Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Media Bias report

By CosmicConservative
Rove Incident Causes Editor to Declare: Keep Political Views to Yourself NEW YORK No matter what you think of Karl Rove -- or anyone else in politics -- please keep it to yourself, or at least falrly quiet. That was the message in a note sent to staffers at the Seattle Times by Executive Editor Dave Boardman after what he called "an awkward moment at yesterday's news meeting." What happened? According to Boardman in the latest email installment of what he calls "Dave's Raves" it was this: "When word came in of Karl Rove's resignation, several people in the meeting started cheering. That sort of expression is simply not appropriate for a newsroom....As we head into a major political year, now's a good time to remember: Please keep your personal politics to yourself."
Nah, there's no groupthink media bias against conservatives or Republicans in the press. None at all. Why in the world would we think so? The only difference between Seattle and every other newsroom in the country is that this one editor was embarrassed enough to chastise his biased compatriots to at least PRETEND to be newspeople. In the other newsrooms I'm sure the editors joined the cheering.

Comments (30)

Andy
To my shame, I was a journalism major in college for a short time (fell into the "All The King's Men" trap). I know it is not Christian to take pleasure in the difficulties of others, but my old dastardly "flesh" just rejoices every time the circulation figures are reported by the newspapers and magazines (Lord, forgive me).
Dadman
Amen. Anti-conservative bias is everywhere. What concerns me is that the bias is now becoming part of the appeal - conservatives watch Fox and libbies watch/read everything else. The media seems to be dividing itself into agenda driven camps, and they're becoming less shy about proclaiming it. I think the example in this post is a relatively rare occurrence.
gjh
I think it said, a few of the people there reacted, not all the people reacted. The cloak of oppression doesn't fit well. I wonder what the reactions were during the Clinton witchunt when the BJ and the blue dress came to light?
Andy
Dadman and gjh: This probably rarely occurs (you are right Dadman), and gjh is correct also. Reporters (righties or lefties) live and die on "sensational" events. The worst thing that could happen to the news biz would be peace and harmony throughout the world. Reporters would be running around trying to find that "man that bit the dog." Look at the days of the "Wild West." Reporters had to invent gunfights to stay employed...the more things change, they more they stay the same. Keep the masses in turmoil to pay the mortgage...(with a few exceptions) a pox on all of their houses!
CosmicConservative
gjh: I'm guessing the media reaction to the blue dress and Monica was the same as mine. Abject disgust and disbelief that a sitting President could be so monumentally stupid. I think that reaction crosses partisan lines. It's what the Left did AFTER that reaction that bothers me in the Lewinsky affair. In the article I posted it doesn't say "few" it says "several". In most people's view of the English Language "few" and "several" are pretty much opposite concepts. This is more of your alternate reality gjh, you can literally read the word "several" in a story and your mind changes that to "few" immediately if "few" better fits your biases.
Andy
CC: I remember the Monica business very well. I did not feel abject disgust, nor disbelief at the stupidity of Clinton. It did not surprise me one bit, nor did it cause me to ponder the stupidity of that particular sitting President. As a disclaimer, I have family/political connections to "Bubba," so I can say honestly that my great surprise was that it took so long for him to screw up so royally. gjh is right about one thing...the glee on the right over this was over the top. I learned that "righties" can be just as brutal as "lefties." There is a great lesson there. I felt that Clinton should have been put out of office in his impeachment trial. Serial liars should not occupy that powerful office. Sometimes I think that many Republican Senators just didn't want the Goracle as the head of the free world, and swallowed hard before their vote to acquit. Best of two evils, huh? I will restate my disdain for righties and lefties in the media that allow their philosophy to color their reporting...I restate it without apology! Very few humans can detach their hearts from their heads...so we truly have "very few" real reporters.
Drax
gjh: I remember when Clinton was finally "caught." I was surprised not one whit by the incident nor his constant lies to us and under oath about the incident. I was not surprised even the slightest by the constant attacks by his spin doctors ("drag a dollar bill through a trailer park" remarks) against Paula Jones (for those keeping score, that lawsuit is why all this came to light...) There was no elation. There was no sadness. There was no feeling at all. Clinton was, and always has been, scum. This incident only PROVED the level of "scum" that he was. CC: I'm reminded of Dan Rather's reaction when he had to (finally) announce that Bush was President. The man was almost in tears. (Contrasted sharply against his elation when he erroneously announced that Gore was....)
Andy
Drax: Bubba was, and probably still is "scum" as you labeled him. But there was elation on the right. That elation, fueled by the hatred of "three dollar Bill" turned the right into something that I did not recognize from my former Republican party (no longer enrolled). I saw too many on the right lose their Reaganesque "class" during the impeachment...grandstanding for the media...offering solemn (fake) platitudes...just hoping that Larry Flynt didn't turn up something on them before it was over. It turned my stomach. That has been repeated by the left with their hatred of President Bush (which I will never understand...I dislike many of his policies, but love and respect him personally). Hatred is a guest that eventually destroys its host. It happened to the right, and it will happen to the left. Think Libertarian! We could use a few good men!
Drax
I didn't experience that, Andy. Sure there were some who were "elated" by the fact that he got CAUGHT....finally, and were devestated that, in the end, he "got away." But, the "elation" had very little to do with "politics." It had to do with the fact that the country had twice elected a person that any thinking person KNEW to be "scum," regardless of his politics.
Andy
Drax: Good for you! I did not experience the personal hatred either...just sadness for Bill, his "holier than thou" foes, and for our Republic. I have no argument with you on this. I was saddened that our nation could be so inane as to twice elect Bill to the most noble of offices. I just shook my head in disbelief both times. But I will again say that the hatred of Bill brought the Republicans down to the level of the Dems. Hatred is dastardly stuff...Republicans have paid the price for that hatred, as the Dems will soon.
gjh
The more things change to more they stay the same. I know many libs who still can't Nixon without spitting and as noted above, cons who do the same with Clinton. When we measure our leaders by the quality of their sex lives or conquests while ignoring their accomplishments or failures in relationship to the country as a whole, we miss the big picture. In my opinion Clinton's biggest mistake in his tenure was his deregulating the broadcast media and ownership where a few, there goes that word again, control the information to the nation. The media frenzy ignited by the Lewinsky affair is not disimilar to the Paris Hilton, Britany Spears crap dominating the news today.
CosmicConservative
The candidates for "Clinton's biggest mistake" are pretty impressive. Here is a short list off the top of my head: Hillary Health Care China Most Favored Nation Status North Korea negotiations Military budget cuts Dismantling the CIA infrastructure Incredibly inappropriate pardons War on Drugs Waco Janet Reno Jocelyn Elders Ruth Vader Ginsberg Al Gore I could go on and on...
Drax
gjh: Another post which highlights your basic amorality and COMPLETE lack of understanding of why (some) people were after Clinton. You'll never understand. You don't see anything wrong with anything that he did. You apparently think that a person who lies to and cheats on his wife in a serial fashion, lies under oath in order to protect his personal fortune, and has his personal attack dogs smear women who were telling the truth about Clinton's actions.....to be a person we should trust with the lives and treasure of our country. We get it. We have ALWAYS gotten it.
gjh
Drax Nothing has changed today as the administration is still waging personal attack of those who do not tow the company line. Every military man who disagreed to to the fiasco in Iraq, before or after the occupation has been fired, er, er. retired. CIA how about Plame, how about Wilson? Claiming executive privilege, where no exists. The war on drug was started with Regean and was a failure to begin with and will be so until rational people use their heads with the drug problem. What about N. Korea? Everything was in check until the Knucklehead in Chief decided to label the axis of evil BS. Your hatred is as bad, misinformed and off base as the Nixon bashers are today. I hope the libs choose Kuzinich (sp) to lead them out of this mess your guy put us into.
Drax
gjh: As usual, you don't understand the issues. What you're talking about with Bush are Bush's POLICY DECISIONS, ones with which you disagree. Are you seriously still talking about Wilson and Plame? What rational person is still talking about them after the facts have been made clear? And, YOU get to decide where executive privlege lies? I don't think so. We'll see where it actually lies when and if the Supremes take the issue on. Until then, BUSH gets to decide when to take executive privlege as.....HE'S the executive.... And N. Korea was "in check" before Bush? My god, what kool-aid have you taken? As CC frequently asks, "what color is the sky in your world?" Clinton was scum. He is a disbarred lawyer. He was the chief executive, charged with executing the laws of the land, yet broke those laws to protect his personal fortune. He sent his attack dogs out to talk to the press, calling the women who charged him with vile conduct every name in the book, attempting to RUIN them...because they were TELLING THE TRUTH. These are not politicos who are no longer in favor and discharged. These were CIVILIAN women who were targeted by the Clinton team for RUIN because they dared to TELL THE TRUTH.... Again. You can't distinguish between our distaste for Clinton and the left's distaste for Bush. Ya'll PERSONALLY attack Bush for his POLICY choices yet FORGIVE Clinton for his personal choices (criminal ones at that) so long as his POLICY choices pleased you. The right, although they disliked "some" of Clinton's policy choices, attacked Clinton for his CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR in a civil case....behavior which has been PROVED. Sigh. You just don't get it. We didn't like Clinton because he was scum. We didn't like some of his policy decisions (just as most don't like many of Bush's policy decisions). The difference is that we don't characterize Bush as a demon because of his policy decisions while ya'll do. The difference is that we characterized the scum Clinton as the scum he was because he was scum...not because of his policy decisions.
gjh
Like they say to Charlie the Tuna "Do you want tuna with good taste or tuna that tastes good?". I liked Ty Cobb for his accomplishments not for his personal life. The world I live in is much like yours except much nicer! When the full story comes out on this leader, you still won't believe it. Hell you won't even believe that Libby was convicted for OUTING A CIA AGENT. In the civilian world that is treason. Have a Rose Colored Day
CosmicConservative
gjh: Do you actually believe that Libby was convicted for "outing a CIA agent?" Do you realize that is insane? Do you realize that he wasn't even CHARGED with that, much less convicted of it? He was charged with lying about who he talked to and when, and was convicted of that charge. He was charged with and convicted of perjury. NOBODY was charged with outing a CIA agent, not even the man who actually has admitted to doing it, Richard Armitage. Again, I can't help but believe that this blog has somehow ripped a fabric in space time and you are contributing to it from a literal alternate reality with completely different facts and history. You make claims that are as demonstrably and monumentally untrue as saying the moon landings never happened. I have to think that you are frequently just trolling here for the reaction you get. Nobody as intelligent as you sometimes appear to be can be that completely ignorant of facts and history.
Drax
It's like gjh just cuts and pastes from the allegations made by nutso lefties before the facts are out and spouts them as if nothing has happened in between.
gjh
I don't know how to cut and paste, I can barely get this machine going at times. He was convicted for lying about the outing of a CIA agent and protected with a commutation and eventually a pardon. I'm waiting to hear that she wasn't covert. That is usually the next thing to come out. She was outed because her old man told the truth about the Niger Scam. The Admin paid him back by trying to F**k with his wife. What a bunch of up standing men. The cover up is being boondoggled by executive privilege. Remember, that is what got Nixon, not the break in but the cover up. I remember, if you got nothing to hide let us look!
Drax
gjh: "I remember, if you got nothing to hide let us look!" HaHaHaHa....oh my. Tell Hillary that. There're a couple of million documents in the Clinton Library which they are hiding until after the election. Oh my. What world indeed?
CosmicConservative
gjh: I truly hope you do not believe your own hype. You are so far gone into BDS and Leftist propaganda that I really do wonder if you are capable of telling truth from fiction. Richard Armitage outed Valerie Plame gjh. He admitted it. The WASHINGTON POST in a key editorial said that the "saddest thing about the Valerie Plame episode is that so many people believed Joe Wilson." Including, I have to say, the Washington Post's reporters and editors. You may be the only person left in America who doesn't realize the truth about Wilson and Plame. But actually I doubt it. By now there is an army of gjh's out there, so poisoned by hatred of Bush and so brainwashed by Leftist propaganda that the truth may never be able to dig its way into the light again.
Andy
gjh: I am a new visitor to this blog, and I have found some good wisdom in some of your comments...have agreed with many of them, but your arguments on this particular issue are really detached from reality. None of your arguments actually match any fact. I will give Clinton credit for what he did good. He signed "welfare reform." Never mind the fact that it was Newt's baby, and he did it reluctantly...he did sign it! (It is proving to be fabulous policy). He did a decent job helping to broker peace in Northern Ireland (a great surprise to me that it has held up). But it has held up. I don't know how much he personally did to make it happen, but I will give him credit for having the vision to try. But CC is right. His list of egregious failures by Bill is just the beginning. The man did not deserve to be in that office. I know the guy, and he is "scum." Bill is the kind of guy that will put his arm around your shoulder, and pee down your leg. A person of such weak character should never occupy high office. I could just spit on President Bush sometimes because of his policies...but he is a man of integrity and character that I have great respect for. I wouldn't spit on Bill if he was on fire.
gjh
Hey guys if you are using Newt as a moral compass your arguements don't hold water. Didn't he serve his wife papers while she was in the hospital for cancer. Got dropped off by his mistress, 3rd wife. I sort of think that is how Gonzo got the idea about the wire tap stuff for Ashcroft. The highest level of prosperity for America was during the Clinton terms. Scum or no scum, I want tuna that taste good, not good taste. Do you really want to take the high ground on morality with the Repub track record of divorce,double lifes, sexual deviants, religious gurus high in the admin with male hookers, anal rape of spouse by the guy in charge of women's health issues? The problem with taking the high road is when you fall it's the landing that kills you.
CosmicConservative
gjh: Again you assert that Democrats are the "good humans" and Republicans are the "evil humans." This theme is so infantile and so demonstrably untrue that it pretty much fits with the rest of your worldview.
gjh
That is not the point at all. The point is don't throw stones if you can't catch em. Quit trying to take the high moral ground on certain matters and cry like a school girl when it gets turned around on you. For every Bill Clinton swipe you'll get a Bob Allen thrown back in your face. This country was better off under Bill Clinton than were are under George Bush. That was all I was trying to say. We went from the greatest period of economic growth and surplus to the greatest national debt this country has ever experienced.
CosmicConservative
gjh: Get real. Your hands must be raw from throwing stones. You routinely describe conservatives and Republicans in the most vicious terms, calling them evil, greedy, stupid, whatever you think is the worst thing you can say about them. Now you have the unmitigated gall to act all outraged because Drax has directed specific attacks at Bill Clinton's obviously immoral behavior? Spare us gjh. Go look up the national debt and the US budget numbers one day gjh to get a real historical view of the real differences between Clinton, Bush, Reagan, etc. If you did that, and were capable of comprehending the reality of it without sending it through your partisan filters first, you would realize how little difference there has been in the budget since the sixties. Clinton's "balanced budget" was almost entirely accomplished through drastic cuts in the military, cuts that we had to reverse, which means he essentially borrowed money from the Bush years by forcing Bush to restore the military after Clinton had virtually dismantled it. Much like Carter and Reagan. It costs more to rebuild something than to maintain it gjh.
gjh
Evil? Greedy? Stupid? You seem to read between the lines.I don't think I have ever used these terms. If these are the most vicious terms you could be ever be called or that your party could be called you've got pretty thin skin and really don't get out into the real world much? I ask some questions or state facts? The questions are never answered and the facts are never challenged only insults lobbed. If you think the country is in better shape now than it was during the Clinton years, I would like to know what the color of the sky is in your world?
CosmicConservative
gjh: Let's look at some numbers: Clinton's average unemployment during his first six years in office was 5.575. Bush's first six years was 5.295. That was AFTER a huge spike in unemployment caused by the 9/11 attacks, something Clinton never had to deal with (even though his actions, imho, led directly to it happening). Six years into Clinton's term the average median income in the U.S. was roughly $43.5K Six years into Bush's term the average median income is roughly $45.5K. I don't have the numbers on this, because with all the tax brackets and stuff it's hard to get a single number, but I think you would agree that U.S. homes are paying less taxes than in Clinton's term. So with higher income and lower taxes, that adds more to personal disposable income. So I could keep looking but so far, unemployment is lower, pay is higher and taxes are lower. Those sure seem to paint a picture of the country being in better shape today than eight years ago.
gjh
Not from where I come from. Lower Michigan has been decimated, the jobless rate is about 10%, the statistics only show those who are collecting unemployment and not the ones who have fallen through the cracks and statistically don't exist. Many are working two or three jobs because if they work more than 24 hours/week would have to be paid benefits.
CosmicConservative
gjh: Wow, the AMAZING thing about Democrats is that no portion of the country EVER suffers disproportionate pain when compared to the rest of the country, that ONLY happens with Republican administrations. I mean there was no job market bust in Denver during the 90s, nope, none at all. Property values did not slide, and entire industries did not leave the area.. Oh, wait.. yes they did. The plural of "anecdote" is not "data" gjh. You made an assertion, I refuted it with actual facts, and you now respond with an anecdote about the local conditions where you live. That's like me saying Global Warming is a hoax because we just had a cold front move through.