Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Are women drawn to men with muscles?

By CosmicConservative
So, what is the major logical fallacy involved in this study, and the conclusion that they reached? Their conclusion is based on interviews they did with 99 college-age men. Actually there are two fallacies, but one is more important than the other.
Women drawn to men with muscles | Oddly Enough | Reuters CHICAGO (Reuters) - Muscular young men are likely to have more sex partners than their less-chiseled peers, researchers at the University of California Los Angeles said on Monday. Their study, published in the Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, suggests muscles in men are akin to elaborate tail feathers in male peacocks: They attract females looking for a virile mate. "Women are predisposed to prefer muscularity in men," said study author David Frederick of UCLA.

Comments (1)

CosmicConservative
Sigh.. I guess this was too easy... The second and minor fallacy is the idea that a bunch of narcissistic body builders would actually be honest in responding to a survey about their sex lives. But the more compelling fallacy is the implication that men simply stand around doing nothing but posing for women who then choose the ones they want. The reality, of course, is that men who aggressively pursue women have more sexual partners than men who don't. I would put this in the category of "major duh". And although I can't point to a study proving this (although such studies probably exist) I would bet that self-absorbed, narcissistic men who spend a lot of time on their "sculpted physiques" are more aggressively pursuing women than dumpy geeks, so the actual comparison of sexual behavior is almost certainly at least as much related to the actual behavior of the men involved as it is to their looks, and frankly, I would bet that the behavior has MORE of an impact. But the study simply ignores this obvious behavioral connection.