Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (12)

Andy
Pace: I think Osama is right. I think we should just go ahead and convert. There is nothing that would thrill me more than seeing my four sons bow down and pray toward Mecca under threat of torture for infidelity to Islam. I would just be trilled if my nieces were covered from head to toe, and stoned if they were found unaccompanied by their husband. I hope that you are tongue in cheek with this, but if not..What the hell does Rush have to do with this? If there were no Rush, Bin Laden would still be a good candidate for the Dem. nomination...sounds just like some of them. This guy is evil personified...and uses the same lingo that most of the US libs do...draw your own conclusions. Like I said...hope you are joking with Bart, and forgive me if I read something into your comment that wasn't intended.
pace
"Bin Laden would still be a good candidate for the Dem. nomination.." All I'll say, Andy is that this kind of hyperbole is right up there with moonbat comparisons of Bush to . No doubt it's titillating to some on the right, but do you really believe that it is constructive to the Republican cause? The Rush reference was because I happened across his program last week while he was fervently attempting to work the same angle. It's something that I would expect to hear on his show, but not so much on this blog.
pace
Hmm.. apparently the blog software filters bracket characters. That was supposed to read as: "..comparisons of Bush to *insert evil dictator*"
Andy
Pace: "No doubt it’s titillating to some on the right, but do you really believe that it is constructive to the Republican cause?" Answering your question as honestly as I can...I'll give you a firm "maybe." With the exception of Bin Laden's invitation to the West to convert to Islam, I have heard one Democrat candidate or another either generally, or specifically mouth his words. A stark contrast will have to be drawn between the ideologies of Dems. and Reps. (where those differences actually exist) if the Republicans stand a chance next year. A frustration is mounting on the right, no doubt. I am one of them. I am not a Republican, so no one should take my moonbat hyperbole as a reflection of the party at large...just my personal dislike of Bin Laden, and current US liberal philosophy.
CosmicConservative
I mostly try to stay out of what I consider to be below-the-belt politics. But these days it's almost impossible to do so since I believe that 95% of Democratic politics is firmly and permanently below the belt. Democrats since Clinton have turned national politics into an ugly street fight, so they should not be surprised if (or when) the Republicans finally take the gloves off and start aiming below the belt themselves. As much as I hate such tactics, I am not going to fault the Republicans for doing what they have to for survival. The Democrats in general, and several in specific (Pelosi, Reid, Kucinich, Kerry, Gore, Hillary, Obama and many more) are extremely vulnurable to comparisons to our enemies in their rhetoric, their actions, their motivations and their ultimate goals. It truly is very difficult to separate the rhetoric of the hard left (see Daily KOS, Moveon.org, Code Pink, Firedoglake, Huffpo, etc...) and the rhetoric of Bin Laden and other Islamist jihadists. It is like they share their talking points. And this hurts the Democratic party, or it should. Hopefully it will. When the Democrats embraced the "America is the problem, there is no victory like defeat" policies of George McGovern, they lost control of the White House until a Southern centrist with hawkish rhetoric finally managed to win a few terms. The current influence of the hard left moonbats who view every problem on the planet as being caused by America, and who see no problem calling General Petraeus "General Betray-us" in a New York Times ad (not one single Democratic Senator or Presidential candidate has denounced that ad) has poisoned the Democratic party. I think this vulnurability is far more pressing and far more difficult to overcome than Democrats think. Right now the conventional wisdom in Washington and by the "punditry" across the country is that Republicans are on the run, they are demoralized and are ripe for getting their butts kicked in 2008 as they did in 2006. This is pretty much what the right thought about the Democrats in 2005. Fortunes change quickly in politics. Hillary, who is the obvious front runner among Democrats, has done the most to try to avoid being thrown in with the hard left, yet even she is still very vulnerable herself. Obama and the rest of the pack of Democratic candidates are virtually joined at the hip to Moveon.org. A savvy Republican with good campaigning skills has more opportunity to use Democratic defeatist rhetoric to their advantage than most people realize at this time. There is a powerful feeling of rage in this country over the Democratic party's years-long effort to undercut everything the military has done in Iraq. The first Republican who can make the point that Democrats are opposed to THE MILITARY, not just BOOOSH, will generate a powerful surge of emotion and motivation on the right to go to the polls and show the Democrats that America is a winner, not a loser. I think Guiliani is the best positioned to do that, but others, including Fred Thompsen, Mit Romney and Duncan Hunter also have the credibility, charisma and campaign savvy to do the same thing. It's going to be an interesting election year. Democrats are about to get a very serious wake-up call about how foolish they have been to cater to their hard left.
pace
I'm finding it hard to fault most of what you've said, CC. With the exception that I perceive that the right has played every bit as dirty as the left - the difference being that the left currently have a much stronger platform in the media outlets. While I am a Democrat, I am also a moderate. I find the Democratic catering to the radical left every bit as objectionable as Republican pandering to the religious right. Both movements have become so viciously diametrically opposed that there seems to be little room for those engaged in more rational thought. I just have no time for vitriolic rhetoric from either side.
pace
Regarding the comparisons of leftist talking-points to OBL.. Modern video editing is a wonderful tool. Of course OBL has made statements regarding US foreign policy that echo what some high profile Democrats (and a few Republicans) have been spouting. He's also said a great many extremely crazy things that don't further anyones agenda here, and which thus are not incorporated into Republican or Democratic video propaganda. As I said, attempts to draw some kind of parallel show a deep level of cynicism, and IMHO are probably not constructive to the wider Republican effort. I'm not even going to get into the flawed logic behind the assertion that "I said some things that you said, therefore we are the same" because I don't think you guys really believe it. It's just a political tool that I can't fault you for using, but which I hope the commentators on this blog would rise above.
CosmicConservative
Pace: It is fair to point out that two people who say the same thing on isolated subjects can not be expected to be in agreement on other subjects. However, we are talking about a singular subject here, and that subject is the war in Iraq. Forget for a moment that virtually every Democrat who is currently parroting Bin Laden originally VOTED FOR the current war. We'll consider that immaterial since Democrats and the vast majority of the American public seem to consider that "ancient history" with no relevance to the current debate. (I do not, of course, I consider Democrats who call a war they voted for "Bush's War" to be so far beyond cynical that there's really not a word, besides dishonest, that applies.) But on the subject of the war in Iraq Bin Laden and many of the mainstream leaders of the Democrat party say the following things: 1. The war in Iraq was initiated because GW Bush had friends in the oil industry and 9/11 was simply a pretext to invade Iraq to get their oil and to avenge the threats on GW Bush's father's life. 2. The war in Iraq is illegal. 3. America must leave Iraq as soon as possible. Immediately in fact. 4. American foreign policy in the middle east is the cause of the 9/11 murderous attacks. 5. George W. Bush is on a religious "crusade" against Islam. 6. GW Bush lied and trumped up intelligence to mislead the country into an illegal war. 7. The U.S. military routinely commits war crimes. 8. The U.S. military routinely commits human atrocities. 9. The U.S. military targets journalists and civilians with impunity. 10. The current American response is "recruiting more terrorists than it is killing." 11. The war in Iraq is bankrupting America. 12. The war in Iraq is squandering American good will around the world. 13. The war in Iraq is destroying the American economy. I could go on. It is one thing to have Dennis Kucinich and Bin Laden both saying "the sky is blue." It is quite another when both are saying that the United States is engaged in an illegal war, that the President of the United States has lied to the world to start an illegal war, and that war needs to be ended regardless of the consequences to the people who live in that country. When the parallels in the commentary are that wide, and that deep on such a pivotal, critical subject as this nation being at war with another nation, I believe it is quite fair, rational and reasonable to say, "Hey Dennis, you sound a whole lot like Bin Laden. Just whose side are you really on?"
Andy
Pace: You wrote: "I’m not even going to get into the flawed logic behind the assertion that “I said some things that you said, therefore we are the same” because I don’t think you guys really believe it. It’s just a political tool that I can’t fault you for using, but which I hope the commentators on this blog would rise above." Sorry man...I really do believe it...and I am just rotten enough not to rise above it. Others may have more class and discretion than I do (I sure hope so). But when opposition forces begin to give "advice" to their foes concerning tactics that will help further their cause, one thing comes to mind..."please throw me in the briar patch."
pace
I gotta be brief, I'm supposed to be working.. If Hillary Clinton (the reference in the original post) observes that "The U.S. military has violated international law in its mistreatment of prisoners", is this the same as if she says that "The U.S. military routinely commits human atrocities"? Clearly there is a profound difference in the two statements, but such critical nuances are easily (and readily) omitted. Such a statement would undoubtedly elicit an excited response across the right-wing blogosphere, observing that yes, Hillary does in fact hate the US Military! Certainly I've read far left commentators regularly make such inflammatory claims (worded particularly as your points were), but the primary contenders in the Democratic Presidential race? I'm not trying to engage you in a pedantic argument around semantics, but nuance is important in language. If you ask me if I think that American foreign policy was primarily responsible 9/11, then I will tell you of course not. But I'd make the statement that it was a contributing factor. That wasn't as brief as I would have liked.
CosmicConservative
Pace: Nuance is important, but so is stature. When someone of Hillary's stature essentially validates claims of our enemies during wartime, it is perfectly reasonable to say "Hillary, you are aiding and abetting the enemy." Because she objectively, provably is. So it doesn't have to be a constant statement from Hillary because her words will be amplified and repeated ad nauseum to provide support for the claims of our enemies against our military. And Hillary knows that but says it anyway because it panders to her base. This is dishonorable behavior targeted at one of our most honorable institutions. It is unconscionable. If Hillary wants to pursue such charges in the relatively subdued and protected airs of the Senate, which is her job that is one thing. When she screeches it out in a political campaign speech it is something else altogether. I will repeat myself. These Democrats think they are building an edifice for their party, but they are really digging a hole. One more thing. Hillary may believe this charge against our military. You may believe this charge against our military. But so far the actual instances of such abuse are far less than similar incidents that occurred during "honorable" wars such as WWI, WWII, the Korean War and others. The truth is that there are evil people in any organization, and those evil people do evil things. To paint the entire military with that same brush is, again, unconscionable. And if Hillary is referring to approved tactics (such as water boarding) then it is simply her OPINION that it is a violation of any prisoner's rights. So far the SCOTUS has not ruled that water boarding is disallowed, and if (when) it does come before that court, I expect it to be a close vote, but my money is on the SCOTUS saying "not torture."