Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Re-reading "The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe."

By CosmicConservative
Last night I decided to reread C. S. Lewis's "The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe" so I would be prepared for the upcoming movie. I read it originally when I was about 12 or so, which is a lot longer ago than I want to admit, and I had forgotten most of the story. I had a sort of fond recollection of how I felt reading all of the Narnia books, but the details were gone. So I read it again last night. I've done this with some other books from time to time. This summer I reread Arthur C. Clarke's "The City and the Stars" because I hadn't read it since High School and I remembered it as a monumentally mind-opening book. Rereading "TCATS" was like a pleasant journey back in time, the book held up very well and I enjoyed it tremendously. As much as I'd like to say the same about TLTWATW, I can't. First of all, I read it in about two hours, maybe less. That's usually a bad sign because I tend to savor good books and let the images and thoughts roll around in my head as I'm reading. It takes me a LOONG time to read "The Lord Of The Rings", which I try to do at least once each year. The main impression I got re-reading TLTWATW was that it lacked depth. I never got a feel for the size or the dynamics of Narnia. I never got a feeling for any of the characters except Aslan and Edmund, the younger boy, and maybe Lucy, the younger girl. All of the other characters just felt like background, they came and went as needed to move the narrative along, but I never got the feel of a culture or a community that moved according to its own internal rules and customs. Strange things kept popping out at me, like the Beavers who ate human style breakfasts, complete with a plate of butter on the table. I don't want to give anything away in case someone reading this is wanting to see the movie and hasn't read the book, but overall the story seemed choppy and disconnected, with minor activities covered in exhaustive detail, while great earth-shaking events came and went in the blink of an eye. Overall the book felt unpolished and incomplete. I know the books were written for children, but so was "The Hobbit" and I don't get that feel rereading the Hobbit. Now I kind of wish I hadn't re-read it. However, I still think it has the makings of a fantastic movie so I have not reduced my anticipation for the movie. I do think that if the movie sticks faithfully to the book, a lot of the elite movie reviewers will be quite put off by much of the story line.

Comments (3)

Brian Dunbar
I know the books were written for children, but so was “The Hobbit” and I don’t get that feel rereading the Hobbit. I think the Narnia books and 'The Hobbit' are for different ages - Narnia would be for kids up to middle school, the Hobbit is best appreciated by mature middle schoolers and kids in high school.
Cullen
I agree with Brian. I am reading the Narnia series to my girls (aged 6 and 4) and they are enjoying it (though it is going over their heads in places). But, the series doesn't feel the same to me as it did when I first read them in sixth grade. I feel the same way about Piers Anthony's work. I loved it when I was 8th and 9th grade, but can't bring myself to even attempt to re-read them today.
CosmicConservative
I have exactly the same reaction to most of Piers Anthony's work, but I do think Ox, Orn and Omnivore still hold up pretty well.