Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review - 3:10 to Yuma

By Dadman
It's quite rare these days to walk out of a theater with your cinematic cravings thoroughly satisfied and eager to tell everyone you meet that you've just experienced one of the best films of the year. Yet, this was my reaction to 3:10 to Yuma. It's the best film I've seen since Letters from Iwo Jima and one of the best westerns I've seen - ever. It's time to add 3:10 to Yuma to the list of the great classic westerns of all time - films like Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, The Magnificent Seven, High Noon, High Plains Drifter, The Outlaw Josey Wales and Unforgiven, to name a few. This is elite company, indeed, but Yuma is more than worthy to be counted among them. Yuma is essentially the story of a down-on-his-luck Arizona rancher, Dan Evans, played brilliantly by Christian Bale, who for $200 agrees to help escort the brutal, charismatic, yet conflicted outlaw, Ben Wade (Russell Crowe), to Contention, Arizona where he will catch the 3:10 train to the Yuma prison, hence the title of the film. Of course, Wade's blood thirsty gang is in hot pursuit and the journey from Bisbee to Contention has all the markings of a suicide mission. Evans takes the job anyway desperate to save his ranch and prove his worth to his older son. This father-son subplot is one of the best aspects of Yuma and actually moved me to tears in the end. I admit it... While all the acting is solid in Yuma, the strength and nuance of Bale's performance is probably the highlight of the film and in my mind one of the reasons the film transcends mediocrity and enters the realm of greatness. Of course, Russell Crowe's performance as Ben Wade is also superb. Crowe inhabits the western genre masterfully. The outstanding performances of Bale and Crowe engage and fascinate and ultimately drive the story forward to a gut-wrenching, suprisingly emotional conclusion. Be aware that Yuma is a gritty, often brutal and bloody, tale inhabited by desperate characters that live on the edge of life and death. If you don't like gunplay and gut shots you might want to pass on Yuma, but I think that would be a mistake. There's a powerful message just beneath the carnage - a message of love and honor and virtue that is rarely found in film's these days. My Stetson is off to director James Mangold and writers Halsted Welles and Michael Brandt. They've created something special with the modern day version of 3:10 to Yuma. Good westerns are about as rare these days as a liberal with common sense so it is gratifying that the critical acclaim and box office success of Yuma will likely lead to more westerns being greenlighted. If they are anywhere near as good as Yuma that will be a very good thing...

Comments (5)

CosmicConservative
Oh crud, you beat me to it. Oh well. The Cosmic Wife and I saw "3:10 to Yuma" as well. I completely agree with everything you say about the movie. Except that I don't. I think it was one of the best films I've seen in a long, long time, except that it isn't. I think the acting was superb, except for the acting I didn't like. I have a very conflicted opinion of this movie. On one level it is an absolutely superb movie, one of the grittiest, truest and most compelling westerns I've ever seen. The main actors, including Bale, Crowe, Peter Fonda (as a Pinkerton-hired bounty hunter), Ben Foster (as Wade's vicious lieutenant) and Gretchen Mol (as the wife of Dan Evans)were some of the best-portrayed and most complex characters I've seen in a western since "The Unforgiven." The story itself is excellent, and the thread of father-son conflict and redemption is so rare in a Hollywood offering that this stands out in marked contrast to the normal cynical fare that is foisted on the public. I definitely think the movie was one of the best of the year, and I highly recommend it to anyone. But I can't get my own impression of the movie completely free of some of the oldest western cliches and worst plot contrivances I've seen in a long time. Everything from the saloon girl who falls for the evil outlaw to the bloodthirsty Indians who live only to torture and kill white people. There are some things in the movie that simply broke my willing suspension of disbelief too thoroughly for me to ignore. I'll describe a few of them, so this is a warning that the rest of this comment is a spoiler, so if you want to see the movie and haven't yet, you probably shouldn't continue reading this comment. . . . OK, duly warned. Perhaps the most disturbing aspect of the movie was the point in Contention where Charlie announced to the town that any person who killed one of Wade's captors would be paid $200. This turned a town full of peaceful, law-abiding citizens into a vicious army of reckless renegades. As completely ridiculous as this concept is (imagine throwing your entire life away and turning into essentially a member of a street gang for a promise of $10,000 IF you manage to kill someone), it became progressively more unbelievable as this ad hoc army of normal citizens first saw the man who promised them $200 murder their own Marshall and his deputies in cold blood, then watched as one after another of their fellows was shot down in a hail of gunfire, first from Dan Evans, then from the outlaw gang themselves. Yet they still continued to try to kill Evans, instead of turning on the man who essentially was killing every man in the town. This is especially disturbing in a movie whose message is about the decency and honor of a simple one-legged rancher. I found this level of cynicism very disturbing and completely antithetical to the actual theme of the movie itself. And, as is so common in movies such as this, we are expected to believe that the crack-shot team of bandits that Wade put together, a team we saw calmly picking off a gatlin-gun operator in the back of a rampaging wagon from a hill at least 250 yards away, could not get a bullet into Dan Evans as he ran down a street no more than 100 feet away. I call this the "Barnaby Jones" effect, and it drives me nuts. The evil villains can be trick-shot artists who can put a bullet into the shirt pocket of their moving target from a mile away, but when it's Barnaby, they can't hit the broadside of a barn with a telescopic sighted rifle, while Barnaby's snap shot from the hip puts a bullet either into their heart, or close enough to their head to make them dive for cover. I was very disappointed that the movie took that approach at the end as Evans and Wade dashed through a hail of poorly-aimed gunfire from a group of bandits whose very existence and success was entirely due to their, frankly, unbelievable accuracy with their guns. So yes, I thought the movie was a great movie. But I was not able to completely engross myself in if for these reasons. And I think that's sort of a shame. Because I really wanted to get that involved into it.
Dadman
While I don't totally disagree with your assessment, I'm just not going to put any energy into criticizing this film. It is simply too good on too many levels to nit-pick. It's weaknesses are shared by many other great westerns that are now considered classics, even masterpieces. No film is perfect. If I were so inclined I could write ad nauseum on the imperfections of Jackson's LOTR, but it would be counter-productive given how truly incredible the films are when considered holistically. And I think that is the best approach with Yuma. Sure, the final scene strained credulity, but by that point in the film I was so engrossed in the Crowe-Bale dynamic and the subplot involving Dan Evan's son it didn't really matter all that much to me. They were having their Butch Cassidy-Sundance Kid moment (another moment that strained credulity by the way but is now considered a classic moment in cinematic history) and I was more than happy to inhabit that moment with them. I'm sorry you failed to become similarly engrossed. Perhaps you could catch another showing of Mr. Bean. Heh...
CosmicConservative
Yeah, the Cosmic Wife feels the same, she loved it too. This probably just gets added to my well-known propensity to be too analytical about everything... I still liked the movie a lot. And I did like the final dynamic between Wade and Evans, although I actually took that as Wade doing something for Dan Evans oldest son than doing something for Dan Evans. But, before we get too choked up about the "sacrifice" Wade made, don't forget him whistling his horse to come after him. It was pretty clear that Wade wasn't going to be in Yuma prison long, if at all. In spite of Dan Evans' heroic sacrifice.
CosmicConservative
As far as Mr. Bean is concerned, I certainly didn't get engrossed in it either, I just thought the last third of the movie was pretty funny.
Dadman
Wade whistling for his horse at the end was a PERFECT cinematic moment, a fantastic way to end this movie. It made me smile from ear to ear because it was precisely what his character would do. Now, I don't believe Wade made much of a sacrifice, but he proved he was not all bad just as Will had claimed. When he blew away his vicious gang he earned in that moment a modicum of redemption. But it was Dan who paid the ultimately price to be redeemed in the eyes of his son. He knew he achieved his goal and he died with a smile on his face. I was moved by the whole end-game dynamic: a brutal killer willing to help his captor find redemption, a father desperate to re-earn his son's respect and save his ranch, and a son who finally gets to see how truly good and heroic his father is. Exquisite. I can't wait to see Yuma again.