Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Freedom's Orphans

By Dadman
Apparently Britain's teenagers are the most impudent and unruly in all of Europe, and perhaps the world. The Brits must be proud. See this from Yahoo News today...
YAHOO News - Report slams Britain for failing 'out of control' teens British teenagers are among the worst behaved in Europe, a study by a leading think-tank said Thursday, blaming government policy failures for high levels of fighting, binge drinking, drug taking and under-age sex... The report -- "Freedom's Orphans: Raising Youth in a Changing World" -- was published as the government announced a new 184-million-pound (275-million-euro, 378-million-dollar) 10-year strategy for young people. It will be supplemented by cash from bank accounts dormant for 15 years or more. IPPR senior research fellow Julia Margo welcomed the funding, which will be spent on "exciting, modern, up-to-date" places for youngsters in every community, as a step in the right direction. But she said the government could have gone further, by making extra-curricular activities compulsory. "Britain has a real problem with its teenagers," she said earlier, highlighting that children may be richer than their predecessors, more computer-literate and fashion-conscious but are "life poor". "British teenagers are more likely to get into fights, hang out with other teenagers, binge drink, take drugs and have under-age and unprotected sex than teenagers in most other European countries. But it isn't their fault." Margo said teenagers should be made to spend less time "hanging out" with each other and challenged the government to be less "touchy-feely", arguing that compulsory, not optional activities, would help reign in unruly teens.
Notice that neither parents nor adult supervision are even mentioned in the article. Government 'policy failures' are cited as the reason Britain's teenagers are out of control. One moonbat quoted in the article even proclaims it's not even the fault of the teenagers themselves and suggests compulsory participation in government programs would rectify the problem. Folks, this is liberal nanny-state moonbatiness at its worst. It doesn't take a genius to understand that it's the parents of these kids and the kids themselves that are responsible for their bad behavior. Yet, libsters somehow miss this obvious fact as they continue to strip all notions of personal accountability from their thinking and look to government to force upon us some kind of miraculous panacea. It'll never happen...

Comments (28)

Andy
Nothing to add Dadman. I think you pretty well covered it. I'd like to see someone argue you on this one.
CosmicConservative
OK, I'll argue with Dadman... The problem is that our culture now pretty much forces both parents to work, meaning these kids have no role models at home to enforce behavioral standards. Since it is not likely that the world economic model is going to go back the the 1950s, where Mom could stay home and raise kids (and who would want such an arrangement anyway, women fought hard to earn the right to the dog-eat-dog business world and the economic freedom that a paycheck provides), there really is no option other than government intervention, which has to take the form of mandated government-approved activities for these poor kids. Compulsory teenage activities will allow the authorities to legally remove potentially unruly teenagers from public areas and put them in situations where peer pressure will inexorably drive them towards more socially acceptable behavior in an environment lacking drugs, illicit sex or violent behavior. OK, that's my daily dose of "thinking like a liberal." Excuse me, I have to go take a shower now....
Andy
CC: Use environmentally friendly soap while you are at it. Your liberal thinking does raise some interesting thoughts though. This is not a personal pat on the back, but when Mrs. Andy & I married, we made a firm decision that I would work and that she would stay at home when the kiddos came. The idea that our culture pretty much forces both parents to work is not really "liberal" at all. It is a liberal hope, but it is driven by "conservative" capitalists. Capitalists have convinced most of us that we need a $35,000 SUV...a $2,000 flat screen TV...a vacation in St. Kits...and Lord knows, we have to have health insurance (we are all sick you know). Don't get me wrong. I am not dissing capitalists, just dropping a thought in. When the kids started to pop out, Mrs. Andy stayed home to raise the children (the jury is still out on whether it was best for them...we believe that it was, but the jury is still out). It was not easy...not easy on the family finances, and especially not easy for Mrs. Andy. When financial reverses came, it was hard on us all...the kids...Mrs. Andy...and me (the guy that was on the mark for family provision). Mrs. Andy and I have never had high income, but we have managed to survive. We live in an old house in an old neighborhood (but it is a nice old house, and it is paid for). We drive used cars (but they are reliable used cars, and they are paid for). Society really does pressure people toward having "Stuff." I fall into that trap occasionally. I have had my eye on this new lawnmower that is like a "Harley" for duds. Thankfully, Mrs. Andy puts valium in my iced tea, and hides the keys when I talk about "running up to Home Depot". Okay CC: Don't try arguing about raising kids again...after all, he is the Dadman.
Dadman
You're hysterical, Andy. I won't argue with your post, by the way, because I completely agree with it...
Andy
Dadman: Of course you agree with my post...YOU ARE THE DADMAN! You are also in complete agreement with Mrs. Andy when you say that I am "hysterical." Mrs. Andy truly appreciates my humor. Often I will break off a really good one...Mrs. Andy will laugh, and tell me "Andy, you are SO FUNNY..."...she will hug me...pat me on the back...and then say "...but looks aren't everything." Interesting topic Dadman...thanks for bringing it up.
Drax
We are at a point in Western society, a point which was inevitable as a result of the "War on Poverty" and "Great Society" thinking, and that point is one where governmental intervention/interference/planning/indoctrination/etc. is necessary. There simply are too many people out there who for too many generations (counted now in the teens....) who have no family which can or will provide any of the "parental guidance" which is necessary to grow the beasts we call "children" into productive citizens. This, of course, is a far cry from the government taking over that function from those who can and will serve as parents, but, removing government entirely from the current societal equation would result in utter chaos. This issue, as with most, is all about where the balance is...not "whether" government is involved in raising our children, but "how much."
Dadman
Drax: Interesting perspective. To a point I agree with you. But as a conservative I am not averse to defining the ideal situation (e.g. that children should be raised and nutured in homes governed by a mother and a father) and advocating that our public policy support the realization of that ideal. When the government of the U.K. (or any government for that matter) fails to even acknowledge the role of good parents I have a huge issue with that...
Andy
Dadman: To quote Archie Bunker: "Thank you very much President Roosevelt!"...to quote myself: "Thank you very much President Johnson." Drax is right if we are dealing with the reality at hand. Dadman is right if we hope against hope that the principles that have sustained us for so long will prevail in our Western society. I think that you both know that society has gotten itself in a mess for a variety of reasons (mostly spiritual...I won't go there). My great hope for my children (and Dadman's and Drax's children) is that the pendulum will swing back. My American History teacher in high school, and two other History teachers at Louisiana Tech lectured me about "the swinging pendulum" of history. I just pray to God that we are finally to the brink...and that the pendulum swings back. See...I can take both sides of the same issue. It comes from being married to Mrs. Andy for 28 years.
ams1491625
"The idea that our culture pretty much forces both parents to work is not really “liberal” at all. It is a liberal hope, but it is driven by “conservative” capitalists. Capitalists have convinced most of us that we need a $35,000 SUV…a $2,000 flat screen TV…a vacation in St. Kits…and Lord knows, we have to have health insurance (we are all sick you know)." The problem is that you do need stuff to live and compete economically in the modern world. Maybe not the TV, but you need at least a car (and all of them are ~$20000 or more), a telephone, and probably some sort of access to e-mail these days. You have to be able to communicate, to make and keep your appointmnets. The modern health care system has been screwed up to the point that there aren't nearly enough doctors to meet demand, and that you need thousands of dollars for any serious injury. You do need health insurance (at least if you want to live past 70 or survive a serious car wreck). I don't like ascetic arguments at all, really. It strikes me as holier than thou to characterize other people's chosen way of life (Especially if both parents are working to support it as opposed to scunging it off welfare!) as if it were all wasteful excess. "I don't need to exist in the (material) world the same way you do, I'm so much better..." Besides, it just opens the can of worms - define what "need" is, versus "luxury". Is living like a medieval peasant still a life of wasteful luxury compared with a bronze-age slave or nomadic hunter-gatherer?
ams1491625
Still, this mandatory child-care activity stuff is sort of creepy. I've often thought of the family as the basic unit of society (societies "cells" if you will). Their makeup and the way they live and raise their kids gives rise to the characteristics of the nation as a whole. Furthermore, it has a basic self-sufficient purpose - Families exist for the sake of raising and establishing their children, ensuring they are prosperous and have everything they need to be well-off. The family exists for the sake of the family. By extension, society and civilization exists to safeguard and serve the member families. (NOT the other way around, which is what socialism has always tried to do). If children are instead raised by the government, they will instead be raised with a different set of objectives in mind - to support and maintain the government (and whoever happens to control it). The government will no longer exist for the sake of it's people, the people will come to exist for the sake of the government. Once this inversion is pulled off, it's hard to see how western government can continue. (PS, ancient Mesopotamia had this sort of view of the universe - everything was owned by the preists and mankind existed only to serve the gods).
ams1491625
PS, both my parents worked to get a machine shop running. I worked with them as the janitor when I was off from school. :-P. Furthermore, we were alone as kids for much of the day from 3:30 to 7:00 or 8:00 at night from junior high onwards. We did our homework and our chores. Our parents succeeded in cultivating an appreciation for hard work and discipline, regardless. (PS in the good old days, it wasn't too much different - parents might have been home to raise their kids, but the kids were off running around the neighborhood with each other in the evenings)
Andy
ams: No holier than thou intended. I don't criticize parents for the choices they make. I am just saying that it can be done. Believe it or not, all cars are not 20,000. Some pretty good ones can be had for 5,000. All houses are not 250,000. Some pretty good ones can be had for half that or less. I am just saying that lifestyle choices do determine our need for income. I'm not stupid enough to believe that good, decent, honest, honorable, productive people haven't been raised by two working parents. I know too many of them. And there is a flip side...some real jerks had a stay-home Mom. The mandatory child care thing is the creepy...I could not agree more with comment #11...right on the mark.
Drax
One of the things which constantly amaze me about intelligent people is the consistency with which they impute their intelligence onto others. The world has a surplus of exceedingly stupid people, people who find even the most simple of tasks too difficult to perform with any degree of consistency. These are not "bad" people. These are not "ignorant" people who CHOOSE to be "stupid," but are people who, by accident of birth simply are not as smart as the average person (and, that would be roughly 1/2 of us....) They're never going to get a college education and work at a white collar job. They're never going to be able to have anything other than menial, mindless jobs which, in great part, pay very little. (Of course, there are still a few well paying menial jobs out there if you can land one...mostly union or government...) What does this mean? This means that there is a whole bunch of people who simply don't have a reasonable possiblilty of raising a family on a single paycheck, as their single paycheck simply isn't enough. Thus, both parents HAVE to work...or rely on government handouts. So, I have no problem with these government services being AVAILABLE....but not compulsory.
Dadman
My issue is not with parents who work out of the home. My issue is with a government who fails to recognize the role of good parenting, who blame poor behavior not on families or individuals but on poor government policy. What's going on in the U.K. is part of that inversion ams was talking about and it's not a positive thing...
Drax
Dadman: That's kind of my point. If, as I assert, we are several generations into the "Great Society" where (in large part) at least two generations of children have been raised essentially by the government, if those children have not been "raised" well, then, how ISN'T it "bad governmental policy" which is at fault, after all, it is the government which did the raising... We can blame the parents and the children all we like, but when the children are raised by parents who cannot or will not fulfill their proper duty, is it a better function of government to step aside or to step in? And, in both cases, at what point? We've put ourselves in a pretty deep hole here, I think. I suppose it's one thing to "stop digging," and another to "fill the hole back in."
Dadman
I'd like to stop digging and fill the hole back in...
Drax
Heh, me too Dadman. I just don't want to fill in the hole with the bodies of a couple of wasted generations....
CosmicConservative
I find it hard to hold parents blameless, they brought the kids into the world and should be aware of their fundamental human responsibilities regardless of what the current government may be saying/doing. However, I also hold the Government to blame for allowing human beings to indulge their tendency to allow their responsibilities to fall to other folks (or governments) to manage. But fundamentally, I blame the parents.
Drax
Hmmm... Let's say that you're raised by parents who not only don't teach you the fundamentals of being a productive citizen in society, but, instead, teach you the opposite of that, i.e., how to be a leeching drain on society, taking everything you can while giving as little as possible in return. Let's say that those parents were raised by parents who did likewise. Further, let's say that there are whole neighborhoods where this paradigm is not only accepted--but is expected. Let's go even further and say that governmental policies not only don't penalize this type of parenting, but reward it. And, even further, let's say that the "leaders" of those who have been raised in this lifestyle not only justify this behavior but blame everyone and everything BUT the parents for allowing this behavior and ATTACK anyone who attempts to redirect thinking on the whole issue. And, even further, say those "leaders" are not only given extraordinary "face time" in the national media, but are given credence by the leaders of one of the two major political parties, who ALSO attack anyone who attempts to redirect thinking on the whole issue. So, we go back to those "parents" who have been raised by "parents" who have been raised by "parents" who have been raised in this environment. We blame them for doing what their "leaders" say they SHOULD do? We blame them for doing what the media says is the "right" thing to do? We blame them for doing that which they are rewarded for doing and penalized for not doing? I can blame them no more than I can blame someone born in China for believing in Communism or someone born in Saudi Arabia for believing that Jews are "pigs." I CAN blame the "leaders" for perpetuating this lifestyle, both those who advocate(d) for it and those who remained silent for so many years before starting to rail against it. They should know better. It is easy for those who have been raised in households which resemble a sane household which teaches personal responsibility and self-worth to point the fingers of blame at those who have been indoctrinated from the earliest age (and for generations) in a self-destructive lifestyle and say "you should know better." But, they don't. Not most of them. They know, like most of us, what they've been taught by their families, in their neighborhoods, by the media, and in their schools. In today's society, government MUST take an active role. There simply are too many parents out there who not only won't do so...but simply are not EQUIPPED to raise productive citizens. (It really doesn't take too many days in Juvenile Court to see the effects of the past 50 years....) Unfortunately, governmental policies have, for the most part, taken the "easy road," attempting to allieviate the symptoms of the Great Society rather than to attack it at its roots, the failure of many families to pass down to their children the fundaments of the "American Dream" with the tools to achieve that dream.
Andy
Drax: I know that this "raising a family on one income" thing was not the intent of the subject. But indulge me please. Rose Howard, Shreveport, LA, 2 daughters, abandoned by husband. Black...No high school...poor reader...even worse at writing...damned hard worker. Cleans houses for well-to-do people. Rides public transportation. Cooks every meal (no McDonalds, or Applebees). Too proud to take handouts or welfare. Daughters graduate high school...graduate college (scholarships and student loans)...one a teacher...one an attorney. Retired on social security, and savings (and probably some help from her daughters). As nicely as I can say this..."One of the things which constantly amaze me about intelligent people is the consistency with which they impute their intelligence onto others."...Dang, I wish I was smart enough to accomplish all of that with the resources at hand. Anyone that believes it can't be done is just dead wrong (regardless of one's intelligence, or starting point). It is all about our expectations and the ability to control our "wanter." Thank you for indulging me. By the way, Rose Howard half-raised me...well, every success story has it's low points I guess.
Andy
Drax: I mis-wrote. Rose's girls went to college on scholarships, and student-work programs...just wanted to clear that up.
Drax
Sure, it "can" be done. Even today. But, are you talking about doing this 50 years ago? 40? 30? I'm not sure that comparing then to now is entirely apples to apples... Are we talking about someone in inner city New York cleaning houses during the day, leaving her kids alone during the summer or paying for daycare...making enough money to pay for the upkeep of her children without any "handouts?" Or, more realisticly, are we talking about someone living in the relatively cheap area of Northern Louisiana? Are we talking about someone who had family available to take care of her kids during the summer while she was at work, or someone who is forced to rely on daycare? There isn't a whole lot which can't be done...by someone....sometimes. What we should rationally expect of people shouldn't be modeled after what exceptional people do...
Andy
Drax: Rose is the exception, and not the rule (as the rule has been defined lately). I just love her so much that I always hold her out as an example. It was cheap Northwest Louisiana...it was in the 60's...it was before everyone had to have color TV, air conditioning, cable, internet, etc. I know that you are right...but my love for achievers like Rose just outweighs my practical side. I am with Dadman...I want to start filling up the hole...still an idealist in many ways. We may be past that in our society...but my "better angels" just keep pushing me to hope otherwise. You are right...Rose is an exceptional person by today's standards...but she was the "rule" in her day. I guess the hole is pretty deep.
CosmicConservative
I hear you Drax. But I will not allow the parents to blame all of their ingrained dependence on the government. As I said, I hold the government responsible too, but human beings should know better.
Drax
I tend to agree that, at some point, grown-ups "should" be able to cast off poor parenting, abusive parenting, early indoctrination from whatever source... But, man...it really takes a strong willed person to shake off the BARRAGE of this kind of influence from so many sources, so many POWERFUL and CREDIBLE sources... I mean, I'm thinking of home schooling my child simply because I don't want to have to de-program her after school each day...
CosmicConservative
Kids learn much more from watching their parents than from listening to them.
Andy
Drax: As a parent that home schooled three of my kids I can tell you that it will be a great experience for you, and for your child (if you go that route). Mrs. Andy & I home-schooled our three oldest sons (only during junior high...or middle school as they call it now). We had (as all who go that route) our own reasons. We were on an Indian Reservation when the two older boys were that age...they were the true minority...the subjects of ridicule, etc. That is not always a really good reason, but it was ours. Our third son was here in Bossier at that age, and too smart to go through Rusheon with the 16-year-old 7th graders. That was a good reason to invest a couple of years in home schooling. Having to deprogram your child every day after school is probably a better reason. It was a great experience. It really did bond us with the boys in ways that are hard to explain. It was a lot of work, but we think that it was worth it (the jury is still out).