Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Another media outlet hoodwinked by their own preconceived notions and biases

By CosmicConservative
The Weekly Standard THE WEEKLY STANDARD has learned from a military source close to the investigation that Pvt. Scott Thomas Beauchamp--author of the much-disputed "Shock Troops" article in the New Republic's July 23 issue as well as two previous "Baghdad Diarist" columns--signed a sworn statement admitting that all three articles he published in the New Republic were exaggerations and falsehoods--fabrications containing only "a smidgen of truth," in the words of our source.
So here's the deal. Some private in the army starts telling stories about the U.S. military committing depraved acts of violence in Iraq, and says that his experience in participating in these acts caused him to become desensitized to the violence to the point that he participated in it himself. He describes soldiers having fun by running over cats and dogs, humiliating and laughing at an Iraqi woman disfigured from some presumed combat related fire, and soldiers wearing Iraqi children's skulls as some sort of bizarre trophy. The New Republic gleefully published this "proof" of U.S. malfeasance in Iraq. Within hours of the story hitting the wires the story came under fire from multiple sources, including soldiers who served with the fellow who wrote the stories. For a while the New Republic and the writer defended the stories and the Army investigated the claims. The claims were found to be completely false, and the writer admitted to making them all up. To me this is more a story about how easy the mainstream media is to hoodwink anytime there is a story that puts the U.S., or more importantly, the U.S. military in a bad light. This is just the latest in a long series of stories that initially put the military in a very bad light, but were then proven to be false. In every case the stories are trotted forward as evidence that the U.S. is "as bad as the terrorists". The initial stories are front page, above the fold stories, and the recantations are buried on page 22. The end result is that the public is left with the impression that the military is committing these depraved acts when there are actually very few examples of the activities described. This general impression reinforces the media's bias against the military even in cases like these where the lies are proven to be false, and so the next person to come forward with similar lies finds it even easier to get their lies published because the lies play right into the editorial bias of the media, and as such are rarely fact-checked. If not for the blogosphere I don't know where we would be today. Thank goodness for those like Michael Yon who bring us the true stories of the military's activities.

Comments (24)

gjh
It is no different whether the exaggerations or falsehoods concern the right or the left. Corporate media ownership causes what we see now as the news. It is actually infotainmemnt. How many times has Paris Hilton been discussed (in minutes of news) in the mainstream media newscasts where important developments in the war, Senate, or any other thing that affects our lives is ignored. Why do you hear nothing but bad about the Canadian Health Care system on the evening national news programs. Just watch the commercials, Merck,GSK,Bayer,AFLACK. They dictate what, by their commercial buying power, what information we receive about Health Care. Have you noticed you have never seen a plight of the American farmer where the sponsor of the news show is ADM or Cargell? Corporate media ownership is a threat to us all whether we are Cons or Libs. By the way, I'm pretty aware of what the MSM is doing as I am a news junkie throught Sat TV. I have not heard anything about this in the MSM. The Weekly Standard is not what anyone could call mainstream. I'll do some research and who they are. Is Bill Kristel of Fox
gjh
I misread the original post, office is busy today. The New Republic is also a fringe player that is a lefty rag. I, as a lefty, only hear of TNR in the backgroung, never mainstream, only looked at the website because you mentioned it. Looks like it needs a better look.
CosmicConservative
Whether it's a lefty rag or not, it claims to be a reputable news publisher. And it has its followers and the story gets picked up in larger distribution channels such as, say Daily KOS or FireDogLake, both of which jumped all over this story as "proof" of the U. S. Military's evil intent.And if you don't think Daily KOS is "mainstream" on the left, you haven't been paying attention to the political climate lately.
gjh
We could p**s back and forth all day, finding fringe publications supporting each others side, freedom of the press will (hopefully) be allowed in this country to continue. My bitch is that the public airways, which are allowed to operate without licencing fees, are allowed to taint their selection of news, or maybe forced to taint their news because of advertisers. When I watch Meet the Press, or This Week or what hard news show, my information should not be bias or not covered because ADM or Pfizer holds the purse strings. Why has no news program covered the fact that the so called death tax campaign was totally financed by the WalMart heirs? It only affects the people so rich, none of the heirs of the heirs of the heirs will ever have to work a day of their lives. The lies of the common family businesses lost and farms lost because of this tax, we never challenged by the MSM. As a member of the public and an owner of those airways I'm a peeved big time.
Drax
gjh: Yes. TNR is a lefty "fringe" publication which has only been in circulation for Ninety Years. It is unsurprising that you have only heard of it in the "background." And, I agree with you. I believe that "news" programs should be held to an OBJECTIVE standard of FACTUAL REPORTING, and those who violate that objective standard are taken to task by the other MSM "news" outlets for their FRAUD and those who intentionally commit such grand fraud be prosecuted to the full extent of the (yet to-be-drafted) law. Those who repeatedly and negligently report fraud as fact should IMMEDIATELY have their license yanked. But, then, we wouldn't have CBS, NBC, ABC, CNN, MSN "news" programs around any longer....
CosmicConservative
I think we have found one of our rare areas of common ground gjh. ;)
Andy
gjh: I was talking with my third son and his friends last night about how the press romanticized the "wild west" in the 1800's. Almost everything they reported (gunfights, quick-draw McGraw stuff) was manufactured from their own hopes of becoming the great journalist of their day. To describe the great bulk of them, they were LIARS. I guess the more things change, the more they stay the same. I do not believe any of our current crop of reporters...they all have an agenda. There are a few reporters/pundits that I have respect for, but very, very few. I am as conservative as they come, but I have respect (for the most part) for Juan Williams. Even though he just gripes me for some of his stands, I think that he is objective about 75% of the time, regardless of his politics. I like Bob Bechtel. I have become disillusioned with Bob lately, because he has become slavish to Hillary again, but for several years you could count on Bob to be pretty objective...had a "real world" view of most situations. On the right, I like Limbaugh (even though he is not a reporter/pundit). He will ferociously stand up for his conservative values...even if it means that he has to criticize Bush...which I understand that he does often. I also like Ann Coulter...because she just looks so darned good. Don't get me wrong...if she were Mrs. Andy I would be in jail for spousal abuse. Smart-mouthed, intelligent women often land their husbands in jail...but she has enough money to bail me out. This quote from your comment sort of confuses me: Why do you hear nothing but bad about the Canadian Health Care system on the evening national news programs. Just watch the commercials, Merck,GSK,Bayer,AFLACK. I know that the geriatric crowd watches the Evening newscasts, and the drug lords are trying to appeal to them, but truthfully I want to know if you know of something good about the Canadian Health Care system. If there is something that I have missed about it's efficiency, or value, I would sure like to look into it. I am not too old to learn something new, and would be very interested to check out any information that you have.
gjh
Andy Go see SICKO, from all reports on both sides of the border it is an accurate portrayal. It was rather interesting to hear the report from one Canadian doctor, who was lobbying for an American version of the Canuck system where multi payers and private insurance would enhance the Canadian delivery of health care. He was asked "Would he trade his health care coverage for the American one" and he answered "Not on your life!" Dadman My comments on TNR was so firmly tongue in cheek, my face was distorted. 95% of the population have no idea of what the TNR is or that it exists, therefore fringe.
gjh
Andy By the way, the Canuck system is rated third in the world while the U.S. is rated 37th. All the independent studies show that Canadians live longer than their American counterparts. Very interesting that the number of heart by passes, in Canada are just a fraction of the ones in the States, but the survival rates in Canada are better. Also in Canada when you get sick, you don't lose your house! Glaring example, my mother-in-law was blinded by cataracts. Her Michigan eye doctor wanted $9000. per eye to operate. A Canadian specialist did both eyes for $1100 total and said he was sorry because it was so expensive, and said the operating room costs ballooned the price.
CosmicConservative
I am willing to entertain the notion that the U.S. Health Care system could be improved. Certainly it is one of my family's highest expenses. We pay more for our therapy and medicine for our son's autism than we pay for all three of our cars put together. Medical costs are a huge issue in our budget for a variety of reasons. However, what I hear about Canada is that the costs are low, but the wait times for common medical procedures are long. Yes, some Americans go to Canada for procedures that are cheaper, but I also hear that some Canadians come to America and pay higher costs to get medical attention that would take weeks or months longer to attain in Canada. Sometimes it isn't just cost that is the issue.
gjh
For Canadians, there is no cost. They pay for it in other ways, via higher personal income tax. No high priority goes to a waiting line. On the other hand if you want a tummy tuck or a nose job, you can pay for it.
CosmicConservative
gjh: That simply does not mesh with the stories I've seen in the news about Canadian patients waiting months for critical organ replacement, or patients waiting for days for simple procedures like setting a broken bone. I know those things happen in Canada. It is a fundamental law of supply and demand that as the cost goes down, the demand goes up. When health care is free, more people seek health care. That's one of the fundamental assumptions of liberals who pursue it. They want it because lower economic segments of the population don't get health care. But when it becomes freely available, the lines start to grow. England in particular has serious problems with waiting lists on medical procedures. Canada may be in a unique position to make something like this work. They have a small population and lots of natural resources. The concern many like me have is that the system will not scale to the population densities we have in the U.S. Studies show that in cities like New York or Detroit, the existing health care systems will be overwhelmed with people seeking medical treatment, and will break down. I'm not dead set against changing our health care system. I will be honest with you all, if we went to a universal health care system in this country (and could depend on services being available) I would be a major beneficiary of that system. It would save me a ton of money, even with increased taxes to pay for it. I am a high user of health care, and I pay a lot for it. But I try not to make national policy decisions based on my narrow self interest. I am not convinced that Canada's system will remain solvent in the long term, I hear lots of stories about long waits for common procedures, and I am very worried that such a system will not scale to provide support for American high-density cities. These are legitimate concerns that have to be carefully evaluated. I don't believe that complex problems always have simple solutions, and I have seen more than one "solution" (like the "Great Society" of LBJ) create far more problems than they "solve." It is not clear to me that European or Canadian universal health care systems work in Europe or Canada, much less that they will work in this country.
gjh
The problem is that the U.S. system is broken down and it is not fixable if it remains in its present form. Not unlike the national media, health care is manipulated by those with the most power. The insurance companies make their rules as they go. The drug companies dictate prices and the hospital franchises set the rates. Tell me one doctor, nurse or any other provider who wants to work for an HMO. When for profit is only concerned for profit, where does the patient or the provider stand? I understand that the conservative mantra is the government does not work, but when the conservatives are in power they make sure that government doesn't work by installing managers that make sure it doesn't work. Remember Rummy's remark about being stuck with the army he's got. How did they "fix it" by bring in as many Blackwater privite mercenaries as there are troops in Iraq. Blackwater was called into N.O. after the hurricane. Government does work if given the proper finacing and power of regulation to make it work. All the other major industrial nations of the world have gov't run health care and all are rated above the best health care that Americans receive, and they only counting those Americans with health care.
CosmicConservative
gjh: Do you rewrite history on the fly, or do you have this whole alternate universe carefully constructed and updated on a daily basis? Rummy's remark was that "you go to war with the army you have" which was a reference to the drastic military reductions in personnel and equipment that Clinton used to fund his attempts to balance the budget. It is interesting to me how you consistently accuse corporations and conservatives of all kinds of evil and malfeasance as a matter of routine, while simultaneously asserting that liberals and career government workers have nothing but my best interests at heart. This seems to me to imply that there are two different kinds of human beings in your alternate reality world, the good ones who end up as Democrats and Government workers, and the evil ones who end up as Republicans or corporate workers. Such a world view seems to me to not only be profoundly bigoted and simplistic, it also seems to be monumentally ignorant of reality. My experience has been that all of these entities employ the same species of human beings and as such have the same issues with corruption, incompetence, self-interest and simple apathy. If anything I think the profit-driven corporate world actually drives behavior that is more customer focused than the profit-less government world. Your assertions that other countries are rated higher than the U.S. in any category doesn't mean squat to me when I see U.N. reports that put despotic regimes which routinely deny women the vote and condone such things as honor killings higher in the human rights scale than the U.S. Most of those lists are pure Leftist propaganda. So spare me.
gjh
I hope you are happy with your health care and it serves the needs of you and your family.
gjh
Are you denying the Blackwater troops don't exist? Are you denying that they are running under the radar as private contractors? By the way, they were just of an example of the conservative way of running government. The concept of the number of troops was in response to a question of the troops being under manned for the mission and under trained. Do you ever address a question asked? The U.N. has nothing to do with rating of health care. In the rest of the world health care is right in the U.S. it is a benefit. Go see SICKO. Try to walk away from it being proud or happy with our system of health regulations.
gjh
Correction above "In the rest of the world health care is a right, in the U.S. it is a benefit"
CosmicConservative
Your assertion that Republicans are alone in employing contract workers as possible mercenaries is naive gjh, to say the least. Go read up on the Bay of Pigs one day. Sicko is, by all accounts, not nearly as bereft of facts and overrun with lies as Fahrenheit 9/11 was, but it is still agenda-driven media. As I said, I am open to looking for ways to improve our system. I'm just not convinced that the Canadian system is the answer. For all the reasons (which you ignored) that I have already stated.
gjh
This probably fodder for another post but, Moore has challenged all comers to debate the facts on F-911 and has no takers. Why don't you issue a blog challenge to Moore? It would make a great interblog debate.
CosmicConservative
gjh: I have posted this link in response to your previous claims that no one challenges Micheal Moore's facts in Fahrenheit 9/11. That is just another lie from Michael Moore. Here is Christopher Hitchens' Slate Magazine article that points out the lies and purposeful misrepresentation of facts in the movie. I don't think I need to point out that Slate Magazine is no right-wing rag. There are entire books that have been written on the subject. In fact Michael Moore was challenged by Sean Hannity to a debate and he declined. For obvious reasons. I am dead serious gjh, you live in some bizarro world where facts are completely different than the real world.
gjh
Also, as I have mentioned before Hitchens is no lefty. The difference with the left wing rags and the right wing rags is: the left allows contrary opinions to be expressed by the other side. That does not happen with lockstep right. Don't bring up Combes as he is a token. Look at MSNBC who you frequently as being left wing liberal, Tucker Carlson, Matthews and Scarborough are all righties. Only Olbermann can be considered a lefty. They are also owned by G.E. which is not a bastion of liberal thinking. My question to you is what world do you live in where you talk, walk and preach in lock step to the mantra of the neocons and libertarians? Take Care
CosmicConservative
gjh: If you think I am in lock step with anyone, you simply are not reading and comprehending my views. I have been at least as critical of George W. Bush as I have been of Hillary Clinton. But it is pointless to try to discuss things with you. You speak, but you don't listen. That's not a debate, that's a monologue. Case in point. You said nobody was willing to debate or challenge Michael Moore's "facts". I linked a very well-researched and well-written article where someone very powerfully challenged his facts, and pointed out that Sean Hannity, at least, has offered to debate Moore. Your disingenuous and irrelevant reply was "Hitchins isn't a liberal." As if that had any bearing whatsoever on the debate point in question. This is your typical technique.
gjh
I guess I missed your link. Moore has taken on everybody,please show me where I can find it.
gjh
Just a heads up righties. The fit has hit the shan in Canada where the Mahar case has just been declassified. It involves extrordinary rendition. In a nut shell the Canuck Feds grabbed this guy as a potential terrorist turned him over the CIA knowing full well that he was to be shipped over seas (Jordan but turn out Syria). He was tortured for about a year then released. Big inquiry in Canada, heads will roll in Canada. Stay tuned.