Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Handmade crafts

By CosmicConservative
Since I've been contemplating making an acoustic guitar, I have also been contemplating the future of handmade crafts in general. There is no doubt that the quality of machine-made items is much more consistent than hand-made items. However, it is still true today, or at least it is still perceived as true today, that the highest quality items are still those that are hand-made. But machine made items are getting better every year, and it should be fairly clear that if things continue as they have gone for over a century, the quality of machine-made craft items will continue to rise as the consistency continues to improve. At first this sounds like good news. A custom hand-made acoustic guitar, for example, goes for an average of about $2,000, with many selling for up to $10,000 or more. At the same time mass-produced guitars sell for about $500 or less. Assuming that the mass-production eventually matches an average hand-made guitar created by a professional luthier, then we should expect the quality of guitars in your local music store to go up as the price goes down. What happens then to luthiers? Will they all go out of business? I doubt it. I think what will happen is that as mass production becomes more (or even completely) machine-controlled, the market will split into a machine-made market and a human made market. Being able to purchase a hand-made item will become a status symbol in itself, and even if the quality is equal to, or even less than, the machine-created one, the mere fact that it was done by a human being will increase the market value of the item. I also predict that the owners of the human made craft item will be completely convinced that there is some mystical or spiritual quality that the human being imparted into the item that could not possibly be put there by a machine. In fact, as machines and computers take on more and more of the day-to-day drudgery of human activity, more and more humans will turn to crafts as a way to make a living for this reason. Taken to it's logical extreme that would suggest that in the far future (say 200 years or so) most human beings will pursue careers in the arts and crafts, pursuing the upper tier of the market for items that will be avaiable for much less at roughly the same quality. So if you want to play guitar for a living, for example, you will likely first own and learn on an extremely high quality guitar roughly comparable to the top end guitars made today, but one made in completely automated mass-production plants for an extremely low cost. Assuming you become a guitar maestro, you will eventually trade in your nearly perfect machine made guitar, for one made by a human luthier who uses traditional materials and techniques. And your audience will swear that you never sounded better.

Comments (1)

Cullen
From the electric side of things, I would argue that this split has already taken place -- to some degree. You also have to look at the consumer. How much is the average consumer going to read into a product before the purchase? How much is the average musician going to read into the product before the purchase? I think that's where we draw the distinction. Most of your high-end, off-the-shelf guitars are not hand made. Even ones that claim they are. Gibson, Fender and PRS's custom-shop guitars (their so-called "hand made" instruments) account for a very small percentage of their business. The rest of it being CNC'd. I would argue that your average, entry-level musical instrument consumer isn't going to know the difference. They aren't going to investigate either. It takes someone who's been playing for a while, someone with the curiosity to learn more about what makes a good instrument good, to find the Heritages, Moonstones, and Bakers. I would also argue, like you said, that the quality of craftsmanship on a CNC made machine is such that -- given similar hardware -- you can't tell a lot of difference between a custom guitar and it's machine-made cousin. So, I agree, it's a status thing.