Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix

By CosmicConservative
Watched it tonight with the Cosmic Wife and Cosmic Son. First I have to say that Order of the Phoenix was one of my least favorite of the Harry Potter books. Especially the ending which quite frankly was nearly incoherent. But most of the book seemed forced and contrived to me, especially the Ron / Hermione relationship. So I wasn't expecting this to be my favorite of the Harry Potter movies. A few thoughts: The cinematography was surprisingly poor in comparison to the previous two Harry Potter movies, which I thought were stunningly filmed. This one struck me as having poor quality control, bad lighting in several segments, and generally poor makeup, poor framing and poor editing. I was quite frankly pretty stunned by how poorly those basic movie crafting things were done. I also felt that the pacing of the movie was inconsistent. It sometimes seemed to lurch forward when it should have paused, and paused when it should have moved forward. The acting has improved a bit, I thought Daniel Radcliffe was better in this movie than in any previous movie. This is the first time that he showed any steel in his backbone. Ron was, again, good. I thought he had slacked off in the last movie, but this time he was back on form and pulled off the hulking/sulking teenager bit fairly well. I was not as thrilled with Hermione this time. She was alternately geeky and goofy instead of her previously steady, studious self. The standout acting in this movie though was by the actress who played Luna Lovegood. She was dead on. She displayed a serious level of stage presence, I found even her quiet, brooding moments to be pulling the eye toward her. In fact I would say that she made the character more compelling than the book's version. There was a sense of earnest wisdom in her that was well beyond the skills of most young actresses. The story was typical Harry Potter stuff. If you haven't read the books, please do. If you have then you know the story. Harry battles his own inner demons in this book, even more than he battles Voldemort. I know a lot of people are going to say that Professor Umbridge was great. The audience certainly seemed to enjoy her pink-clothed, small-statured, giggly sort of evil. And it got a chuckle out of me from time to time. But, as in the book, I simply could not buy that this sycophantic functionary could have outmaneuvered Dumbledore. She's just too vapid. And the acting was simply too melodramatic, I would have found her far more sinister if she had not flounced around with that silly grin on her face all the time. I know that was done purposefully, I just didn't like it. I wonder if the director didn't deliberately save up all the budget for the final climactic battle scene in the Ministry of Mysteries, or whatever that hall of glass globes was. Once we got there the CGI improved dramatically. I did feel, just as I did in the book, that it was not credible that the children could have battled the adult death-eaters even as effectively as they did. But once the Order of the Phoenix arrived, the CGI and the acting was quite good. That was by far the best part of the movie. Now I have to be fair and say that I judge a Harry Potter movie differently than most movies. Mostly that's because of the expectations I have that money is really no object, and so there is no monetary reason that the film makers would skimp on the fundamentals. So I am probably harsher than I would be in reviewing a movie like "Transformers" for instance (I plan on seeing this soon). But that's the price they pay for being such a successful franchise. I have the same approach to Spiderman, Pirates of the Caribbean, Shrek and other franchise blockbusters. I expect a lot when I go to see one of them. All in all though, I liked it. I particularly liked that they did not put a single Quidditch match in the movie. I really, really hate that game. Overall though, still a good movie to go see. I definitely recommend it, if just for the final battle alone.

Comments (2)

pace
It certainly was not my favorite of the Harry Potter movies. Like you, I found certain effects early in the movie to appear a little low-budget, such as Sirius Black speaking through the fire. In previous movies, the fire itself became animated and spoke. In this movie, they had superimposed Sirius' ghostly visage over the fire and it looked ultra-cheesy IMHO. The final battle scene was good, but the movie felt as though it ended prematurely. My wife - who is a rabid Potter fan - believes they must have cut out a great deal of footage. This movie was shorter than the previous two I believe, which is a little odd given that this book is one of the more involved/longer. I was pleasantly surprised by Transformers, by the way.
CosmicConservative
The Sirius Black in the fire sequence was one of the ones I noticed too. The director chose to cut the Quidditch match, which is fine with me because I hate that stupid game, but it does have an actual plot element associated with it that was missing in the movie.