Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Galadriel does Dylan...

By CosmicConservative
BBC NEWS | Entertainment | Blanchett wins top Venice award Cate Blanchett has been named best actress at the Venice Film Festival for her role in the Bob Dylan biopic I'm Not There. The actress has been hotly tipped to be nominated for an Oscar for her performance in the Todd Haynes film.
So... why wasn't she nominated for "Best Actor" instead? There are so many great places to take this story. I know it's not "cool" or "hip" to have this sort of attitude, but I personally think Bob Bylan is the single most over-rated performer in my entire lifetime. He posed on the cover of Life magazine (or something) in a leather motorcycle jacket, and suddenly he's a "beat poet" and everyone starts listening to his "songs" as if they were relevant. My personal opinion is that his musical style was simplistic, his lyrics were okay, but nothing that compared to, say, Paul Simon or John Lennon, and his entire career is one of narcissistic, or even nihilistic self-absorbtion. The one area he definitely excelled is in his overarching cynicism. And yes, I know that trendy pseudo-intellectuals are attracted to cynicism like horseflies to horse poop, but I find cynicism to be perhaps the least challenging of intellectual exercises. In fact I would call cynicism the intellectual equivalent of being a weekend couch-potato compared to a performer. The fact that the best "actor" they could find to play him is probably most famous for playing a fey elf maiden who sent a little hobbit off to save the world is just too funny. Other tidbits from this award show, of course the Best Director award went to some elitist who made yet another Bush bashing anti-Iraq-war movie. At what point is the Left going to realize that their approach to awards is like shooting fish in a barrel? It's just dead simple to win an award, you just have to promote a utopian, idealized view of the world that can never be achieved while viciously savaging those who attempt to deal with the real world by taking real actions that have real consequences. It's tiresome.

Comments (18)

Andy
CC: Amen! Dylan is mind-numblingly (is that a word?) over-rated. Not really much talent. But, Forever Young has to rank on my top 5 all time favorites. (Not his performances...but many others...especially the consummate commie Joan Baez...I just hate to love her work, but I do) I guess even a blind squirrel finds an acorn every once in a while.
Drax
Blowing in the Wind. Gotta Serve Somebody. It Ain't Me Babe. Just Like a Woman. Knocking on Heaven's Door. Lay, Lady, Lay. Like A Rolling Stone. Mr. Tambourine Man. Rainy Day Women. Shelter From the Storm. Simple Twist of Fate. I like Dylan.
CosmicConservative
OK, so let's compare: Blowing in the Wind to Scarborough Fair. Gotta Serve Somebody to Imagine In Ain't Me Babe to Revolution Just Like a Woman to Something.. I'm not saying that Dylan couldn't write. I'm saying that he is vastly overrated. He has a few songs that I like, but very few when compared to, say, Bernie Taupin, John Fogerty or many others. Of those in your list the only one I really like is Like a Rolling Stone, and that's mostly for sentimental reasons. Of those I think were vastly superior to Dylan in what Dylan is usually considered so good (lyrics, not score), I would definitely put all of these way ahead of Dylan in both quantity and quality: John Lennon Paul McCartney Paul Simon John Fogerty Bernie Taupin Brian Wilson Jim Croce Buddy Holly Stevie Wonder Of course it's all taste, so there's no "right" or "wrong" opinion on this stuff I guess. But my opinion, right or wrong, is that Bob Dylan is a top notch songwriter, probably in the top 25, MAYBE in the top ten, but he is idolized by so many people as being somehow profound and brilliant, and that I just don't see. His best work, as good as it is, doesn't come close to comparing to "City of New Orleans" or "Scarborough Fair" or "Revolution" or "Fortunate Son" or a whole host of other songs, folk, rock and/or protest. I'll put it another way. Rock history without The Beatles would be completely different. Without Paul Simon we would have lost a generation's worth of rock anthems. Without Jim Croce we'd have lost one of our most authentic voices, without John Fogerty we'd have had to suffer through nothing but psychedelic rock in the 60s. Without Dylan we'd have to do without a bunch of hippies singing "Blowing in the Wind" every time they get lost trying to consider how to interpret geopolitical global events.
Andy
CC: You are killing me here man. Jim Croce is on my top 5 with "Roller Derby Queen", and "Rapid Roy, The Stock Car Boy." I am kidding, of course. Croce was a genius...Photographs and Memories, Time in a Bottle, I've Got A Name, One Less Set of Footsteps...on and on. I'll give you Paul McCartney on the list...a great songwriter, though a bad judge of second wives. Eddie Holland has to be there...he made my cousin Martha Reeves a superstar with Heatwave, and Dancin' in the Streets. Willie Nelson is at the top for me...Crazy, Night Life...too many others to type...true genius as a musician, performer, and songwriter. Dylan is not in the top 10 songwriters. But, I do truly love Forever Young.
Drax
If you can be considered to be in the top 100 songwriters who have ever lived, then, I don't see how you can be "vastly overrated." If, by consensus, you are termed the "voice of a generation," I really can't see you being overrated. His songs continue playing on the air waves somewhere...all the time....forty years and more since they were released. And, he wrote those by himself...not as part of a group. Let's see. What did Lennon do after the Beatles? "Mind Games" and "Imagine." (And, I don't put "Imagine" anywhere in the running for even a "good song," let alone one which is "great..." It's all taste...) McCartney? After the Beatles? "Band on the Run." "Silly Love Song" (Hey it was popular if crap) "Maybe I'm Amazed." "The Long and Winding Road." "Live and Let Die." (Go Bond!) I can't go on. He was crap after the Beatles, just bubblegum pop song after bubblegum pop song. Croce. I don't think I've heard a song of his which I didn't like. I can't compare a single one to "Blowing in the Wind." Or to "Mr. Tambourine Man." Or "Knocking on Heaven's Door." Love Nelson. Beatles? Mostly bubblegum pop music except for a couple of albums. Totally mindless crap. Until Revolver....I don't like their stuff so much. Took a while for them to hit their non-bubblegum pop creative stride... Dylan wrote a ton of songs which were utter crap as well. But, some of the songs he wrote will exist until the sun burns out in the sky. As will many, many of those of the Beetles. Not Croce, I don't think. Maybe one song by Lennon after the Beatles. None by McCartney after the Beatles. There aren't many artists who you might say that about. And, if you can say that, you can't be very "overrated," I don't think.
CosmicConservative
Dylan's reputation is what keeps his songs on the radio, not his talent. McCartney and Lennon did sometimes write as a pair, but in general they wrote songs separately. Among the songs Paul McCartney wrote with no input from Lennon are "Hey Jude", "Yesterday", "Let it Be", "Blackbird", "When I'm 64" and a host of others. "Yesterday" is the most covered song in the history of the music industry. I don't think Paul McCartney's record needs my defense. Yes he did only a few really good songs after breaking up with the Beatles, but so did Lennon, who had his own string of rock anthems written solo by him while with the Beatles. These songs will be played until human beings are no longer human beings. The early Beatles, the period you call "utterly mindless crap" gave us everything from "Twist and Shout" to "A Hard Days Night." I don't consider that to be a period of bubble gum pop, that was pretty hard-driving rock and roll in my mind. Croce may not be long remembered, but if not that's a shame. His songs are evocative and lyrical, with a gritty, realistic feel to them, and the guitar player who played with Croce (and who died in the same plane wreck) was the best finger-picking guitarist I heard playing in a popular act. "Alabama Rain" and "Photographs and Memories" are as good as any love songs ever written. It is very easy to be in the top 25 of something and still be vastly overrated. People act as if Dylan is some sort of song-writing god. He was one of a large group of very talented song writers, that's all. Getting a Presidential award for his "poetry" is way more than he ever deserved. I suppose you could say the same thing about McCartney's knighthood too, to be fair...
Andy
Drax: Glad you love Willie...what's not to love huh? Bobby D: To each his own I guess. Just not a Dylan fan outside of Forever Young. Concensus certainly may have crowned Bob as the voice of his generation. I know that many just love Dylan, and God bless 'em. I am sure that his music struck a chord in their hearts that was very relevant at the time. But KC and the Sunshine Band did for a lot of kids, too. (like I said, to each his own) Over-rated may be too strong a term. Dylan was certainly no one hit wonder. His music did influence an entire generation (don't get it myself, but there are a lot of things I don't grasp). Croce: I think you said it best...never heard a song of his that you didn't like. When someone never lays a dookie, now that is special. That's why I love Jim, and Willie...even when they didn't show their true genius, they never dropped a turd. Dylan did write a bunch of stuff that was crap, and I respect him for putting it out there to be heard. Most artists would throw it in the trash can, but Dylan was not afraid to bare his soul to folks (even if there was no commercial value). And we can't leave out Elton John...oh man...how I hate to love his work, but I just can't help it. Maybe you are right. Anyone in the top 100 can't be considered over-rated...Dylan definitely is in the top 100. My apologies.
Drax
CC: I think that it's a gross exaggeration to say that it's easy to be in the top 25 of anything when that anything includes the whole world and includes all of time. It was the symbiosis...the gesalt of the Beatles. While the songs may have been written solo, it was a joint effort...not only them..but their producer. Reviewing many of those songs, both were credited for many... People don't listen to someone's reputation. They listen to the song. If people play a song because of the reputation of the singer or writer, then their audience will leave them for a station which plays songs which they actually like. The complexity of some of Dylan's songs is amazing. Never a couple of verses (such as "Blackbird" or "Yesterday" or most of the Beatles' songs...) I didn't have much use for the early Beatles. Some of their stuff was toe tapping good, to be sure, but, until "Revolver" there weren't very many songs which survived reading without the beat. Dylan's good songs do. (His crap doesn't, and there was a ton of crap...I even waded through Trantula...OMG....) It's all taste.
CosmicConservative
I guess the reason I don't care for Dylan's work is because the stuff he wrote comes across to me as typical pseudo-profundity. In other words it sounds profound, but it's really not. "Blowin' in the Wind" is an excellent example. It sounds so profound, but it says nothing. It offers no insights, reveals no deeper truths and provides no guidance for future considerations. It's just intellectual pablum. And I think that's why the Left loves it so much, because that's what the Left loves. It's not so much that Dylan was bad, as that there are so many who were so much better that never got the credit they earned, while Dylan, in his leather motorcycle jacket, smoking a cigarette, channeled James Dean and Marlon Brando, leading a generation to believe he was more than he really was. Compare "Blowing in the Wind" to any one of Paul Simon's great folk-rock songs. Let's just pick "The Boxer" for example.
I am just a poor boy though my story's seldom told, I have squandered my resistance for a pocketful of mumbles such are promises... All lies and jest, still a man hears what he wants to hear and disregards the rest....
Man, that, my friend, is writing. It tells a story. It reveals deeper truths about humanity. It provides guidance for future considerations. It ends like this:
In the clearing stands a boxer and a fighter by his trade, and he carries the reminders, of every blow that laid him low or cut him 'til he cried out, in his anger and his pain, I am leaving I am leaving but the fighter still remains...
Dylan could not hope to write anything so deep and so profound, but he could write gibberish that SOUNDED profound, such as
You never turned around to see the frowns on the jugglers and the clowns When they all come down and did tricks for you You never understood that it aint no good You shouldnt let other people get your kicks for you You used to ride on the chrome horse with your diplomat Who carried on his shoulder a siamese cat
A siamese cat? Clowns doing tricks for you? Let other people get your kicks for you? Huh? Sounds real deep, but I defy you to find any true meaning in it. Is he talking about some rich person who fell on hard times? Or a politician who fell to scandal? Or a child born with a silver spoon? I guess you could say that the vagueness of it is what makes it so profound, and I'd say "A man hears what he wants to hear and disregards the rest.... " ;) Scarborough Fair, with it's background lyrics of "Generals order their soldiers to kill, and to fight for a cause, they have long ago forgotten" doesn't have to be vague to be profound and compelling. You don't have to wonder what's blowing in the wind at Scarborough Fair, it's right there in front of you. I guess I'm just not subtle enough to "get" Dylan. And I don't suppose I ever will be.
pace
Dylan just never did it for me. Neither his song writing, nor his vocal performances. Paul Simon? Yep, I can dig it!
Drax
It's taste, man....not subtlety. There is a feel to the words and the sound of Dylan. Like some poetry, the sound of it surpasses the meaning of it. His sounds, his words are evocative. The harshness of "It ain't me" as he tells his lover that there's nothing but stone inside. The plaintif cry of "Lay, Lady, Lay" as he begs his lover to stay. Don't get me wrong. I like Dylan. I think that his poetry is some which will last as long as music has any meaning. I don't take anything from the Beatles, I just wasn't a fan. I absolutely loved some of their songs, but never really "got" them. ("Yellow Submarine?" Talk about a "what the #!%& song..."I am the walrus..cook coo ca choo????" But, good beat and a great sound...) When it comes to actual lyrics, I love much of Randy Newman. ("Political Science." "Sail Away.") I love Simon. I love the Mamas and Pappas. Never got Hendrix except the guitar....Can't leave Kristofferson out of the songwriting equation either....("Me and Bobby McGee...") It's all taste. But, as in all things commercial and driven by taste, a consensus is formed. It would be hard to convince me that the consensus about Dylan isn't that he was one of greatest songwriters who ever graced the planet.
CosmicConservative
One thing I'm trying to get across that isn't coming across is what I mean by vastly overrated. Yes, it is fair to say that it is hard to overrate someone who is in the top 25 of anything they have ever done. But this is like the Babe Ruth thing, even if someone is in the top 25 of their profession, it is still very common for them to be vastly overrated. I put Einstein in that category, for example, and I am a huge fan of Albert Einstein. But the idea that he was far beyond his peers, such as Heisenberg or Bohr, just to name two, is something that Einstein himself would have laughed at. As brilliant as Einstein was, his actual reputation far exceeds his actual talent. And I don't mean that to denigrate the man, it simply is not possible to be what the public thinks he was. So when I say that Dylan is overrated, I mean that in a similar way. His reputation is far beyond his actual accomplishments, and I mean FAR beyond. He is a decent songwriter, and an average performer. He somehow managed to strike a chord (pun intended) with the public at a particular time and as a result his reputation grew beyond anything that can be supported by his work. As good as his work is (and I can intellectually appreciate that his work must be good, although I frankly don't see it myself). I say the same thing about the Beatles, and I'm a certified Beatlemaniac. I do think the Beatles talents were less exaggerated in their reputation than Dylan's were though. Bob Dylan, the myth, is far more likely to be what people think about than Bob Dylan the man. That's what I'm trying to say. As a songwriter Bob Dylan's talents were exceeded by several individuals who receive far less credit than Dylan, in spite of their superior skills, and that bugs me. It always bugs me when the myth of a person outgrows the actual person and people believe the myth. I've already added Babe Ruth to that list. I would also add Noam Chomsky, Ernest Hemingway, Bill Clinton, John Wayne and many others to that list. Including the Beatles. But even considering that there are many whose legend outstripped their talents, I think Bob Dylan is much farther from his legend than usual. I really think he is a fairly mundane talent, who happened to be in the right place at the right time with the right look, and he rode that fame for the rest of his life.
Drax
I just disagree that he is a "mundane talent." I think that he was one of the all time great talents. I would be VERY hard pressed to name 25 song writers, in the history of mankind, who is better, who has a more impressive and lasting body of work. I take your analogy of the Ruth/Cobb debate, or the Ruth canard that he so far outstripped the rest of the field. (Disregarding that, in home runs, at the time, that isn't even debatable...but the rest...) When you are in that most elite of circles, whether in entertainment or athletics, when you are "one of the best" that means that you are better than 99.9999999999999% of the rest. But, there are some who are as good, are better, or are just a little less good, but, in every case, the margin between those in that elite circle is very, very small. Even the nearly undefeatable Moses only won by the smallest or margins, measured in fractions of fractions of seconds. Ruth is a legend. Cobb is a legend. That is by consensus of those who watched and those who played. The same is true of Dylan. Is he THAT much better than the others who are ALSO legends? Of course not. Is he better than ALL of those who are ALSO legends? Of course not. But, he is better than almost every songwriter who has ever put pen to paper. And, vocally? He and Willie. Two screeching voices that no sane person would ever think would sing popular songs. But they did. Somehow, they were able to tailor their words and music, their style, into something that a HUGE number of people not only liked but fell in love with, DESPITE a voice "only a mother could love." That, I think, is much more impressive than those insipid pop singers with the great voices singing insipid and forgettable songs. We're not going to forget Dylan. When the sun burns out in the sky, he will still be playing somewhere. That's how it is with legends.
CosmicConservative
Ah... nonsense. They'll be saying "Bob who?" long after Paul McCartney and John Lennon are still household names. Assuming anyone still lives in houses that is. Or listens to music. Luis Armstrong? Probably. Frank Sinatra? Probably. Elvis Presley? Certainly. Hank Williams? Perhaps. Johnny Cash? Maybe. Bob Dylan? Perhaps. I'll grant you the screeching voice though. Although he somehow managed to do a credible job on "Lay Lady, Lay." And I had forgotten about one of his best songs, The Times They Are A'Changing."
Drax
Sinatra? You've got to be kidding. He struck a chord when he was a young heartthrob. He struck a different chord when he was a member of the ratpack. He struck a different chord when he became Chariman of the Board. Those chords no longer resonate as they once did. However, his rendition of "New York, New York" will probably last as long as New York does.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I can't tell you how many people would look at your "Dylan will last forever" and your "Sinatra? You've got to be kidding" comments and say "Pshaw, Baby Boomer..." I could even have put Bing Crosby there. Or Diana Ross. Or Rita Moreno. You're right about a lot of it being taste.
Drax
Other than "New York, New York," name five songs (without looking them up) which Frankie sang. Name one he wrote. Moreno as well. Ross? Maybe as a member of the Supremes, and, more as part of the "Motown Sound" than as an individual band. Crosby? "White Christmas." Last forever. I don't really know why you're comparing performers to songwriters when songwriting is the issue...
CosmicConservative
I didn't say that I was one of those who would defend Sinatra, just that there are plenty who would. Personally I don't care much for his singing, and you are right, I shouldn't be dragging singers into this.