Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Troy Terrific!!!

By CosmicConservative
So I've been doing some checking on Troy Tulowitzki's statistics this year. Here are some facts: Troy led all rookies in the entire major leagues in RBIs, OPS, Slugging percentage, hits and runs. He was in the top two or three in virtually every other offensive category, including home runs (he "only" hit 24). What this doesn't even capture is the number of critical hits in big games Troy delivered, such as the first RBI of the 13th inning of the wild card deciding game, and the tying run in the same inning. But that's not even remotely all... Troy led ALL SHORTSTOPS in the entire major leagues (not rookies, ALL SHORTSTOPS) in the following categories: - total chances (meaning he got to a ball to make a play) - fielding percentage (usually the most important stat for a fielder) - range factor (I can't claim to understand this statistic) - double plays (is there a more important stat besides fielding %?) - Assists (how many times he got the ball to another fielder to make the out) - Putouts (how many outs he himself recorded) Add to that the fact that Troy recorded the first unassisted triple play in the majors in 40 years or so. I cannot imagine what sort of media attention Troy would be getting if he played on the Yankees or the Giants. This is un-freaking believable! The only stats that I can find that he did not lead were total errors and "zone range" which is supposed to be a measure of the percentage of balls within his "zone" he managed to make a play on. Both of those were led by Omar Vizquael (Troy was second in those). These are not merely Rookie of the Year stats, these are un-freaking believable for a rookie SHORTSTOP. He should win the gold glove hands down in his rookie year. And I can't see how anyone can argue that Coors Field inflated his fielding numbers. Combining his offensive and defensive numbers makes it almost inconceivable that Troy will not win Rookie of the Year. But he won't. And he probably won't win the gold glove either. Because he plays for the Colorado Rockies. That's why. That's why Matt Holliday won't win MVP either, in spite of leading the league in batting average and RBI, among other offensive categories, and delivering the tying and winning runs in last night's decisive final game. Sometimes it's really tough to be a Rockies fan...

Comments (15)

Dadman
Hey, nobody west of the Mississippi gets much attention. And that goes for all sports. My vote would go to Troy and Matt. Too bad I don't have a vote, eh?
CosmicConservative
Jake Peavey? Barry Bonds? Brandon Webb? Ken Griffey or Randy Johnson when they were at Seattle? Ken Caminiti? Tony Gwynn? Jerry Rice? Joe Montana? Emmitt Smith? Troy Aikman? John Elway? Kobe Bryant? Wilt Chamberlain? Sorry, not buying that. I know I am a complete and total homer, but there is no doubt in my mind that Denver gets special negative treatment from the rest of the country when it comes to sports. The Denver Broncos, winner of two Super Bowls, AFC representative in five super bowls, acknowledged perennial powerhouse in the AFC West have exactly ONE representative in the football Hall of Fame. John Elway. In order to get there John had to win two Super Bowls and post the at the time NFL Record for wins and second place in pass attempts and pass completions. Until he won his second Super Bowl, the general scuttlebutt in the league was that he "was not a lock" to get in. Karl Mecklenberg? Not in. Sammy Winder? Not in. Any member of the "Orange Crush" defense that terrorized the league for a decade? Not in. Nine years ago a young first baseman named Todd Helton joined the Rockies. He had slightly better numbers than Troy Tulowitzki (over .300 batting average, 25 home runs, more RBIs..) and he led all rookies in all of those categories. He was an obvious 'real deal' franchise player who has gone on to become the current offensive player with the highest batting average since Tony Gwynn. He just set the major league record for consecutive seasons with more than 20 doubles. His LIFETIME batting average is over .330. So obviously the Rookie of the Year award went to a Chicago Cubs pitcher named Kerry Woods who struck out a lot of players, but who didn't even lead all rookie pitchers in ERA, BA against or (I think) wins. Do you think if Todd played in San Francisco he would have lost out to a pitcher who had a brief and controversial career, but gained a lot of attention because of his ability to throw the ball 100mph? I don't think so... I can't really argue with MVP selections, I do think that you really only can make a case for MVP if your team makes the playoffs. Otherwise a player has to be unbelievably awesome to hope to qualify for MVP, and I don't think any Rockies player has been THAT awesome. And I do think Larry Walker may have won MVP the year the Rockies made the playoffs... Not sure though.. I really do think the league discriminates against the Rockies. I think the umpires are far more likely to call a ball a strike when a Rockies player is at bat, and I think they are far more likely to miss calls on home runs. FOUR times this year video has proven that a ball ruled a ground rule double for the Rockies was really a home run, and once a ball that was ruled a home run for the other team was shown to be a ground rule double. NONE of those calls has gone to the Rockies. I suppose you could argue that Matt Holliday didn't score the winning run Monday night, but I have to tell you, I've watched that video and I don't think you can tell if he did or not, so I'm going with the ump's call on that one. But even if it was missed, that's notable mostly for its rarity. The league hates the Rockies. The umpires hate the Rockies. ESPN hates the Rockies. EVERYBODY hates the Rockies. The scorn and derision that is heaped on this team in the national media is unbelievable. ESPN had a lead story yesterday about the NL team who had the most amazing playoff run in recent history yestrday. It was a huge story that covered the entire season to show how amazing that team's comeback was and how great of a story it was for baseball. Were they talking about the Rockies' 14 - 1 run down the stretch and dramatic victory over the Padres in Monday's record-setting "play-in" game? No, the story was about the Phillies' 12 - 4 run and the Mets collapse at the same time. If it weren't so typical, I would not have believed it. The Rockies' obviously far greater comeback and far more compelling story was not even mentioned. It was as if it didn't even happen.
Andy
CC: Yea well...how many New Orleans Saints are in the Hall of Fame? And just think about how fabulously successful the Saints franchise has been. I actually know how many. You can see the list at: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Orleans_Saints#Pro_Football_Hall_of_Famers None of them are career Saints...several only either playing for one or two years, and Ditka and Stram as coaches, or career stats, etc. Just be happy to have some Super Bowls, several league championships, and not having to wear a Kroger sack to the Broncos games... Pulling for your Rockies today...got my fingers crossed, and tongue tied.
Drax
CC: Gotta agree with the premise that prennial losers (such as the Rockies) with the sole exception of the "loveable losers" (Cubbies) have their players passed over frequently for many awards. However, on Elway. Come on! He was 1st Ballot Hall material (as was Marino as was Kelly) even before he won his first SuperBowl. Most of the Broncos who participated in those games are NOT Hall material. (I really can't think of one who would be other than Elway. Elam? Rod Smith won't make the cut either, I don't think when his stats are compared to his contemporaries. (Denver was a running team....))
CosmicConservative
There was a ton of debate on Elway's suitability for the Hall even after he won his first Super Bowl. Before then he was generally viewed as a big game loser. Karl Mecklenberg? Tom Jackson? Jason Elam will be the second Bronco in the Hall. No other Bronco than John Elway is good enough? On a team that went to three superbowls in ten years?
Andy
Drax: You could not be more right about Elway...heckuva player...painted as a pansy by the media...but as tough as nails, and hung in there much longer than any of us would have. I didn't like the guy in his early years, but came to realize that he was for real as time passed. He was attacked by the media as a whimp because of his blond hair and supposed advantages...during that period, I learned not to listen to, nor believe the media. If Elway had never won a Super Bowl, he would have been a first ballot pick. But, how about Otis Armstrong? I have to go now...too many teenagers in the house needing questions answered (man, how out of luck are they?)
Drax
No. I don't think any were. Davis could have been had he had a longer career. Again. I don't know where you got the idea that the WINNINGEST QUARTERBACK IN NFL HISTORY the author of "The Drive," the quarterback with the most "comebacks" in NFL history wasn't a lock to be inducted on the first ballot, but it doesn't jibe in any fashion with my recollection. Agreed, there is an inexcusable premium on Superbowl victories (or championships or post season play) in all sports when it comes to making the various Halls, resulting in some people making the Hall who arguably shouldn't in comparison to others who should, but....there are some guys that never win the big show that are so dominant in their era at their position that they are shoo-ins. (Kelly, Thomas, Smith are prime examples....)
CosmicConservative
OK, perhaps here in Denver there was an ingrained inferiority complex due to the fact that after five super bowl appearances and two wins, there was NOT ONE SINGLE Bronco in the HOF, so people may have exaggerated the situation with Elway's chances. But I can assure you that up until at least the first Super Bowl win, the discussion here was all about how Elway would never get in. And it was a very frequently discussed topic, I can tell you.
Dadman
Hey, let's talk about the Arizona Cardinals now... ;)
CosmicConservative
Who? ;) Actually I'm rootin' for 'em. I want the Rockies to get another crack at Webb. If the Phillies win the series, I'd rather see Arizona go all the way than the Phillies. I don't understand why the World Series is even played. Half of those games the pitcher doesn't even swing a bat. How do you call that "baseball"?
Dadman
No...the Arizona Cardinals football team. You know, one of the worst professional sports franchises in history. They have won 2 significant games this season - one against Pittsburgh and the another against Seattle - so there is a little hope they might actually finish with a winning record... As for the Diamondbacks, they have overachieved this season much like the Rockies. No one expected them to win the division and virtually no one expects them to beat the Cubbies. I think they might just keep surprising the so-called experts... A second round match up with Colorado might not be such a bad thing. Sooner or later the Rocks are going to start dropping some games...might as well be against the Snakes...
Andy
Dadman: Just be glad that you have the Cardinals in Arizona. You could be stuck with The Saints...for the rest of your natural life.
CosmicConservative
OK, how many Hall of Fame players came from Arizona, a team that has never even reached the Super Bowl, let alone won one? By the way, did they bench Matt Leinert? What the heck is up with that?
Dadman
Um...that number would be 11...16 if you count those who played only a minor part of their career for the Cardinals and later made the HOF (but you knew this of course). I have only this to say about that: Hahahahahaha!!!! The Cardinals suck and always have! Leinert is still considered the starter, but Warner goes in when the team is running their no huddle scheme. Leinert has been whining about it, but the strategy seems to be working...at least for now. Leinert's complaining has caused my respect for him to drop precipitously. I took him to be somewhat less self-centered than a lot of pro athletes, but I may have been wrong. Warner on the other hand is the model of class and professionalism. When he was benched in favor of Leinert all he said was he would prefer to be the starter, but he would accept his role as backup and mentor to the youngster. Leinert, in contrast, acts like a baby when Whisenhunt starts rotating in Warner for only some of the plays...
Drax
I would have thought that Linert's taste in dates would clue you in as to his temperment.... As to the Hall of Fame stuff... There are only 241 members in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. That is a very short list. Of those 38 are not players. That leaves 203 actual players in the Hall. Of those, 47 are Pre-Modern Era, leaving 156 actual modern day players selected to the Hall. You might be able to make an argument that there are some Broncos who have been left out of that elite group, but, if you look at their years of eligibility and who they were up against when time came to cast the votes, I think that that argument would be VERY difficult to sustain.