Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Fun ahead...

By CosmicConservative
OK, I'm going to try to draw an editorial cartoon today or tonight, then scan it and post it. I welcome all critiques, criticisms and downright nastiness. But then I KNOW I suck. ;)

Comments (44)

Dadman
What is this, dueling editorial cartoons? Does everything need to be a competition? This is why I was never very keen on posting any of my cartoons...
Dadman
If you REALLY know you suck why waste the time doing it? There must be some other motivation?
CosmicConservative
No, I enjoy trying it. It's not a competition. Seriously. I just haven't done it in a long time. I like to doodle and I just want to try a cartoon again. As I said, I did it for about a year at Softdisk Publishing, and I got some nice comments from some of our readers. I enjoyed it. I don't pretend to be remotely as good an artist as you are, and I'm certainly not competing with you. I just think it would be cool to have a cartoon up now and then to provide both some visual interest and some humor to the site.
Dadman
Right. It sure has the distinct odor of a competition when you trash one person's cartoon and then offer to post your own.
CosmicConservative
So, if I promise never to put up a 'toon of my own, you'll grace us with your efforts? I could probably accept that...
Andy
CC: I will scan, and e-mail you my last game of "Hangman." You can publish it on the blog, and claim credit for it if you want...won't hurt my feelings at all.
Dadman
Nope. Post all the cartoons you want. I'm just happy to be the catalyst for you new found interest in editorial cartooning...
CosmicConservative
I'm not sure how something that I did for a year for a disk-based software monthly publication as part of my job as "managing editor" of the publication can be described as a "new found" interest, but it is true that your cartoons have rekindled my interest. But I'm sure it will pass. I don't have the natural talent you have for it. BTW, it was Dilbert that actually first sparked my "desire" to draw cartoons and publish them. When I was running the editorial staff at Softdisk, we received a submission from Scott Adams, then an unknown cartoonist who was publishing his 'toons on the pre-Internet web called "usenet." He sent me several cartoons that I was interested in, but he wanted way too much money. My boss, the President of the company, thought cartoons would be a good thing to add to the format but was unwilling to meet Adams' prices, so I told him I would draw a few and see what I could do. So, not to burst your bubble, Dadman, but it was Scott Adams who first triggered my attempts at "professional" cartooning. And I rejected his submissions and published my own. How's that for hubris? Besides, I still can't draw hands.
CosmicConservative
Boy, talk about a poorly titled post....
Dadman
Hubris is something you have plenty of, Cosmic. Plenty...
Dadman
How could I have forgotten that you were once a managing editor/professional cartoonist, who received 'nice' comments from readers and rejected the work of Scott Adams, now one of the most successful cartoonists on the planet, so you could publish your own stuff. Thanks for reminding me. I'll just toss all those drawings you did in MY sketchbook back in high school that look very much like stuff I was drawing at the time. Yes, I still have them. It would seem your interest in drawing began somewhat before you rejected Scott Adams. If only you could draw hands you might be retired by now like Gary Larson or Bill Watterson. Post away... P.S. SoftDisk published a couple of my toons too... and paid quite well for them as I recall...
CosmicConservative
Dadman: Wow. I had no idea this was such a sensitive issue. I apologize. I would have gladly published Scott Adams' toons, I couldn't afford them. At the time I thought he was greatly over-estimating their value. Now I realize he was just greatly over-estimating our budget. I have always appreciated how much I learned to draw from your natural talent, and have always wished that I had such a talent of my own. I certainly did copy your style back then, having none of my own to fall back on. I still struggle with that. Even in my doodles. I think that having a personal "style" is one of the things that distinguishes an artist like yourself from a derivative hack like me. There is no doubt that such a lack of natural ability is one of the great disappointments of my life. But you know, somehow I still enjoy trying to draw regardless of my acknowledged lack of skill, style or originality. In spite of all of that and the unvarnished, acknowledged truth of my pronounced lack of skill or talent..... I actually have received some compliments on my work from time to time. I know its hard to believe, but apparently there are others as tone-deaf to art as I am out there. Go figure.
CosmicConservative
One final comment. I never said that Dilbert sparked my interest in drawing. Dilbert sparked my interest in PUBLISHING my drawings. And more out of necessity than real desire. That plus my overarching hubris that I could actually pull it off, a trait I admit I have in just about any field. In some cases that willingness to take a chance and lack of fear of failure has actually been called a positive trait of mine. I think I'll stick to that interpretation myself. As far as an interest in drawing is concerned, I think it is fair to say I have always had that. There was one guy I knew in High School though, whose skill was such that I was so impressed that I tried to copy him and tried to learn from him. There is no doubt that he influenced what little technique I have to this day. I have always been grateful for that. And still am to this day.
Dadman
Before posting any of my own cartoons (which I've been very hesitant to do for now obvious reasons) I was frequently encouraged to do so by you and others. So, before finally doing it, I mentioned that I wasn't really interested in my 'toons being critiqued or criticized. I said I don't handle the criticism well. I thought I was fairly clear about that. Yet, within moments of the first cartoon posting you offer a long-winded criticism of the cartoon's content. I guess you surmised that would be okay as long as you complimented the artwork. (The cartoon was published in a local newspaper, by the way, with a distribution of about 70K. The cartoon met the needs of the client precisely; both they and the readers were very pleased). Then you did the same for the second cartoon. It ticked me off. For some inexplicable reason you were doing precisely what I more or less asked not be done. And then after ripping my stuff announce you are going to begin posting your own editorial cartoons and magnanimously offer to accept all criticism, even nasty ones (in contrast to me I suppose). Am I too sensitive to criticisms of my cartoons? Well, I opened myself up to the criticism of 70K readers every week for the better part of a year and that frankly didn't bother me at all. But your criticisms, especially after encouraging me for so long to post some of my toons, well, that really got under my skin...
Dadman
So what's the truth, Cosmic? Are your claims of 'sucking' genuine, or does your self-proclaimed hubris convince you that you have what it takes to be a successful editorial cartoonist. Which is it? I'm getting mixed messages here...
Andy
So I guess that no one wants to borrow my crayons...I had such high hopes... This must be the best "read" in the history of blogging...thanks guys!
Dadman
Cartoons are typically 'colored' using some kind of graphics software, like PhotoShop. At least that is how I would do it. I was looking forward to creating some new stuff, adding color, and then posting it here on the blog. Not so much anymore. I'm sincerely glad you find this amusing. You made me smile ;)
CosmicConservative
I misunderstood. I thought you said "be gentle" not "Don't critique." I thought I was "being gentle." Still, I don't have time to respond right this minute. I will when I get home.
Andy
Man...there is some real "history" going on here in the cartoon wars...my apologies for any distraction from this entertaining furor. Please forgive my obvious ignorance of a deep seated hatred and resentment between friends...you know...Momma always said that life is like a box of chocolates... I hope you boys kiss and make up... Dadman: What is PhotoShop? (Don't bother answering)
CosmicConservative
More history than I knew Andy, really. I certainly would never have suggested posting my own lame attempt at a cartoon had I known the result of that comment. Dadman, let me attempt to address your comments as rationally and calmly as possible. And then you can decide if you want to post cartoons or not. I hope you do. I like them. I think they will bring humor and enjoyment to others who read the blog. Just as I think your posts bring a great deal to this blog and I have done nothing but express my appreciation and enjoyment of your posts since you started posting. I am sorry if my comments bothered you. I did not intend for them to. I'm not going to defend them, they are there for people to read and decide for themselves if they were mean-spirited or competitive. I can say from my heart that they were not intended to be. I don't have much stomach myself now for posting my own attempt, it is clear to me that doing so is a lose-lose situation. I am doing my best to accept your comments without taking them personally myself. So far I've been able to do that, and I am worried that if I attempt to explain, defend or justify my comments that it will result in further difficulties. And I would rather not do that, good friends are too hard to come by for me to jeopardize one over an issue like this. I sincerely, truly apologize and deeply regret my words and their result. I hope you realize how appreciative I am and always have been of your talents and your success with your artwork. You are absolutely correct when you say that I copied your style in my own lame attempts at cartooning. I don't believe that is anything I have ever denied or hidden. Imitation is, after all, the sincerest form of flattery.
CosmicConservative
I see now that you have deleted the posts with your cartoons. I am doubly regretful of that.
CosmicConservative
I will answer this question:
So what’s the truth, Cosmic? Are your claims of ’sucking’ genuine, or does your self-proclaimed hubris convince you that you have what it takes to be a successful editorial cartoonist. Which is it? I’m getting mixed messages here…
In one of the posts you deleted I talked about how editorial cartoons are sometimes drawn by "artists" of dubious talent. That there is a sort of "threshold" of art that is required to get the message across, and beyond that, the art is just that, art for art's sake. Many great editorial cartoons have very poor art, the message is what makes the medium. Now, obviously a great artist creates more enduring and more pleasing results, but for an editorial cartoon, if your message is clear enough, even poor artwork can get the point across. So I don't think it is contradictory to say that I "suck" at art, but could potentially create a passable editorial cartoon. I also never said that I had "what it takes" to be a "successful editorial cartoonist." I said that I had drawn some, less than a dozen probably, and had published them to generally more positive than negative response on Softdisk Publishing monthly disk magazines. I described one, which I considered my best, the "Nerd Hell" cartoon. That was not, by the way, the one that got the most positive response, I think the one I did that got the most response was actually a Mac vs. PC cartoon which had very little "artwork" since computers aren't that difficult to draw. They don't have hands, for example. But because it was on "Diskworld" which was the Mac product, and the Mac got the better of the PC, it hit the target audience right in their tickle spot. Or some of them anyway. Enough to comment on it in their comments to the editor. I would describe myself as a "cartoon dilettante" if I wanted to describe myself as anything. But even a blind pig can find an acorn now and then. And making fun of the PC in a Mac publication was sort of like shooting fish in a barrel. That's one reason I liked the "Nerd Hell" cartoon, it was more general and poked fun at the reader instead of the reader's enemies. Now, on to what I really think about my "art" skills. As if I haven't covered this before. I think I have some limited ability to navigate some of the craft of drawing cartoon characters. But it is all derivative. What is not "Dadman" is either "Trudeau" or "Watterson". I would say that my most common doodles of faces look more like Trudeau than anything else these days. Not because I like his style better, but because I seem to be able to copy it better. Every now and then I will surprise myself with a drawing that I think is halfway decent, and doesn't seem to be derivative of anything else. But usually it's a mistake that caused the result, and I can never seem to duplicate it no matter how hard I try. As far as becoming a professional editorial cartoonist, do I think I could get cartoons published? Yes I do. And yes, that is exactly the hubris coming out. In general I pretty much think I can do anything I set my mind to, if I spend enough time, energy and focus on it. That's such a core aspect of my personality that I don't care to defend it. I have had photographs published by the Denver Post, believe it or not. Not in their paper, but in their online version. I even got paid for it. Does that mean I think I'm a professional photographer? No, but it does mean that I managed to get paid for a photograph I took and had it published. And the only reason is because I was determined to do so. Not because I'm some sort of world-class photographer. I'm just a hack who took a whole lot of pictures and then wrote a bunch of hiking articles until they finally liked a few and published them. I think the same approach would work for editorial cartoons as well.
Dadman
Hmmmm...how's the view up there on the high road? Profuse apologies are not really necessary, but I accept those you've offered. I should not be so sensitive to criticism, but, alas, when it comes to my cartoons I am. I thought I had given fair warning. I must say that I am much more sensitive to criticism from friends. Criticism, in my view, is simply not the role of a friend in this instance. I'm certainly not going to feel inclined to post any original artwork if I know it is going to be met with a formal critique. No fun in that. What's the point? Let the anonymous blog posters do the criticizing if they feel like it. I've known you long enough to understand that your first impulse is to analyze and assess. Sometimes your own self-proclaimed hubris (your word not mine) leads you to believe you are an authority in all things and causes you to be dismissive of other people's talents and experiences. Do you really think I was not aware of the issues you raised in your criticisms of my cartoons' content? I clearly understand both the challenges and objectives of a successful editorial cartoon. In this case, your criticisms were just superfluous and unnecessary. But annoying nevertheless from my perspective. Be that as it may, I apologize for over-reacting. I confess to being temperamental and emotional at times... Just like Charles Schulz I suppose.
Andy
Dadman: Hey man, I assume that you are ignoring my stupid comments in this back and forth. I just wanted to make sure you understand that when I was offering my crayons, it was an attempt (however feeble) to highlight my own incompetence as an artist...coloring books are about as far as I ever got in the pursuit of art. I really couldn't tell for sure if you were upset with me, or CC, or both of us... I sure didn't mean any offense, and hope none was taken. I like the cartoons...Go Diamondbacks!?
Dadman
How could I be upset with you, Andy? You're such a cuddly, lovable redneck... All is well...
Andy
Dadman...you left out "ignorant"...am very happy that you still love me. By the way, when I asked you not to explain PhotoShop there was a good reason. I made the mistake of asking CC what an iPod was (it was a joke). About half way through his explanation my quickly failing brain exploded. I was left with almost no ability to absorb your explanation of PhotoShop (besides, I know that PhotoShop is the store you take your film to be developed). See...I'm not nearly as dumb as I seem!
CosmicConservative
Dadman: In spite of my self-admitted "hubris" I believe I have been properly appreciative of yours and others' talents. I do not believe I am dismissive of others' talents, even when I am analyzing and critiquing them. I can point out that Tiger Woods made a bad bogey on a hole without implying that I am a better golfer, or that he is a hack. I gave Tony Romo serious grief over his five interceptions and fumble in the Monday night football game, but I don't believe I ever suggested that he lacks talent as a professional quarterback. If anything I expressed profound appreciation of his ability to win a game in spite of his own undeniable mistakes. I have also done my level best to keep this discussion civil and avoid the sort of personal comments that are permanently hurtful. No matter what I may have said that caused you to feel upset, none of it was intended to cause harm, nor to suggest deeper character flaws. I am deeply regretful that you have decided not to post your cartoons here. Perhaps one day you will reconsider. I will do my best not to critique them in the future.
Dadman
It feels dismissive, as if you think I have no idea that cartoons need to resonate with their intended audience. My mistake, I suppose, was posting some older cartoons that had a decidely local target audience. I was just trying to give your blog's readers an idea of my cartooning style (since it has come up often) and offer an example of something I've done in the past that was published. I was also testing out my new scanner...
CosmicConservative
Well, keep testing it out then. And repost the cartoons. I'll keep my claws in this time. ;)
Dadman
I wasn't suggesting you have any deep character flaws, by the way, unless you consider hubris a character flaw. I know I don't. I also think a penchant for analysis and criticism is really more of a virtue than a flaw - in most cases. My cartoons would be an exception. ;) Just ask yourself as the criticism begins to form in your mind and flow from your fingertips, does the intended receipient of the criticism already know what you are about to tell them. In this case, the answer would have been a clear 'yes'...
CosmicConservative
I can't get my blasted scanner to work....
CosmicConservative
Like many things I think hubris is blessing and curse. A person needs enough "hubris" (or simple self-confidence) to give them the willingness to tackle new challenges with a sense that they can succeed at them. The question for me isn't whether I have enough, but whether I have too much. And I guess if I had to pick which way to err, I think I would err on the side of too much than too little. Which is perhaps a way of saying I'd rather reach for the stars and fail, than reach for the ground and succeed. And sometimes, those stars are closer than you think.
Dadman
Just a couple more comments pertinent to this crazy thread... While any hack with sufficient persistence might stumble into an opportunity to get a cartoon published here or there, that is a far cry from actually being employed by an established media outlet (e.g. newspaper, magazine, e-zine, whatever) as an editorial cartoonist responsible for producing a certain number of professional quality cartoons each week on deadline. I was hired by our local newspaper to be their editorial cartoonist. I was a member of their editorial staff. I went through a series of interviews with the paper's editor and publisher (I learned later that I was competing with about 20 other applicants), I was asked to produce a portfolio of my work for evaluation. I was offered the job. Now, it was a job on-the-side of my day job, the pay was poor, and the deadlines were sucking the life and fun out of my weekends (and time with my family) so I resigned after about 7 months. The experience has taught me to have even greater respect for those editorial cartoonists out there who produce a new cartoon almost daily. It's difficult, challenging work. Hacks simply can't cut it...
CosmicConservative
I never said they could... To reuse an analogy, I made an eagle once on the golf course. But I ain't no professional golfer. I'm lucky if I break 100. As I think I said, even a blind pig can find an acorn now and then.
Dadman
Let's talk when an editor other than yourself publishes your cartoons ;)
CosmicConservative
Heh. Fair enough. Sounds almost like a challenge... Now who was it talking about "competition?"
Dadman
Yeah, the gauntlet has been chucked. Just kidding... To be clear, my issue was never with you posting your own cartoons on your own blog. It was all about you ragging on my 'toons... Just to be clear.
CosmicConservative
To be equally clear, I don't think I "ragged on" your 'toons. I think I said nothing but nice things about the first one, only pointing out that we had no problem with cars pushing kids on bikes off roads in our area, we had more problems with dogs attacking kids on bikes. How you took that as a vicious criticism is, frankly, beyond my ken. On the second cartoon I did offer the suggestion to enhance the impact by utilizing more symbolic elements. That would qualify as a critical comment (in the textbook definition of the word "critical" not the street vernacular definition), but I still don't think it qualifies as "ragging" your efforts. Frankly based on this exchange I am fairly well convinced that any comment I make about your cartoons would be perceived in a negative light, so I can assure you that I won't offer suggestions or critiques in the future. I have repeatedly and glowingly praised your artistic efforts in the past, and even in the "ragging" I thought my positive comments far outweighed my critical ones. As far as the gauntlet being thrown... I dunno... You know me well enough to know that I both enjoy a challenge and like attempting new things. I've never tried to get a cartoon published by a "respected" publication. I am considering the possibility of sending something to our local paper, the "Fairplay Flume." And yes, only because of this exchange. I can't say I've had a burning desire to get an editorial cartoon published in the past, although I've thought about it from time to time. The only ones I published at Softdisk were ones I drew for the same reason I wrote the product reviews, the editorials, the programming column and the letters to the editor reply. Because I didn't have to increase my monthly budget, and I simply enjoyed doing it. If I were to get a cartoon published in the Flume, would that qualify as being "published by some editor other than myself?"
Dadman
I was just kidding, but you're free to do whatever you want...
CosmicConservative
Ah, I don't have the time or talent really. I'll add this to my list of "things I really wish I wasn't too lazy to actually attempt instead of just talking about it." That's a pretty long list these days...
CosmicConservative
I do wish you'd reconsider posting the toons though....
Drax
Yah, they were well drawn and I chuckled. Not much more you can ask than that...