argument here is not that an injustice has not been done, but that the case cannot be tried without damaging National Security. If you want a detailed explanation of that ruling, you are welcome to read the majority opinion of the Court, who made the ruling, instead of demanding an explanation from this blog.
CosmicConservative
I will say that the rather small amount that the defendent was asking for in this case does actually do something to enhance his credibility. $75,000? Man, you think John Edwards would have taken that case?
Rick Swartz
CosmicConservative: The German government seems to think it's quite true, but they don't want to start an obvious diplomatic nightmare by getting noisy about it. It was embarrassing enough for them that the Munich DA was forced to issue warrants on the CIA members involved. The conservative government in Germany is happy that the relationship with the US has finally thawed. I would still like to know what you personally would think if it happened to you and the Government in question denied you a hearing on the basis of state secrets.
CosmicConservative
I would think it sucked. How about you? Seriously, is this the worst example of government ineptness you can come up with? I'm sure the 3,000+ victims of the 9/11 attack find the previous decade's worth of incompetence and ignorance to be a fairly good example of government incompetence, especially when Bin Laden was TWICE offered to the US on a silver platter and was turned down. How about the innocent people killed when Clinton lobbed cruise missiles at an aspirin factory? Think their survivors have a legitimate grudge? Or the thousands of cuban nationals abandoned on the shores of Cuba to torture and murder in Castro's gulags? I gotta think they threw some curses across the ocean to the north. Or the millions of Japanese and asian nationals in WWII who were imprisoned for years with no cause, no warrant and no hope of release until the war was over? Where does your outrage begin and end? My guess is that the agents involved have been dealt with and won't be in a position to do such a thing again. I also suspect that the government has quietly offered some recompense to the erroneously imprisoned individual. The issue here is whether or not it hurts the national security to have a trial. The SCOTUS said "yep, it will". You either respect that decision or you don't. In this case, I do.
Andy
Rick: I was probably being a bit flippant. I actually thought through your argument before it appeared. While writing my comment, I qualified it by saying that I do not know much about this case, and tried to put myself in this guy's shoes. If Andy Smith was on the terrorist radar screen, I would be on guard. But, there are not many Andy Smith's on the terrorist radar screen. (But who knows...little kids named Jimmy Something are being hauled off of airplanes) If this guy was guilty of nothing, I have compassion for him. But I also have compassion for the millions of Jews slaughtered in the 30's and 40's just because of their circumcision. I have compassion for the hundreds of thousands of Christians slaughtered in Rwanda. I also have compassion for every man, woman, and child that lives under Islamic totalitarian rule. When anyone lives in a culture that dictates behavior as they do (and everyone seems to have the same name), you just have to try to laugh to keep from crying (even though it is not funny at all). As cold and hard as this sounds, a few mistakes (if this was a mistake) are not worth abandoning the global search for these jackass terrorists. We have to stop and kill them all. I don't know about you, but I am not willing to have my children and grandchildren bow down toward Mecca several times a day. I am not willing to have my granddaughters wear stupid headgear and never cast a vote for their leadership. I am not willing to have my sons in slavery to the lie of Islam. This is what the Islamic terrorist movement is about...they want you to convert, or die. This is a real war for your way of life. Excuse me if I seem to be a bit "rednecky" about it, but I care more about myself and my family than I do some poor guy whose Dad named him Andy Smith. By the way...I would feel just as badly for some guy named Timothy Mcveigh, or Richard Nixon, or Jimmy Carter, or some chick named Brittney Spears.
Rick Swartz
That pretty much sums it up. As a person who is often mistaken for someone else (There seems to be a lot of Rick Swartzs out there), the whole thing freaks me out. The idea that receiving justice at the end could also be impossible strikes me as horrid. On a side note, it is refreshing to be able to leave a comment without being bombarded with obscenities.
CosmicConservative
For the most part we're pretty nice around here. If you stay away from cartooning.... ;)
Bart the Builder
"SCOTUS", sounds like a bad case of jock itch!