Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

How far would you go?

By Dadman
At a recent movie viewing I noticed there are a couple films coming out soon with strong vigilante themes: Death Sentence starring Kevin Bacon and The Brave One starring Jodie Foster. I have to believe that before such projects are greenlighted by the studios they conduct some surveys and/or focus groups to determine which plot themes would be positively received by audiences. Now, I don't know this for sure, but I'd be willing to wager a few bucks that such research is conducted. And if I'm right Hollywood is attempting to tap into the frustration people are feeling with respect to violent crime and a wussy justice system that tends to treat hardened criminals with more understanding and compassion than their victims. The tagline of Death Sentence is: "How far would you go to protect your family?" That's good question. I think those that go to see Death Sentence will enjoy watching Kevin Bacon go after the criminals who wantonly killed his son and threaten his family. How far would you go?

Comments (7)

CosmicConservative
OK, so I have to make sure we are on the same page with terminology. "Protect your family," to me, means steps you would take to remove a threat to your family, such as an armed intruder. In that case I have no principle against using whatever deadly force is necessary to protect my family. "Vigilante," to me, means retribution for acts already committed. I do have principles against taking the law into my own hands. Now, in both cases, would I be able to live up to my expectations? Would I be able to point a gun at an intruder and pull the trigger? I think so, but you never know until you are in that situation. Similarly, if someone murdered my family in particularly vile and violent ways, would my principles against taking the law into my own hands overcome my own desire for retribution? I don't know, and I hope I never have to find out.
Andy
CC: You have no idea how completely I agree with your comment. As I read the post, I was posing my answer. I did not have to. Every thought and emotion that I wanted to convey...you did it. Just an Amen.
Drax
It is easy to think that one would take violent action to protect one's family or take retribution on those who did violence to your family. But, contrary to common perception, Americans, generally are not violent people, else, in this land of "a gun for every hand," we would see the dead bodies of rapists and murderers strewn about the landscape. We are a nation of laws. We trust, for the most part, for the law to do what it's supposed to do. And, for those who haven't ever visited violence on another with premeditation, it is not something which comes naturally to people in this civilized nation. That being said, we DO hear about some who visit retribution on those who did harm to their loved ones. I suspect that I'd be one of those....
Andy
CC: The phrase that struck me was "I think so, but you never know until you are in that situation." I have said those exact words so many times that I can not count them. I like to think that Drax and I would be lined up together guns-a-blazing at the scum...but you never know until you are actually faced with a situation how you will react. Thanks Dadman...very thought provoking.
Dadman
I agree that you never know how you'll respond to a situation until you are in it. But I can imagine a situation, say my family is sadistically butchered and the perp walks on a technicality and then proceeds to taunt me in some way. If my family were gone I literally would have nothing to lose if I went after the guy...and I think that is precisely what I would do.
Andy
Dadman: I sure want you on my side the next time I have nothing to lose...
ams182764
Hmm. Not that I'm Rambo or anything (combat skills training has made that abundantly clear), but it seems the standard biological answer to "what would you do to protect your family?" is anything at all within your power. My answer as well. As far as being a nation of laws - the police can't defend you - it's impossible for that sort of omnipresence to exist, even with massive surveillance. The only thing the law can do is punish crime after the fact and dispose of criminals to deter such actions in the future. When the law doesn't even do that, how much longer will we be a naton of laws? It isn't that the law demands a strict standard of evidence and an extreme burden of doubt that is the problem: I would still rather err on the side of letting the guilty go free by a wide wide margin, lest the innocent be punished. It is that once guilt is determined beyond that reasonable doubt, no significant punishment or quarantine is forthcoming. If a rapist knew that the moment he was dismissed on a technicality, the father was likely to drop him on the courthouse steps with a sniper rifle, it would certainly do much to deter him from committing the crime. If not, it would certainly prevent him from repeating it.